Paul LePage: AFTER VOTERS PASSED MAINECARE EXPANSION, LEPAGE BLOCKED IMPLEMENTATION
In 2017, Maine Voters Overwhelmingly Voted to Expand Medicaid
11/7/17: Maine Voters Voted To Expand Medicaid 59 Percent To 41 Percent. “Maine voters said clearly on Tuesday that they support expanding the state's Medicaid program despite uncertainty caused by President Donald Trump's and congressional Republicans' efforts to repeal the Affordable Care Act. With 70 percent of precincts reporting at 10:25 p.m. Tuesday, vote tallies showed support for expansion at 59 percent and opposition at 41 percent. The Medicaid expansion question came to the ballot after years of legislative debate and rejection, including five bills that were vetoed successfully by Republican Gov. Paul LePage. Tuesday's passage of Question 2 will leave an indelible mark on the termed-out governor's legacy. [Bangor Daily News, 11/7/17]
- Voter-Approved Medicaid Expansion Law Increased The Qualifying Income To 138 Percent Of The Federal Poverty Level, Or $16,643 For Singles, $28,180 For A Family Of Three, And $39,716 For A Family Of Five. “Currently, Maine's Medicaid program, known as MaineCare, covers a range of groups, such as pregnant women, parents with children younger than 18 and disabled people. Qualifying income thresholds vary. Parents and disabled adults, for example, qualify if their incomes are below 100 percent of the federal poverty level. That's $12,060 a year for a single person, $20,421 for a family of three and $28,780 for a family of five. The bill passed in November would raise the qualifying threshold to 138 percent of the federal poverty level. That's $16,643 a year for a single person, $28,180 for a family of three and $39,716 for a family of five. The bill also expands coverage to adults who are not disabled and don't have children, which would be a change from current law.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/11/17]
- Voter-Approved Medicaid Expansion Law Expanded Medicaid To Non-Disabled Adults Without Children, A Change From Current Law. “Currently, Maine's Medicaid program, known as MaineCare, covers a range of groups, such as pregnant women, parents with children younger than 18 and disabled people. Qualifying income thresholds vary. Parents and disabled adults, for example, qualify if their incomes are below 100 percent of the federal poverty level. That's $12,060 a year for a single person, $20,421 for a family of three and $28,780 for a family of five. The bill passed in November would raise the qualifying threshold to 138 percent of the federal poverty
level. That's $16,643 a year for a single person, $28,180 for a family of three and $39,716 for a family of five. The bill also expands coverage to adults who are not disabled and don't have children, which would be a change from current law.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/11/17]
NPR: “Medicaid Expansion Would Bring Health Coverage To About 70,000 People In Maine.” “Medicaid expansion would bring health coverage to about 70,000 people in Maine.” [NPR, 11/8/17]
NPR: “Medicaid Expansion Would Also Be A Win For Hospitals.” “Medicaid expansion would also be a win for hospitals. More than half of them in Maine are operating in the red. Across the state, they provide more than $100 million a year in charity care, according to the Maine Hospital Association. Expanding Medicaid coverage would bolster their fiscal health and give doctors and nurses more options to treat their formerly uninsured patients, says Jeff Austin, a spokesman with the association.” [NPR, 11/8/17]
- Maine Hospital Association Spokesman Said Expanding Medicaid In Maine Would Help Hospitals’ Fiscal Health And Give Doctors And Nurses More Options To Treat Low-Income Patients. “Medicaid expansion would also be a win for hospitals. More than half of them in Maine are operating in the red. Across the state, they provide more than $100 million a year in charity care, according to the Maine Hospital Association. Expanding Medicaid coverage would bolster their fiscal health and give doctors and nurses more options to treat their formerly uninsured patients, says Jeff Austin, a spokesman with the association.” [NPR, 11/8/17]
Governor LePage Called On The Legislature To Find Money To Implement Medicaid Expansion Without Raising Taxes Or Using State Savings “LePage triggered some gasps from lawmakers assembled in the House chamber when he said Maine should enact Medicaid expansion, which became the law following a 2017 referendum, before this November's election. But he quickly shifted to ‘the bad news,’ which isn't news at all: He wants the Legislature to appropriate funding to do it without raising taxes, relying on gimmicks or touching the state's accumulated savings -- and only after clearing waitlists for services to elderly and disabled Mainers. ‘Appropriate the money so we can do it,’ LePage said. Gideon bristled at LePage's demands in comments to reporters following the speech. She has argued that there is enough money in the state's Medicaid account to cover expansion costs until 2019. ‘When the Legislature needs to appropriate the funds, we will absolutely do that, but we'll do it on our timetable,’ Gideon said.” [Bangor Daily News, 2/13/18]
Headline: “Maine’s Governor is Trying to Block the State’s Medicaid Expansion the Day After Voters Overwhelmingly Supported it.” [Business Insider, 11/8/17]
Headline: “LePage Accuses Medicaid Expansion Supporters of Lying But Offers Scant Proof.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/31/17]
Portland Press Herald Editorial Headline: “Gov. LePage Way Off Base on State Question 2: He’s Wrong About How Much Medicaid Expansion Costs, How it Works, and Who Gets it.” [Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 10/30/17]
Headline: “LePage: Medicaid Expansion Would ‘Kill’ Maine.” [Bangor Daily News, 8/15/17]
Portland Press Herald Editorial Headline: “LePage’s Medicaid Stance Subverts the Voters’ Will; He’s Had His Chance to Obstruct Expansion – Now it’s His Duty to See That it Takes Place.” [Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 12/13/17]
Headline: “LePage Digs in for Medicaid Expansion Funding Battle.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/11/17]
Alan Caron Column Headline: “Republicans Mess With Medicaid Expansion at Their Own Peril; Augusta Has Gotten into a Bad Habit, Under Gov. LePage, of Ignoring the Will of Maine Voters.” [Portland Press Herald, 11/14/17]
Headline: “LePage Erects High Hurdles for Medicaid Expansion After Maine’s Historic Vote.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/8/17]
In April 2018, Paul LePage Missed a Deadline and Failed to Submit a Proposal to the Federal Government Indicating How Maine Would Expand Medicaid
April 2018: The Deadline For The Maine Department Of Health And Human Services To File A Plan With The Federal Government With How Maine Intended To Expand Medicaid Passed Without Governor LePage’s Administration Submitting Such A Proposal. “Tuesday was the deadline for the Maine Department of Health and Human Services to file a plan with federal regulators for how the state planned to expand Medicaid coverage to an estimated 70,000 additional adults as part of a ballot initiative approved by Maine voters last November. But Gov. Paul LePage has said repeatedly that his administration would not move forward with implementation until the Legislature funds expansion fully, raising the specter of potential legal challenges. On Tuesday, expansion advocates held a news conference calling on LePage to submit the state's implementation plan to the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.” [Kennebec Journal, 4/4/18]
LePage Fought Against Expansion Even After the Voters Passed it, Arguing That Since the Legislature Had Failed to Fund it, He Did Not Need to Implement it – Expansion Advocates Argued Expansion Could Have Been Paid for by Existing Surpluses. According to the Bangor Daily News, “LePage has led the fight against expansion during his tenure, vetoing legislative expansion plans five times. Lawyers for his administration have argued that the state has not had to implement the law because it has not been funded by the Legislature, which failed earlier this year to pass a start-up funding package over the governor's veto. Advocates for expansion, led by the progressive Maine Equal Justice Partners, have shot back by saying that existing surpluses or Medicaid funds could be used fund it, at least in the interim. Murphy has largely upheld their arguments so far and did so again in her Wednesday order.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/21/18]
New York Times Headline: “A Vote Expanded Medicaid In Maine. The Governor Is Ignoring It.” [New York Times, 7/24/18]
New York Times: Despite Voter Approving Medicaid Expansion LePage “Refused To Expand The Program, Blasting It As A Needless, Budget-Busting Form Of Welfare.” According to the New York Times, “Brandy Staples, a 39-year-old breast cancer survivor, had expected to become eligible for Medicaid coverage this month after Maine voters approved an expansion of the program last fall. Instead, she found herself in a courtroom here on Wednesday, watching the latest chapter unfold in a rancorous, drawn-out battle over whether she and thousands of other poor people in the state will get free government insurance after all. Ignoring the binding vote, Gov. Paul LePage has refused to expand the program, blasting it as a needless, budget-busting form of welfare.” [New York Times, 7/24/18]
In May 2018, the Paul LePage Administration Was Sued Over its Failure to Implement the Will of the Voters and Expand Medicaid
HEADLINE: “Maine Advocates Sue State Over Inaction On Medicaid Expansion.” [Congressional Quarterly Healthbeat, 4/30/18]
May 2018: Maine Equal Justice Partners Sued The State Of Maine To Force It To Expand Medicaid As Approved By Maine Voters. “The advocacy group that led the successful ballot-box campaign to expand Medicaid in Maine filed a lawsuit Monday seeking to compel the state to implement the program. Maine Equal Justice Partners filed the suit in state Superior Court in Augusta, arguing that the failure to expand Medicaid is harming low-income Mainers who by law should be eligible to receive Medicaid insurance this year.” [Kennebec Journal, 5/1/18]
In June 2018, a Maine Court Ordered the Paul LePage Administration to Implement Medicaid Expansion
Headline: “Court Orders Maine Governor to Expand Medicaid.” [Politico, 6/4/18]
Headline: “Judge Orders LePage to Submit Plan for Medicaid Expansion.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/4/18]
June 2018: The Maine Superior Court Ordered Maine To Implement Medicaid Expansion and File its Plan to Expand Medicaid With the Federal Government. “Today, the Maine Superior Court issued a decision ordering the LePage Administration to implement the voter-approved Medicaid Expansion law and file a State Plan Amendment. Speaker of the House Sara Gideon released the following statement: ‘Voters, and now the Maine Superior Court have made it clear - implementation of this law is a responsibility and obligation that needs to be fulfilled. No more delays. Thousands of Mainers cannot afford to wait any longer for the health care they need to be and stay well.’” [Press Release, Maine House Democrats, 6/4/18]
Headline: “LePage Files Appeal Over Court Order on Medicaid.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/8/18]
Headline: “LePage Asks Maine’s Top Court to Overrule Judge’s Order to Submit Medicaid Plan.” [St. John Valley Times, 6/19/18]
Headline: “LePage Again Ordered to File Medicaid Plan, So He Submits.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/19/18]
In July 2018, Paul LePage Vetoed Legislation That Would Have Funded the First Year of Medicaid Expansion
Headline: “LePage Says He’ll Go to Jail Before He Let’s Maine Expand Medicaid.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/12/18]
Headline: “LePage Wins Latest Swipe Against Medicaid Expansion.” [Associated Press, 7/9/18]
Headline: “Veto Ends Any Chance LePage Will Follow Law; After Moving the Goalposts on Medicaid Expansion, He Blames Others for its Being Stalled.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/3/18]
Headline: “LePage Vetoes Medicaid Expansion Funding; Lawmakers Will Try an Override in July, and Supporters of Extending Benefits to 70,000 Mainers Still Urge Them to Enroll.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/30/18]
Headline: “LePage Says He’ll Veto Medicaid Expansion Funding Bill.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/29/18]
Headline: “LePage Foils Medicaid Expansion Again as His Veto Stands.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/10/18]
Headline: “House Republicans Back LePage Veto, Keeping Medicaid Expansion in Limbo.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/9/18]
Headline: “LePage Vetoes 23 Bills, Including One for Medicaid Expansion.” [Morning Sentinel, 7/3/18]
Headline: “Signups Start for Expanded Medicaid, But Path Still Rocky; Gov. LePage’s Veto of a Bill to Fund the Voter-Approved Law Raises Doubts, But Supporters Urge People to Apply Anyway.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/3/18]
In July 2018, LePage Vetoed Legislation That Would Have Funded The First Year Of Medicaid Expansion. In July 2018, LePage vetoed LD837. “The Maine Legislature doesn't plan to waste any time next week in dealing with Gov. Paul LePage's veto of a funding source for Medicaid expansion. House Speaker Sara Gideon's office anticipates the matter will come after the long holiday weekend. LePage said in vetoing the bill that it was the seventh time he'd used his veto power to thwart an expansion of Medicaid to 70,000 people. He described those vetoes as being ‘among the most important acts of my governorship.’” The House’s attempt to override Governor LePage’s veto failed by a vote of 85-58. [State of Maine Legislature, LD 837, Roll Call #698, 7/9/18; Associated Press, 7/3/18]
- The Legislation Would Have Funded $31 Million Claims Cost And $3.8 Million In Administrative Costs. “LD 837 “An Act To Provide Supplemental Appropriations and Allocations for the Operations of State Government,” was amended by Rep. Drew Gattine to allocate $31 million in claims cost, in addition to the $3.8 million in administrative costs. The bill passed the House 78-58.” [Press Release, Speaker Sara Gideon, 6/19/18] Headline: “As LePage Fights Medicaid, Mainers Apply.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/24/18]
Headline: “Maine’s Top Court Backs Ruling That LePage Must Send Medicaid Expansion Plan to Feds.” [St. John Valley Times, 8/26/18]
In September 2018, Paul LePage Filed His Medicaid Expansion Plan with the Federal Government, But Urged the Federal Government to Reject the Plan
Headline: “LePage’s Obstruction Continues as Thousands of Mainers Await Access to Health Insurance.” [Bangor Daily News, 9/8/18]
Headline: “LePage Says He’ll Deny Applicants Until Medicaid Expansion is Funded.” [St. John Valley Times, 9/10/18]
Headline: “LePage to Feds: Deny Medicaid Plan.” [Kennebec Journal, 9/5/18]
Headline: “LePage Files Medicaid Expansion Plan, But Asks Officials to Reject it; Even as He Complies With a Court Order to Submit a State Plan Amendment to Federal Authorities, He Undermines it.” [Portland Press Herald, 9/5/18]
In Sept. 2018, LePage Complied With a Court Order to Submit Documentation to the Federal Government to Expand Maine’s Medicaid Program, But Asked Federal Officials to Deny the Application. According to the Portland Press Herald, “The LePage administration complied with a court order Tuesday and finally submitted required documents to the federal government to expand Medicaid to 70,000 Mainers - but there's a catch. Gov. Paul LePage, an expansion opponent, is asking federal officials to deny the application.” [Portland Press Herald, 9/5/18]
In November 2018, Paul LePage Administration’s Was Again Ordered by a Maine Court to Implement Medicaid Expansion
Headline: “LePage Requests Stay of Order to Implement Medicaid Expansion.” [St. John Valley Times, 11/28/18]
Headline: “Mills’ Office Opposes LePage in Medicaid Expansion Court Fight That Will Drag Past Election Day.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/24/18]
Headline: “LePage Seeks Medicaid Expansion Delay.” [Morning Sentinel, 11/29/18]
In Nov. 2018, the Maine Superior Court Ordered LePage’s Administration to Implement Voter-Approved Medicaid Expansion. According to the Bangor Daily News, “A judge ordered Gov. Paul LePage's administration on Wednesday to implement voter-approved Medicaid expansion, which could be one of the final steps in a monthslong court battle over whether the state must provide 70,000 Mainers with health coverage. The 21-page ruling from Superior Court Justice Michaela Murphy found that the Maine Department of Health and Human Services has ‘failed and refused to comply’ with the law passed by Maine voters in 2017 that would expand Medicaid under the federal Affordable Care Act.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/21/18]
- Headline: “A Judge Ordered LePage to Expand Medicaid. He Plans to Keep Fighting It.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/21/18]
In December 2018, a Maine Court Denied Paul LePage’s Stay Request for Expansion
Headline: “Judge Rejects LePage Bid to Stall Medicaid Expansion.” [St. John Valley Times, 12/7/18]
December 2018: Maine Superior Court Denied LePage Administration’s Stay Request for Medicaid Expansion. “Judge Michaela Murphy of the Maine Superior Court has denied a stay request by the LePage Administration regarding implementation of voter-approved Medicaid expansion, but set a new February 1st deadline to being enrolling eligible Mainers. Speaker of the House Sara Gideon released the following statement: ‘The Court is yet again asserting that Medicaid expansion is the law of the land and Governor LePage and his Administration are being held accountable. While I’m deeply disappointed that this needless battle has delayed the 70,000 Mainers who are eligible from receiving access to healthcare, the end is in sight. I am eager to work in partnership with Governor-elect Mills to ensure this law is followed and that more Mainers are accessing the care they deserve to be and stay well.’” [Press Release, Speaker Sara Gideon, 12/6/18]
LePage Fought Protracted Legal Battle to Block Medicaid Expansion Approved by Ballot Initiative in 2017, Pushing Implementation Until After His Departure Form Office in 2018. According to the Bangor Daily News, “A judge has denied Gov. Paul LePage’s administration’s request to stay an order forcing it to implement voter-approved Medicaid expansion, but pushed the deadline to do so back to after the Republican leaves office. The Thursday ruling effectively hands the long-running political and legal fight over implementing a policy that voters approved in 2017 to Gov.-elect Janet Mills, a Democrat who has said fully implementing the expansion plan is a top priority.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/6/20]