Paul LePage: CRITICISM OF LEPAGE AS GOVERNOR, GENERALLY
Criticism of Paul LePage’s Leadership/Ability to do the Job
Portland Press Herald Editorial: “Gov. Lepage Acts Like He’s In Over His Head; Personnel Meltdowns… Show A Management Style Unsuited To Public Office.” (Portland Press Herald, 05/01/11)
According To A Newspaper Story With The Headline, “Executive Branch Has Become 3-Ring Circus” And Another Newspaper Story With The Headline, “Ringmaster Over His Head Under Big Top,” Under Paul Lepage “The Executive Branch Is Now Officially A Three-Ring Circus,” With Paul Lepage As “The Ringmaster Himself.” He Is “Utterly Unprepared…For The Center Ring Of Maine’s State Government.” According to a newspaper story with the headline, “Executive branch has become 3-ring circus” and another newspaper story with the headline, “Ringmaster over his head under Big Top,” the “sudden departures of commissioners Darryl Brown from the Department of Environmental Protection and Philip Congdon from the Department of Economic and Community Development confirm what many have long feared since Team LePage rode into Augusta promising to transform Maine state government into something …well, different. They’ve done it: After just under four months, the executive branch is now officially a three-ring circus. In one ring we have Brown, who was forced to step down after Attorney General William Schneider informed him that…conflict-of-interest laws prohibit Brown, who owns a development consulting firm, from presiding over the DEP. For weeks, Brown insisted that he was not in violation of identical federal and state statutes – which made him ineligible to serve if 10 percent or more of his income in the last two years came from applicants for and holders of federal clean water permits. He was, as he [later] conceded… ‘obviously’ wrong.” “In another ring we have Congdon.” He “admitted to lawmakers at his confirmation hearing in January [2011] that his career with Texas Instruments had precious little to do with the art and science of community and economic development. And when asked at the same hearing how he planned to jump-start the economy of Aroostook County, Congdon unabashedly admitted that rural development was something ‘I haven’t thought about.’ Apparently he still hasn’t. In his now-infamous appearance before the Caribou Chamber of Commerce…Congdon left the entire audience in shocked silence after opining that a) universities have gone downhill since they started admitting blacks, b) things are in the state they are today because of poor parenting and c) the people in Aroostook County will prosper only if they ‘get off the reservation’ and get to work.” “Which brings us to the ringmaster himself. LePage’s reaction to the latest in his never-ending series of sideshows…illustrates once again how utterly unprepared the man is, was and may forever be for the center ring of Maine’s state government. Rather than admit that his transition team blew it by failing to vet Brown against an easy-to-find state law before choosing him as Maine’s top environmental cop, LePage blamed the law. And he vowed, come hell or high wires, to change it.” (Portland Press Herald, 04/29/11, and Waterville Morning Sentinel, 04/30/11)
PPH Editorial: Paul Lepage “Has Surrounded Himself With People Who, Like Him, Are Novices To State Government…And Excluded Those Who Could Augment His Get-Tough Philosophy With Experience, Expertise And An Occasional Dash Of Common Sense.” His Administration Looks “Like A Relentless March Toward Disaster.” According to an editorial with the headline, “Gov. LePage acts like he’s in over his head; Personnel meltdowns…show a management style unsuited to public office,” Paul LePage “recklessly established a culture of so-called ‘straight talk’ that more often than not manifests itself in outrageous pronouncements and hurtful wisecracks that leave many Mainers at least shaking their heads and sometimes shaking their fists.” “Unfortunately, the problems with LePage’s administration go beyond his own or his appointees’ loose lips. It’s beginning to look as though LePage may not be up to the job.” “LePage’s repeated refusals to take responsibility for bad decisions or apologize for offending the people who pay his salary exacerbate the difficulties he’s had getting his administration up and running.” “For the most part, the governor has surrounded himself with people who, like him, are novices to state government. He has filled his administration with people he is comfortable with, politically and personally, and excluded those who could augment his get-tough philosophy with experience, expertise and an occasional dash of common sense. LePage doesn’t seem to take advice from anyone, much less from newspaper editorials, but we’ll offer some anyway.” “Seeking the right kind of help could rescue his administration from what looks for all the world like a relentless march toward disaster. He wouldn’t be the first governor, or president, or CEO, to realize that he was in over his head and needed to eat some humble pie to save himself.” (Portland Press Herald, 05/01/11)
The Resignations Of Three Top Lepage Officials In His First Four Months As Governor Raised “Questions About Lepage’s Management Abilities” And Highlighted “A Lackadaisical Vetting Process.” Paul LePage, in less than his first four months as governor, “lost his communications director and two Cabinet members.” “The resignations of [the] three officials” raised “questions about LePage’s management abilities.” “While LePage’s willingness to part with his appointees is seen by some as a sign of his flexibility, the loss of three key people so early in the administration points to a lackadaisical vetting process, said Ronald Schmidt Jr., chairman of the Political Science Department at the University of Southern Maine.” (Kennebec Journal, 05/01/11)
PPH Editorial: LePage Repeatedly Refuses “To Take Responsibility For Bad Decisions Or Apologize For Offending The People Who Pay His Salary.” “Unfortunately, the problems with LePage’s administration go beyond his own or his appointees’ loose lips. It’s beginning to look as though LePage may not be up to the job.” “LePage’s repeated refusals to take responsibility for bad decisions or apologize for offending the people who pay his salary exacerbate the difficulties he’s had getting his administration up and running.” “For the most part, the governor has surrounded himself with people who, like him, are novices to state government. He has filled his administration with people he is comfortable with, politically and personally, and excluded those who could augment his get-tough philosophy with experience, expertise and an occasional dash of common sense. LePage doesn’t seem to take advice from anyone, much less from newspaper editorials, but we’ll offer some anyway.” “Seeking the right kind of help could rescue his administration from what looks for all the world like a relentless march toward disaster. He wouldn’t be the first governor, or president, or CEO, to realize that he was in over his head and needed to eat some humble pie to save himself.” (Portland Press Herald, 05/01/11)
Criticism of Paul LePage’s Tendency to Lie/Exaggerate
The Bangor Daily News Described Paul Lepage As An “Insensitive And Crude” Liar Who Makes “Ridiculous Claims.” According to a Bangor Daily News column titled, “Sideshow Paul,” Governor LePage’s “infamous cracks, which range from the insensitive and crude to the exaggerated and invented, have begun to suggest a pattern. On the one hand, the pattern may be evidence of an undisciplined and intemperate manner and nothing more.” “But there is another possible explanation, one that arises from a bit of armchair psychological analysis. The ridiculous claims about black fly and buffalo surveys, the crack about Libby Mitchell getting old, threatening to punch a reporter, and the ‘Kiss my butt’ and now the ‘women may have little beards’ remarks may be a kind of strategy. The behaviors may not be consciously chosen, but Mr. LePage may have learned that these jibes deflect and distract.” (Bangor Daily News, 02/25/11)
Maine People’s Alliance’s Mike Tipping: “Governor Lepage Has A Habit Of Using False Anecdotes To Back Up His Policy Positions. It Started During His Campaign And Has
Continued Throughout His Time In Office. He Routinely Makes Up Regulations That Don’t Exist, Conversations That Never Happened And Discriminatory Practices That Have Never Occurred.” Mike Tipping, who “works at the Maine People’s Alliance and Maine People’s Resource Center and writes a political column for the Portland Press Herald,” wrote in a blog post on the Bangor Daily News Internet site, “Governor LePage has a habit of using false anecdotes to back up his policy positions. It started during his campaign and has continued throughout his time in office. He routinely makes up regulations that don’t exist, conversations that never happened and discriminatory practices that have never occurred. LePage has repeated some of these claims even after they have been proven to be false. (http:// thetippingpoint.bangordailynews.com/2013/04/18/ state-politics/lepage-windmill-conspiracy-theory)
- The Common Theme Among These Lies “Is That They All Seem Designed To Highlight Some Extreme Example Of What Lepage Sees As Wrong With The World And Justify His Policy Prescriptions.” He Uses These Anecdotes, Which Are Lies, To Make And Justify “His Decisions As Governor.” What these lies have in common is that they all seem designed to highlight some extreme example of what LePage sees as wrong with the world and justify his policy prescriptions. If any of them were true, they would be very compelling. LePage added a new false anecdote to his repertoire as he spoke to the Skowhegan Area Chamber of Commerce” in April 2013. “At the end of long rant against the wind power industry, filled with claims that the renewable resource doesn’t create jobs and leads to higher electricity rates, LePage took aim at one wind turbine in particular. ‘Now, to add insult to injury, The University of Maine, Presque Isle – anybody here been up there to see that damn windmill in the back yard? Guess what, if it’s not blowing wind outside and they have somebody visiting the campus, they have a little electric motor that turns the blades. I’m serious. They have an electric motor so that they can show people wind power works. Unbelievable. And that’s the government that you have here in the state of Maine,’ said LePage.” “The University of Maine at Presque Isle’s award- winning wind turbine was built in 2009 and serves as both a source of power for the campus and a demonstration of clean energy in action.” “‘If there’s no wind, the turbine won’t spin,’ explained [University of Maine at Presque Isle Director of Community and Media Relations Rachel] Rice. ‘There has to be naturally-occurring wind in order for the turbine to spin.’” “LePage’s false anecdotes, like this one, aren’t just a source of confusion and comedy. They also provide some troubling insight into the way he makes and justifies his decisions as governor. It’s hard to trust any policy stance of someone who is either so incredibly gullible or is willing to cynically and habitually lie in such a transparent way in order to advance his own agenda.” (http:// thetippingpoint.bangordailynews.com/2013/04/18/ state-politics/lepage-windmill-conspiracy-theory)
Paul Lepage Regularly “Forays Into Exaggeration And Hyperbole.” He “May Find Exaggeration A Useful Political Tool, But It Is Neither Ethical Nor Responsible For Making Sound Public Policy Or Informing The Public,” The Lewiston Sun Journal Opined. Paul LePage regularly “forays into exaggeration and hyperbole.” “Recently the governor said Maine students are looked down upon across the country because they are poorly educated. ‘I don’t care where you go in this country. If you come from Maine you’re looked down upon,’ the governor said during a July 25 [2012] press conference during which he outlined several educational initiatives.” “All of which must have struck people who travel as odd, having perhaps never heard anything like that from a single person ‘from away.’ Pressed…on how he knew that to be fact, the governor’s spokesperson, Adrienne Bennett, explained that the governor did not have research on the subject but was drawing on his own experience. ‘He is a businessman. It’s from his life experience,’ Bennett told the Bangor Daily News. ‘While it’s anecdotal, he believes it.’” “To emphasize his point, the governor added that Maine students need to take a special test to be admitted to the College of William and Mary, an excellent school that is part of the public university system in Virginia. A simple telephone call found that statement to be untrue; the school has no special test for Maine students. The governor was merely repeating something he had heard.” “The governor’s most egregious exaggeration came in December [2011] when he said a member of Forbes magazine’s staff had told him the state could improve its business climate by cutting its welfare programs. Contacted by the Sun Journal, the Forbes magazine writer acknowledged he had talked to someone in the LePage administration but had told them nothing of the sort. At the time, the governor was in the middle of a controversial attempt to cut welfare expenses.” “The governor may find exaggeration a useful political tool, but it is neither ethical nor responsible for making sound public policy or informing the public.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 08/12/12)
Lewiston Sun Journal: “Paul Lepage Has Shown A Disconcerting Tendency…To Either Mishear, Misinterpret Or Misquote Important Information He Has Been Told,” Including “Information He Has Been Told By Federal Officials.” According to the Lewiston Sun Journal, “Gov. Paul LePage has shown a disconcerting tendency…to either mishear, misinterpret or misquote important information he has been told by federal officials. In the long run, the mistakes will hurt the governor’s credibility or, worse, could lead legislators to enact budgets based upon bad information.” For example, “the governor seems to have conflated or confused a conversation he had with U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius” in April 2011. He was “trying to cut $220 million from the state’s Medicaid program, but that would require a so- called Maintenance of Effort waiver from Sebelius’ department. The governor said he was told…the state would have to make cuts to the program before Sebelius’ department would consider granting the waiver.” “Federal sources refused to confirm Sebelius gave LePage such advice and declined to confirm that the…cuts are necessary to obtain a waiver. Confronted with that information, a LePage spokesperson said the administration knew it could apply for the waiver at any time and that cutting the budget first was meant to ‘put pressure’ on the federal government to grant the waiver. If we understand that correctly, the idea would be to knowingly create a budget crisis and then shift the blame to the feds. That would be playing politics with benefits that thousands of elderly and disabled people depend upon.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/11/12)
“Politicians In Maine Often Complain About Lepage’s Suspicion Of Expertise. ‘He Runs Things On Anecdotes And Doesn’t Tell You The Source,’” One Democratic State Senator Said. “Politicians in Maine often complain about LePage’s suspicion of expertise. ‘He runs things on anecdotes and doesn’t tell you the source. He just takes one data point out of the whole if it furthers his ideological agenda,’ says Justin Alfond, a Democratic state senator.” (The American Conservative, 09/01/12)