Paul LePage: FOREST PRODUCTS INDUSTRY

Biomass

  • In 2016, LePage Refused to Sign a Bipartisan Bill Creating A Commission To Study The Economic, Environmental, And Energy Benefits Of The Maine Biomass Industry. In April 2016, LePage let LD1693 became law without his signature after passing both chambers of the Legislature without roll call votes. The bill was a “Resolve, Establishing the Commission To Study the Economic, Environmental and Energy Benefits of the Maine Biomass Industry.” [Maine State Legislature, LD 1693, 4/28/16]
  • The Bill Created A Commission Of Legislators, A Wood Harvester, A Sawmill, The Pulp And Paper Industry, And Users Of Biomass Energy To Study How To Maintain A Sustainable Future For Maine’s Biomass Industry. “Aiding this initiative is another recently passed bill that, in order to study economic, environmental and energy benefits of Maine’s biomass industry, establishes a commission consisting of legislators, a wood harvester and representatives of the biomass energy industry, a sawmill, the pulp and paper industry, and users of biomass energy. One initiative of the commission, which has to report results by December, is to examine and evaluate public policy and economic proposals to create and maintain a sustainable future for the Maine biomass industry.” [Biomass Magazine, 4/19/16]

Headline: “LePage Urges Lawmakers to Oppose Biomass Industry Subsidy.” [Portland Press Herald, 1/11/18]

  • In 2018, LePage Said He Opposed Two Bills That Would Have Funded a $45 Million Subsidy to Help Maine’s Biomass Industry. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Gov. Paul LePage told lawmakers he opposes a pair of bills that would have taxpayers fund a $45 million subsidy to help Maine's foundering biomass industry.” [Portland Press Herald, 1/11/18]
  • One Bill Would Create a $20 Million Revolving Loan Fund for Investments in Biomass Plants, the Other Bill Would Provide $25 Million for Steam Piping to Power Nearby Manufacturing Facilities from Biomass Plants – the Two Bills Were Merged into One With a $25 Million Price Tag That LePage Still Opposed. According to the Portland Press Herald, “One of the bills proposed Wednesday, sponsored by Sen. Troy Jackson, D-Allagash, would create a $20 million revolving loan fund for capital investments in biomass plants, which burn wood to generate power for the electric grid. The second bill, sponsored by Sen. David Woodsome, R-North Waterboro, would provide $25 million to extend steam piping from existing biomass plants to nearby manufacturing facilities, build co-generation plants that produce electricity and heat for sawmills, and convert fossil-fuel boilers in public buildings and businesses to biomass boilers. The sponsors of the two bills agreed Wednesday to merge the measures into a single bill with a $25 million price tag. LePage, however, said he still opposed that measure.” [Portland Press Herald, 1/11/18]

Forest Products Industry

LePage “Refused to Meet with Federal Experts Working to Find Ways to Strengthen Maine’s Forest Products Industry.” According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “The LePage administration did not seek federal funds to preserve 6,400 acres of working forest land and refused to meet with federal experts working to find ways to strengthen Maine’s forest products industry.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

  • Headline: “Federal Team Starts Tour of Maine Forest Products Industry.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/17/16]
  • LePage Said He Wouldn’t Meet With the Team Evaluating Maine’s Forest Products Industry Until the Commerce Department Reconsidered its Tariffs on Canadian Paper Imports. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Federal, state and local officials gathered Wednesday called collaboration critical, but Gov. Paul LePage has said he won't work with the team until the Department of Commerce reconsiders tariffs on Canadian paper imports.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/17/16]

Logging on State-Owned Land

Paul Lepage, In 2011, Vetoed A Bill To Prohibit The Employment Of “Foreign Laborers At Logging Operations On State-Owned Land.” Paul LePage, in 2011, “citing potential constitutional issues…vetoed a bill that would have prohibited the Maine Department of Conservation from employing foreign laborers at logging operations on state-owned land.” “Sen. Troy Jackson, D-Allagash, introduced LD 340 to write the prohibition into statute after he documented an instance of a Canadian logger working on a public lot in northern Maine.” “Jackson, a logger himself, and others have accused landowners and contractors of skirting or violating federal and state laws by hiring lower-cost Canadian loggers while Maine workers struggle to find jobs.” “In his letter to lawmakers, LePage wrote that he was vetoing the bill on constitutional grounds. He also referenced the fact that his predecessor, Democratic Gov. John Baldacci, vetoed a similar bill in 2003.” (Bangor Daily News, 06/08/11)

In 2015, Bipartisan Majorities in the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of a Bill Establishing Penalties for Unlawful Tree Cutting. In June 2015, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD670 by a 108-36 vote and the Senate by a 33-1 vote. LD670 “provides for consequences for the unlawful cutting of trees. It makes a distinction between the unlawful cutting of trees in areas zoned for residential use and the unlawful cutting of trees in other areas. It also makes a distinction between the unlawful cutting of ornamental or fruit trees and the unlawful cutting of all other trees. If a person cuts down or damages trees without permission on land the person does not own, the person is liable to the owner for damages. The owner of the land may choose which valuations and calculations to apply to determine the damages to be paid. The court may reduce the damages awarded for good cause shown when the cutting of trees was done negligently or without fault. Chapter 241 authorizes an additional award of punitive damages if the person acted with malice, and deletes the cap on the recovery of costs of professional services for asserting a claim, including attorney's fees. Chapter 241 provides that public utilities and their contractors are not liable for damages when the cutting or removal of trees is necessary to improve the safety and reliability of the public utilities' delivery of products and services.” [Summaries of Bills, LD670, 2015; Maine State Legislature, LD670, 2015]

April 2015: LePage Refused To Release Conservation Bond Money Approved By Maine Voters Until Legislature Agreed To Increased Tree-Cutting On State Land. “A bipartisan group of lawmakers will propose legislation Tuesday that would force Gov. Paul LePage to issue voter-approved bonds, setting up a possible showdown over conservation money that the governor is using to gain political leverage. The bill, announced by Sen. Roger Katz, R-Augusta, would almost certainly be vetoed by LePage, who is withholding $11.4 million previously approved by voters for the Land for Maine's Future program until legislators agree to increase tree cutting on state- owned land. Lawmakers would need a two-thirds majority in both the Senate and the House to override a veto.” [Bangor Daily News, 4/28/15]

  • Bangor Daily News: “Members Of Both Parties” Decried LePage’s Tactic, Saying He Was Delaying 30 Projects Already Approved For Funding. “Conservationists and members of both parties have decried LePage's tactic, saying his use of the bonds as political leverage threatens 30 projects already approved for funding around the state, including a plan in Cumberland and North Yarmouth to preserve 215 acres at Knight's Pond and Blueberry Hill.” [Bangor Daily News, 4/28/15]

Forest Products Industry Stats Under Paul LePage

Between 2011 and 2016, Five of Maine’s Paper Mills Shut Down, Costing Thousands of Mill Jobs. According to the Natural Resources Council of Maine, “Since Governor LePage was elected, five paper mills have shut down, and thousands of mill workers have lost their jobs in Maine.” [Natural Resources Council of Maine, 2016]

Bangor Daily News: “Maine Was Devastated by Mill Closures During LePage’s Tenure.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine was devastated by mill closures during LePage’s tenure. Between 2013 and 2016, paper mills in East Millinocket, Bucksport, Lincoln, Old Town and Madison.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/31/18]

Bangor Daily News: “Between 2013 And 2016, Paper Mills in East Millinocket, Bucksport, Lincoln, Old Town and Madison Shut Down” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine was devastated by mill closures during LePage’s tenure. Between 2013 and 2016, paper mills in East Millinocket, Bucksport, Lincoln, Old Town and Madison.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/31/18]

Bangor Daily News: “Mill Closures Have Had a Ripple Effect Throughout the Forest Product Industries,” Especially Damaging Logging and Biomass Energy Production. According to the Bangor Daily News, “The mill closures have had a ripple effect throughout the forest product industries, including biomass energy production and logging. A study conducted after the closure of mills in Old Town and Lincoln last year concluded that at least an additional 563 jobs could be lost as a result across Penobscot, Piscataquis, Hancock and Waldo counties. Among those hardest hit would be the loggers who supplied the raw material to the mills.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16]

  • Study Of 2015 Mill Closures In Old Town And Lincoln Concluded That At Least 563 Additional Jobs Would Be Lost From Surrounding Communities. According to the Bangor Daily News, “The mill closures have had a ripple effect throughout the forest product industries, including biomass energy production and logging. A study conducted after the closure of mills in Old Town and Lincoln last year concluded that at least an additional 563 jobs could be lost as a result across Penobscot, Piscataquis, Hancock and Waldo counties. Among those hardest hit would be the loggers who supplied the raw material to the mills.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16]

LePage “Struggled to Keep Maine’s Legacy Paper Industry Viable” During His Time as Governor. According to the Bangor Daily News, “While he struggled to keep Maine’s legacy paper industry viable or to seal some high-profile deals to lure global companies such as Airbus to Maine, he worked aggressively outside the public spotlight to make state government more responsive to business needs.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/17/18]

2016: Despite Downward Trend In Maine Forest Products Industry, “LePage Has Taken Few Steps to Transition the State Toward an Economy Less Dependent On Extracting Natural Resources.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “In spite of this downward trend plaguing Maine’s natural resource economy, LePage has taken few steps to transition the state toward an economy less dependent on extracting natural resources.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/16/16]

By 2015, Maine Paper Mills That Once Employed More Than 18,000 Mainers Provided Jobs to Only 5,500. According to an editorial from the Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel, “Pulp and paper mills that once employed more than 18,000 Mainers now provide jobs to about 5,500.” [Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel, Editorial, 10/4/15]

Portland Press Herald Headline: “Maine’s Lincoln Mill Lays Off 200 After Boiler Explosion.” [Portland Press Herald, 12/11/13]

Bangor Daily News Headline, “East Millinocket Paper Mill Announces Layoffs Affecting 212 Workers.” [Bangor Daily News, 2/6/14]

Bangor Daily News Headline: “Old Town Fuel & Fiber Closes, Leaving 180 Workers Furloughed Indefinitely.” [Bangor Daily News, 8/14/14]

Bangor Daily News Headline: “Verso Mill in Bucksport to Close by Year’s End, 570 Employees to Lose Jobs.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/1/14]

Maine Public Headline: “Shock Ripples Through Jay Region as Verso Cuts 300 Jobs at Androscoggin Mill.” [Maine Public, 8/20/15]

Sept. 2015: Lincoln Paper And Tissue, Penobscot County Company With 170 Workers, Filed For Bankruptcy. According to the Associated Press, “Lincoln Paper and Tissue in Penobscot County has filed for bankruptcy. The company, which employs 170 people in the production of specialty tissue for products like party napkins and medical tissues, filed a voluntary petition for Chapter 11 bankruptcy Monday.” [Associated Press, 9/29/15]

Sept. 2015: Expera Specialty Solutions Announced Plans To Close Pulp Mill In Old Town That Employed 195 Workers. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Expera Specialty Solutions announced Tuesday that it would shut down its pulp mill in Old Town by the end of the year. The Wisconsin-based company, which purchased the mill less than a year ago and then restarted it, cited falling market prices for pulp, combined with wood costs, as factors in the decision. The mill in Penobscot County employs 151 hourly workers and 44 salaried workers.” [Portland Press Herald, 9/29/15]

Bangor Daily News Headline: “Madison Paper Mill to Shut Down by May, Lay Off 214.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/14/16]

WGME Headline: “Verso to Shut Down Machine, Lay Off 190 at Jay Mill.” [WGME, 11/1/16]

Lewiston Morning Sentinel Headline: “Jay Mill to Shut Down Paper Machine Permanently, Cut 120 Jobs.” [Lewiston Morning Sentinel, 7/19/17]

Spat Between Critical Sawmill Owners and Paul LePage

Headline: “Watchdog Finds no Proof That LePage Punished Sawmill Owners Who Criticized Him.” [Bangor Daily News, 8/20/18]

Portland Press Herald: “Maine’s Legislative Watchdog Found No Evidence That Gov. Paul LePage Was Directly Involved in a February Decision to Divert Timber Harvested on Public Lands Away From Two Maine Mills.” According to the Portland Press Herald, “Maine's legislative watchdog found no evidence that Gov. Paul LePage was directly involved in a February decision to divert timber harvested on public lands away from two Maine mills.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/21/18]

  • The Two Maine Mills That Lost Out on Timber Had Been Critical of LePage’s Stance on U.S. Tariffs on Canadian Lumber, Felt Like They Were Being Retaliated Against.” According to the Portland Press Herald, “The two companies who lost out on the timber, Moose River Lumber and Pleasant River Lumber, both owned by the Brochu family, had been publicly critical of the governor's position on U.S. tariffs on Canadian lumber and some felt they were being retaliated against.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/21/18]
  • Legislative Watchdog Found the Decision to Divert the Timber Was Made by the Director of Maine Forest Service Because the Company the Timber Was Diverted to Had Been Facing a Critical Shortage of Logs at the Time. According to the Portland Press Herald, “The watchdog agency found that the decision to divert the spruce and fir timber that had been harvested in Maine away from the Brochus' mills and to Stratton Lumber was made solely by the director of the Maine Forest Service, Doug Denico. It

also affirmed that the decision was made because Stratton Lumber was facing a critical shortage of logs at the time.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/21/18]

  • Portland Press Herald Editorial Headline: “Probes Necessary After LePage’s Lack of Candor.” [Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 3/26/18]
  • In Feb. 2018, the Bureau of Public Lands Stopped Sending Timber Harvested from State-Owned Lands to a Maine-Owned Lumber Mill, Sending it Instead to a Canadian-Owned Mill. According to an editorial in the Portland Press Herald, “Last week, it was first questions over the allocation of timber from state-owned lands. In February, the Bureau of Public Lands stopped shipping such timber to mills owned by Jason and Chris Brochu, sending it instead to a Canadian-owned mill.” [Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 3/26/18]
  • Headline: “Watchdog Agency to Review Public-Timber Dispute; the Governor Says he Supports a Probe into Diversion of Logs from Mills Owned by LePage Critics.” [Portland Press Herald, 3/24/18]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “By Refusing to Allow Commissioners to Answer Questions or Appear Before Committees [About the Timber Diversion], LePage Has Stifled Needed Oversight and Given the Impression That His Administration Has Things to Hide.” According to an editorial in the Bangor Daily News, “By refusing to allow commissioners to answer questions or appear before committees, LePage has stifled needed oversight and given the impression that his administration has things to hide. The case of the diverted wood is convoluted and confusing, which is why lawmakers need to sort out what happened and why.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 3/22/18]

Forest Legacy Conservation Program

Headline: “Maine Won’t Participate in Forest Legacy Conservation Program.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/9/15]

LePage “Did Not Seek Federal Funds to Preserve 6,400 Acres of Working Forest Land.” According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “The LePage administration did not seek federal funds to preserve 6,400 acres of working forest land and refused to meet with federal experts working to find ways to strengthen Maine’s forest products industry.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

  • Bangor Daily News: “The LePage Administration Has Decided to Take a Pass on Applying for its Share of Federal Conservation Funds.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “The LePage administration has decided to take a pass on applying for its share of federal conservation funds.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/9/15]
  • Under LePage, Maine Lost $1.725 Million in Federal Funding for the Forest Legacy Program.

Image: see original report, p. 179

Image: see original report, p. 179

[Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

  • Maine Center for Economic Policy: “Maine Competes Very Well for These Funds; the Governor Refused Needed State Support for the Project and the State Could Not Apply.” According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “Note: Maine competes very well for these funds; the governor refused needed state support for the project and the state could not apply.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]
  • Bangor Daily News: “Maine Consistently Has Led the Nation in Applying for and Receiving Forest Legacy Funding, But the State Has Opted to Skip Several Applications Rounds Under LePage.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “She [Mills] also has pledged to be more proactive in seeking federal Forest Legacy funds to protect working forests from development. Maine consistently had led the nation in applying for and receiving Forest Legacy funding, but the state has opted to skip several application rounds under LePage.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/11/18]

Opportunity Zone Grants

July 2018: LePage Granted Special Discretion For Tax Breaks To Two Paper Mill Towns Despite “Declines In Most Paper Industry Sectors.” “Out of 32 places to give tax breaks to investors, Gov. Paul LePage had special discretion for two. For each of those special picks, LePage looked to paper towns. The governor's use of those special selections to pick Madawaska and Baileyville reflect a hope that, despite declines in most paper industry sectors, the mills that have endured some brutal years may still draw new investment or serve as an anchor for sustaining rural economies.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/18/18]

  • Bangor Daily News: LePage Chose Not To Grant Opportunity Zone Status To Paper Mill In Verso After Telling Bucksport Mill Owners To “Get Out Of The State Of Maine.” “LePage did leave out some towns with operating mills. He did not pick Skowhegan, where owner Sappi had already begun a $165 million investment, or Jay, where Verso owns a mill. Verso's move to shut its Bucksport mill and sell it for scrap angered LePage to the point of telling the company to ‘get out of the state of Maine.’" [Bangor Daily News, 7/18/18]

Put ME to Work

In 2018, LePage Vetoed a Budget That Funded a Bipartisan Effort to Train the Next Generation of Logging Operators Throughout the State by Implementing the Professional Logging Contractors’ Mechanical Operator Training Program at Three Community College in Maine – the Legislature Overrode LePage’s Veto. According to the Professional Logging Contractors of Maine, “Workforce Development— LD 1373, An Act to Create the Put ME to Work Program was a bi-partisan effort by members of the Maine Legislature to assist the logging industry train the next generation of logging operators that are desperately needed throughout the State. This is the funding mechanism that assisted with the implementation of the PLC’s Mechanical Logging Operator training program at three of Maine’s Community Colleges. This bill was designed to provide operational funding for the next two years to get this important program off the ground. Funding ($1,000,000) and language from this bill was included in the State budget, which was passed by both the House and Senate on Wednesday, June 17th. The Governor vetoed the budget, but the Legislature voted to override the veto on June 30th.” [Professional Logging Contractors of Maine, Accessed 12/8/21]

Source report (PDF)