Stockton Faced 12 Lawsuits Over Police Brutality, Including One Death, During Kevin Lincoln’s Tenure As Mayor
Stockton Faced 12 Lawsuits Over Injuries Or Death Caused By Police Officers During Lincoln’s Tenure As Mayor. [U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California via PACER, accessed 2/11/26; San Joaquin County Superior Court, Civil Case Search, accessed 2/11/26]
- 10 Of The 12 Cases Were Dismissed And One Of Those Was Settled For $400,000. [U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California via PACER, accessed 2/11/26; San Joaquin County Superior Court, Civil Case Search, accessed 2/11/26]
- One Of The 12 Cases Was Settled For An Unknown Amount. [U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California via PACER, accessed 2/11/26; San Joaquin County Superior Court, Civil Case Search, accessed 2/11/26]
- One Of The Cases Was Listed As Disposed Of. [U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California via PACER, accessed 2/11/26; San Joaquin County Superior Court, Civil Case Search, accessed 2/11/26]
NOTE: The cases filed before 2021 originated before Lincoln took office as mayor but were discussed in executive session by Stockton City Council during his tenure.
Lawsuits Against The City Of Stockton Involving Police |
|---|
Year Filed | Case Number | Case | Court | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
2015 | Nathaniel Smith v. City of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Smith sued Stockton, alleging police shot and injured him. The case was dismissed with prejudice. | |
2017 | Trinidad Brown v. Eddie Diaz et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Brown sued Stockton police officers, alleging unreasonable force and false criminal charges after police allegedly pointed a gun at his face and tased him in the face. In 2022, the case was dismissed with prejudice. | |
2019 | Francisco Duarte et al. v. City of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Duarte and Gutierrez sued Stockton, alleging a wrongful arrest and use of unreasonable force by police officers during a street gathering on Cinco de Mayo 2017. Plantiffs’ complaint also alleged police made false reports about them. In 2024, the appeal by Duarte was voluntarily dismissed. | |
2020 | James Weaver Jr. et al. v. City of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Weaver sued Stockton, alleging police wrongfully arrested him and assaulted him in front of three minor children. In 2023, the case was dismissed with prejudice. | |
2020 | Kevin Brasley et al. v. City Council of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Brasley et al. sued Stockton, alleging deprivation of constitutional rights. The complaint alleged police arrested Brasley even though he did not fit the description of an unrelated suspect. It also alleged police beat Brasley with a baton, breaking his arm. In 2023, the case was dismissed with prejudice. | |
2020 | Gerardo Rodriguez Pacheco et al. v. City of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Pacheco et al. sued Stockton, alleging a police officer threw him to the ground, handcuffed him, and slammed the plaintiff’s face on the hood of his patrol car, fracturing his face and requiring surgery. In 2023, the case was dismissed with prejudice. | |
2021 | David Guidry v. City of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Guidry sued Stockton police officers for allegedly attacking him, tasing him, and arresting him after he filmed them on 5/27/20. In 2023, both parties agreed to the case being dismissed with prejudice. Stockton City Council voted to settle the matter with Guidry for $400,000. | |
2021 | Karen Sutherland et al. v. City of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Karen Sutherland sued Stockton police for allegedly killing her son, Shaye Allen Sutherland, while he was unarmed, handcuffed, and restrained on 10/8/20. The complaint alleged officers forced Sutherland to the ground and applied force with a police baton and body weight for three minutes until he died by asphyxiation. In 2024, the case was dismissed with prejudice. | |
2021 | Joshua Otero et al. v. Fernando Posada, Jr. et al. | San Joaquin County Superior Court | Otero et al. sued Stockton police officers, alleging they caused severe injuries in a motor vehicle accident. The City of Stockton moved to dismiss. In 2025, the case was disposed of. | |
2022 | Davion Barlow et al. v. Officer Nicholas Fogal et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Barlow and Tuuga sued Stockton police officers for allegedly assaulting them after a traffic collision and fabricating claims of resisting arrest. In 2023, the case was dismissed. | |
2023 | Melvin Justin Curry v. City of Stockton et al. | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California | Curry sued Stockton police officers, alleging excessive and unlawful force after they allegedly broke his arm in his home during a mental health call placed by his mother. In 2024, the case was dismissed with prejudice. | |
2023 | Byron Santos v. City of Stockton et al. | San Joaquin County Superior Court | Santos sued over Stockton, alleging police officers beat him unconscious with a metal baton during a traffic stop. In September 2024, the parties settled the case. | |
[U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California via PACER, accessed 2/11/26; San Joaquin County Superior Court, Civil Case Search, accessed 2/11/26]