Paul LePage: 2013 BIENNIAL BUDGET
2013: LePage Budget Proposal Eliminated Revenue Sharing with Municipalities, Removed Most Homestead Exemptions. In 2013 LePage “proposed a complete suspension of municipal revenue sharing for the next two years as part of its plan to balance the current state budget and pay for state services without new taxes. Stopping revenue-sharing payments to cities and towns would save $98.9 million each in fiscal years 2014 and 2015, according to the governor's office. The $6.3 billion proposal also eliminates the homestead property tax exemption and circuit breaker program for everyone except people older than 65 and veterans.” [Bangor Daily News, 1/11/13]
- Over 100 Local Officials Opposed to LePage Budget, Said it Would Balloon Property Taxes. LePage’s “proposed $6.3 billion two-year state budget would balloon property taxes, slash municipal services and make Maine businesses less competitive. That was the message delivered to the Legislature's tax and budget-writing committees
Wednesday by more than 100 local officials, businesses and others affected by the governor's plan.” [Kennebec Journal, 3/14/13]
- “Of the Different Types Of Taxes, The Property Tax Hit Lower-Income Residents Hardest.” The Bangor Daily News reported, “Forty-three percent of all taxes collected in Maine in 2009 were property taxes, both residential and commercial, according to Maine Revenue Services data. Income and consumption taxes accounted for 28 percent each of total tax collections… Of the different types of taxes, the property tax hit lower-income residents hardest, Maine Revenue Services data show.” [Bangor Daily News, 2/22/13]
- Kennebec Journal Editorial: Previous LePage Budget Promises Now Being Paid for on Backs of Local Governments. The Kennebec Journal wrote of LePage’s budget promises, “we were skeptical when Gov. Paul LePage and legislative allies touted the ‘biggest tax cut in Maine history’ in 2011 and bragged that it put money in the pocket of almost all Mainers, particularly middle- and lower-income workers, including thousands who would now pay ‘no tax at all.’ Impressive if true, but, of course, it's not. Not even close… The uneven distribution of the tax burden was brought home this year when LePage told us how he would pay for his tax cuts. He proposed cuts to municipal revenue sharing, cuts to property taxpayer relief programs, cuts to General Assistance, cuts to teacher retirement contributions and flat education funding -- all designed to balance the books by shifting responsibility from the state to local governments, inevitably raising taxes on the people the governor claims to have helped.” [Kennebec Journal editorial, 4/28/13]
- Portland Press Herald Editorial: Taking Money from Municipalities “Not the Answer.” The Press Herald opined of LePage’s claim he had no choice but to cut revenue sharing in the 2013 budget, when he had previously pushed tax cuts in the last budget. The Herald wrote, “These tax cuts have been touted as having broad benefits, but that is not the whole story. Taxpayers at the lower end of the income scale are getting a break, but nowhere near as much as they would lose if their rent or municipal property tax was hiked to pay for the state withholding revenue sharing. The trade-off would be equally bad for low-income and middle -income Mainers who got a few hundred dollars more in their paychecks but lost their health insurance or aid for a disabled child so what the governor calls ‘job creators’ can get a tax cut they don't need. The governor made a strong case, but it may not be the one he was trying to make. Lawmakers from both parties are going to need more revenue to balance this budget and taking it from municipalities is not the answer.” [Portland Press Herald editorial, 2/7/13]
- HEADLINE: LePage, as Mayor, Decried Budget Shift LePage, as Governor, Calls Necessary. The Kennebec Journal reported, “Many continue to lament Gov. Paul LePage's proposal to cut more than $400 million from revenue sharing to municipalities in his budget for the next two budget years… But as mayor, LePage also liked state funding. For example, he clashed with the administration of Gov. John Baldacci in 2009 when the state changed the way it reimbursed schools, leaving Waterville with likely $1.1 million less in funding than it expected. That change was
discovered days before LePage announced his 2010 gubernatorial run… ‘All they're doing is transferring state responsibility onto taxpayers, and people keep falling for this governor's bull--,’ he was quoted as saying.” [Kennebec Journal, 2/10/13]
HEADLINE: LePage's Proposed Budget Includes Income Tax Increase. The Kennebec Journal reported, “Gov. Paul LePage's two-year budget makes no mention of a tax increase, but it will raise the tax bill of the average Mainer by $49 over the next two years. The proposal relies on subtle but lucrative changes to the state's income tax indexing. How it would work is complicated, but the result is a projected increase of more than $8.6 million in state income tax collections over the next two fiscal years beginning July 1 and an estimated $1.5 million in the subsequent years.” [Kennebec Journal, 1/14/13]
- Conservative Tax Group Said LePage Budget Had “Stealth Tax Increase.” The Tax Foundation, which “has ties to conservative groups and is considered pro-business,” accused LePage of “of slipping a ‘stealth tax increase’ into his proposed 2014- 15 biennial budget. The foundation's analysis found that the governor's proposal to forgo adjusting income tax rates to inflation in 2014 and 2015 will raise average tax rates ‘in all cases.’” [Sun Journal, 2/7/13]
Editorial: LePage Budget “Passing the Buck to the Taxpayer.” Seacoast Online opined of LePage’s 2013 budget, “We understand Maine is in a tough position, with high unemployment and tepid economic growth predicted. But there needs to be a better solution than this age-old regressive one of passing the buck to the taxpayer. For instance, LePage calls for a reduction of 200 state workers. According to the Maine Department of Labor, the state employed more than 23,500 people in 2011. With a population of slightly less than 1 million, that's more than 2 percent of all of the state's residents. The Legislature needs to take a hard look at this in the months to come. We value our school and municipal employees, who are already too few due to recent flat budgets, and we believe they deserve to remain employed. And their salaries should not be paid by skyrocketing property taxes to offset these draconian budget cuts. They deserve better. The taxpayers deserve better.” [Seacoastonline.com, 1/20/13]
Editorial HEADLINE: Budget is no Place to Make Election Policy. In a 2013 editorial, the Bangor Daily News wrote, “The Maine Clean Election Act benefits voters too much to fall victim to state government’s lingering fiscal problems. The voter-approved public campaign financing system should be considered on its merits as a tool for democracy, not as a state budget line competing for scarce government funds. Jonathan Wayne, executive director of the Maine Ethics Commission, warned the Legislature’s budget-writing Appropriations Committee last week that Gov. Paul LePage’s proposal to cut a total of $4 million in state funding for the Maine Clean Election Fund in the two-year budget… would eliminate the option of public campaign financing for legislative and gubernatorial candidates in 2014… the governor effectively relegated consideration of the way Maine conducts its elections to a line item on a two-year budget.” [Bangor Daily News editorial, 3/6/13]
LePage Budget Proposal Called for Altering Manufacturing Property Tax Revenue for Municipalities. The Sun Journal reported of LePage, “The governor's proposed budget eliminates the Business Equipment Tax Reimbursement, or BETR, program, a property tax relief program created by Gov. Angus King in 1995, and moves all businesses -- except retail -- into the Business Equipment Tax Exemption, or BETE… here's the difference in a nutshell: The BETR program reimburses a business for property taxes it paid to the municipality, while the BETE program exempts businesses from having to pay the property taxes in the first place and instead reimburses the municipalities for the lost revenue.” [Sun Journal, 1/17/13]
- Administration Claimed Change Would Benefit Businesses While Local Governments Did Not “Buy it.” The Sun Journal reported, “The administration claims the elimination of BETR and expanding BETE will streamline the ‘cumbersome’ process for the businesses, the municipalities that collect the property taxes and the state, which handles the reimbursements… [government relations director of the Maine Municipal Association Geoff] Herman doesn't buy it: ‘That argument doesn't weigh very much against the loss of $10 million annually in a couple dozen municipalities across the state,’ he said.” [Sun Journal, 1/17/13]
Gov. Paul Lepage’s Proposed $6.3 Billion Two- Year State Budget Would Balloon Property Taxes, Slash Municipal Services And Make Maine Businesses Less Competitive. “Gov. Paul LePage’s proposed $6.3 billion two- year state budget would balloon property taxes, slash municipal services and make Maine businesses less competitive. That was the message delivered to the Legislature’s tax and budget- writing committees…by more than 100 local officials, businesses and others affected by the governor’s plan.” (Kennebec Journal, 03/14/13)
LePage’s Office Said His Budget Included a Proposal to Completely Suspend Municipal Revenue Sharing for Two Years, Saving $98.9 Million in FYs 2014 and 2015. It included a proposal to completely suspend “municipal revenue sharing for…two years as part of its plan to balance the current state budget and pay for state services without new taxes. Stopping revenue-sharing payments to cities and towns would save $98.9 million each in fiscal years 2014 and 2015, according to the governor’s office.” (Bangor Daily News, 01/11/13)
- Augusta Mayor Said LePage’s Budget Would Force Cities and Towns to Raise Property Taxes. Augusta “Mayor William Stokes said cities and towns will be forced to raise property taxes if the Legislature approves Gov. Paul LePage’s proposal to eliminate state revenue sharing payments for two years.” “‘We have no other source of revenue except through the property tax. It’s a way of shifting costs to the most regressive form of taxation the state has, the property tax,’” he said. (Kennebec Journal, 01/12/13)
- Mike Tipping: Municipalities Will Be Forced to Increase Property Taxes in Order to Maintain Basic Services…Will Increase Taxes Most on the Poor and the Middle Class.” Mike Tipping wrote in the Kennebec Journal, “this shifting of the burden to municipalities…represents a large part of the new LePage tax increase. Faced with the huge budget shortfalls that this proposal would cause…municipalities will be forced to increase property taxes in order to maintain basic services. This regressive move will increase taxes most on the poor and the middle class.” “Property taxes aren’t the only taxes that would be increased if LePage got his way.” “LePage’s budget proposal adds some new taxes, including a tax on the sale of newspapers and other types of published periodicals.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/24/13)
LePage’s Budget Proposal Included “Eliminating The Tax Exemption For Newspapers And Other Publications Issued At Least Four Times A Year.” More specifically, it included “eliminating the tax exemption for newspapers and other publications issued at least four times a year.” “His budget proposal also changes the indexing process for the income tax in a way that will disproportionately affect the poor.” (Kennebec Journal, 01/22/13)
Tax Foundation Found a “Stealth Tax Increase” in LePage’s Budget Proposal, Finding That His Proposal to “Forgo Adjusting Income Tax Rates To Inflation In 2014 And 2015 Will Raise Average Tax Rates ‘In All Cases.’” “The Tax Foundation…accused Gov. Paul LePage of slipping a ‘stealth tax increase’ into his proposed 2014-15 biennial budget. The foundation’s analysis found that the governor’s proposal to forgo adjusting income tax rates to inflation in 2014 and 2015 will raise average tax rates ‘in all cases.’” (Bangor Daily News, 02/06/13)
LePage’s Budget Proposal Would “Raise The Tax Bill Of The Average Mainer By $49 Over The Next Two Years” According to LePage’s Associate Commissioner of Tax Policy. The income tax part of this proposal will “raise the tax bill of the average Mainer by $49 over the next two years.” “If the Legislature approves the plan, average Mainers who pay income taxes will see a combined two-year increase of $49 in their tax bills, according to Michael Allen, LePage’s associate commissioner of tax policy.” (Kennebec Journal, 01/15/13)
LePage’s Budget Included Eliminating the Business Equipment Tax Reimbursement Program – Maine’s Paper Companies Opposed the Measure. An early 2013 legislative hearing “included testimony from some of the state’s largest businesses opposing LePage’s plan to eliminate the Business Equipment Tax Reimbursement program, or BETR. The governor wants to replace the 1995 program with the Business Equipment Tax Exemption, BETE. Both programs reimburse businesses for taxes paid to municipalities on equipment investments. Many business representatives who testified…support the transition to BETE because it maintains a higher reimbursement rate than the older program. Their opposition stems from the governor’s plan to suspend BETR payments for one year, a proposal that would cost businesses participating in the program a combined $38.8 million. According to budget documents prepared by Maine Revenue Services, the measure would save the state $11.8 million.” “Maine paper companies, among the heaviest users of the program, according to Maine Revenue Services data, were united in opposing the measure.” “Ed Snook, with B&M, said the program leveled the playing field with other states. Suspending the reimbursement even for a year could be viewed as a tax increase by B&M’s parent company, B&G Foods Inc., possibly resulting in job cuts, he said. The argument was repeated by more than a dozen businesses and their advocates, including the Maine State Chamber of Commerce and Portland Regional Chamber of Commerce.” (Kennebec Journal, 03/14/13)
“The $6.3 Billion Proposal…Eliminates The Homestead Property Tax Exemption And Circuit Breaker Program For Everyone Except People Older Than 65 And Veterans.” “The $6.3 billion proposal…eliminates the homestead property tax exemption and circuit breaker program for everyone except people older than 65 and veterans.” (Bangor Daily News, 01/11/13)
“The Only People Who Seem To Be Protected From Disproportionate Tax Increases In Lepage’s Budget Are Wealthy Individuals And Corporations. These Privileged Groups Get To Keep The Massive New Tax Breaks That Lepage And The Republican Legislature Gave Them In The…[Previous] Budget.” “The only people who seem to be protected from disproportionate tax increases in LePage’s budget are wealthy individuals and corporations. These privileged groups get to keep the massive new tax breaks that LePage and the Republican Legislature gave them in the last budget.” (Kennebec Journal, 01/22/13)
Lewiston Sun Journal Editorial: “Governor Has Chosen Tax Increases.” The Lewiston Sun Journal opined in an editorial titled, “Governor has chosen tax increases,” Governor “Paul LePage is all about hiking taxes, property taxes,” in reference to his proposals to eliminate the homestead property tax exemption and circuit breaker for most Mainers. “While the governor may tell himself he is not proposing to raise taxes, when you start cutting tax discounts for property taxpayers you are increasing what they pay. And that, in anyone’s book, is a tax increase.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/27/13)
Lewiston Sun Journal Editorial: “Governor Paul LePage is All About Hiking Taxes, Property Taxes…While the Governor May Tell Himself He is Not Proposing to Raise Taxes, When You Start Cutting Tax Discounts for Property Taxpayers You Are Increasing What They Pay. And That, in Anyone’s Book, is a Tax Increase.” The Lewiston Sun Journal opined in an editorial titled, “Governor has chosen tax increases,” Governor “Paul LePage is all about hiking taxes, property taxes,” in reference to his proposals to eliminate the homestead property tax exemption and circuit breaker for most Mainers. “While the governor may tell himself he is not proposing to raise taxes, when you start cutting tax discounts for property taxpayers you are increasing what they pay. And that, in anyone’s book, is a tax increase.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/27/13)
Tax Foundation “Suggests That Lepage’s Proposal To Switch In 2016 To A Practice Called ‘Chained Consumer Price Indexing’ Would Adversely Affect Taxpayers” By Causing “Taxes To Increase Faster Than Under The Method Currently Used.” In addition, the Tax Foundation “suggests that LePage’s proposal to switch in 2016 to a practice called ‘chained consumer price indexing’ would adversely affect taxpayers” by causing “taxes to increase faster than under the method currently used.” (Bangor Daily News, 02/06/13)
LePage Budget Included A Change in Funding to General Purpose K-12 Aid “That Will Force Local Taxpayers to Pick Up Some of the Costs.” This budget proposal also included “flat-funding General Purpose Aid to K-12 public education at $895 million annually, which reflects the current year’s total allowance after the curtailment LePage announced” in late December 2012. It also included “shifting the responsibility for funding teacher pensions from a 100 percent state commitment to a shared responsibility between the state and local districts, a move that will force local taxpayers to pick up some of the costs.” (Bangor Daily News, 01/11/13)
Paul Lepage, In January 2013, Proposed A Budget That Did Not Increase Funding For Public Schools. Paul LePage, in January 2013, proposed a budget that would flat-fund education. “Funding for public schools and higher education will remain flat in the next two years if Gov. Paul LePage’s $6.3 billion biennial budget proposal makes it through the Legislature unscathed.” (Bangor Daily News, 01/11/13)
- “Among 230 School Units In Maine, All But 72 Are Projected To Have Less State Funding To Work With Next Year.” Paul LePage “proposed shifting $28.9 million in pension contributions from the state onto Maine public schools, then offsetting half of the cost with a $14.5 million increase in General Purpose Aid to schools.” “Among 230 school units in Maine, all but 72 are projected to have less state funding to work with next year once the retirement contributions are subtracted from their state aid.” (Kennebec Journal, 02/23/13)
LePage’s Budget Proposed Shifting $28.9 Million in Pension Contributions From the State Onto Maine Public Schools. Paul LePage “proposed shifting $28.9 million in pension contributions from the state onto Maine public schools, then offsetting half of the cost with a $14.5 million increase in General Purpose Aid to schools.” “Among 230 school units in Maine, all but 72 are projected to have less state funding to work with next year once the retirement contributions are subtracted from their state aid.” (Kennebec Journal, 02/23/13)
Paul Lepage, In January 2013, Proposed A Budget That Did Not Increase Funding For Higher Education. Paul LePage, in January 2013, proposed a budget that would flat-fund education. “Funding for public schools and higher education will remain flat in the next two years if Gov. Paul LePage’s $6.3 billion biennial budget proposal makes it through the Legislature unscathed.” (Bangor Daily News, 01/11/13)
Enacted Budget – Passed Over Paul LePage’s Veto
LePage Vetoed Budget. The Sun Journal reported in June 2013, “LePage made good on long-standing threats to veto a two-year state budget proposal unanimously endorsed by a legislative committee. In his veto letter to the Legislature, LePage called the budget ‘an opportunity missed,’ criticizing tax increases and education funding in the proposal, while Democrats vow they have the votes to override the governor… LePage has threatened a veto since the budget came out of committee.” [Morning Sentinel, 6/25/13]
Maine Legislature Overrode LePage’s Budget Veto. In 2013 the Maine House and Senate voted “to override Republican Gov. Paul LePage’s veto of the two-year, $6.3 billion state budget, avoiding a state government shutdown and temporarily raising sales, meals and lodging taxes… The biennial budget, because it was passed so late in the legislative session and is considered an emergency measure, required a two-thirds vote in the House and Senate to take effect by the July 1 start of the new fiscal year… The votes to override the budget veto put legislators in a position Wednesday to divvy up about $1.25 million for roughly 130 bills that passed without dedicated funding. The bills that gain funding will go to LePage, who could veto them, sign them or let them take effect without his signature.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/26/13]
- Budget Avoided Most of the Revenue Sharing Cuts. “The 13-member Appropriations Committee wrote a unanimously supported package that avoids nearly 65 percent of the revenue sharing cuts and restores some property tax relief — in part by raising the sales
tax from 5 percent to 5.5 percent, and meals and lodging taxes from 7 percent to 8 percent until July 1, 2015. The lawmakers also introduced a $30 million boost in spending on public schools and funds to restore merit and longevity pay for state workers who have had their salaries frozen for more than four years.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/26/13]