Joe Mitchell Downplayed The Failures Of Iowa’s Privatization Of Medicaid Saying There Were Some “Bumps In The Road”; A Year Later, Private Medicaid Firms Serving Iowans Were Investigated By The Federal Government For Unfairly Denying Services
2016: Iowa Privatized Its Near $4 Billion Medicaid Program Which Served About 600,000 Residents
Associated Press: “Iowa Privatized Its Roughly $4 Billion Medicaid Program, Which Serves About 600,000 Residents, In 2016.” Iowa privatized its roughly $4 billion Medicaid program, which serves about 600,000 residents, in 2016. At the time, former Gov. Terry Branstad argued the new setup would be more efficient and save the state money. Since then, health care providers and Medicaid recipients have filed complaints about reduced services and delayed reimbursements. Data on costs also shows the state hasn’t reached its intended goal on savings. [Associated Press, 2/11/18]
2018: Mitchell Said The Iowa Legislature “Has Tried To Make Sure They Are Giving The Quality Care To Our Citizens They Deserve” With Oversight Bills He Believed Would “Smooth Bumps In The Road”
Mitchell On Iowa’s Privatization Of Medicaid: “What The Legislature Has Tried To Do … Is Put Oversight Bills On These Manage Care Operations To Make Sure They Are Giving The Quality Care To Our Citizens They Deserve.” “Former Republican Gov. Terry Branstad ordered Iowa follow other states in hiring national companies to administrate its Medicaid program in 2015. Since then, controversy over whether taxpayers are saving money by the privatization of Medicaid has persisted. […] Mitchell: ‘What the Legislature has tried to do … is put oversight bills on these manage care operations to make sure they are giving the quality care to our citizens they deserve. The oversight bill we passed this last legislative is going to try to smooth the bumps in the road, but I'm all for putting more government oversight on the managed care operations to make sure that they're putting people over profits.’” [Southeast Iowa Union, 10/19/18]
Mitchell Said The Oversight Bill Passed In The Previous Session Was “Going To Try To Smooth The Bumps In The Road.” “Former Republican Gov. Terry Branstad ordered Iowa follow other states in hiring national companies to administrate its Medicaid program in 2015. Since then, controversy over whether taxpayers are saving money by the privatization of Medicaid has persisted. […] ‘What the Legislature has tried to do … is put oversight bills on these manage care operations to make sure they are giving the quality care to our citizens they deserve. The oversight bill we passed this last legislative is going to try to smooth the bumps in the road, but I'm all for putting more government oversight on the managed care operations to make sure that they're putting people over profits.’” [Southeast Iowa Union, 10/19/18]
Mitchell On The Iowa’s Challenges With Medicaid: “It's No Secret The Medicaid Program Was Implemented Poorly, But Last Session The Legislature Put In An Oversight Provision.” “The privatization of Medicaid has been surrounded by controversy and conflicting data since then-Gov. Terry Branstad ordered the shift in 2015. His successor, Gov. Kim Reynolds, has continued to support the move. But hospitals and nursing homes officials say Medicaid costs continue to increase while reimbursements to the facilities fail to cover the costs of Medicaid patients. ‘It's no secret the Medicaid program was implemented poorly, but last session the legislature put in an oversight provision,’ Mitchell said.” [Daily Democrat, 2/18/19]
Iowa’s Medicaid Privatization Produced “Barely Half” The Savings That Were Anticipated…
2018: Republican State Auditor Found Medicaid Privatization Saved The State “Barely Half” Of What Gov. Branstad Projected When The Change Was Instituted Two Years Earlier. “Iowa saved $126 million this year from privatizing its Medicaid system, barely half what former Gov. Terry Branstad projected when he forced the change in 2016, according to an audit released Monday. The report by Auditor Mary Mosiman also found officials and lawmakers have failed to file quarterly financial reports as required by state law. She said they ‘should have worked together to establish a method to estimate the program cost savings’ when moving from state-managed Medicaid to a system managed by for-profit health care companies.” [Associated Press, 11/26/18]
Democrats And Some Health Care Providers Questioned Whether Privatization Produced Any Savings At All, Noting State Had Poured Money Into Medicaid To Offset Losses Sustained By Insurers. “Democratic critics and some health care providers have questioned whether the Medicaid change really is producing any savings. DHS has poured more money into Medicaid because insurance providers claimed they were sustaining losses. Iowa officials said in August they were giving Amerigroup and UnitedHealthcare, the two companies that manage the program, an additional $103 million over last year’s funding.” [Associated Press, 11/26/18]
…While Causing “Reduced Services And Delayed Reimbursements” For Recipients And Providers
Iowa’s Medicaid Privatization Effort Resulted In “Reduced Services And Delayed Reimbursements.” “Iowa privatized its roughly $4 billion Medicaid program, which serves about 600,000 residents, in 2016. At the time, former Gov. Terry Branstad argued the new setup would be more efficient and save the state money. Since then, health care providers and Medicaid recipients have filed complaints about reduced services and delayed reimbursements. Data on costs also shows the state hasn’t reached its intended goal on savings. Gov. Kim Reynolds, a Republican who is seeking her first four-year term as governor, has acknowledged there have been mistakes in the program’s transition. [...] Disability Rights Iowa helped file a lawsuit against the state that claimed the privatized system has cut services for disabled patients, but the suit was dismissed.” [Associated Press, 2/11/18]
Medicaid Recipients Reported Being Denied Necessary Health Care And Providers Complained They Received “Low Reimbursement.” “Despite that, criticism of the program has not stopped. Complaints from providers about low reimbursement are reminiscent of the same complaints voiced four and five years ago. Advocates say Medicaid members, particularly those who require long-term supports, struggle to obtain the care they need. ‘Iowans were made more vulnerable by privatization,’ said Jenn Wolff, a disability advocate behind the #UpgradeMedicaid initiative. […] Early on, Iowans claimed they were denied necessary health care and providers complained they failed to receive full or partial reimbursement for their services. At one stage, the Iowa Ombudsman’s Office assigned a full-time staff member to respond to Iowans’ complaints about the managed-care program, Ombudsman Kristie Hirschman said in 2017.” [The Gazette, 5/11/21]
Some Iowans Said They Were “Denied Necessary Health Care” When Medicaid Was Privatized. “But the abrupt exits of those previous insurers resulted in upheavals for Medicaid member services, patients and advocates say. Early on, Iowans claimed they were denied necessary health care and providers complained they failed to receive full or partial reimbursement for their services. At one stage, the Iowa Ombudsman’s Office assigned a full-time staff member to respond to Iowans’ complaints about the managed-care program, Ombudsman Kristie Hirschman said in 2017.” [The Gazette, 5/11/21]
- The Gazette Reported That “Challenges Plagued [Iowa’s Managed-Care Medicaid] Program Since Day One” And Continued When The Program Switched Management. “This year marks the fifth anniversary since Iowa overhauled its Medicaid program, moving it from a state-run system to a managed-care model that handed the reins over to private, out-of-state insurance companies. […] Challenges plagued program since day one. The switch to managed care didn’t happen without what one state official at the time described as bumps in the road. Even before the switch, the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention stepped in to delay the transition over concerns about the state’s readiness. Federal health officials gave their approval in early 2016, and the program switched management on April 1 of that year. Challenges continued to plague the program. Managed-care organizations left the program due to what they described as chronic underfunding, starting with the exit of AmeriHealth Caritas in late 2017 and followed by UnitedHealthcare of the River Valley in 2019. Two managed-care organizations, Amerigroup and Iowa Total Care, currently manage the program. State officials say a third insurer may be brought into the program as they approach contract negotiations for Amerigroup, whose current contract is scheduled to expire in mid-2023. But the abrupt exits of those previous insurers resulted in upheavals for Medicaid member services, patients and advocates say” [The Gazette, 5/11/21]
Medicaid Recipients, Including People With Disabilities, Saw Their Services Severely Reduced, While Some Were “Trapped In Endless Appeals”
Private Insurers Failing To Comply With Their Contracts Meant Recipients Were “Going Without Services, Such As Bathing And Wound Care.” “Sand also reported that the two companies managing the Medicaid program, Amerigroup and Centene Corp., operating as Iowa Total Care, violated provisions of the contract established with the DHS. He said Amerigroup failed to comply with one provision of the contract, and ITC failed to comply with numerous provisions. For example, in multiple documented instances, both companies failed to comply with the contract clause requiring Home and Community Based Services providers to continue providing services to a member switching from one provider to another. ‘This has resulted in members going without services, such as bathing and wound care, thus violating the contract, and state and federal law, while the company still receives payment for their care,’ Sand said in the report.” [ABC News, 10/20/21]
One Complaint To The Iowa Office Of Ombudsman Said That A Man Who Was Quadriplegic And Receiving At-Home Care Had His Services Reduced “By More Than 70 Percent.” “The Iowa Office of Ombudsman said in its annual report that it received more than 225 complaints last year related to the private health insurance companies that run the state’s Medicaid program for the poor and disabled. […] One involved a quadriplegic receiving at-home care whose monthly services were reduced by more than 70 percent, even though his private insurance company had not cited any evidence that his condition had improved.” [Associated Press, 4/2/18]
Another Medicaid Recipient, A Man With A Severe Brain Injury Induced By A Crash, Sued The State After His Home Help Budget Was Reduced By 50% Due To Medicaid Privatization. “Iowa is one of 38 states that radically changed the way it runs Medicaid over the past few years. The state moved about 600,000 people on the government-run health program into care that is managed by for-profit insurance companies. The idea is that the private companies would save the state money, but it has been a rocky transition in Iowa, especially for people like Neal Siegel. Siegel is one of six disabled Iowans suing the state, alleging that Medicaid managed care, as it is known, deprives thousands of Iowans with disabilities the right to live safely in their homes. […] Then last year, Wargo says, they got a letter in the mail from AmeriHealth Caritas, the company that manages his care. Siegel's budget for home help had been slashed by 50 percent, Wargo says.” [NPR, 10/7/17]
Des Moines Register: Many Disabled Iowans Complained About Privatized Medicaid MCOs Repeatedly Trying To Cut Their Care, Leaving Them “Trapped In Endless Appeals.” “Campbell is among scores of disabled Iowans who have complained about Medicaid managed-care companies trying to save money by cutting the assistance they receive at home. Some, like Campbell, have won on appeal - only to see those same Medicaid managers later try to cut their care again. They find themselves trapped in endless appeals, according to a quarterly report by Iowa's Long-term Care Ombudsman […] Campbell was one of the first disabled Iowans the Des Moines Register featured last year in its reporting on how for-profit companies were running Iowa's $5 billion Medicaid program, which serves roughly 600,000 clients. Since then, many other Iowans have come forward to recount similar struggles. He suspects the managed-care companies hope Iowans like him will become discouraged and stop appealing such cuts.” [Des Moines Register, 7/6/18]
2019: The U.S. Office Of Inspector General Investigated Medicaid Firms For Allegedly Denying Iowans Health Care
April 2019: Denial Of Health Care Claims Under Privatized Medicaid Prompted Federal Investigation By The U.S. Office Of Inspector General. “Federal officials have launched an investigation into the insurance companies that contract with several states across the country to oversee Medicaid managed-care programs, including Iowa's. On Wednesday, the U.S. Office of Inspector General announced a review of medical and dental services and drug prescription denials by the managed-care organizations that oversee Medicaid members' care. In Medicaid contract agreements, financial risk for the cost of Medicaid services is shifted from state and federal governments to the managed-care organizations, the Inspector General's Office wrote in a news release. This shift ‘can create an incentive to deny beneficiaries' access to covered services.’ The Inspector General added that state Medicaid agencies and the federal government are responsible for the financial risk associated with Medicaid services and that managed-care organizations must ensure beneficiaries receive covered services.” [The Gazette, 4/17/19]
April 2019: Des Moines Register Headline: “Feds To Investigate Whether Medicaid Firms Are Unfairly Denying Care To Disabled People.” [Des Moines Register, 4/17/19]
April 2019: Des Moines Register: “Federal Investigators Will Look Into Whether Private Medicaid Management Companies, Including Those Covering More Than 600,000 Poor Or Disabled Iowans, Are Unfairly Denying Services.” “Federal investigators will look into whether private Medicaid management companies, including those covering more than 600,000 poor or disabled Iowans, are unfairly denying services. […] The federal agency’s Office of Inspector General agreed to look into the matter. A listing on its website says a report could be expected in 2020.” [Des Moines Register, 4/17/19]