Paul LePage: 2017 BIENNIAL BUDGET & SHUTDOWN

Gov. Paul LePage’s Proposed Budget

Governor LePage Proposed Cutting The State Workforce By 500 In His Budget Proposal. “In his budget proposal unveiled in January, LePage wants to cut income and corporate taxes, reduce the state workforce by 500, further reduce welfare rolls and fundamentally change the state's education funding formula. He also proposed nullifying the 3 percent surcharge on wealthy Mainers by setting the top tax rate at 7.15 percent this year, down from the current 10.15 percent on earnings above $200,000. And by 2020, all taxpayers would be paying a flat tax of 5.75 percent under LePage's plan.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/7/17]

Governor LePage Proposed Cutting Welfare Rolls In His Budget Proposal. “In his budget proposal unveiled in January, LePage wants to cut income and corporate taxes, reduce the state workforce by 500, further reduce welfare rolls and fundamentally change the state's education funding formula. He also proposed nullifying the 3 percent surcharge on wealthy Mainers by setting the top tax rate at 7.15 percent this year, down from the current 10.15 percent on earnings above $200,000. And by 2020, all taxpayers would be paying a flat tax of 5.75 percent under LePage's plan.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/7/17]

Governor LePage Proposed Nullifying The 3 Percent Surcharge On Wealthy Mainers That Voters Passed Via Referendum In November 2016 By Cutting The Top Tax Rate From 10.15 Percent To 7.15 Percent On Earning Above $200,000. “In his budget proposal unveiled in January, LePage wants to cut income and corporate taxes, reduce the state workforce by 500, further reduce welfare rolls and fundamentally change the state's education funding formula. He also proposed nullifying the 3 percent surcharge on wealthy Mainers by setting the top tax rate at 7.15 percent this year, down from the current 10.15 percent on earnings above $200,000. And by 2020, all taxpayers would be paying a flat tax of 5.75 percent under LePage's plan.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/7/17]

  • 11/8/16: Maine Voters Voted To Raise Taxes On High Earners By 3 Percent To Help Pay For Public Education. “Nov. 8, 2016: Maine votes to raise taxes on high earners as rural voters helped Republican Donald Trump get elected president in a schizophrenic election entrenching a divided Legislature. The 3 percent surtax on high earners for education funding passed with 51 percent of votes, Democrat Hillary Clinton won Maine's presidential race, but dropped the 2nd Congressional District to Trump and legislative Republicans and Democrats kept their respective Senate and House majorities, but with weaker margins.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

Governor LePage Proposed Cutting Income And Corporate Taxes In His Budget Proposal. “In his budget proposal unveiled in January, LePage wants to cut income and corporate taxes, reduce the state workforce by 500, further reduce welfare rolls and fundamentally change the state's education funding formula. He also proposed nullifying the 3 percent surcharge on wealthy Mainers by setting the top tax rate at 7.15 percent this year, down from the current 10.15 percent on earnings above $200,000. And by 2020, all taxpayers would be paying a flat tax of 5.75 percent under LePage's plan.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/7/17]

Governor LePage Proposed Reducing State Reimbursement Rates To Hospitals And Cut MaineCare Eligibility For 25,000 Individuals. “Also Tuesday, lawmakers on the Legislature's Appropriations and Health and Human Services committees held a joint public hearing on LePage's two-year state budget plan, considering portions of the proposal that would reduce state reimbursement rates to hospitals and reduce MaineCare eligibility for nearly 25,000 Mainers, including about 5,000 single adults ages 18 and 19. The eligibility changes alone would save the state about $140 million. House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, signaled Democrats' opposition to the plan. ‘Democrats will not sign off on a plan that would have such negative consequences in rural Maine,’ Gideon said in a written statement. ‘Critical-access hospitals are already undergoing layoffs or facing closure. We need a transformational plan for Maine's economy that involves pulling our state together, instead of deepening the divide between our rural and our urban areas.’” [Portland Press Herald, 2/21/17]

Nov. 2016 – Maine Voters Voted to Raise Taxes on High Earners to Pay for Public Education Funding

11/8/16: Maine Voters Voted To Raise Taxes On High Earners By 3 Percent To Help Pay For Public Education. “Nov. 8, 2016: Maine votes to raise taxes on high earners as rural voters helped Republican Donald Trump get elected president in a schizophrenic election entrenching a divided Legislature. The 3 percent surtax on high earners for education funding passed with 51 percent of votes, Democrat Hillary Clinton won Maine's presidential race, but dropped the 2nd Congressional District to Trump and legislative Republicans and Democrats kept their respective Senate and House majorities, but with weaker margins.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

Jan. 2017 – Gov. Paul LePage Released His Two-Year Budget Plan, Proposing Flat Income Tax and Cuts to Welfare

1/6/17: Governor LePage Released His Two-Year Budget Plan, Including A Flat Income Tax And Cuts To Welfare, Despite His Prior Similar Proposals Not Being Enacted By The Legislature. “Jan 6, 2017: LePage releases his final two-year budget plan, proposing a flat income tax by 2020 and deep welfare cuts, but it never has a chance. After the Legislature enacted two straight two-year budgets over LePage vetoes in 2013 and 2015, the governor released a proposal that contained many of his old ideas, including a flat income tax and deep welfare cuts.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

March 2017 – Maine Legislature Enacted a Supplemental Budget Funding Higher Education and Addiction Treatment

In 2017, LePage Refused to Sign a Supplemental Budget Bill. The House passed the supplemental budget package by a 142-1 vote and the Senate by a 34-0 vote, and the budget became law without Governor LePage’s signature. [State of Maine Legislature, LD 302, Roll Call #11, 3/2/17]

  • The $29 Million Budget Included $5 Million In State And Federal Funds To Fund Opioid Addiction Treatment To Low-Income And Uninsured Mainers. “This morning, members of the House of Representatives voted 142 to 1 in favor of LD 302, ‘An Act To Make Supplemental Appropriations and Allocations for the Expenditures of State Government and To Change Certain Provisions of the Law Necessary to the Proper Operations of State Government for the Fiscal Year Ending June 30, 2017.’ Later, members of the Senate voted unanimously to finally enact the budget and send it to Gov. Paul LePage. The governor has 10 days to sign it, veto it, or allow it to become law without his signature. After a push from democratic leaders, specifically an amendment offered by Sen. Cathy Breen, D-Falmouth, the supplemental budget bill now contains nearly $5 million in state and federal funds to provide opioid addiction treatment to Mainers most in need of help — the uninsured and those with low incomes. This $29 million dollar spending package also contains $7.1 million in funding to keep tuition low at the University of Maine, $7 million to the Maine Military Authority in Aroostook county, and $5.5 million to rehabilitate fish hatcheries in our Inland Fisheries & Wildlife Department. Additionally, the package moves $35 million to the state’s Rainy Day Fund.” [Press Release, Speaker Sara Gideon, 3/2/17]
  • The $29 Million Budget $7.1 Million To Keep Tuition Low At The University Of Maine, $7 Million For The Maine Military Authority, And $5.5 Million For Rehabilitation Of Fish Hatcheries. “This morning, members of the House of Representatives voted 142 to 1 in favor of LD 302, ‘An Act To Make Supplemental Appropriations and Allocations for the Expenditures of State Government and To Change Certain Provisions of the Law Necessary to the Proper Operations of State Government for the Fiscal Year Ending June 30, 2017.’ Later, members of the Senate voted unanimously to finally enact the budget and send it to Gov. Paul LePage. The governor has 10 days to sign it, veto it, or allow it to become law without his signature. After a push from democratic leaders, specifically an amendment offered by Sen. Cathy Breen, D-Falmouth, the supplemental budget bill now contains nearly $5 million in state and federal funds to provide opioid addiction treatment to Mainers most in need of help — the uninsured and those with low incomes. This $29 million dollar spending package also contains $7.1 million in funding to keep tuition low at the University of Maine, $7 million to the Maine Military Authority in Aroostook county, and $5.5 million to rehabilitate fish hatcheries in our Inland Fisheries & Wildlife Department. Additionally, the package moves $35 million to the state’s Rainy Day Fund.” [Press Release, Speaker Sara Gideon, 3/2/17]

April 2017 – Democrats Introduced Their Two-Year Budget Plan, Including New Revenue from the Voter-Approved Surtax on High Income Earners

4/6/17: Democrats Release Their Budget Proposal Called The “Opportunity Agenda,” Which Included Spending The $265 Million In New Revenue From The Voter-Approved Surtax. “April 6: Democrats roll out a countering plan, while Republicans dismiss it and say they won't accept a budget that does not repeal the voter-approved surtax. Legislative Democrats' unveiled their ‘Opportunity Agenda,’ a plan to spend $265 million in anticipated new revenue using the last budget as the framework. Much of it was directed at property tax relief. Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, called it ‘a therapy session.’” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

Republicans Said They Would Oppose Any Budget That Did Not Repeal The Voter-Passed Surtax. “April 6: Democrats roll out a countering plan, while Republicans dismiss it and say they won't accept a budget that does not repeal the voter-approved surtax. […] Republicans also dug in against the surtax, with Senate Majority Leader Garrett Mason, R-Lisbon Falls, saying his party ‘will accept nothing less than a repeal’ in the budget.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

June 2017 – Budget Negotiations Stalled Over the Future of the Voter-Passed 3% Surtax on High Income Earners

Republican Senate President Mike Thibodeau Proposed $100 Million In New Education Funding, Pulled From “Existing Resources,” Which Sara Gideon Called A Non-Starter Since It Would Result In Cuts Elsewhere. “On Wednesday, Thibodeau told reporters that Senate Republicans were proposing $100 million in new education funding in the 2018-2019 budget year, finding the money ‘within existing resources.’ The breakdown of where that money would come from is unclear: Sen. Roger Katz, R-Augusta, a member of the budget committee, said some of it would come from the Maine Department of Health and Human Services, while his caucus is also looking at ways to ‘decrease the size of state government so we can increase funding for public education.’ […] But to Democrats, that sounds like ‘cuts’ in other areas of government. House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, called that a non-starter, saying, ‘We don't think those are acceptable ways to pay for education funding.’” [Bangor Daily News, 6/1/17]

  • Republicans Offered The Additional $100 Million For Education Funding In Exchange For Killing The Voter-Approved Tax On High-Income Individuals To Fund Education, Estimated To Raise $320 Million Annually. “State budget negotiations appeared to begin in earnest Wednesday, with Senate Republicans offering to make $100 million in new funding available to schools if Democrats agree to repeal a voter-approved ballot measure to fund education through a tax on high-income earners. Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, said his party's offer satisfies the will of voters who passed the ballot referendum last fall that tacks a 3 percent surcharge on all household incomes over $200,000. Thibodeau said the $100 million annually would come from projected state revenues over the next two-year budget cycle. Thibodeau's proposal got a chilly reception from Democrats and House Republicans. Democrats, who hold the majority in the House and have 17 of the 35 seats in the Senate, said Thibodeau's offer would amount to cutting about $200 million from public schools, based on estimates that the new tax surcharge will pump up to $320 million into schools annually.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/1/17]

6/2/17: Legislative Democrats And Republicans Were Split On How To Fund Public Education At 55 Percent From The State, Either Through A 3 Percent Surtax On Income Above $200,000 Or Another Way. “Months after the Legislature first began holding public hearings on LePage's budget proposal, a major sticking point remains the voter-approved 3 percent surtax on household income above $200,000 to raise revenues for classrooms. The debate swirls around the state of Maine's tax revenues, and whether that surtax will dampen hearty revenues projected in years to come. Following concern from Republicans that the surtax is already driving away business leaders and professionals, several Democrats have said they're willing to remove the tax. But they would only agree to that, Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon said, if Republicans provide another way to reach the requirement that voters approved in 2004 to require the state to fund 55 percent of local education costs.” [Associated Press, 6/2/17]

House Speaker Sara Gideon: “Democrats Are Absolutely Ready To Consider How To Fund Education Fully With Other Revenue Sources, But We Do Not See A Way That 3 Percent (Surcharge) Is Repealed And That We Actually Pay For Education Fully With Existing Resources.” “House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, said the Republican proposal was a positive, if small, step forward. ‘Democrats are absolutely ready to consider how to fund education fully with other revenue sources, but we do not see a way that 3 percent (surcharge) is repealed and that we actually pay for education fully with existing resources,’ she said. ‘It's just not possible without what we believe are probably very detrimental cuts to programs that all of us care about - we are open to see what the proposal is - but right now we are still hundreds of millions of dollars apart.’” [Portland Press Herald, 6/1/17]

6/2/17: Speaker Sara Gideon Said Democrats Would Be Open To Scrapping The 3 Percent Surtax Only If Republicans Provided A Way For The State To Fund 55 Percent Of Public Education Costs. “Months after the Legislature first began holding public hearings on LePage's budget proposal, a major sticking point remains the voter-approved 3 percent surtax on household income above $200,000 to raise revenues for classrooms. The debate swirls around the state of Maine's tax revenues, and whether that surtax will dampen hearty revenues projected in years to come. Following concern from Republicans that the surtax is already driving away business leaders and professionals, several Democrats have said they're willing to remove the tax. But they would only agree to that, Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon said, if Republicans provide another way to reach the requirement that voters approved in 2004 to require the state to fund 55 percent of local education costs.” [Associated Press, 6/2/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: LePage Engaged In “Game Of Chicken” With Legislators Over Government Shutdown; Traveled To DC Amid Looming Shutdown. In June, 2017, the Bangor Daily News published am editorial saying, “In typical LePage style, he threw in a threat. ‘I'm the worst guy in the world to play chicken with because I don't veer either way,’ he told WVOM Tuesday morning. ‘I go straight ahead. So if there's a collision to be had, it's coming Friday night.’ Negotiating a budget is not a game of chicken. It is not a battle to be won through collisions to see who remains standing. It requires veering. A real governor would get legislative leaders in a room and work toward a compromise, not simply issue demands and threats. Instead, with a government shutdown looming, LePage is headed to Washington to talk with the Trump administration about energy policy.” [Bangor Daily News—Editorial, 6/27/17]

  • 2017: LePage’s Budget Proposal Included Tax Break For Maine’s Highest Income Earners, “One Of LePage’s Highest Priorities.” “Two proposals are only about $25

million apart in terms of how much money would be raised and devoted to education. Both include a tax break for Maine's highest income earners, one of LePage's highest priorities. This numerical gap and details of where the money would come from could be resolved if there were serious negotiations taking place.” [Bangor Daily News—Editorial, 6/27/17]

  • GOP Senate President, House Speaker Sara Gideon “Can’t Finalize A Budget On Their Own” Due To “Late Hour Of The Budget Process” LePage Interfered In. “Senate President Mike Thibodeau and House Speaker Sara Gideon, despite their serious work on bridging the differences between their caucuses, can't finalize a budget on their own. Because of the perilously late hour of the budget process and because of an expected veto from LePage, two-thirds of lawmakers are needed to pass a budget, and to override a veto if one is forthcoming.” [Bangor Daily News—Editorial, 6/27/17]

Democratic Speaker of the House Offered to Compromise on the Size of the Surtax on the Wealthy, Reducing it from 3% to 1.5% and Raising the Income Threshold

Portland Press Herald Editorial: “Democrats, Like House Speaker Sara Gideon, Have Strongly Advocated For Honoring The Voters’ 55 Percent Mandate, But They Have Been Less Firm In Their Commitment To The Size Of The Tax Surcharge.” “By making a non-negotiable demand of the full repeal of a voter-approved 3 percent surtax on income greater than $200,000, they have put themselves in the position of: Ignoring the mandate of the voters in not one but two referendum elections; Making a tax cut for the wealthiest 2 percent of Mainers their top priority; Forcing local property tax payers to pay more for schools. […] Democrats, like House Speaker Sara Gideon, have strongly advocated for honoring the voters' 55 percent mandate, but they have been less firm in their commitment to the size of the tax surcharge. […] Between Thibodeau's position and Gideon's, there is a $220 million gap. Republicans say it should be spent to cut taxes on the wealthiest; Democrats say it should be used to pay for schools.” [Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 6/4/17]

Bangor Daily News: “House Democrats Have Blinked In A Standoff Over Education Funding, Angering Progressives By Offering Republicans A Deal To Increase The Threshold For Maine’s Surtax On High Earners And Lower It From 3 Percent To 1.75 Percent.” “House Democrats have blinked in a standoff over education funding, angering progressives by offering Republicans a deal to increase the threshold for Maine's surtax on high earners and lower it from 3 percent to 1.75 percent.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/7/17]

Sara Gideon Offered Republicans A Deal To Fund Public Education At 55 Percent From The State While Lowering The Surtax To 1.75 Percent While Increasing The Threshold To Incomes Above $300,000, Which Was Estimated To Generate $128 Million Over Two Years. “House Democrats led by Speaker Sara Gideon of Freeport tried that this week, offering a deal to fund education at 55 percent by the 2019 fiscal year while increasing the surtax's threshold to $300,000 and lowering it to 1.75 percent, which is estimated to generate $128 million over two years.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/7/17]

  • The Plan Would Raise The Additional $114 Million By Raising The Sales Tax From 5.5 Percent To 5.75 Percent, Increasing The Lodging Tax From 9 Percent To 10 Percent, And Raising Taxes On Tobacco Products. “To offset the difference, House Democrats' plan would find another $114 million by raising the sales tax from 5.5 percent to 5.75 percent, the lodging tax from 9 percent to 10 percent and raising taxes on tobacco products to the same rate as cigarettes, which is called equalization.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/7/17]
  • Sara Gideon: “Democrats Put Forward A Plan That Funds Public Education At 55 Percent, Reduces The 3 Percent Surtax, Rejects Destructive Cuts Contained In The Original Proposal From The LePage Administration And Avoids A Government Shutdown.” On June 7, 2017, Sara Gideon posted on her political Facebook page, “Democrats put forward a plan that funds public education at 55 percent, reduces the 3 percent surtax, rejects destructive cuts contained in the original proposal from the LePage administration and avoids a government shutdown. We are at the table, waiting for the GOP response.” [Speaker Sara Gideon Facebook, 6/7/17]

Kennebec Journal: “House Democrats Touted Their Proposal As A Way To Achieve The Elusive Target Of 55 Percent State Funding For Public Schools While Scaling Back The 3 Percent Tax Surcharge That Voters Approved In November.” “The latest machinations over the 3 percent tax hike on personal income over $200,000 a year highlight the political challenges facing lawmakers as they attempt to strike an as-yet-elusive budget deal before the end of the month. House Democrats touted their proposal as a way to achieve the elusive target of 55 percent state funding for public schools while scaling back the 3 percent tax surcharge that voters approved in November.” [Kennebec Journal, 6/8/17]

Democratic Senate Minority Leader Troy Jackson Called Sara Gideon’s Offer To The Republicans “More Generous Than Many People Would Have Liked,” But Said It Showed That The Democrats Were Serious About Negotiating And Passing A Budget. “Democrats have mostly moved in unison on the budget to date. However, Senate Democrats haven't been touting Gideon's plan on education funding, reflecting difference that's likely more about negotiating tactics and less about policy. In a statement, Senate Minority Leader Troy Jackson, D-Allagash, said Gideon has ‘made yet another offer in an effort to get Republicans to negotiate seriously’ and called it ‘more generous than many people would have liked.’ ‘But it shows how serious we are about doing our jobs and passing a budget to avoid the kind of crisis that Republicans seem determined to create,’ he said. ‘The ball is in their court.’” [Bangor Daily News, 6/7/17]

Gov. Paul LePage Said He’d Veto Any Budget That Included Tax Increases or Increased Education Funding Without Changes to the Education Funding System

6/2/17: Governor LePage Said He Would Veto Any Budget That Increased Education Funding Without Changes To The Education Funding System. “As lawmakers spend the weekend haggling over the budget behind closed doors, Gov. Paul LePage said this week that he'll veto any budget that increases education funding without big changes to the system.” [Associated Press, 6/2/17]

June 2017 – Dem. Speaker of the House and Republican Senate President Created Bipartisan Budget Committee to Come Up With a Final Budget Compromise

HEADLINE: “Six Lawmakers Will Decide If Maine Gets A Budget Or A Government Shutdown.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/13/17]

6/13/17: Budget Negotiations Stalled In The Appropriations Committee Negotiations, Prompting Sara Gideon And Republican Senate President Thibodeau To Create A Special Bipartisan Budget Committee. “June 13: Budget negotiations stall in the Appropriations Committee, so Thibodeau and Gideon convene -- and lead -- a special committee whose work is poisoned from the start, allowing LePage to re-enter the process.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

6/13/17: A Six-Member Committee Was Appointed To Meet In Public And Produce A Budget Deal After The State Legislature Deadlocked On The Budget Over The Issue Of Education Funding. “A small group of lawmakers has the task of coming up with a budget deal over the next few days and averting a government shutdown at the peak of the state's tourism season. Lawmakers have arrived at a deadlock on education funding after months of deliberation, and negotiations over a final budget deal in the last few weeks have revealed staunch division among legislative leaders and the 13-member appropriations committee. So, legislative leaders have decided to turn to a rarely used tactic of appointing a six-member committee of lawmakers to meet in public and come up with a strongly supported budget deal in the coming days. Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon said the process will be accountable and transparent, and she noted it appears to be the first time lawmakers are resorting to the tactic in budget negotiations. The Republican-controlled Senate on Tuesday voted on a swirl of competing budget proposals during a session marked by exasperation and partisan votes.” [Associated Press, 6/13/17]

  • One Day After Sara Gideon And Senate President Mike Thibodeau Told Reporters That The Budget Conference Committee Would Conduct Its Negotiations In Public, The Conference Committee Spent Most Of Its Day In Closed-Door Negotiating Sessions. “A special panel of six Maine lawmakers set up to broker a deal on the state's next two-year budget remained far apart late Wednesday after spending hours behind closed doors meeting with legislative leaders and other lawmakers. While members spent part of Wednesday morning in the public committee room they broke up around midday and didn't return until after 7:30 p.m. The shift to closed-door negotiations came a day after House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, and Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, told reporters that the panel would do its work in public.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/15/17]

Republican House Minority Leader Ken Fredette Said That The Special Budget Committee Was “Doomed To Fail.” “June 13: Budget negotiations stall in the Appropriations Committee, so Thibodeau and Gideon convene -- and lead -- a special committee whose work is poisoned from the start, allowing LePage to re-enter the process. […] So, Thibodeau and Gideon took their chambers into procedural votes allowing them to send it to a six-person committee. House Republicans weren't on board with that plan and House Minority Leader Ken Fredette, R- Newport, told the Bangor Daily News on the first day the panel met that its work was ‘doomed to fail.’” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

Republican Reps. Fredette And Timberlake Said The Structure Of The Conference Committee Was Such That Thibodeau And Gideon Needed The Support Of Only Two Other Individuals To Move A Budget Forward. “Fredette and Rep. Jeff Timberlake, R-Turner, a conservative member of the Appropriations Committee, said the structure of the conference committee means the budget is basically in the hands of Thibodeau and Gideon, who need the support of only Sen. Roger Katz, R-Augusta, and Rep. Aaron Frey, D-Bangor, respectively, to push it forward. ‘We've got essentially the two majority leaders writing the budget,’ Fredette said. ‘This process is a failed process. We were never told Mike and Sara were going to appoint themselves to the committee, which leaves them writing the budget and damn it, they're setting themselves up for a failure. When that happens it's not going to be House Republicans' fault. This is doomed for failure.’” [Bangor Daily News, 6/14/17]

Mid-June 2017 – Republicans Aligned with Gov. Paul LePage and Stalled the Work of the Special Budget Committee

6/15/17: The Budget Conference Committee’s Negotiations “Stalled,” Leading Sara Gideon To Blame House Minority Leader Ken Fredette For The Committee Having Done “No Real Work” Yet. “Negotiations on Maine's two-year state budget stalled on Thursday when the Legislature's top Democrat blasted Republicans aligned with Gov. Paul LePage for holding out as lawmakers breezed by their deadline for an agreement. House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, angrily said during a Thursday afternoon meeting of the special six-person panel convened to close the budget amid a long impasse over education funding that it has done ‘no real work’ this week. She blamed House Minority Leader Ken Fredette, R-Newport.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/15/17]

Bangor Daily News: Sara Gideon “Blast[ed] LePage-Aligned House Republicans” For Failing To Come To The Table To Negotiate On The State Budget. “It comes one day after an unproductive Thursday meeting of the six-person committee tasked with closing the Legislature's impasse on education funding, where House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, raised the specter of a shutdown to blast LePage-aligned House Republicans. ‘When all these things fail,’ she told WCSH, referring to services that could be stopped, ‘there will be one party who didn't come to the table to make sure that state government kept functioning.’” [Bangor Daily News, 6/16/17]

6/17/17: Governor LePage Met With Budget Negotiators And Aligned Himself With House Republicans On The Budget Negotiations, Against Senate Republicans And Democrats. “LePage has suggested the state follow Congress in using continuous resolutions to fund state government amid gridlock, and his administration criticized legislative leaders this week for taking the unprecedented step of leaving budget negotiations to a ‘super committee’ of six lawmakers. LePage met be\hind closed-doors with leaders Friday, and aligned himself with House Republicans at odds with Democrats and Senate Republicans over an impasse on education funding.” [Associated Press, 6/17/17]

The Conference Committee Missed Its Deadline To Vote The Budget Out Of The Committee, Essentially Ensuring That Governor LePage Would Not Get The Budget With 10 Days Or More Before The Budget Needed To Be Signed Into Law On July 1. “On Thursday, the Legislature stumbled past a deadline to vote a budget out of the committee, which means any final budget that gets two-thirds approval in both chambers is now virtually assured to get to LePage's desk with less than 10 days -- the period he can hold a bill before signing or vetoing it -- before a shutdown that would come if there is no budget by July 1.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/16/17]

Sara Gideon Said That Governor LePage Had Told Her Multiple Times That He Would Hold Any Budget The Legislature Sent Him For The Full 10 Days, Triggering A State Shutdown, Unless The Legislature Sent Him The Budget He Supported. “Meanwhile, LePage cast a large shadow over the negotiations, despite the fact that lawmakers could enact a budget without his support by once again overriding his veto. Gideon said the governor told her on two occasions last week that he would exercise his right to hold the budget for 10 days -- thereby triggering a government shutdown -- unless Democrats send him a budget he supports. And LePage hinted again Tuesday that he has no plans to back down from the political fight as his administration prepares for a potential shutdown.” [Kennebec Journal, 6/28/17]

June 30, 2017 – Paul LePage-Aligned House Republicans Blocked the Speaker of the House and Senate President’s Proposed Budget, Forcing a Government Shutdown

6/29/17: Budget Conference Committee Recommended A Two-Year Budget Of $7.1 Billion, Brokered By Sara Gideon And Senate President Mike Thibodeau. “Barely a day away from a government shutdown, a special six-person budget committee recommended a tenuous two-year state spending plan to the Legislature late Thursday, setting up a scramble to wrangle two-thirds support and a showdown with Gov. Paul LePage. The deal brokered by Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, and House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, has a bottom line of $7.1 billion and appears to be the state's only hope of avoiding a shutdown.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/29/17]

  • Bangor Daily News: “Thibodeau And Gideon Grew Tired Of The Committee’s Lack Of Progress And Cut Their Own Budget Deal, Sending It To The Floor.” “Just more than a day before Maine's Saturday shutdown, Thibodeau and Gideon grew tired of the committee's lack of progress and cut their own budget deal, sending it to the floor on June 30, which angered House Republicans and Senate Democrats alike.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]
  • Sara Gideon And Senate President Thibodeau’s Budget Deal Cut The Surtax, Increased Education Funding By $162 Million, And Kept A LePage-Opposed Lodging Tax. “Just more than a day before Maine's Saturday shutdown, Thibodeau and Gideon grew tired of the committee's lack of progress and cut their own budget deal, sending it to the floor on June 30, which angered House Republicans and Senate Democrats alike. It proposed cutting the surtax but included $162 million in additional education funding, but it left a lodging tax increase in place that LePage had already

expressed opposition to earlier in the day. The next day, he held a hastily arranged news conference to say he wouldn't sign it.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

  • Gideon/Thibodeau Compromise Budget Increased The Lodging Tax From 9 Percent To 10.5 Percent. “The deal brokered by Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, and House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, has a bottom line of $7.1 billion and appears to be the state's only hope of avoiding a shutdown. But it's full of pitfalls that could repel some Republicans and Democrats in what promises to be a dramatic set of votes on Friday. Minority members in both parties said they were left out of negotiations, with Rep. Tom Winsor, R-Norway, casting the lone vote against the plan. Chief among potential conflict points are a lodging tax increase and overall price tag that Gov. Paul LePage has said is too high, as well as repeal of a surtax that progressive Democrats have staunchly defended. […] To offset some of the lost revenue, the plan would raise Maine's lodging tax from 9 percent to 10.5 percent beginning Oct. 1 -- higher than the Senate Republican proposal of 10 percent that was made earlier this week.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/29/17]
  • Compromise Budget Repealed The Voter-Approved Surtax On High-Income Voters To Fund Education And Increased State Funding For Public Education By $162 Million. “The deal brokered by Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, and House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, has a bottom line of $7.1 billion and appears to be the state's only hope of avoiding a shutdown. But it's full of pitfalls that could repel some Republicans and Democrats in what promises to be a dramatic set of votes on Friday. Minority members in both parties said they were left out of negotiations, with Rep. Tom Winsor, R-Norway, casting the lone vote against the plan. Chief among potential conflict points are a lodging tax increase and overall price tag that Gov. Paul LePage has said is too high, as well as repeal of a surtax that progressive Democrats have staunchly defended. […] The plan aims to resolve Maine's budget impasse by increasing state aid to K-12 public education funding by $162 million over the current biennium while eliminating the surtax on high-income earners approved by voters in 2016.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/29/17]
  • Compromise Budget “Would Use Unspent Medicaid Funding And $10 Million Over The Biennium From The Fund For A Health Maine, Which Is Underwritten By A Lawsuit Against Tobacco Companies.” “The compromise plan also would use unspent Medicaid funding and $10 million over the biennium from the Fund for a Healthy Maine, which is underwritten by a lawsuit against tobacco companies.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/29/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Democrats “Capitulated On The 3 Percent Tax…Giving An Income Tax Break To Maine’s Top Earners.” “Democratic leaders pledged to maintain the surtax, and the more than $300 million in additional education funding it was predicted to generate over the next two years. Republicans leaders sought to repeal the surtax. In the end, Democrats capitulated on the 3 percent surtax, which was stripped from the final budget agreement, giving an income tax break to Maine's top earners. They compromised on the $300 million in additional education funding, settling for about half as much by agreeing to a Senate Republican plan to generate additional revenue by raising the state's lodging tax, which was a compromise from GOP members who generally oppose tax increases.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Democratic Senate Minority Leader Troy Jackson Said The Compromise Budget Was “Not The Largest Education Increase In Our History, It Is The Largest Cut To Public Education In Our State’s History And Maine Students Will Be Worse For It.” “Senate Minority Leader Troy Jackson, D-Allagash, said he hated the budget before him and his vote wasn't for the budget but against a state government shutdown. Jackson said those who have pitched the budget as an historic investment in public schools were wrong, because it was voters last November who truly made the largest investment in education, and the new budget cut that in half. ‘I offer to you this budget is not the largest education increase in our history, it is the largest cut to public education in our state's history and Maine students will be the worse for it, and for what?’ he said. ‘For what reason are we dismissing the will of the Maine voters, the same voters who elected us to this Legislature?’” [Kennebec Journal, 7/1/17]

HEADLINE: “LePage Says He Won’t Sign Latest Budget Proposal And Will Allow A Shutdown.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/30/17]

6/30/17: Governor LePage Said That He Wouldn’t Sign The Compromise Budget Proposal If It Passed Out Of The State Legislature. “Gov. Paul LePage said Friday that he won't sign a state budget package endorsed Thursday night by a special panel, ensuring a partial shutdown of state government at midnight. The Republican governor's opposition to the budget deal would force Maine's first state government shutdown since 1991, which could stretch 10 days if LePage holds a budget bill for the full time the Constitution allows before he must act. A budget would go to him tonight if the Legislature can muster two-thirds votes in both chambers, but even that was a big ‘if’ on Friday.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/30/17]

  • Governor LePage Said He Opposed The $7.1 Billion Cost Of The Budget And That It Raised The Lodging Tax To 10.5 Percent Without Income Tax Cuts. “LePage told reporters his major objections were the overall cost of the budget package -- around $7.1 billion -- and that it proposes raising the state's lodging tax from 9 percent to 10.5 percent without income tax cuts. However, the budget package currently under consideration contains an income tax cut of 3 percent because it eliminates the surtax on income above $200,000 per year for education which was approved by voters last year.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/30/17]

Maine House Of Representatives Voted 87-60 To Enact The Compromise Budget In The Evening Of June 30, Short Of The Two-Thirds Support Needed To Override A Veto. “Maine residents may wake up with a partial government shutdown after resistance from House Republicans prevented enactment of a two-year budget. The Maine House voted 87-60 to enact the budget on Friday night. But that is short of the two-thirds support needed. Republican House Minority Leader Ken Fredette says that GOP Gov. Paul LePage is offering his own budget plan as an alternative. That plan has not been finalized yet, however, and lawmakers haven't reviewed it. Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon has adjourned the House while lawmakers await LePage's budget bill.” [Associated Press, 7/1/17]

Maine Senate Voted 34-1 In Favor Of The Compromise Budget. “The Maine Senate has voted overwhelmingly in favor of a $7.1 billion, two-year budget proposal that some Democrats said they hated. The Senate voted 34-1 Friday in favor of the budget, which now heads back to the House. The budget needs buy-in from House Republicans to achieve the needed two-thirds support.” [Associated Press, 7/1/17

Bangor Daily News: “In A Show Of Loyalty To LePage, 60 House Republicans Block A Thibodeau-Gideon Budget And Force A Shutdown.” “July 1: In a show of loyalty to LePage, 60 House Republicans block a Thibodeau-Gideon budget and force a shutdown, then make a counteroffer.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

  • House Minority Leader Ken Fredette Defended House Republicans, Saying They Wanted To Deliver To Governor LePage A Budget He Would Sign, Rather Than One That Passed But Would Sit For 10 Days On The Governor’s Desk. “House Minority Leader Ken Fredette, R-Newport, defended his caucus' stance, saying they must deliver a budget LePage ‘could sign’ rather than one that passes with two-thirds majorities and sits on the governor's desk for the allotted 10 days he has to act on it.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

July 1, 2016 – Maine State Government Shut Down for the First Time in 25 Years

HEADLINE: “Partial Government Shutdown In Maine After Budget Impasse.” [Associated Press, 7/1/17]

HEADLINE: “LePage, Lawmakers Fail To Reach Budget Deal, Triggering Government Shutdown.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Associated Press: Maine’s First Government Shutdown In A Quarter-Century Began After House Republicans Failed To Support A Proposed $7.1 Billion Budget. “A partial state government shutdown began early Saturday in Maine after lawmakers failed to meet a deadline for a new state budget while House Republicans revealed they were working with GOP Gov. Paul LePage on a secret, alternative plan. A proposed two-year, $7.1 billion budget wasn't approved Friday night after resistance from House Republicans, whose concerns include $162 million allotted for increased education spending. The shut-down is Maine's first in a quarter-century.” [Associated Press, 7/1/17]

Associated Press: “Maine’s Government Shut Down For The First Time Since 1991 At 12:01 A.M. Saturday, As Republicans In The House Of Representatives Left To Chants Of ‘Shame’ After They Effectively Killed A Two-Year Budget Compromise Forged By Two Legislative Leaders.” “Maine's government shut down for the first time since 1991 at 12:01 a.m. Saturday, as Republicans in the House of Representatives left to chants of ‘shame’ after they effectively killed a two-year budget compromise forged by two legislative leaders.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Three And A Half Hours Before The End Of The Fiscal Year, LePage Announced His Own Budget Proposal. “But no one had seen LePage's latest budget proposal - announced on the House floor just 3.5 hours before the end of the fiscal year - and the scene in the State House was one of confusion as lawmakers, lobbyists and state workers awaited word on the budget.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/1/17]

  • Speaker of the House Said Governor LePage Did Not Have A Formal Counterproposal To The Legislature-Passed Budget, And Then Threw A “Temper Tantrum” When It Was Clear Democrats Would Not Accept His Proposed Changes. “Afterward, House Speaker Sara Gideon told lawmakers that LePage did not have a formal, written counterproposal to offer and then threw a ‘temper tantrum’ after it was clear Democrats would not go along with his proposed changes. Gideon said the governor then walked out by saying, ‘Shut her down.’” [Portland Press Herald, 7/1/17]
  • House Speaker Sara Gideon: Governor LePage “Presented Us With A List Of Demands And When They Weren’t All Met – And I Want To Indicate That I Was Willing To Work With Most Them, Almost All Of Them – He Had A Temper Tantrum, He Walked Out With The Words ‘Shut Her Down.’” “Afterward, House Speaker Sara Gideon told lawmakers that LePage did not have a formal, written counterproposal to offer and then threw a ‘temper tantrum’ after it was clear Democrats would not go along with his proposed changes. ‘He presented us with a list of demands and when they weren't all met — and I want to indicate that I was willing to work with most of them, almost all of them — he had a temper tantrum, he walked out with the words ‘Shut her down,’’ Gideon told the House chamber minutes before midnight. ‘I want you all to know tonight that after the governor's aggressive behavior, specifically towards me, I left the Blaine House but my three male colleagues chose to stay and continue talking.’” [Portland Press Herald, 7/1/17]
  • House Speaker Sara Gideon: “I Myself, Have Met, Or Spoken With, The Governor At Least Five Times In The Past Week Alone, And While We Were Unable To Come To An Agreement, We Did Negotiate Until The Very End, Including Tonight When The Governor Summoned Four Leaders To The Blaine House.” GIDEON: “There have been some who have tried to say that the Chief Executive has somehow been left out of the budget process. I want to assure you that nothing could be further from the truth. I, myself, have met, or spoken with, the governor at least five times in the past week alone, and while we were unable to come to an agreement, we did negotiate until the very end, including tonight when the governor summoned four leaders to the Blaine House. He presented us with a list of demands, and when they weren’t all met, and I want to indicate to you that I was willing to work with most of them, almost all of them, he had a temper tantrum. He walked out with the words ‘Shut her down.’ I want you all to know tonight that after the governor’s aggressive behavior, specifically towards me, I left the Blaine House, though my three male colleagues chose to stay and continue talking.” [Speaker Sara Gideon Facebook, 6/30/17] (VIDEO) 2:40
  • House Speaker Sara Gideon: “I Want You All To Know Tonight That After The Governor’s Aggressive Behavior, Specifically Towards Me, I Left The Blaine House, Though My Three Male Colleagues Chose To Stay And Continue Talking.” GIDEON: “There have been some who have tried to say that the Chief Executive has

somehow been left out of the budget process. I want to assure you that nothing could be further from the truth. I, myself, have met, or spoken with, the governor at least five times in the past week alone, and while we were unable to come to an agreement, we did negotiate until the very end, including tonight when the governor summoned four leaders to the Blaine House. He presented us with a list of demands, and when they weren’t all met, and I want to indicate to you that I was willing to work with most of them, almost all of them, he had a temper tantrum. He walked out with the words ‘Shut her down.’ I want you all to know tonight that after the governor’s aggressive behavior, specifically towards me, I left the Blaine House, though my three male colleagues chose to stay and continue talking.” [Speaker Sara Gideon Facebook, 6/30/17] (VIDEO) 2:40

Governor LePage Proposed A Budget Deal That Purportedly Funded Education At $160 Million Over Current Levels, But “Add[ed] A Number Of Potential Poison Pills For Progressives,” Including A Statewide Teacher Contract, An Identification Program For Tax-Exempt Property Held By Land Trust, And Repealing Ranked-Choice Voting. “Details were thin Friday on LePage's proposed deal, but the Bangor Daily News obtained what one lawmaker said is a list of LePage's demands. The list stated the governor would allow $160 million in added education funding over the two-year budget that ended Friday night, minus the voter-approved surtax on high earners that is earmarked for education funding but Republicans have aimed to kill. That's only $2 million shy of Thibodeau's and Gideon's education figure, but LePage's latest offer reportedly adds a number of potential poison pills for progressives, including a pilot program for a statewide teacher contract already rejected by Democrats, a program that would identify tax-exempt property held by land trusts and the repeal of the voter-approved ranked-choice voting law.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

  • Governor LePage Said Sara Gideon Was “Controlled By Union Bosses” For Not Agreeing To Education Policy Changes That The Legislature Had Previously Rejected. “The Maine Legislature tracked toward a potential Monday vote to reopen state government after Republicans aligned with Gov. Paul LePage fleshed out a two-year budget offer that was revised downward in cost on Sunday. It was no sure thing on Sunday evening, when the hunkered-down Republican governor interrupted negotiations to blast House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, saying she's ‘controlled by union bosses’ for not agreeing to previously rejected education policy changes. The Legislature's special budget panel was expected to vote Sunday night on a $7.1 billion offer from House Republicans, 60 of whom forced the Saturday shutdown by blocking a deal brokered by Gideon and Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/2/17]

During the Shutdown, Paul LePage Refused to Cross the Street to Meet in Person With Legislative Leadership

Speaker of the House Sara Gideon Invited Governor LePage To Present His Budget Proposals To The Budget Conference Committee, But He Declined Saying, “It’s Not My Budget, It’s The House Republicans.” “On Saturday, Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon of Freeport, who has clashed with LePage throughout the budget negotiations, formally invited LePage to present his proposals to the six-member budget conference committee. According to Gideon, LePage declined the invitation by replying, ‘It's not my budget, it's the House Republicans.’” [Kennebec Journal, 7/2/17]

Boston Globe: Governor LePage And Speaker of the House Sara Gideon Each Refused To Cross Capitol Street To Negotiate With The Other During The First Day Of The Government Shutdown. “Maine Governor Paul LePage was absent from the evening meeting at the State House, to which Speaker of the House Sara Gideon had invited him. The two had traded barbs on Twitter earlier in the day over where to meet to discuss the shutdown, with each refusing to cross Capitol Street to speak to the other. ‘Been available to negotiate since 8,’ tweeted LePage, who wanted to meet at the Blaine House, his residence. ‘@saraGideon is welcome to come over any time.’ Gideon replied in a tweet of her own: ‘I am at the State House. This is where budget negotiations belong.’” [Boston Globe, 7/2/17]

7/1/17: Speaker of the House Sara Gideon Called On Governor LePage To “Walk The 100 Yards Across The Street And Come Into This Building, Look State Workers In The Eye At The Same Time And Do His Job.” “On Saturday, Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon of Freeport formally invited LePage to present his proposals to the six-member budget conference committee. But LePage declined, saying, ‘It's not my budget, it's the House Republicans,’ according to Gideon. ‘He needs to walk the 100 yards across the street and come into this building, look state workers in the eye at the same time and do his job,’ Gideon said.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/1/17]

July 3, 2016 – Paul LePage Gave State Employees the Day Off on the First Work Day of the Government Shutdown

Governor LePage Gave State Employees The First Work Day, Monday July 3, During The Government Shutdown Off Of Work. “Since the Legislature has still failed to put a budget in place, Governor Paul R. LePage has announced he will allow state employees to take administrative leave with pay for Monday, July 3. This is the same authority the Governor exercises in administratively closing non-emergency state offices the day before Christmas or Thanksgiving so employees can enjoy an extended holiday with their families and loved ones. In addition, the Governor will provide employees already working as designated emergency personnel on Monday with compensatory time off for the work they perform on that day.” [Press Release, Office of Governor LePage, 7/2/17]

  • Governor LePage: “Speaker Of The House Sara Gideon Is Intent On Prolonging The State Government Shutdown And Making It Uncertain Whether State Employees Who Have Been Forced Out Of Work Will Get Paid For Monday.” “‘Speaker of the House Sara Gideon is intent on prolonging the state government shutdown and making it uncertain whether state employees who have been forced out of work will get paid for Monday,’ said Governor LePage. ‘It is unconscionable for state workers to lose a day’s pay because of the Legislature’s repeated failure to put a budget on my desk.’” [Press Release, Office of Governor LePage, 7/2/17]
  • Governor LePage: “It Is Unconscionable For State Workers To Lose A Day’s Pay Because Of The Legislature’s Repeated Failure To Put A Budget On My Desk.”

“‘Speaker of the House Sara Gideon is intent on prolonging the state government shutdown and making it uncertain whether state employees who have been forced out of work will get paid for Monday,’ said Governor LePage. ‘It is unconscionable for state workers to lose a day’s pay because of the Legislature’s repeated failure to put a budget on my desk.’” [Press Release, Office of Governor LePage, 7/2/17]

Portland Press Herald: “As Part Of The Budget Deal, All State Employees Will Be Paid For Any Work Hours Lost During The Shutdown.” “As part of the budget deal, all state employees will be paid for any work hours lost during the shutdown.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/4/17]

July 2 and 3, 2017 – Special Budget Committee Voted Out Another Budget Plan, Paul LePage-Aligned House Republicans Blocked It

7/2/17: Budget Conference Committee Endorsed A Two-Year $7.1 Billion Budget That Kept The 10.5 Percent Lodging Tax But Delayed Its Implementation By A Month. “The Maine Legislature's special budget panel endorsed a two-year budget late Sunday, setting up a high-pressure round of Monday floor votes on Day 3 of a state shutdown, but risking another impasse with Gov. Paul LePage over hiking the lodging tax. […] Over the weekend, legislators worked to gain a deal that LePage would sign. House Republicans presented, then modified a proposal, but the committee changed it to hike the lodging tax from 9 percent to 10.5 percent like the earlier Thibodeau-Gideon deal, but putting it into effect in November.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/3/17]

  • The Compromise Budget Did Not Include A Pilot Program For A Statewide Teacher Contract, But Made Concessions On The Governor’s Request For Incentivizing School District Regionalization. “The governor may also find more fault with the deal: It also doesn't include a proposed pilot program for a statewide teacher contract, which Democrats in the House of Representatives rejected in bill form last month. However, it does make concessions on his demands for money to incentivize school district regionalization and to study the impact of conservation land on property taxes.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/3/17]

7/2/17-7/3/17: Special Budget Committee Voted Out Another Budget Plan That Had Tax Increases In It, And House Republicans Blocked The Deal. “July 2: The panel mostly ignores that plan and votes out another package defying LePage's no-tax hike warning. In a late-night vote, Thibodeau and Gideon lead the panel into voting for yet another budget that defied LePage by leaving the lodging tax increase in after he issued a Facebook video saying he wouldn't agree to a tax increase. House Republicans signaled that he wouldn't sign it. July 3: House Republicans again block that deal, but LePage and Gideon hastily negotiate a deal to ax the lodging tax increase and end the shutdown.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

During the Shutdown, Paul LePage Allegedly Told Lawmakers That He’d Be Going on Vacation During it

Lawmakers Said Governor LePage Called Them To Tell Them He Was Going On Vacation While The Government Was Shut Down, But His Spokeswoman Later Said He Would Not Be Leaving The State. “Earlier Monday, the lawmakers said that LePage called them to say he was going on vacation, but LePage spokeswoman Adrienne Bennett said Monday night that the governor would not be going on vacation. ‘(He) will not be leaving,’ she said in an email. The news that LePage said he was planning to take a vacation amid a state budget shutdown was paired with reports out of New Jersey -- also a state shutdown over the budget -- that Gov. Chris Christie and his family visited a beach closed to the public, prompting outrage.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/4/17]

July 3, 2017 – Paul LePage and the Speaker of the House Negotiated an End to the Shutdown

HEADLINE: “LePage, Gideon Cut Late-Night Deal To End Shutdown.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/3/17]

7/3/17: Governor Paul LePage And Sara Gideon Struck A Deal To End The Government Shutdown, With The House Of Representatives And Senate Voting After Midnight To Pass The Budget. “Hope soared at the State House just after 10 p.m. Monday when Gov. Paul LePage and Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon struck a deal for a bipartisan budget bill and an end to Maine's three-day government shutdown. The House of Representatives voted 147-2 in favor of the deal at nearly 1 a.m. Tuesday and the Senate followed suit 35-0. LePage signed the budget into law.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/3/17]

Details of Final Compromise Budget

7/3/17: Sara Gideon And Governor LePage Negotiated A Deal To Eliminate The Lodging Tax Increase In Exchange For Blocking Changes To Maine’s Behavioral Health System And Additional Early Childhood Education Funding. “July 3: House Republicans again block that deal, but LePage and Gideon hastily negotiate a deal to ax the lodging tax increase and end the shutdown. When that deal went to the House floor, a smaller group of 54 Republicans again withheld their votes to block a two-thirds majority. But negotiations dragged on in private. By 9:30 p.m., LePage and Gideon hammered out a deal that eliminated the lodging tax increase in exchange for blocking changes to Maine's behavioral health system and adding federal funds to early childhood education programs. The Legislature approved it easily and the shutdown ended when LePage signed it just after 1 a.m. on July 4, holding a celebratory signing alongside a group mostly made up of House Republicans and praising them for holding firm to control majority Democrats.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/5/17]

The Budget Deal Cut The Proposed Increase To The Lodging Tax In Exchange For A Two-Year Moratorium On Changing The Funding Structure Of Maine’s Behavioral Health System And More TANF Funding For Early Childhood Education Programs. “According to Rep. Patricia Hymanson, D-York, House chairwoman of the Legislature's Health and Human Services Committee, key elements of the deal include negating the proposed lodging tax increase, which LePage and Republicans have treated as a poison pill. In exchange, Hymanson said, Democrats were able to secure two items they have been fighting for this year: One is a two-year moratorium on changes to the funding structure for the state's behavioral health system, which the Department of Health and Human Services has been trying to implement since a 2016 Burns & Associates report. The other item is the allocation of more federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families funding for early childhood education programs.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/3/17]

New York Times: LePage And Sara Gideon “Crafted A New Deal That Scrapped The [Lodging Tax] Increase, Added Money For Head Start Programs And Protected Behavioral Health Reimbursements.” “Late last week, Senate Republicans and the Democrats who control the House agreed on a compromise budget. In a major concession by Democrats, it would repeal a voter-approved tax surcharge on the state's highest earners, which had been expected to generate more than $300 million for education. But the bill also contained a roughly $20 million increase in the state's lodging tax -- as had the budget Mr. LePage first proposed. On Monday, Mr. LePage said he would not sign a budget that included the lodging tax increase. Late in the evening, he and Sara Gideon, the Democratic House speaker, crafted a new deal that scrapped the increase, added money for Head Start programs and protected behavioral health reimbursements.” [New York Times, 7/3/17]

The Compromise Budget Agreement Struck Between Sara Gideon And Governor LePage Would “Likely Require A Supplemental Budget In 2018 Because It Leaves Additional Funding For Maine Direct-Care Workers Unaddressed In The Next Fiscal Year.” “The two-year state budget may be signed, but Gov. Paul LePage and the Legislature's top Democrat have already teased their tacks for the next standoff, likely to happen sometime next year. The budget agreement reached by the Republican governor and House Speaker Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, will likely require a supplemental budget in 2018 because it leaves additional funding for Maine direct-care workers unaddressed in the next fiscal year.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/6/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Compromise Budget Increased Cash Assistance For Poor Families For The First Time Since 2001, From $485 Per Month To $582 Per Month For A Family Of Three. “But a close reading of the budget tells a more complicated tale — a tale that includes some victories for low-income Mainers that mostly happened under the radar, that will prove significant, and that fly in the face of LePage’s agenda. The two-year budget that just took effect, for example, includes the first increase since 2001 in the amount of cash assistance a poor family with kids can collect through the state’s Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. On Oct. 1, the maximum cash benefit for a poor family of three will rise to $582 from $485. It’s not a lot of money to survive on, but a 20 percent bump will prove significant for a family living on the edge — easing the toxic stress that goes along with not being able to make ends meet.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Compromise Budget Linked Cash Assistance To Rise With Inflation Each Year. “The two-year budget that just took effect, for example, includes the first increase since 2001 in the amount of cash assistance a poor family with kids can collect through the state’s Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. On Oct. 1, the maximum cash benefit for a poor family of three will rise to $582 from $485. It’s not a lot of money to survive on, but a 20 percent bump will prove significant for a family living on the edge — easing the toxic stress that goes along with not being able to make ends meet. Not only that. The budget changed state law to ensure the cash benefit amount rises each year based on inflation. The spending plan also includes funding and a change in state law to start a program that helps low-income families obtain used cars, so parents can attend work or school.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Compromise Budget Included Funding To Start A Program To Help Low-Income Families Obtain Used Cars In Order To Get To Work Or School. “The two-year budget that just took effect, for example, includes the first increase since 2001 in the amount of cash assistance a poor family with kids can collect through the state’s Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. On Oct. 1, the maximum cash benefit for a poor family of three will rise to $582 from $485. It’s not a lot of money to survive on, but a 20 percent bump will prove significant for a family living on the edge — easing the toxic stress that goes along with not being able to make ends meet. Not only that. The budget changed state law to ensure the cash benefit amount rises each year based on inflation. The spending plan also includes funding and a change in state law to start a program that helps low-income families obtain used cars, so parents can attend work or school.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Compromise Did Not Include Proposed Millions Of Dollars Of Cuts To Maine’s Safety Net, Including Kicking Parents And Young Adults Off Medicaid. “It’s also worth noting what didn’t make it into the two-year budget that took effect — notably millions of dollars in damaging cuts to Maine’s safety net that LePage included in his first budget proposal earlier this year. The budget doesn’t include cuts that would have kicked parents and young adults off Medicaid, and it retains state funding for General Assistance — the last-resort source of aid that residents obtain through city hall or at their local town offices.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Compromise Did Not Include The LePage-Proposed Cuts To General Assistance. “It’s also worth noting what didn’t make it into the two-year budget that took effect — notably millions of dollars in damaging cuts to Maine’s safety net that LePage included in his first budget proposal earlier this year. The budget doesn’t include cuts that would have kicked parents and young adults off Medicaid, and it retains state funding for General Assistance — the last-resort source of aid that residents obtain through city hall or at their local town offices.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Compromise Budget Repealed The 3 Percent Surtax On Incomes Above $200,00. “It’s easy to look at the top-line details of Maine’s recently passed two-year state budget and conclude that Democrats in the Legislature came out of the ordeal of a government shutdown virtually empty-handed. Republicans entered this year’s legislative session with a goal of repealing the 3 percent surtax on incomes above $200,000 that voters passed into law last November, and they succeeded. The final budget includes no additional tax on the state’s top earners.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Compromise Budget Added About Half Of The $300 Million In Public Education Funding That The 3 Percent Surtax Was Supposed To Raise. “Republicans entered this year’s legislative session with a goal of repealing the 3 percent surtax on incomes above $200,000 that voters passed into law last November, and they succeeded. The final budget includes no additional tax on the state’s top earners. That surtax was supposed to raise more than $300 million in funding for public schools in its first two years; the final budget added about half that amount beyond Gov. Paul LePage’s initial budget proposal.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “Democrats Capitulated On The 3 Percent Surtax…Giving An Income Tax Break To Maine’s Top Earners.” “In the end, Democrats capitulated on the 3 percent surtax, which was stripped from the final budget agreement, giving an income tax break to Maine’s top earners. They compromised on the $300 million in additional education funding, settling for about half as much by agreeing to a Senate Republican plan to generate additional revenue by raising the state’s lodging tax, which was a compromise from GOP members who generally oppose tax increases.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: The Budget Included An Additional $162 Million For Schools. “In the end, the surtax was repealed, but the budget includes an additional $162 million for schools, with $27.5 million directed to schools with high percentages of students in poverty.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/7/17]

Republican Senate President Thibodeau Said The Budget Made “The Largest Investment In K-12 Education As A State In Our History. I Think We Ought To All Be Proud Of That.” THIBODEAU: “We actually invested over $150 million new dollars in K-12 education, most of that money in year number two. A significant increase in public education and our support for it. And you know, look, educating our children is important and an expensive proposition and it does have a substantial impact on people’s property taxes, but we are, and have made, the largest investment in K-12 education as a state in our history. I think we ought to all be proud of that.” [Maine Public Radio, 6/14/18] (AUDIO) 15:05

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “In Education, Much Of The Increased Funding The Two-Year Budget Includes Will End Up In School Districts With High Proportions Of Low-Income Students.” “In education, much of the increased funding the two-year budget includes will end up in school districts with high proportions of low-income students. The budget, for example, ends the state practice of deducting state aid, dollar for dollar, from those districts that receive federal Title I funds, which are earmarked for high-poverty districts. And by altering the school funding formula, the new two-year budget earmarks more state funds for low-income districts that have trouble raising money from local property taxpayers.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “Also Important, The Budget Includes Changes That Put New Emphasis On Public Preschool And After-School Programs — Opportunities That Can Make A Difference In Academic Achievement For Students From Low-Income Families.” “Also important, the budget includes changes that put new emphasis on public preschool and after-school programs — opportunities that can make a difference in academic achievement for students from low-income families.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Sara Gideon: Final Compromise Budget Protected The Homestead Property Tax Exemption “For Most Families.” “In a divided government, I truly believe that compromise was necessary to reach a final agreement, and that improving Maine’s economy is the key to our future. We were successful by balancing investments that will strengthen our State, while rejecting policies that would negatively impact middle class families. The 2017-2018 Biennial Budget: […] Bolsters property tax relief: Protects the Homestead exemption for most families. This critical program reduces property tax bills by exempting a portion of the home’s value from tax assessment.” [Speaker Gideon, 2017 Legislative Report, 12/27/17] Bangor Daily News Editorial: Final Budget Included $14 Million For Direct Care Workers. “None of these changes made it into the final budget. Instead, it includes a boost in TANF benefits and allocates more than $14 million to support direct care workers. Low pay is causing shortages of workers needed to care for the elderly and disabled.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/7/12]

Editorial Commentary About the Final Budget

Bangor Daily News Editorial: The Budget Included Victories For Low-Income Mainers, Included “Because Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon Advocated For Them,” Including An Increase In TANF Benefits. “The claims that Democrats lost big have come from the right and left sides of the political spectrum. And some Democratic priorities certainly took a hit. But a close reading of the budget tells a more complicated tale -- a tale that includes some victories for low-income Mainers that mostly happened under the radar, that will prove significant, and that fly in the face of LePage's agenda. The two-year budget that just took effect, for example, includes the first increase since 2001 in the amount of cash assistance a poor family with kids can collect through the state's Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. On Oct. 1, the maximum cash benefit for a poor family of three will rise to $582 from $485. It's not a lot of money to survive on, but a 20 percent bump will prove significant for a family living on the edge -- easing the toxic stress that goes along with not being able to make ends meet. Not only that. The budget changed state law to ensure the cash benefit amount rises each year based on inflation. The spending plan also includes funding and a change in state law to start a program that helps low-income families obtain used cars, so parents can attend work or school. Those initiatives are in there because Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon advocated for them as part of far-reaching legislation she proposed earlier this year to spend the state's sizable balance of federal welfare funds in ways that actually help low-income families.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: The Budget “Includes Some Victories For Low-Income Mainers That Mostly Happened Under The Radar, That Will Prove Significant, And That Fly In The Face Of LePage’s Agenda.” “The claims that Democrats lost big have come from the right and left sides of the political spectrum. And some Democratic priorities certainly took a hit. But a close reading of the budget tells a more complicated tale — a tale that includes some victories for low-income Mainers that mostly happened under the radar, that will prove significant, and that fly in the face of LePage’s agenda.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/12/17]

HEADLINE: “Maine’s Unnecessary Government Shutdown Can End With Compromise, Not Extortion.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “The Failure To Reach A Budget Agreement Rests At The Feet Of 60 Republicans Members Of The House Of Representatives, Led By Reps. Ken Fredette And Ellie Espling.” “Maine’s government is shut down. It didn’t have to happen. The failure to reach a budget agreement rests at the feet of 60 Republicans members of the House of Representatives, led by Reps. Ken Fredette and Ellie Espling, who were more intent on kowtowing to Gov. Paul LePage’s demands than serving the people who elected them.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Gov. LePage Could Sign Any Budget Lawmakers Put Before Him, He Has Made The Choice Not To. He Has Made It Clear That He Would Only Sign A Budget That Matched His Ever-Changing Wish List. This Is Not Governing Or Leadership, It Is Extortion.” “Failing to understand Maine’s system of government, Fredette said it was lawmakers responsibility to deliver a budget LePage could sign, as if they work for the governor, not the Maine people. LePage could sign any budget lawmakers put before him, he has made the choice not to. He has made it clear that he would only sign a budget that matched his ever-changing wish list. This is not governing or leadership, it is extortion.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Kennebec Journal Editorial: “If Maine Government Goes Over The Brink, The Blame Will Not Be On The Presiding Officers. It Will Rest Of Gov. LePage And The Members Of The House Who Backed Him.” “The governor and his allies are trying to convince wavering House members that if the government shuts down, most people will blame the Democrats. But that would be a risky supposition. The Democrats did not refuse to negotiate -- the governor did. The Democrats did not force the resignation of the state's budget director two weeks before the shut-down deadline -- the governor did. And the Democrats did not reintroduce unpopular and unworkable policy demands at the last minute, the way that the governor did by making an already-rejected pilot program for a statewide teachers contract a nonnegotiable condition. Last week, Gideon and Thibodeau were reportedly only $25 million apart on a deal: a difference of less than three-tenths of 1 percent in a proposed $7 billion budget. If Maine government goes over the brink, the blame will not be on the presiding officers. It will rest on Gov. LePage and the members of the House who backed him.” [Editorial, Kennebec Journal, 6/27/17]

Kennebec Journal Editorial On A Possible Government Shutdown: “The Democrats Did Not Refuse To Negotiate – The Governor Did. The Democrats Did Not Force The Resignation Of The State’s Budget Director Two Weeks Before The Shut-Down Deadline – The Governor Did.” “The governor and his allies are trying to convince wavering House members that if the government shuts down, most people will blame the Democrats. But that would be a risky supposition. The Democrats did not refuse to negotiate -- the governor did. The Democrats did not force the resignation of the state's budget director two weeks before the shut-down deadline -- the governor did. And the Democrats did not reintroduce unpopular and unworkable policy demands at the last minute, the way that the governor did by making an already-rejected pilot program for a statewide teachers contract a nonnegotiable condition. Last week, Gideon and Thibodeau were reportedly only $25 million apart on a deal: a difference of less than three-tenths of 1 percent in a proposed $7 billion budget. If Maine government goes over the brink, the blame will not be on the presiding officers. It will rest on Gov. LePage and the members of the House who backed him.” [Editorial, Kennebec Journal, 6/27/17]

Kennebec Journal Editorial On A Possible Government Shutdown: “The Democrats Did Not Reintroduce Unpopular And Unworkable Policy Demands At The Last Minute, The Way That The Governor Did By Making An Already-Rejected Pilot Program For A

Statewide Teachers A Nonnegotiable Condition.” “The governor and his allies are trying to convince wavering House members that if the government shuts down, most people will blame the Democrats. But that would be a risky supposition. The Democrats did not refuse to negotiate -- the governor did. The Democrats did not force the resignation of the state's budget director two weeks before the shut-down deadline -- the governor did. And the Democrats did not reintroduce unpopular and unworkable policy demands at the last minute, the way that the governor did by making an already-rejected pilot program for a statewide teachers contract a nonnegotiable condition. Last week, Gideon and Thibodeau were reportedly only $25 million apart on a deal: a difference of less than three-tenths of 1 percent in a proposed $7 billion budget. If Maine government goes over the brink, the blame will not be on the presiding officers. It will rest on Gov. LePage and the members of the House who backed him.” [Editorial, Kennebec Journal, 6/27/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial On Budget Negotiations: “[Republican Senate President] Thibodeau And Gideon, Like Real Leaders, Are Looking For Areas Of Compromise, Which Many In Their Party May Not Like But Realize Are Necessary To Come To A Budget Agreement.” “There is one path -- and one day -- left to finalize a state budget and avert a government shutdown. If legislative negotiators can reach agreement on a spending plan and both chambers of the State House approve it Friday, it could be on the governor's desk hours before a new budget must be in place. […] Thibodeau and Gideon, like real leaders, are looking for areas of compromise, which many in their party may not like but realize are necessary to come to a budget agreement.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 6/29/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “The Failure To Reach A Budget Agreement Rests At The Feet Of 60 Republicans Members Of The House Of Representatives, Led By Reps. Ken Fredette And Ellie Espling, Who Were More Intent On Kowtowing To Gov. Paul LePage’s Demands Than Serving The People Who Elected Them.” “Maine's government is shut down. It didn't have to happen. The failure to reach a budget agreement rests at the feet of 60 Republicans members of the House of Representatives, led by Reps. Ken Fredette and Ellie Espling, who were more intent on kowtowing to Gov. Paul LePage's demands than serving the people who elected them.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “Other Legislative Leaders, Especially House Speaker Sara Gideon And Senate President Mike Thibodeau Took Their Responsibilities Seriously. They Presided Over Weeks Of Negotiations.” “Other legislative leaders, especially House Speaker Sara Gideon and Senate President Mike Thibodeau took their responsibilities seriously. They presided over weeks of negotiations that resulted in a two-year spending budget that was approved by a 34-1 vote in the Senate Friday. The same budget passed the House by a vote of 87-60, falling short of the two-thirds necessary to enact the budget immediately and to override a potential veto from LePage.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “This Is What A Compromise Budget Looks Like…It Was Compromise, Not Hollow Threats And Grandstanding, That Allowed The State To Move Forward.” “This is what a compromise budget looks like. Each legislative caucus, and the governor, got some of what they wanted, but also agreed to things they didn’t like. The lesson from the shutdown of 2017? In the end, it was compromise, not hollow threats and grandstanding, that allowed the state to move forward.” [Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 7/7/17]

Source report (PDF)