2022: Joe Mitchell Voted For A $16.4 Million Per Year Program Requiring School Districts To Publish Information On Their Curricula And Allow Parents To Opt Their Children Out From Certain Learning
March 2022: Mitchell Voted For H.F. 2577. In March 2022, Mitchell voted for H.F. 2577: “A bill for an act relating to education, including requiring the boards of directors of school districts and the governing boards of charter schools to publish certain specified information, modifying provisions related to required social studies instruction, and providing civil penalties.” The bill passed the House (60-36) and stalled in the Senate Appropriations Committee in April 2022. [Iowa State Legislature, H.F. 2577, 3/29/22]
- H.F. 2577 Would Have Required School Districts To Adopt A “Transparency” Policy Allowing Parents To Review Instructional Materials Used In Classrooms, And Opt Their Children Out Of Receiving Certain Materials. “According to the bill, a school district has to adopt a policy for parents of enrolled students to review instructional materials in the classroom, which is something most districts already have in place. This policy now includes charter schools, which were previously exempt, but still does not include private schools. The bill also allows parents to opt their students out of receiving certain instructional materials. The district’s ‘transparency’ policy will need to be prominently displayed on its website and the school board should provide district parents with either an electronic or written version of the policy annually. Districts would need to have available electronic or printed textbooks, a course syllabus or written summary of the material that will be taught in the class, an explanation on how the class meets or exceeds state educational standards, and a ‘list of all instructional materials that will be used in the student’s class.’” [Iowa Starting Line, 3/29/22]
- Iowa Starting Line: “Districts Would Need To Have Available Electronic Or Printed Textbooks, A Course Syllabus Or Written Summary Of The Material That Will Be Taught In The Class, An Explanation On How The Class Meets Or Exceeds State Educational Standards, And A ‘List Of All Instructional Materials That Will Be Used In The Student’s Class.” “The district’s ‘transparency’ policy will need to be prominently displayed on its website and the school board should provide district parents with either an electronic or written version of the policy annually. Districts would need to have available electronic or printed textbooks, a course syllabus or written summary of the material that will be taught in the class, an explanation on how the class meets or exceeds state educational standards, and a ‘list of all instructional materials that will be used in the student’s class.’” [Iowa Starting Line, 3/29/22]
Mitchell Argued The Requirements For Teachers To Put Their Learning Materials Online Was A Reasonable Request. “Henry County’s two state legislators answered questions from the public during the Mount Pleasant Area Chamber Alliance’s legislative breakfast Saturday at the Masonic Lodge. […] Other audience members questioned Mitchell on efforts in the Legislature to require teachers to put their learning materials online so parents can see them. Mitchell said it was a reasonable request designed to increase transparency.” [Southeast Iowa Union, 3/14/22]
- According To The Nonpartisan Iowa Legislative Servies Agency (LSA), Implementing The Required “Transparency” Policies Under H.F. 2577 Was Estimated To Cost $16.4 Million Annually. “A modified
version of the Republican-led teacher curriculum-review bill is being debate on the Iowa House floor this evening. The new version of the bill, House File 2577, trimmed the estimated cost of implementing the new ‘transparency’ policies from $27.4 million annually for school districts to $16.4 million annually, according to the nonpartisan Iowa Legislative Services Agency (LSA). The LSA’s estimate is based on school districts finding enough substitute teachers to cover the full-time teachers’ classrooms while they compile all the materials for inspection. Iowa is in the midst of a substitute teacher shortage in addition to its full-time teacher shortage.” [Iowa Starting Line, 3/29/22]
- The Linn-Mar Community District Board Of Education Said H.F. 2577 “Would Put An Undue Burden On Our Teachers” And “Put Additional Financial Strain On Districts Across The State In Updating Our Technology Systems To Meet New Transparency Requirements.” “The Linn-Mar Community School District Board of Education is writing today asking you to vote NO on HF 2577. The impact of this legislation, if passed, would drastically limit the ability of educators to adapt and meet the individualized needs of their students. It would also put additional financial strain on districts across the state in updating our technology systems to meet new transparency requirements. […] This legislation would put undue burden on our teachers and further entrenches the growing problem of teacher retention and recruitment. Our teachers are comprehensively trained to recognize the needs of our students and have devoted their lives to the most important work a society can undertake – the education of its children.” [Linn-Mar Community District Board Of Education, 3/28/22]