Paul LePage: APPOINTMENTS
“Perhaps The Most Commonly Heard Complaint Throughout The State House These Days Is That Those Anointed [By Paul Lepage] To Run Various Agencies Have Precious Little Idea How Those Operations Actually Function. What’s Worse, Second-Tier Managers Who Could Help Accelerate That Learning Curve Have Either Resigned Or Been Fired.” “Perhaps the most commonly heard complaint throughout the State House these days is that those anointed to run various agencies have precious little idea how those operations actually function. What’s worse, second-tier managers who could help accelerate that learning curve have either resigned or been fired.” (Portland Press Herald, 04/29/11)
Mary Mayhew – DHHS
Paul Lepage Hired Mary Mayhew, A Corporate Lobbyist, To Run Maine’s Department Of Health And Human Services (DHHS). From the beginning, Mayhew was seriously unqualified for the job. She had no significant administrative credentials and her primary State House experience was as a lobbyist for the Maine Hospital Association.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/05/11 and 03/25/12)
Bruce Poliquin – State Treasurer
Paul Lepage’s Handpicked State Treasurer Bruce Poliquin Has Been Dogged By Numerous Ethical Issues, Including Not Adequately Disclosing “His Business Income As Required By Maine Law,” Potentially Violating The Prohibition On “The State Treasurer… Engaging In Commerce While …In Office,” And Taking A Tax Break To Which It Does Not Appear That He Was Entitled, Saving Him Between $200,000 And $250,000 In Property Taxes. Bruce “Poliquin was chosen by the Republican majority in the Legislature in December 2010 to serve as treasurer, following a recommendation from Gov. Paul LePage.” (Kennebec Journal, 02/28/12) “State Treasurer Bruce Poliquin did not adequately disclose his business income as required by Maine law, but he shouldn’t be fined for it. That’s the recommendation of the staff at the Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices in response to a complaint filed by the Maine Democratic Party.” Poliquin “said he found the disclosure form confusing, leading him to omit three sources of income: Membership dues from his Popham Beach Club, non-cash income from Marshall Mall Associates and income his son received during a summer internship.” “Ethics staff said that Poliquin’s original income disclosure reported his ‘most significant income sources.’” The “staff didn’t recommend the maximum $100 fine because Poliquin had already filed an amended income disclosure before the commission requested it.” Maine’s Constitution “prohibits the state treasurer from engaging in commerce while he or she is in office.” Bruce Poliquin owns “Dirigo Holdings LLC, a real estate business that runs the Popham Woods Condominiums in Phippsburg.” “Attorney General William Schneider…issued an advisory opinion saying Poliquin should take steps to insulate himself from the Dirigo Holdings, such as establishing a blind trust.” “The treasurer issued a short written statement saying he would follow the AG’s advice.” “Prior to the AG’s opinion, Poliquin told radio station WGAN 560 that he was too busy to be involved with Dirigo Holdings and that the company was effectively managed by a bookkeeper. However, the AG report noted that Poliquin is ‘the sole member of and registered agent for Dirigo Holdings LLC.’ The report also noted that Poliquin is the sole signatory for the company checkbook.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 02/27/12) In addition, “he appeared before the Phippsburg Planning Board…to request permission to expand one of his businesses, the Popham Beach Club.” (Kennebec Journal, 02/28/12) “Poliquin…acknowledged that his appearance… [in 2011] before the Phippsburg Board of Selectmen advocating for the Beach Club was a mistake.” On the issue of taxation, Bruce Poliquin enrolled “his Georgetown waterfront property in the state’s 40-year-old Tree Growth Tax Program. Property owners enrolled in Tree Growth receive significant property tax breaks for engaging in harvesting activities designed to bolster the state’s forest products industry.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 02/27/12) “According to Mary McDonald, who is the assistant to the Georgetown Board of Selectmen, Poliquin enrolled in the program in 2004 when he applied to set aside 10 acres of his property for tree growth.” (Bangor Daily News, 02/02/12) “However, a deed restriction on Poliquin’s property appears to prohibit most of those activities. The restriction is enshrined in perpetuity, part of a land swap between the Nature Conservancy and the parcel’s previous owners.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 02/27/12) “The Maine Forest Service, in a 2009 report, identified the treasurer’s Georgetown property as an example of a possible misuse of that program.” “‘For several reasons, including difficulty of road access and the restrictions on timber harvesting according to the state’s shoreland zoning regulations, the ability to harvest any timber on this property – even if that was the interest of the landowner – is extremely limited,’ the MMA said in the report.” (Bangor Daily News, 02/02/12) “The Tree Growth program…allowed the treasurer to pay about $30 a year on…[a] 10-acre parcel, a savings of roughly $30,000 every year since he enrolled in the program in 2004.” In 2012 he “applied with the Georgetown Board of Selectmen to withdraw his land from the Maine Tree Growth Tax Law program, following claims that he’d misused the abatement law as a tax shelter.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 03/14/12) Paul “LePage stepped in to defend the treasurer, saying it was up to towns to enforce the law and that to this point he hadn’t heard any complaints. Towns are charged with enforcing the Tree Growth law.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 02/27/12)
Bill Beardsley – Maine Board of Education
Paul Lepage Nominated To The Maine Board Of Education A College President Who Did Not Report Allegations Of Pedophilia, Even Though He Was Legally “Required To Report Such Allegations.” According to a news story with the headline, “LePage picks controversial commissioner for Board of Education,” Paul LePage nominated “Bill Beardsley to become a member of the Maine Board of Education.” When Bill Beardsley was the president of Husson College he was told “that the Rev. Bob Carlson, who was the chaplain at Husson from 1995 to 2006, sexually abused several children over 40 years, according to a person interviewed by the Maine State Police. Soon after police began investigating Carlson, he committed suicide.” “Beardsley, who would have been required to report such allegations, said he was warned about inappropriate sexual relationships involving Carlson but did not know minors were involved. ‘I absolutely had no knowledge of any unlawful activity by Rev. Bob Carlson,’ he” said. (The Portland Press Herald, 08/30/12)
- Beardsley Said he Had no Knowledge of Unlawful Activity. “Beardsley, who would have been required to report such allegations, said he was warned about inappropriate sexual relationships involving Carlson but did not know minors were involved. ‘I absolutely had no knowledge of any unlawful activity by Rev. Bob Carlson,’ he said earlier this month.” [Morning Sentinel, 8/30/12]
Philip Congdon – Maine Department of Economic and Community Development
Paul Lepage Appointed Tea Party Activist Philip Congdon To Be The Commissioner Of The Maine Department Of Economic And Community Development. Congdon “Admitted To Lawmakers At His Confirmation Hearing…That His Career…Had Precious Little To Do With The Art And Science Of Community And Economic Development” And “That Rural Development Was Something” He Had Not “‘Thought About.’” Paul LePage, in January 2011, appointed Philip Congdon, a “retired Texas Instruments executive,” to be the commissioner of the Maine Department of Economic and Community Development. (Portland Press Herald, 01/24/11) He was also a “former member of the Maine Constitutionalists, a tea party organization in Waldoboro.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/29/11) Philip Congdon “admitted to lawmakers at his confirmation hearing in January [2011] that his career with Texas Instruments had precious little to do with the art and science of community and economic development. And when asked at the same hearing how he planned to jump-start the economy of Aroostook County, Congdon unabashedly admitted that rural development was something ‘I haven’t thought about.’ Apparently he still hasn’t. In his now-infamous appearance before the Caribou Chamber of Commerce…Congdon left the entire audience in shocked silence after opining that a) universities have gone downhill since they started admitting blacks, b) things are in the state they are today because of poor parenting and c) the people in Aroostook County will prosper only if they ‘get off the reservation’ and get to work.” (Portland Press Herald, 04/29/11)
- He “Was Forced To Resign” After He Left An “Entire Audience In Shocked Silence After Opining That A) Universities Have Gone Downhill Since They Started Admitting Blacks, B) Things Are In The State They Are Today Because Of Poor Parenting And C) The People In Aroostook County Will Prosper Only If They ‘Get Off The Reservation’ And Get To Work.” In his now-infamous appearance before the Caribou Chamber of Commerce…Congdon left the entire audience in shocked silence after opining that a) universities have gone downhill since they started admitting blacks, b) things are in the state they are today because of poor parenting and c) the people in Aroostook County will prosper only if they ‘get off the reservation’ and get to work.” (Portland Press Herald, 04/29/11) Democratic state Representative John Martin sent a letter to Paul LePage that “included…quotations attributed to Congdon. ‘The following comments were reported to me,’ Martin wrote in his letter dated April 25, 2011. ‘The problem with higher education today dates back to the civil rights movement in the ’60s that allowed blacks to enter colleges. That resulted in the large amount of remedial education required in colleges.’ ‘People in Aroostook County ought to get the hell off the reservation and create jobs for Aroostook County. You have not done a good job of
educating your kids.’” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 05/04/11) Congdon “was forced to resign…after reportedly making…[this] series of inappropriate comments.” (Portland Press Herald, 06/03/11) “LePage’s office announced the resignation of Congdon two days after receiving Martin’s letter.” “Congdon later told a Sun Journal reporter that he was misquoted and that his comments had been taken out of context. ‘Unfortunately, I thought I was talking to people who were sufficiently intelligent enough to understand my real meaning,’ Congdon told the Sun Journal a day later. ‘I was mistaken.’” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 05/04/11)
Darryl Brown – Department of Environmental Protection
Paul Lepage’s First DEP Commissioner Had To Resign After The State Attorney General’s Office Determined He Is Ineligible To Serve In This Position Under State Law Because Of Conflicts Of Interest Involving His Consulting Firm. Darryl Brown, in April 2011, resigned “as commissioner of Maine’s Department of Environmental Protection after the Attorney General’s Office said he was ‘unqualified’ to serve under Maine law.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 04/28/11) “The Attorney General’s Office said it appeared Brown had a conflict of interest as DEP commissioner because of his financial interests in a consulting firm, Main-Land Development Consultants, that he owns. The firm represented developers as they sought DEP permits for projects.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/29/11) He “was forced to step down after Attorney General William Schneider informed him that those pesky environmentalists were right all along – conflict-of-interest laws prohibit Brown…from presiding over the DEP.” (Portland Press Herald, 04/29/11)
- “Despite Early Evidence” That The Commissioner “Was Potentially Ineligible…The Administration” Did Not Investigate The Situation. “Despite early evidence Brown was potentially ineligible…the administration” did not investigate the situation. “Instead, they relied on a preliminary inquiry conducted by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and, for a time, Brown’s word that he was, in fact, eligible.” Two months before Darryl Brown resigned “two senior LePage administration aides talked with legislative leaders…about amending state law to ensure he could” stay in his cabinet post, but legislative leaders rejected the idea. Despite this outreach, Paul “LePage said he never asked legislative leaders to change the law while Brown was in office.” (Kennebec Journal, 05/01/11)
- When It Became Obvious That There Was A Problem, The Lepage Administration Tried To Change The Law To Keep The Commissioner In Office. “By state law, anyone who has received, in the two previous years, at least 10 percent of their income directly or indirectly from clients who receive or apply for permits or licenses under the federal Clean Water Act may not be commissioner of the DEP. The state law mirrors federal law, except a violation of the federal law doesn’t make a commissioner ineligible to serve, but results in a loss of federal permitting authority. Maine Attorney General William Schneider issued a letter…that said it appeared Brown was ineligible. Schneider’s letter said that if Brown couldn’t produce documents showing there was no conflict of interest, he would be unqualified to serve. That created a problem for Brown, because Schneider noted that any documentation he provided would be considered public
record. Release of those records could hurt Brown’s business, which consults for other companies on land-use issues, said Brown’s personal attorney, L. Clinton Boothby.” Earlier in 2011 “Brown insisted that he was eligible, saying, ‘I am confident that I don’t exceed the 10 percent threshold.’ Brown said…that he was ‘obviously’ wrong, but that Maine’s law is ‘silliness.’ ‘It truly is nothing more than silliness,’ he said. ‘It precludes anybody with any kind of experience, and the kind of management that’s required at a department like the Department of Environmental Protection, to be left out of the process and not be able to be involved.’” “LePage criticized Maine’s law as ‘inflexible.’ He said he has spoken with legislative leaders about changing it.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 04/28/11) “Rather than admit his choice for commissioner of the Department of Environmental Protection was not properly cleared of potential conflicts under state and federal law and, therefore, a poor choice, Gov. Paul LePage blamed the needed conflict-of- interest law – and pledged to have it changed.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/29/11)
- Bangor Daily News Editorial: Brown a Poor Choice. The Bangor Daily News opined of LePage’s pick of Darryl Brown, “Rather than admit his choice for commissioner of the Department of Environmental Protection was not properly cleared of potential conflicts under state and federal law and, therefore, a poor choice, Gov. Paul LePage blamed the needed conflict-of-interest law — and pledged to have it changed. Lawmakers can’t go along with this.” [Bangor Daily News editorial, 4/28/11]
Joseph Ponte – Maine Department of Corrections
Corrections Corp. Of America, In 2010, Indirectly Contributed $25,000 To Paul Lepage’s Gubernatorial Campaign. Paul Lepage, In 2011, Appointed A Corrections Corp. Of America Executive To Head The Maine Department Of Corrections. Paul LePage appointed Joseph Ponte “to lead the Department of Corrections.” At the time of the appointment he was “the warden of a prison in Nevada that’s owned by Corrections Corp. of America, the country’s largest private-sector corrections company.” At the time of the appointment “Ponte said he still owns stock in Corrections Corp. of America and has no plans to give it up.” “Ponte has more than 40 years of public- and private-sector experience in corrections, having served in corrections departments in Massachusetts, Rhode Island and Idaho.” “Town officials in Milo have been in touch with Corrections Corp. of America since 2008 about the prospect of building a for-profit prison there, but the company has refused to commit unless Maine law is changed to allow prisoners to serve time in private facilities. The company donated $25,000 to the Republican Governors Association, which transferred the money to its Maine political action committee. The committee spent its money to help elect LePage.” (Kennebec Journal, 01/25/11) In effect, Corrections Corp. of America “contributed $25,000 to LePage’s election campaign through a contribution to the Republican Governors Association.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/25/11) Paul “LePage said there is no connection between the prospect of a prison in Milo, Corrections Corp. of America’s donation and his selection of Ponte.” He “said the position was offered to people from Maine, but ‘they refused it because we couldn’t pay enough.’” (Kennebec Journal, 01/25/11) Corrections Corp. of America has no facilities in Maine. (www.cca.com/facilities/?state=ME)
Patricia Aho – Department of Environmental Protection
Paul Lepage Made A Lobbyist For Oil And Chemical Producers, Including “Companies Opposing The BPA” Ban, The DEP Commissioner. Paul LePage named Patricia Aho the Deputy Commissioner of DEP in February 2011. She is “a former lobbyist for…companies opposing the BPA rule.” (Bangor Daily News, 02/05/11) “As a lobbyist in 2010, Aho represented several clients before the Legislature, including auto manufacturers, the American Chemistry Council, the American Petroleum Institute, Casella Waste Systems, Dead River Co., Poland Spring and Verso Paper, according to the Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices.” (Portland Press Herald, 09/10/11) Paul LePage later named Patricia Aho the DEP commissioner. “The state Senate in September [2011] approved the appointment.” (Portland Press Herald, 10/16/11)
Richard McGoldrick – Finance Authority of Maine
LePage Nominated Richard McGoldrick to FAME, But McGoldrick Withdrew His Name from Consideration After It Emerged That LePage Had Already Committed to Appointing Someone Else to the Role. According to the Kennebec Journal, LePage admitted his error in the appointment of Richard McGoldrick who “requested that the administration withdraw his nomination to the agency that is redeveloping the former Brunswick Naval Air Station. McGoldrick's email was triggered by LePage's failure to reappoint Susan Snowden to the Finance Authority of Maine, which provides access to low-interest financing to development projects… LePage acknowledged the error, writing that he had committed to re-seat Snowden… The correspondence, obtained through a Freedom of Access Act request by the Portland Press Herald, explains why two of the governor's more than 70 nominees withdrew before last week's confirmation hearings at the State House. It also sheds light on recent protests from a Brunswick official that appointments to the base redevelopment agency, and perhaps others, are based more on politics and favors than expertise.” [Kennebec Journal, 9/12/12]
- McGoldrick Donated to LePage, Republican Party. “McGoldrick is a frequent participant in the political process. In 2010, he donated $750 to LePage's campaign, the maximum allowed at the time. He also gave $1,500 to the Maine Republican Party.” [Kennebec Journal, 9/12/12]
Unfilled Positions
Bangor Daily News: LePage Left “Hundreds Of Vacant Seats On State Boards And Commissions.” “Gov. Janet Mills is now more than two months into her tenure and has made many breaks from former Gov. Paul LePage, but she and her administration have barely begun to fill hundreds of vacant seats on state boards and commissions. Those spots often fly under the radar when it comes to observing state government, but there are more than 300 of these groups that help advise policymakers and regulate most facets of life, from the Maine Public Utilities Commission to the State Board of Funeral Service.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/14/19]