2020: Joe Mitchell Voted To Make It More Difficult For Iowans Suffering From Asbestos Or Silica-Related Health Issues To Seek Damages For Exposure

March 2020: Mitchell Voted For S.F. 2337. In February 2020, Mitchell voted for S.F. 2337: “A bill for an act relating to civil actions involving asbestos and silica, and including applicability provisions.” The bill passed the House (54-46) and was signed into law by Governor Reynolds in June 2020. [Iowa State Legislature, S.F. 2337, 3/10/20]

  • Under S.F. 2337, Iowans Would Have To Name A History Of Employers And Products Associated With Asbestos Or Sicilian Exposure In A Sworn Affidavit Detailing Evidence Of Their Claims Against Defendants. “Iowans who claim sickness from asbestos exposure may soon have to provide more detailed information in order to sue for damages. As a result of the over-naming of defendants in asbestos and silica lawsuits, the Iowa House and Senate passed Senate File 2337 (“SF2337”). Governor Kim Reynolds is expected to sign it into law. […] SF2337 provides new rules for asbestos-related lawsuits. Plaintiffs suing companies over claimed exposure to asbestos and silica would have to establish a basis for the allegation against specific defendants. The File requires anyone filing an asbestos or silica lawsuit to include a sworn affidavit detailing the evidence against each named defendant in the initial pleading, along with other responsible parties– including bankrupt entities–and a full list of current and former employers. Iowa plaintiffs would have to identify each current and past work site, as well as the frequency of their exposure to asbestos. The affidavit would have to list each product to which exposure to asbestos or silica is claimed, and identify each manufacturer, distributor, and seller of that product. SF2337 calls for the dismissal of any defendant for which the plaintiff fails to provide this information”. [Chicago Bar Association, @theBar Blog, 5/18/20]

Mitchell Supported A Bill Limiting Non-Economic Damages For Medical Malpractice Cases Because Of Concerns Hospital CEOs Had Voiced To Him

Mitchell Supported A Bill That Would Limit “Non-Economic” Damages For Medical Malpractice Or In Cases Against The Owner Or Operator Of A Commercial Motor Vehicle. “The bill would limit ‘non-economic’ damages for medical malpractice or in cases against the owner or operator of a commercial motor vehicle. Cornell said he's representing a family whose father, an employee of the Iowa Department of Transportation, was killed while working along the side of the road when he was struck by a vehicle. He said the cap in this bill would limit the family of five to receiving $1 million, which he thought was wrong. Mitchell said he did not believe the bill was a violation of the Seventh Amendment, and reiterated that the cap applied only to non-economic damages. He said that the high cost of medical malpractice lawsuits has forced small hospitals to close, and that this issue is the No. 1 concern of hospital CEOs he's talked to.” [Southeast Iowa Union, 3/14/22]

Mitchell Explained His Support For The Bill Was Due To The Concerns Hospital CEOs Had Shared With Him. “The bill would limit ‘non-economic’ damages for medical malpractice or in cases against the owner or operator of a commercial motor vehicle. Cornell said he's representing a family whose father, an employee of the Iowa Department of Transportation, was killed while working along the side of the road when he was struck by a vehicle. He said the cap in this bill would limit the family of five to receiving $1 million, which he thought was wrong. Mitchell said he did not believe the bill was a violation of the Seventh Amendment, and reiterated that the cap applied only to non-economic damages. He said that the high cost of medical malpractice lawsuits has forced small hospitals to close, and that this issue is the No. 1 concern of hospital CEOs he's talked to.” [Southeast Iowa Union, 3/14/22]

  • Justia: “Non-Economic Damages Refer To Compensation For A Wide Array Of Non-Monetary Losses” Or “Intangible Suffering.” “This intangible suffering is the basis for non-economic damages. While they don't come with a price tag, the law recognizes that these losses are just as real as financial costs. […] Non-economic damages refer to compensation for a wide array of non-monetary losses. These can include: Pain and Suffering: This encompasses the physical pain and discomfort you endure as a result of the injury. Emotional Distress: This includes anxiety, depression, fear, insomnia, PTSD, and other psychological impacts stemming from the trauma of the injury. Loss of Enjoyment of Life: This compensates for the inability to partake in hobbies, recreational activities, and other life pleasures that were possible before the injury. Disfigurement and Physical Impairment: This addresses scarring, physical alterations, and permanent limitations that can have a profound impact on a person's life and self-esteem. Loss of Consortium: This is a claim that can sometimes be

brought by a spouse or family member for the loss of companionship, support, and intimacy resulting from your injuries.” [Justia, accessed 5/21/26]

Source report (PDF)