2021: Joe Mitchell Voted For A Bill Removing Restrictions On Open Enrollment Which Cost One School District Thousands Of Dollars After More Than 150 Students Left
2021: Mitchell Voted For A Bill That Caused Schools To Lose Students To Lax Open-Enrollment Requirements, One School District Losing 152 Students
April 2021: Mitchell Voted For H.F. 228. In April 2021, Mitchell voted for H.F. 228: “A bill for an act relating to voluntary diversity plans under the state’s open enrollment law.” The bill passed the House (56-35) and was signed into law by Governor Reynolds in May 2021. [Iowa State Legislature, H.F. 228, 4/20/21]
- H.F. 228 Removed Restrictions On Open Enrollment That Were Intended To Encourage District Racial Diversity. “In May, Gov. Kim Reynolds signed legislation ending Voluntary Diversity Plans in the state which placed limits on open enrollment in an attempt to encourage racial diversity within a district. Davenport, Des Moines, Postville, Waterloo, and West Liberty were the only districts in the state with Voluntary Diversity Plans. Prior to H.F. 228, a plan was allowed if: The percentage of minority students in the school district exceeded the percentage of minority students in the state by at least 20 points, or the percentage of minority students at one school exceeded the percentage of minority students in the district as a whole by at least 20 points.” [NBC, 9/16/21]
- Davenport Community School District: Open Enrollment Allowed “A Parent Or Guardian Residing In A School District [To] Enroll Their Child In A Public School In Another School District Without Paying Tuition, Provided They Comply With Filing Deadlines And Procedures.” “What is open enrollment between districts? In the state of Iowa, a parent or guardian residing in a school district may enroll their child in a public school in another school district without paying tuition, provided they comply with filing deadlines and procedures.” [Davenport Community School District, accessed 5/21/26]
- H.F. 228 Resulted In 157 Students Leaving Davenport Community School District. “An additional 157 students have left the Davenport Community School District since an open enrollment law took effect in Iowa. In May, Gov. Kim Reynolds signed legislation ending Voluntary Diversity Plans in the state which placed limits on open enrollment in an attempt to encourage racial diversity within a district. Davenport, Des Moines, Postville, Waterloo, and West Liberty were the only districts in the state with Voluntary Diversity Plans. Prior to H.F. 228, a plan was allowed if: The percentage of minority students in the school district exceeded the percentage of minority students in the state by at least 20 points, or the percentage of minority students at one school exceeded the percentage of minority students in the district as a whole by at least 20 points.” [NBC, 9/16/21]
- Davenport Community School District Specialist Martin Schilz: “It’s Roughly 7500 Dollars Give Or Take That Those Students, When They Leave They Take That Money With Them Out Of The District.” “In May, Gov. Kim Reynolds signed legislation ending Voluntary Diversity Plans in the state which placed limits on open enrollment in an attempt to encourage racial diversity within a district. Davenport, Des Moines, Postville, Waterloo, and West Liberty were the only districts in the state with Voluntary Diversity Plans. Prior to H.F. 228, a plan was allowed if: The percentage of minority students in the school district exceeded the percentage of minority students in the state by at least 20 points, or the percentage of minority students at one school exceeded the percentage of minority students in the district as a whole by at least 20 points. ‘Under that system, requests to open enroll would be denied if they lead to a greater imbalance in the demographic balance of the district,’ Davenport Community School District Specialist Martin Schiltz said during a presentation to the school board on Monday. According to the district, 157 students who would not have been allowed to leave the district prior to the law change, have open enrolled elsewhere. ‘It’s roughly 7500 dollars give or take that those students, when they leave they take that money with them out of the district,’ Schiltz said. ” [NBC, 9/16/21]