John Braun Claimed He Was “Not In Any Way Opposed To Unions” But Frequently Spoke Out Against Them And Voted To Undermine Workers’ Ability To Unionize Their Workplace

2016: Braun Suggested Raises For State Employees Were “Unnecessary,” Calling The State Workforce’s Collective Bargaining Agreement “Very Expensive & Unusual”

2016: Braun Called Raises For State Employees “Very Expensive & Unusual,” Suggesting They Were “Unnecessary” And Would “Exacerbate Income Inequality Among The State’s Workforce.” “Bottom Line: Up Front. Very Expensive & Unusual - The Governor negotiated Collective Bargaining Agreements for 2017-19 that are double the cost of any prior agreements. The result is nearly half of the state’s workforce receiving pay increases of more than 10% over the next two years. The raises are unusual both in scope and structure (3 raises in 2 years) and exacerbate income inequality among the state’s workforce as more highly paid staff will see bigger increases in their paychecks. Unnecessary? - Reports from the Governor’s own budget office show that Washington does a good job retaining employees. The turnover rate is well-below the national public sector average. And nearly all state employees have seen their wages rise faster than inflation during this decade.” [John Braun, Economic Sense Eighth Edition, December 2016]

  • Washington’s Governor Negotiated Collective Bargaining Agreements For 2017-19 That Would Increase Pay For Nearly Half Of The State’s Workforce By More Than 10% Over The Following Two Years. “Bottom Line: Up Front. Very Expensive & Unusual - The Governor negotiated Collective Bargaining Agreements for 2017-19 that are double the cost of any prior agreements. The result is nearly half of the state’s workforce receiving pay increases of more than 10% over the next two years. The raises are unusual both in scope and structure (3 raises in 2 years) and exacerbate income inequality among the state’s workforce as more highly paid staff will see bigger increases in their paychecks. Unnecessary? - Reports from the Governor’s own budget office show that Washington does a good job retaining employees. The turnover rate is well-below the national public sector average. And nearly all state employees have seen their wages rise faster than inflation during this decade.” [John Braun, Economic Sense Eighth Edition, December 2016]

2021: Braun Said He Was “Not In Any Way Opposed To Unions” But Said He Thought Public-Sector Unions Had “Outsized Influence” In Washington

2021: Braun Said He Was “Not In Any Way Opposed To Unions” But Said He Thought “In Our State, You Have The Public-Sector Unions Who Have Outsized Influence.” “But the power wielded by largely public-sector unions has rekindled longstanding complaints from conservatives who say labor has outsized influence in Olympia. ‘I’m not in any way opposed to unions,’ said Senate Republican leader John Braun, R-Centralia. ‘I just think, in particular in our state, you have the public-sector unions who have outsized influence.’” [Seattle Times, 8/2/21]

2024: Braun Voted To Allow Employers To Hold Mandatory “Captive Audience” Meetings To Coerce And Intimidate Workers Against Unionization

2024: Braun Voted Against S.B.5778, A Bill Protecting Workers Who Chose Not To “Captive Audience” Meetings

February 2024: Braun Voted Against S.B. 5778, A Bill “Protecting The Rights Of Workers To Refrain From Attending Meetings Or Listening To Their Employer’s Speech On Political Or Religious Matters.” In February 2024: Braun voted against: “AN ACT Relating to protecting the rights of workers exercising their right to refrain from attending meetings or listening to their employer’s speech on political or religious matters.” The bill passed the Senate by a vote of 28-20 and was signed into law. [Washington State Legislature, S.B. 5778, 2/7/24]

  • S.B. 5778 Protected Employees From Mandatory “Captive Audience” Meetings. “The Legislature passed ESSB 5778, known as the Employee Free Choice Act (EFCA), marking a significant development in Washington labor laws. This act prohibits employers from mandating, under the threat of disciplinary action, that employees attend meetings or speeches on religious or political matters. The law is set to take effect on June 5, 2024. Traditionally, employers have held mandatory ‘captive audience’ meetings to share corporate and personal views. An employee’s unexcused absence from these meetings could result in discipline. These meetings are especially common during labor organizing efforts and when employers have aligned personal or business-related interests with particular political or religious candidates or movements. Under the EFCA, ‘political matters’ means any matters relating to political office or parties, legislative or regulatory proposals, and the decision to join any political party or political, civic, community, fraternal, or labor association or organization. ‘Religious matters’ means any matters related to religious affiliation or practice, and the decision to join or support any religious organization. […] Captive-audience meetings have historically been utilized by employers to combat unionization efforts. Such meetings were legal but regulated by the National Labor Relations Board and state agencies. Prior to the EFCA, the only major restriction on mandatory captive-audience meetings was that such meetings could not be held too close to the start of the secret ballot election period. However, because its broad definition of ‘political matters’ encompasses the decision to join a labor organization, the EFCA forbids employers’ mandatory captive-audience meetings relating to the decision to join a labor association or organization. This could potentially conflict with existing labor laws and affect labor organizing activities in Washington.” [Ballard Spahr, 4/12/24]

“Captive Audience” Meetings Were Mandatory Meetings Employers Held During Work Hours To Coerce And Intimidate Workers Against Unionization

Communications Workers Of America District 1: “Captive Audience Meetings Are Mandatory Meetings Held By An Employer During Work Hours In Order To Pressure Employees Against Joining A Union.” “Captive audience meetings are mandatory meetings held by an employer during work hours in order to pressure employees against joining a union, interrogate workers about the organizing campaign, and dis seminate union-bashing materials like videos and flyers. A 2009 study found that employers held captive audience meetings in 89% of union election campaigns between 1999 and 2003. This tactic is a major factor in why private sector unionization has fallen to 6.4%.” [Communications Workers Of America District 1, accessed 2/26/26]

  • Emergency Workplace Organizing Committee: During Captive Audience Meetings, Management Exposes Workers To “Anti-Union Talking Points” To Dissuade Workers From Joining A Union. “Union-Busting Tactic #1: Captive Audience Meetings. What it looks like Management holds meetings in which they expose workers to anti-union talking points. Management can also prohibit pro-union employees from attending and present counter arguments, and they’ll accuse those who speak up of being ‘disruptive’ or ‘negative.’ The goal of these meetings is to turn people against unions, usually by scaring them or implying that unions are evil, but management won’t say that, of course. Instead, they’ll claim to be providing ‘all of the facts’ so that workers can make ‘an informed decision.’ These meetings used to be illegal, precisely because they are so effective at frightening employees and unfairly swaying the results of a union election. What you might hear ‘A union is a third party.’ ‘We’re not against unions, but we don’t need one.’ ‘They’ll make you go on strike.’ ‘You’ll get dues deducted from your paycheck.’ ‘There’s no guarantee you’ll make more money.’ ‘We might have to close.’” [Emergency Workplace Organizing Committee, 12/12/25]
  • Workday Magazine: “Employees Who Fail To Attend Or Leave” Captive Audience Meetings “Can Be Disciplined.” “Captive audience meetings allow employers facing an organizing drive to gather large groups of employees on company time and push their views about a union or unions in general. Employees who fail to attend or attempt to leave such meetings can be disciplined. An employer is allowed to make statements and

predictions about the union’s effect on the company so long as objective facts support the comments. However, the employer’s message cannot contain a ‘threat of reprisal’ if their employees choose to organize, nor a ‘promise of benefit’ if their employees refrain from organizing (although it is illegal, workers report that employers do use captive audience meetings to make explicit and implicit threats and promises all the time). Currently, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) does not allow employers to hold such meetings within 24 hours of an election due to their highly influential nature.” [Workday Magazine, 3/21/23]

2024: Braun Voted Against Allowing Digital Signatures For Union Authorization Cards, Making It Harder For Workers To Organize Their Workplace

February 2024: Braun Voted Against, S.B. 6060, A Bill “Concerning The Acceptance Of Electronic Signatures By The Public Employment Relations Commission For New Organizing Petitions.” In February 2024, Braun voted against S.B. 6060, a bill “concerning the acceptance of electronic signatures by the public employment relations commission for new organizing petitions.” The bill passed by a vote of 31-18. [Washington State Legislature, S.B. 6060, 2/6/24]

  • S.B. 6060 Allowed Digital Signatures From Public Employees Seeking To Join Unions, Which Several Other States Already Accepted. “State lawmakers approved SB 6060, which will modernize the state’s Public Employment Relations Commission by allowing the agency to accept digital signatures from public employees seeking to join together in unions. The National Labor Relations Board already accepts electronic signatures for private sector union drives, and multiple states—including Oregon, California, and Minnesota— already accept the same for public employees. Sponsored by Sen. Joe Nguyen (D-White Center), SB 6060 adds Washington to the growing list of states to do so. It passed the Senate 31-18, the House 92-4 and was signed into law by Gov. Jay Inslee.” [Washington State Labor Council, AFL-CIO, WSLC Legislative Report, 2024]
  • 2015: Ogletree Deakins: Allowance Of Electronic Signatures On Union Authorization Cards Would “Expedite And Expand The Organizing Process.” “The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) has made union organizing by email and social media a reality. The NLRB’s General Counsel issued Memorandum 15-08 on September 1, 2015, stating that, ‘[e]ffective immediately, parties may submit electronic signatures in support of a showing of interest.’ On October 26, 2015, the General Counsel issued Revised Memorandum 15-08 providing more detail and examples of how the new process will work. Employers should expect unions to take advantage of this groundbreaking development by using email and social media to expedite and expand the organizing process.” [Ogletree Deakins, 11/9/15]

2025: Braun Voted To Allow Employers To Force Their Workers To Give Up Their Right To Sue Their Employer As A Condition Of Grievance Settlements

April 2025: Braun Voted Against S.B. 5503, A Bill “Concerning Public Employee Collective Bargaining Processes.” In April 2025, Braun voted against S.B. 5503, a bill “concerning public employee collective bargaining processes.” The bill passed by a vote of 30-18. [Washington State Legislature, S.B. 5503, 4/15/25]

  • S.B. 5503 Prohibited Public Employers From Forcing Workers To Waive Their Federal Or State Statutory Rights As A Condition For Settling A Grievance Under A Collective Bargaining Agreement. “SB 5503. This bill makes changes to Public Employment Relations Commission procedures related to representation petitions, hearings and the merging of bargaining units under the Public Employees’ Collective Bargaining Act. Public employers are prohibited from requiring a worker to waive any federal or state statutory right to claim a condition of settling a grievance under a collective bargaining agreement.” [King 5, 6/27/25]
  • S.B. 5503 Prohibited Grievance Settlements From Waiver An Employee’s Right To Sue Their Employer In The Future As A Condition Of The Settlement. “The Senate has concurred in the House’s amendments SB 5503. The bill has now passed the legislature and goes to the Governor for signature or veto. AWC continues to have significant concerns about Section 6 of the bill, but the Legislature left those concerns unaddressed. Section 6 undermines grievance settlements by prohibiting them from including a waiver of an

employee’s right to sue their employer in the future as a condition of the settlement. AWC is sending a letter to Governor Ferguson asking for a veto of Section 6 because it will discourage settlements. AWC has maintained that this change is unnecessary since settlements are voluntary agreements, and the section will add costs for all parties in a grievance dispute. In Washington, the Governor is empowered to veto an entire section from a bill without vetoing the entire bill. AWC was neutral on the rest of the bill, so we are asking only for a partial veto of Section 6.” [Association of Washington Cities, 4/28/25]

Source report (PDF)