Jay Feely: The One Big Beautiful Bill Let ACA Tax Credits Expire, Driving Up Health Care Costs For More Than 49,000 Individuals In AZ-01 On Marketplace Plans

2025: Feely Said The Expiration Of ACA Tax Credits Was A “Mess,” But He Suggested It Was Democrats’ Fault

2025: Feely Asked Why Democrats Did Not Vote To Extend Obamacare Subsidies When They Controlled The Federal Government. “Let me correct @SenWarren …. -Democrats created Obamacare, -Voted for more subsidies during COVID -Knew expiration was 2026 Why didn’t Democrats vote to extend subsidies when you controlled Presidency, House and Senate? Now they blame Republicans for not fixing their mess.” [Jay Feely, Twitter, 10/13/25]

Image: see original report, p. 27

[Jay Feely, Twitter, 10/13/25]

  • Feely Said Democrats “Voted For More Subsidies During COVID” And “Knew Expiration Was 2026” And “Now They Blame Republicans For Not Fixing Their Mess.” “Let me correct @SenWarren …. - Democrats created Obamacare, -Voted for more subsidies during COVID -Knew expiration was 2026 Why didn’t Democrats vote to extend subsidies when you controlled Presidency, House and Senate? Now they blame Republicans for not fixing their mess.” [Jay Feely, Twitter, 10/13/25]

The One Big Beautiful Bill Made Health Care More Expensive For More Than 49,000 AZ-01 Residents That Got Coverage From ACA Marketplace Plans

2025: More Than 49,000 Individuals In AZ-01 Were Enrolled In ACA Marketplace Plans. [KFF, 10/3/25]

Number Of AZ-01 Residents Enrolled In ACA Marketplace Plans In 2025

Congressional District

ACA Marketplace Enrollees

AZ-01

49,245

[KFF, 10/3/25]

2025: More Than 423,000 Individuals In Arizona Were Enrolled In ACA Marketplace Plans. [KFF, 4/2/25]

Number Of Arizona Residents Enrolled In ACA Marketplace Plans In 2025

State

ACA Marketplace Enrollees

Arizona

423,025

[KFF, 4/2/25]

2025: A 60-Year-Old Couple Making $85,000 In AZ-01 Would See A 240% Increase In Their Average Out-Of-Pocket Monthly Premium Payments If The ACA Tax Credits Expired. [KFF, 10/9/25]

Image: see original report, p. 28

[KFF, 10/9/25]

KFF Health System Tracker: Insurers That Participated In The ACA Marketplaces Raised Premiums On Average By 20% In 2026. “For 2026, across 312 insurers participating in the ACA Marketplaces from the 50 states and the District of Columbia, this analysis shows a median proposed premium increase of 18%, which is about 11 percentage points higher than last year. This is the largest rate change insurers have requested since 2018, the last time that policy uncertainty contributed to sharp premium increases. On average, ACA Marketplace insurers are raising premiums by about 20% in 2026. Based on a more detailed analysis of available documents from insurers in 19 states and the District of Columbia, like in prior years, growth in health care prices stood out as a key factor driving costs in 2026. Insurers cite increasing cost and utilization of high-priced drugs as well as general market factors, such as increasing labor costs and inflation, as contributing to premium increases.” [KFF Health System Tracker, 8/6/25]

The One Big Beautiful Bill Did Not Extend Enhanced Premium Tax Credits For ACA Marketplace Plans. “The OBBBA did not extend enhanced premium tax credits for ACA marketplace plans. As a result, when open enrollment begins on November 1, 2025, 20 million marketplace enrollees will see their premium costs spike.” [Center for American Progress, 7/29/25]

  • The Majority Of Insurers Took Into Account The Potential Expiration Of Enhanced Premium Tax Credits For Their Rate Increases. “In addition to rising healthcare costs, the majority of insurers are also taking into account the potential expiration of enhanced premium tax credits in their premium rate increases for the next year. The expiration of enhanced tax credits will lead to out-of-pocket premiums for ACA marketplace enrollees increasing by an average of more than 75%, with insurers expecting healthier enrollees to drop coverage. That, in turn, increases underlying premiums. Other federal policy changes, like the implementation of tariffs and the ACA Marketplace Integrity and Affordability rule were also discussed, though to a lesser extent.” [KFF Health System Tracker, 8/6/25]
  • The Majority Of Insurers Assumed Enhanced Tax Credits Would Expire At The End Of 2025, Which Caused Them To Raise Their Rates By An Average Of 4%. “Uncertainty over federal policy changes has forced insurers to make some assumptions when developing their rates for 2026. Commonly mentioned by insurers is the impact of the expiration of enhanced premium tax credits, which are scheduled to sunset at the end of 2025, unless extended by Congress. The majority of insurers have assumed that enhanced tax credits will expire at the end of this year, driving rates an average of 4 percentage points higher than they otherwise would be. These increased rates are due to insurers anticipating that some healthier members will leave the ACA Marketplaces when their subsidies decrease, creating an enrollee base that is less healthy and more expensive on average.” [KFF Health System Tracker, 8/6/25]
  • The Expiration Of Enhanced Tax Credits Would Lead To Out-Of-Pocket Premiums For ACA Marketplace Enrollees Increasing By An Average Of Over 75%. “In addition to rising healthcare costs, the majority of insurers are also taking into account the potential expiration of enhanced premium tax credits in their premium rate increases for the next year. The expiration of enhanced tax credits will lead to out-of-pocket premiums for ACA marketplace enrollees increasing by an average of more than 75%, with insurers expecting healthier enrollees to drop coverage. That, in turn, increases underlying premiums. Other federal policy changes, like the implementation of tariffs and the ACA Marketplace Integrity and Affordability rule were also discussed, though to a lesser extent.” [KFF Health System Tracker, 8/6/25]

January 2026: About 70,000 Fewer Arizonans Signed Up For ACA Insurance Compared To 2025

Arizona Mirror Headline: “Arizona ACA Health Insurance Enrollment Plummets As Premiums Soar Without Enhanced Subsidies.” [Arizona Mirror, 1/14/26]

About 70,000 Fewer Arizonans Signed Up For Insurance Through The Affordable Care Act In 2026 Compared To 2025 According To Data From The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. “About 70,000 fewer Arizonans have signed up for health insurance through the Affordable Care Act after Republicans in Congress refused to extend tax credits and premiums soared. One analysis found that insurance premiums on the ACA marketplace for Arizona jumped nearly 30% on average. Data released this week by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services show that 353,000 Arizonans have signed up for 2026 ACA insurance plans, nearly 17% fewer than purchased plans for 2025. The open enrollment period for the ACA ends on Thursday.” [Arizona Mirror, 1/14/26]

  • Arizona Mirror: “One Analysis Found That Insurance Premiums On The ACA Marketplace For Arizona Jumped Nearly 30% On Average.” “About 70,000 fewer Arizonans have signed up for health insurance through the Affordable Care Act after Republicans in Congress refused to extend tax credits and premiums soared. One analysis found that insurance premiums on the ACA marketplace for Arizona jumped nearly 30% on average. Data released this week by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services show that 353,000 Arizonans have signed up for 2026 ACA insurance plans, nearly 17% fewer than purchased plans for 2025. The open enrollment period for the ACA ends on Thursday.” [Arizona Mirror, 1/14/26]

Source report (PDF)