Joe Mitchell Supported The One Big Beautiful Bill, Which Gave Billions In Tax Breaks To The Ultra-Wealthy At The Expense Of Working Families And In The Iowa State Legislature He Voted Twice To Cut Taxes For The State’s Wealthiest Individuals

2022: Mitchell Voted To Cut Taxes For Iowa’s Wealthiest Individuals And Said The State Should Not “Penalize People For Being Successful”

2022: Mitchell Voted For H.F. 2317, A Bill Eliminating Iowa’s Four Tax Brackets To Phase In A Flat Tax

February 2022: Mitchell Voted For H.F. 2317. In February 2022, Mitchell voted for H.F. 2317: “A bill for an act relating to state revenue and finance by modifying the individual income tax, making appropriations, and including effective date and applicability provisions.” The bill passed the House (61-34) and was signed into law by Governor Reynolds in March 2022. [Iowa Legislature, H.F. 2317, 2/16/22]

  • H.F. 2317 Created A Single Income Tax Bracket That Would Reduce Taxes Over Time To Reach A Flat 3.9% Rate By 2026. “House File 2317 is the result of negotiations among Republicans in the House and Senate, as well as the governor’s office. It would create a single income tax bracket for all Iowans, lower the corporate tax rate, eliminate taxes on retirement income and reduce some corporate tax exemptions. […] The most significant change is an income tax cut: Iowans, regardless of income, would pay the same 3.9% rate. […] Under current law, Iowa would have four tax brackets in 2023, with the lowest earners paying 4.4%. The bill still divides Iowa into four tax brackets for 2023, the first step in a gradual process to a flat rate in 2026.” [Iowa Capital Dispatch, 2/24/22]
  • One State Senator Who Opposed The Bill Presented Evidence That Iowans Making More Than $1 Million Annually Would See A Higher Reduction In Their Taxes Than Earners Making $68,000, The Median Household Income In Iowa. “Most Democrats were opposed to the tax cut package, arguing the flat income tax rate and corporate cuts would unfairly prioritize the highest-earning Iowans. Sen. Zach Wahls presented data on the median household income in Iowa – earners who make $68,000. He said those individuals would see their state taxes reduced by about $563 under the plan. Meanwhile, Iowans who earn more than $1 million annually would see a much higher reduction.” [Iowa Capital Dispatch, 2/24/22]

Iowa’s State Budget Was Expected To Suffer A $1.9 Billion Hit, As The Tax Cuts Disproportionately Benefited The Wealthiest Iowans

According To The Nonpartisan Legislative Services Agency (LSA), Under H.F. 2317, Iowa’s State Budget Was Expected To Lose $1.9 Billion Per Year. “Iowans would pay a 3.9% income tax under a massive tax bill passed Thursday by the Iowa Legislature, part of what GOP leaders called the ‘largest tax cut in Iowa history.’ ‘This transformative legislation is the greatest act of social justice that we have done here in the six years that I have been here,’ said Rep. Jon Jacobsen, R-Council Bluffs, who delayed a trip to his daughter’s wedding to vote on the bill. House File 2317 is the result of negotiations among Republicans in the House and Senate, as well as the governor’s office. It would create a single income tax bracket for all Iowans, lower the corporate tax rate, eliminate taxes on retirement income and reduce some corporate tax exemptions. The nonpartisan Legislative Services Agency (LSA) estimates the bill would result in a reduction of $1.9 billion per year in tax revenues going to the state’s general fund. It would mean a $1.7 billion income tax cut for Iowans and a $230 million reduction in the corporate tax rate when changes are fully implemented in fiscal year 2028.” [Iowa Capital Dispatch, 2/24/22]

2024: The Center On Budget And Policy Priorities: “Millionaires In Iowa Will See An Average Tax Cut Of $23,471, While Households Earning Under $20,000 Will Receive Just $24 On Average — A Disparity Of Over 900 Times.” “The 3.8 percent flat income tax structure benefits Iowa’s wealthiest residents far more than low- and middle-income families, who already pay a greater share of their income in state and local taxes than the wealthy. Recent estimates from the state’s Department of Revenue show that nearly half of the tax benefits go to the top 5 percent of taxpayers. Millionaires in Iowa will see an average tax cut of $23,471, while households earning under $20,000 will receive just $24 on average — a disparity of over 900 times.” [Center On Budget And Policy Priorities, 11/11/24]

Estimates From The Iowa Department of Revenue Showed Nearly Half Of The State’s Tax Benefits Were Going To The Top 5% Of Taxpayers. “The 3.8 percent flat income tax structure benefits Iowa’s wealthiest residents far more than low- and middle-income families, who already pay a greater share of their income in state and local taxes than the wealthy. Recent estimates from the state’s Department of Revenue show that nearly half of the tax benefits go to the top 5 percent of taxpayers. Millionaires in Iowa will see an average tax cut of $23,471, while households earning under $20,000 will receive just $24 on average — a disparity of over 900 times.” [Center On Budget And Policy Priorities, 11/11/24]

Center On Budget And Policy Priorities: “Iowa’s 2022 Tax Cut Experiment Is Already Showing The Strains On Public Resources, Limiting The State’s Ability To Invest In Critical Needs For Iowa Families And Communities.” “Iowa’s 2022 tax cut experiment is already showing the strains on public resources, limiting the state’s ability to invest in critical needs for Iowa families and communities. The scale of revenue loss Iowa is already experiencing — an 11 percent reduction over two years — is comparable to Kansas’ disastrous tax cuts a decade ago.” [Center On Budget And Policy Priorities, 11/11/24]

Mitchell Touted The Passage Of Iowa’s Flat Tax Saying The State Should Not “Penalize People For Being Successful”

Mitchtell Touted The Passage Of A Bill Eliminating Iowa’s Income Tax Brackets, Saying The State Should Not “Penalize People For Being Successful.” “During his opening remarks, Mitchell touted the House's recent passage of a bill to gradually adopt a flat income tax of 4 percent in the next four years. This would eliminate the state's current tax brackets, of which there are nine ranging from less than 1 percent to 8.53 percent. The bill would also eliminate taxes on retirement income, give tax breaks to retired farmers and people who retire from employee-owned companies. Mitchell said he feels good about being able to ‘give money back to Iowans’ instead of finding new ways to spend the state's $1 billion surplus. ‘It's not for us to go on a spending spree,’ he said. Keosauqua resident Tom O'Donnell asked the legislators why they favored a flat tax. […] ‘To get more people, we need a competitive tax environment,’ Shipley said. Mitchell echoed Shipley's comments, saying the state should not ‘penalize people for being successful.’ He also brought up how Iowa's taxes compare to neighboring states. ‘Illinois has lower taxes than us. That's crazy,’ Mitchell said.” [Southeast Iowa Union, 2/21/22]

2021: Mitchell Voted To Cut Taxes For The Highest Income Bracket And Phase Out Iowa’s Inheritance Taxes

May 2021: Mitchell Voted For S.F. 619. In May 2021, Mitchell voted for S.F. 619: “A bill for an act relating to state and local revenue and finance by modifying future tax contingencies, the state inheritance tax, the sales and use tax relating to food banks, the tax on promotional play receipts, the sales and use tax relating to food banks, the tax on promotional play receipts, mental health and disability services funding, school district funding, commercial and industrial property tax replacement payments, providing for housing incentives, providing for other properly related matters, making appropriations, and including effective date, applicability, and retroactive applicability provisions.” The bill passed the House (64-28) and was signed into law by Governor Reyolds in June 2021. [Iowa State Legislature, S.F. 619, 5/18/21]

  • S.F. 619 Reduced The Top Individual Income Tax Rate From 8.53% To 6.5%, Cut The Number Of Tax Brackets From Nine To Four, And Phased Out Iowa’s Inheritance Tax. “In the final days of the session, the law, Senate File 619, passed the Senate with a 29-15 vote and passed the House 64-28. […] The law will also ensure income tax cuts passed in a 2018 law take place as scheduled by eliminating a requirement that the state meet revenue growth goals before the cuts can take effect. More: Kim Reynolds wants more tax cuts, and she wants to do that by removing the 'triggers.' What does that mean? Iowans will now see the following tax changes go into effect Jan. 1, 2023: The top individual income tax rate will drop from 8.53% to 6.5%. The number of Iowa income tax brackets will fall from nine to four. The ability to deduct individual income taxes paid to the federal government will go away, which could add to some Iowans' tax bills. The law will also phase out Iowa's inheritance tax by Jan. 1, 2025.” [Des Moines Register, 6/16/21]

Institute On Taxation And Economic Policy: The One Big Beautiful Bill Would Give The Richest 1% Of Americans $117 Billion In Net Tax Cuts In 2026

Institute On Taxation And Economic Policy: The House-Passed Reconciliation Bill Would Give The Richest 1% Of Americans $117 Billion In Net Tax Cuts In 2026. “The House of Representatives today narrowly passed a massive tax and spending reconciliation bill that now heads to President Trump’s desk. Please see below for a statement from ITEP and our latest updated analysis of how the bill’s tax provisions will affect families at different income levels nationally and in every state. […] The richest 1 percent of Americans would receive a total of $117 billion in net tax cuts in 2026. The middle 20 percent of taxpayers on the income scale, a group that has 20 times the number of taxpayers as the richest 1 percent, would receive less than half that much, $53 billion in net tax cuts that year.” [Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, 7/3/24]

The One Big Beautiful Bill’s Biggest Tax Cuts Benefited The Wealthiest Giving Them Tax Cuts Three Times Greater Than For Working Americans

The One Big Beautiful Bill’s Biggest Tax Cuts Benefited The Wealthiest. “The One Big Beautiful Bill includes the largest tax cuts in U.S. history. Whether it’s actually ‘beautiful’ is in the eye of the beholder. At every income level taxes should subside. That’s a big selling point from President Donald Trump and fellow Republicans who pushed the law through Congress with no Democratic support. It will benefit everyone. But the biggest cuts go to the wealthiest taxpayers – the ones who pay the lion’s share of taxes. For most families the savings will be miniscule in comparison, in raw dollars and as a share of income. And millions will lose subsidized health insurance and other benefits. Critics see a plan that widens income inequality and, worse, offsets tax cuts for the wealthy with draconian spending cuts that hit lower-income households.” [Cronkite News, 7/16/25]

The House-Passed Republican Reconciliation Bill Extended The Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Which Skewed In Favor Of The Wealthy By Providing Them Tax Cuts That Were Three Times Greater Than For Working Americans. “The tax provisions of the House Republican reconciliation bill double down on the failures of the 2017 tax law, which was skewed in favor of the richest people in the country, further eroded the nation’s revenue base, and didn’t produce the promised economic gains for working people.[1] Instead of changing course and prioritizing people with low and moderate incomes as House Republicans’ rhetoric about supporting hard-pressed working families would suggest, the House Republican tax bill only offers more of the same. The bill is heavily skewed to the wealthy: Under the bill, the top 1 percent of people would receive tax cuts three times the size of those for people with incomes in the bottom 60 percent, measured as a share of after-tax income. (See Figure 1.) The top 0.6 percent of people — the 1.2 million people with annual incomes above $1 million — would receive more total tax cuts than the 127 million people with incomes below $100,000. […] The bill extends and expands the 2017 tax law’s increase in the estate tax exemption, boosting the cut in estate taxes for the 1 in 1,000 wealthiest estates to $6.3 million.[3] Next year a couple could pass on an estate worth up to $30 million tax free, $1.7 million more than under a simple extension of the 2017 law.” [CBPP, 5/22/25]

CBS: “Like Penn Wharton, Other Researchers Have Said The Republican Bill Is Likely To Benefit Wealthy Americans At The Expense Of People Lower Down The Ladder.” “Like Penn Wharton, other researchers have said the Republican bill is likely to benefit wealthy Americans at the expense of people lower down the ladder. The measure would likely reduce the financial resources available to the lowest-earning 10% of U.S. households by $1,600 per year, or almost 4% of their annual income, according to a report published earlier this month by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. White House officials have previously questioned the CBO's scoring of the bill. But the highest-earning 10% of households would see a gain of $12,000 per year in resources, while middle-income households would see a gain of $500 to $1,000, the CBO projected. Its analysis is based on the bill's tax breaks, as well as reductions for federal programs and reductions in state funds for safety net programs such as Medicaid and food stamps. In considering the impact of higher U.S. debt on future generations, the cost would come in the form of lower wages and higher costs, such as more expensive mortgages, Smetters said.” [CBS News, 6/26/25]

The Hill: “The Republicans’ ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ Will Make The Poorest Americans Even Poorer, While Padding The Wallets Of The Highest Earners The Most, According To An Analysis Released Monday By Congress’s Budget Arm.” “The Republicans’ ‘big, beautiful bill’ will make the poorest Americans even poorer, while padding the wallets of the highest earners the most, according to an analysis released Monday by Congress’s budget arm. The assessment, conducted by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) at the request of top Democrats, found that the top 10 percent of earners in the country will see an average boost of $13,600 per year over the next decade as a direct result of provisions in the law, while the bottom 10 percent will see an average annual decrease of $1,200. The report challenges the arguments made by President Trump and other Republicans that the massive domestic policy package would benefit workers at all levels of wealth and income. And it’s given fuel to the attacks from Democrats that the legislation was, all along, designed to help the wealthiest people at the expense of the working poor.” [The Hill, 8/11/25]

  • The Hil Headline: “Budget Office Says GOP’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ Will Make Rich Richer, Poor Poorer.” [Hill, 8/11/25]

Source report (PDF)