2022: Kevin Lincoln Voted To Decrease Stockton’s Capital Improvement Budget By $23.3 Million While Old Wood And Stone Curbs Sat In Disrepair And The City Faced A Negligence Lawsuit Over Dangerous Infrastructure
2022: Lincoln Voted For The FY 2022-23 Annual Budget, Which Decreased Stockton’s Capital Improvement Budget By $23.3 Million Compared To The Prior Year
2022: Lincoln Voted To Adopt The Stockton FY 2022-23 Annual Budget. “Adopting the Fiscal Year (FY) 2022-23 Annual Budget, the 2022-2027 Capital Improvement Plan, and the FY 2022-23 Fee Schedule […] Yes: Christina Fugazi , Sol Jobrack, Susan Lenz, Kevin J Lincoln II, Kimberly Warmsley, and Daniel Wright. Absent: Paul Canepa.” [Stockton City Council, Meeting Minutes, 6/21/22]
FY 2022-23: Stockton’s Capital Improvement Budget Decreased $23.3 Million Compared To The Prior Year Budget. “The FY 2022-23 Capital Improvement Program budget is $139.3 million, which is a decrease of $23.3 million compared to prior year budget. Planned General Government projects decreased $6.6 million, Transportation projects are down $3.9 million, and Utility projects are decreasing $12.8 million.” [City of Stockton, Annual Budget, Page 59, FY 2022-23]
- Transportation Projects Were Down $3.9 Million And Utility Projects Were Down $12.8 Million. “The FY 2022-23 Capital Improvement Program budget is $139.3 million, which is a decrease of $23.3 million compared to prior year budget. Planned General Government projects decreased $6.6 million, Transportation projects are down $3.9 million, and Utility projects are decreasing $12.8 million.” [City of Stockton, Annual Budget, Page 59, FY 2022-23]
Stockton Had A History Of Decades-Old Street Curbs In Disrepair
2022: Stockton Record: “While Many Areas Of Town Have Been Brought Into The 21st Century, Others Are Stuck In The Stone — Or Wood — Age.” “The city of Stockton is as old as the state of California, and while many areas of town have been brought into the 21st century, others are stuck in the stone — or wood — age. Redwood curbs can be found predominantly south of Harding Way and north of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, Stockton Public Works Director Jodi Almassy said. The curbs are not contiguous in any one neighborhood, she said, more so ‘sprinkled’ across that section of south Stockton. A combination of old granite and cobblestone curbs can also be found in south Stockton.” [Stockton Record, 10/19/22]
2018: South Stockton Had Decades-Old Street Curbs That Were Crumbling Or Rotting Away. “Scattered throughout south Stockton are decades-old street curbs that are crumbling or rotting away, and Ralph Lee White would like to see the city replace them soon. […] White, a former city councilman who lives in south Stockton, said there are several redwood curbs along residential streets in his neighborhood rotting away.” [Stockton Record, 6/20/18]
Image: see original report, p. 56
2022: Lincoln Acknowledged That Repairs Were Long Overdue In Many Of Stockton’s Neighborhoods
2022: In His State Of The City Address, Lincoln Said Many Of Stockton’s Neighborhoods And Parks Had Been Long Overdue For Repairs, Renovations, And Rehabilitation. “About 700 people gathered at the Port of Stockton’s Rough and Ready Island to listen to Mayor Kevin Lincoln give his State of the City address, the first to be in-person since 2019. […] Stockton’s bankruptcy left the city with millions of dollars in backlogged maintenance. Lincoln said many of the city’s neighborhoods and parks have been long overdue for repairs, renovations and rehabilitation. He highlighted the city's recent $9 million investment to address 50% of the backlog of sidewalk repairs and 25% of the backlog on tree maintenance across Stockton. The city’s public works maintenance is addressed on a citywide priority basis.” [Stockton Record, 5/19/22]
2022: Stockton Did Not Specifically Earmark Money For Redwood Or Cobblestone Curbs
2022: Stockton Allocated $10.2 Million To Begin Work On More Than $50 Million In Deferred Maintenance. “In May, the city allocated $10.2 million to begin work on more than $50 million in deferred maintenance, but the money is not specifically earmarked for the redwood or cobblestone curbs. In June at the city’s budget hearing, Stockton Mayor Kevin Lincoln said the city needs to clarify its position in committing to inclusion and equity when targeting investment areas and initiatives. He specifically requested staff come back with a price on replacing all the redwood curbs in south Stockton.” [Stockton Record, 10/19/22]
2022: None Of The $10.2 Million Was Specifically Earmarked For The Redwood Or Cobblestone Curbs. “In May, the city allocated $10.2 million to begin work on more than $50 million in deferred maintenance, but the money is not specifically earmarked for the redwood or cobblestone curbs. In June at the city’s budget hearing, Stockton Mayor Kevin Lincoln said the city needs to clarify its position in committing to inclusion and equity when targeting investment areas and initiatives. He specifically requested staff come back with a price on replacing all the redwood curbs in south Stockton.” [Stockton Record, 10/19/22]
- Lincoln Said He Requested Staff Obtain A Price Estimate For Replacing Redwood Curbs In South Stockton. “In May, the city allocated $10.2 million to begin work on more than $50 million in deferred maintenance, but the money is not specifically earmarked for the redwood or cobblestone curbs. In June at the city’s budget hearing, Stockton Mayor Kevin Lincoln said the city needs to clarify its position in committing to inclusion and equity when targeting investment areas and initiatives. He specifically requested staff come back with a price on replacing all the redwood curbs in south Stockton.” [Stockton Record, 10/19/22]
Stockton Faced A Lawsuit Over A Dangerous Sidewalk And Settled The Case For $650,000
2019: Laura Dinges Sued The City Of Stockton For General Negligence. [San Joaquin County Superior Court, Laura Dinges v. City of Stockton et al., Case No. STK-CV-UPI-2019-17043, Complaint, filed 12/23/19]
Image: see original report, p. 58
Dinges Said She Was Walking On The Sidewalk In Stockton When She Fell On Dangerously Raised Pavement And Suffered Bodily Injury. “Plaintiff Laura Dinges was walking on the sidewalk on the east side of Venetian Drive between Loggia Way and Belleni Drive, in Stockton, California, when she tripped and fell on dangerously raised pavement causing her to suffer bodily injury.” [San Joaquin County Superior Court, Laura Dinges v. City of Stockton et al., Case No. STK-CV-UPI-2019-17043, Complaint, filed 12/23/19]
Image: see original report, p. 58
May 2023: A Jury Found That The Property Was In A Dangerous Condition At The Time Of The Injury And Awarded Dinges A Total Of $756,500 In Damages. [San Joaquin County Superior Court, Laura Dinges v. City of Stockton et al., Case No. STK-CV-UPI-2019-17043, Verdict Form, filed 5/5/23]
Image: see original report, p. 59
Image: see original report, p. 59
Image: see original report, p. 60
NOTE: The City of Stockton filed an appeal after the jury issued a verdict.
September 2023: Stockton City Council Voted Unanimously To Settle The Case Brought By Laura Dinges In The Amount Of $650,000. “8. REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION Lori Asuncion, City Attorney - reported in the matter of Laura Dinges vs. City of Stockton, et al San Joaquin County Superior Court Case #STKCVUPI2019-17043, City Council voted unanimously 7-0 to settle in the amount of $650,000 dollars.” [Stockton City Council, Meeting Minutes, 9/26/23]
Stockton Faced A Lawsuit For An Unstable Tree And Settled The Case
2022: Ariana Leon Solis Sued Stockton For A Dangerous Condition After A Falling Tree Branch Knocked Her Unconscious. “On April 11, 2022, an overweight, 30-foot-long branch with a 20-foot-wide crown split off from the trunk of a tree located at 222 E Weber Ave in Stockton and slammed down onto the vehicle Plaintiff was sitting in. The size and weight of the tree caused the roof of the vehicle to cave in striking the top of Ms. Solis’ head and knocking her unconscious. Ms. Solis experienced an immediate onset of pain at the time of the incident and was transported to the emergency room for an evaluation. […] The City of Stockton is liable under California Government Code §835, which states, ‘Except as provided by statute, a public entity is liable for injury caused by a dangerous condition of its property if the plaintiff establishes that the property was in a dangerous condition at the time of the injury, that the injury was proximately caused by the dangerous condition, that the dangerous condition created a reasonably foreseeable risk of the kind of injury which was incurred, and that: (b) The public entity had actual or constructive notice of the dangerous condition under Section 835.2 a sufficient time prior to the injury to have taken measures to protect against the dangerous condition.’” [San Joaquin County Superior Court, Ariana Leon Solis v. City of Stockton et al., Case No. STK-CV-UPI-2022-8699, Plaintiff Mandatory Settlement Conference Statement, filed 8/9/24]
Solis’ Legal Statement: “The City Of Stockton Allowed The Subject Tree To Go Unpruned And Grow To Be Structurally Unstable And Defective.” “The City of Stockton allowed the Subject Tree to go unpruned and grow to be structurally unstable and defective. The instability is evidenced by the photos of the tree and its continual loss of branches. Make no mistake, a tree that is repeatedly dropping branches onto a heavily trafficked sidewalk is a dangerous condition.” [San Joaquin County Superior Court, Ariana Leon Solis v. City of Stockton et al., Case No. STK-CV-UPI-2022-8699, Plaintiff Mandatory Settlement Conference Statement, filed 8/9/24]
2024: Solis And The City Of Stockton Settled The Case. “To the court, all parties, and any arbitrator or other court-connected ADR neutral involved in this case: 1. This entire case has been settled. The settlement is: Unconditional.” [San Joaquin County Superior Court, Ariana Leon Solis v. City of Stockton et al., Case No. STK-CV-UPI-2022-8699, Notice of Settlement of Entire Case, filed 10/2/24]