Rhett Marques: Critics Called H.B. 129 “New Segregation” And Opposed Using Public Dollars For Private Schools; Alabama Daily News Reported That CHOOSE Act Applicants Were More Likely To Be White And Less Likely To Be Black Compared To Alabama’s Public School Population
Democratic Lawmakers Questioned Whether H.B. 129 Would Be Used As A Mechanism For “New Segregation,” Saying “They Will Get Paid To Go And Segregate”
House Minority Leader Democrat Bobby Singleton Questioned Whether The CHOOSE Act Would Be A Mechanism For White Families To Leave Public Schools Saying, “This Is The New Segregation. They Will Get Paid To Go And Segregate.” “Ivey called for the passage of the bill in her State of the State address last month and named it a top priority for the session. ‘With the CHOOSE Act, Alabama will now be able to be a leader when it comes to school choice, and I am hopeful this will make a difference in Alabama families. Let me also be clear that my commitment to public education remains unrelenting. At the end of the day, we all want every Alabama student, no matter the zip code, to receive a quality education,’ Gov. Ivey said as she signed the bill at a ceremony Thursday. […] A lawmaker questioned whether the program would be a mechanism for white families to leave public schools. ‘This is the new segregation. They will get paid to go and segregate,’ said House Minority Leader Bobby Singleton (D-Greensboro). The approved plan is smaller than a $500 million proposal introduced last year that critics said would drain too much from public education.’” [WAKA 8, 3/8/24]
Democratic Rep. Curtis Travis Said He Was Worried H.B. 129 Would Be Using Tax Dollars “To Create Separation,” Saying “It’s Not That History Tends To Repeat Itself, But That People Tend To Repeat History.” “The Alabama House of Representatives Tuesday approved a a [sic] voucher-like program for schools after a debate lasting over four hours. HB 129, sponsored by Rep. Danny Garrett, R-Trussville and known as the CHOOSE Act, passed the House on a 69-34 vote. Six Republicans joined Democrats in voting against the bill. […] Opposition to the bill came mostly from Democrats, who said that the bill would destroy public education in Alabama. Some likened the bill to a form of modern-day segregation. Rep. Curtis Travis, D-Tuscaloosa, cited his experience during desegregation of schools in Hale County in the late 1960’s and early 1970’s, when private schools serving mostly white students were built in response to federal desegregation orders. He said he was worried that the Legislature would be using tax dollars ‘to create separation.’ ‘It’s not that history tends to repeat itself, but that people tend to repeat history,’ Travis said.” [Alabama Reflector, 2/28/24]
Democratic Sen. Rodger Smitherman Opposed The CHOOSE Act For Using Public Dollars For Private Schools, Saying “This Is A Situation Where We Are Looking To Provide Money For People To Take Their Kids Anywhere They Want To Take Them — As If We’ve Taken Care Of All Our Other Problems.” “Ivey called for the passage of the bill in her State of the State address last month and named it a top priority for the session. ‘With the CHOOSE Act, Alabama will now be able to be a leader when it comes to school choice, and I am hopeful this will make a difference in Alabama families. Let me also be clear that my commitment to public education remains unrelenting. At the end of the day, we all want every Alabama student, no matter the zip code, to receive a quality education,’ Gov. Ivey said as she signed the bill at a ceremony Thursday. […] Opposed lawmakers expressed concern about using public dollars for private schools. ‘This is a situation where we are looking to provide money for people to take their kids anywhere they want to take them — as if we’ve taken care of all our other problems,’ said Sen. Rodger Smitherman, a Democrat from Birmingham. While the program would initially be aimed at low and middle-income families, opposed lawmakers questioned how much they would benefit, noting that private school tuition is often more than the $7,000 the state would provide.” [WAKA 8, 3/8/24]
Alabama Daily News: CHOOSE Act Applicants Were More Likely To Be White And Less Likely To Be Black Compared To Alabama’s Public School Population
Alabama Daily News: “Compared With Alabama’s Public School Population, CHOOSE Act Applicants Are More Likely To Be White And Less Likely To Be Black.” “The racial breakdown also differs between new and renewal applicants. Black students make up a larger share of new applicants than renewal applicants, while white students make up a larger share of the renewal pool. Compared with Alabama’s public school population, CHOOSE Act applicants are more likely to be white and less likely to be Black. Public school enrollment is about 50% white and 32% Black, while CHOOSE Act applicants are 67% white and 23% Black. Alabama does not collect statewide private school or homeschool enrollment data, making it difficult to know how closely the applicant pool matches students enrolled in either of those school settings.” [Alabama Daily News, 5/26/26]
Alabama Daily News: “Public School Enrollment Is About 50% White And 32% Black, While CHOOSE Act Applicants Are 67% White And 23% Black.” “The racial breakdown also differs between new and renewal applicants. Black students make up a larger share of new applicants than renewal applicants, while white students make up a larger share of the renewal pool. Compared with Alabama’s public school population, CHOOSE Act applicants are more likely to be white and less likely to be Black. Public school enrollment is about 50% white and 32% Black, while CHOOSE Act applicants are 67% white and 23% Black. Alabama does not collect statewide private school or homeschool enrollment data, making it difficult to know how closely the applicant pool matches students enrolled in either of those school settings.” [Alabama Daily News, 5/26/26]