Paul LePage: HEALTH INSURANCE
Health Insurance Coverage Requirements
In 2015, Bipartisan Majorities in the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of a Bill Requiring Insurance Carriers to Provide Doctors With Their Requirements for Inpatient Coverage Following Breast Cancer Treatment, and for the Physicians to Provide the Same Information to Their Patients. In June 2015, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD359 by a 145-0 vote and the Senate by a 34-0 vote. LD359 “requires carriers to provide written notice regarding the requirements for inpatient coverage following treatment of breast cancer to physicians participating in the carrier's provider network and requires attending physicians to provide a similar notice to patients when consulting with patients about breast cancer treatment. The requirements of Public Law 2015, chapter 227 apply to all individual and group health insurance policies and contracts issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2016.” [Summaries of Bills, LD359, 2015; Maine State Legislature, LD359, 2015]
In 2015, Bipartisan Majorities in the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of a Bill Requiring Health Insurance Companies to Provide Enrollees With Information About Prescription Drug Coverage and Formularies. In June 2015, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD636 by a 126-12 vote and the Senate by a 31-3 vote. LD636 “requires all health insurance carriers offering individual and group health plans to provide certain information with respect to prescription drug coverage to prospective enrollees and enrollees on its publicly accessible website consistent with the requirements of the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. The law requires carriers to post each prescription drug formulary for each health plan in a manner that allows enrollees to determine whether a particular prescription drug is covered under a formulary. The law also requires carriers to provide information about utilization review, prior authorization or step therapy, cost-sharing, exclusions from coverage and the amount of coverage for out-of-network providers or noncovered health care services.” [Summaries of Bills, LD636, 2015; Maine State Legislature, LD636, 2015]
In 2018, Bipartisan Majorities of the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of Legislation Requiring Health Insurers to Cover Services Provided by a Licensed Naturopathic Doctors if the Patient Would be Reimbursed if the Services Had Been Provided by Other Licensed Providers. In March 2018, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD1030 by a 135-11 vote and the Senate by a 32-2 vote. LD1030 “requires health insurance carriers to cover services provided by licensed naturopathic doctors if those services are within the scope of the naturopathic doctors' license and would be reimbursed if the services were provided by other licensed providers. The law also prohibits carriers from excluding a naturopathic doctor from their provider networks as long as the naturopathic doctor is willing to meet the same terms and conditions as other participating providers.” [Summaries of Bills, LD1030, 2018; Maine State Legislature, LD1030, 2018]
Paul Lepage Supported Eliminating Maine’s Health Insurance Mandates Not Required By The Federal Government. Paul LePage, in 2010, said he would “aim at reducing health care mandates, which he said put Maine companies at a competitive disadvantage.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 04/18/10) “Maine cannot afford a health care system ‘saddled with Cadillac mandates,’ so he would reduce minimum coverage guidelines to federally established levels,” Paul LePage said. “That would allow Maine people to buy coverage that makes sense for them.” (Portland Press Herald, 05/09/10)
- Maine Requires Coverage Above And Beyond Federal Requirements, Including Coverage For Diabetes Supplies And Autism. Historically, Maine has placed requirements on health insurers – such as making them provide plans to people with pre-existing conditions and not allowing them to base premiums on an individual’s health status – that other states have not, making costs higher in Maine.” (Kennebec Journal, 08/24/10)
- Maine Required Insurance Coverage For Autism. “In 2010…Maine…enacted legislation requiring insurance coverage for autism.” The federal government does not require such coverage. (www.ncsl.org/issues-research/health/autism-and- insurance-coverage-state-laws.aspx)
- Maine Required Insurance To Cover Diabetic Supplies. Maine also requires insurance to cover diabetes supplies. The federal government does not require such coverage. (Bangor Daily News, 05/10/96)
Health Insurance Across State Lines
Paul Lepage “Supports Allowing Individuals And Businesses To Purchase [Health] Insurance Across State Lines,” Even Though The End Result Of Such A Change Would Likely Be The Elimination Of Insurance Mandates In The State. Paul LePage “supports allowing individuals and businesses to purchase [health] insurance across state lines.” (Portland Press Herald, 05/09/10) If health insurance could be sold across state lines health insurers would likely “cluster in one state, follow that state’s regulations and sell the product to everyone in the country. In practice, that means we will have a single national insurance standard. But that standard will be decided by South Dakota. Or, if South Dakota doesn’t give the insurers the freedom they want, it’ll be decided by Wyoming. Or whoever. (Washington Post Blogs, 02/17/10)
“The Maine State Chamber Of Commerce, Anthem Blue Cross And Blue Shield And Other Groups Said” Allowing “Mainers To Purchase Insurance Across State Lines…could Hurt Maine businesses.” “The Maine State Chamber of Commerce, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield and other groups said a slate of proposals that would allow Mainers to purchase insurance across state lines would have far-reaching consequences that could hurt Maine businesses and create an uneven playing field among insurers.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/12/11)
Insurance Coverage Stats Under Paul LePage
Headline: “New Census Data Reveal Maine is the Only State That Has Not Experienced an Increase in the Percentage of People with Health Insurance Since ACA Passage.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, Press Release, 9/16/15]
- Subheadline: “Maine has Fallen from 10th to 24th in the Nation for the Percentage of People with Health Coverage Since 2010.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, Press Release, 9/16/15]
In 2014, 10.1% of Mainers (134,000) Did Not Have Access to Health Insurance, “Statistically the Same as in 2010 When Congress Passed the ACA.” According to a press release from the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “The Census Bureau today released the country’s official data on health insurance rates, which showed that 134,000 or 10.1% of Mainers lacked access to health insurance in 2014, statistically the same as in 2010 when Congress passed the ACA.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, Press Release, 9/16/15]
In 2018, Maine’s Uninsured Rate Was 8.1%, Ranking it 26th Nationally. [United Health Foundation, America’s Health Rankings, 2018]
Small Group Insurance
LePage Signed a Health Insurance Overhaul Bill Into Law, “An Attempt To Spur More Competition In Maine’s Health Insurance Market By Making It Easier For Insurers To Offer New Plans For Small Groups And Individuals And By Allowing Small Businesses To Band Together And Negotiate More Favorable Rates.” Paul LePage, in 2011, signed into law and has since defended LD 1333, which became Public Law 90. “The insurance overhaul bill – called Public Law… 90 – was an attempt to spur more competition in Maine’s health insurance market by making it easier for insurers to offer new plans for small groups and individuals and by allowing small businesses to band together and negotiate more favorable rates. The bill also created a high-risk pool – or reinsurance program – to protect insurance companies from the high costs of covering patients who require the most medical care. The law funds the program in part through a $4 assessment on the monthly premium of anyone with private insurance.” (Bangor Daily News, 11/23/12)
Legislation Was “Funded By A Tax On Premiums Of As Much As $4 Per Person Per Month On Almost Every Policyholder In Maine.” More specifically, it is “funded by a tax on premiums of as much as $4 per person per month on almost every policyholder in Maine.” (Kennebec Journal, 05/17/11)
- The Monthly Tax Was “to Help Cover The Cost Of Those In The High-Risk Pool…Shifts The Risk Of Insuring These People From Insurance Companies To Thousands Of Maine Residents.” The “monthly tax of at least $4…assessed on all other policyholders to help cover the cost of those in the high-risk pool…shifts the risk of insuring these people from insurance companies to thousands of Maine residents.” (Bangor Daily News, 05/19/11)
The Law “Allows Insurers to Charge Different Rates Based on Patients’ Age, Geography and Health Status.” “In addition, the law allows insurers to charge different rates based on patients’ age, geography and health status. Proponents say that part of the bill is an attempt to woo more young, healthy patients into the marketplace by allowing insurers to charge them less.” (Bangor Daily News, 11/23/12)
The Law Allowed “Insurance Companies To Raise Rates In The Small-Group Market – Which Includes Small Employers – By 10 Percent Or Less Without Approval From The State’s Bureau Of Insurance.” It also changed state law to allow “insurance companies to raise rates in the small-group market – which includes small employers – by 10 percent or less without approval from the state’s Bureau of Insurance.” (Bangor Daily News, 11/23/12)
Consumers for Affordable Health Care Study Found That 54% of Individual Health Insurance Policyholders in Maine Saw Premium Increases, as Did 90% of Small Business Policholders. According to a study by Consumers for Affordable Health Care, since this bill became law “54 percent of individual policyholders in Maine saw premium increases, while 90 percent of small business policyholders saw rates go up. Small-group plans cover up to 50 employees.” (Bangor Daily News, 11/23/12)
The Bill Was “Enthusiastically Endorsed by Insurance Companies.” In addition to the abovementioned rate increases, under this bill, which was “enthusiastically endorsed by insurance companies…many consumer protections enacted over two decades disappeared. Especially hard hit: people living in rural areas and folks over 40. Among other things, the new law abolished protections for rural families that had required insurers to have at least one doctor in their provider networks within 30 miles of where those families lived and at least one hospital within 60 miles. The law also allows insurance companies to effectively double rates for older residents. That provision is affecting not only individuals and families, but also small businesses that employ older workers. Within months of the bill’s passage, insurers began jacking up the rates they charged businesses with older workers by 90 percent or more.” “As consumer advocates had feared, hardest hit were indeed older workers and people living in rural areas, most of whom saw good coverage options previously available to them disappear.” (Politics Daily, 09/10/12)
The Bill “Abolished Protections For Rural Families That Had Required Insurers To Have At Least One Doctor In Their Provider Networks Within 30 Miles Of Where Those Families Lived And At Least One Hospital Within 60 Miles.” In addition to the abovementioned rate increases, under this bill, which was “enthusiastically endorsed by insurance companies…many consumer protections enacted over two decades disappeared. Especially hard hit: people living in rural areas and folks over 40. Among other things, the new law abolished protections for rural families that had required insurers to have at least one doctor in their provider networks within 30 miles of where those families lived and at least one hospital within 60 miles. The law also allows insurance companies to effectively double rates for older residents. That provision is affecting not only individuals and families, but also small businesses that employ older workers. Within months of the bill’s passage, insurers began jacking up the rates they charged businesses with older workers by 90 percent or more.” “As consumer advocates had feared, hardest hit were indeed older workers and people living in rural areas, most of whom saw good coverage options previously available to them disappear.” (Politics Daily, 09/10/12)
The Bill “Allows Insurance Companies To Effectively Double Rates For Older Residents.” In addition to the abovementioned rate increases, under this bill, which was “enthusiastically endorsed by insurance companies…many consumer protections enacted over two decades disappeared. Especially hard hit: people living in rural areas and folks over 40. Among other things, the new law abolished protections for rural families that had required insurers to have at least one doctor in their provider networks within 30 miles of where those families lived and at least one hospital within 60 miles. The law also allows insurance companies to effectively double rates for older residents. That provision is affecting not only individuals and families, but also small businesses that employ older workers. Within months of the bill’s passage, insurers began jacking up the rates they charged businesses with older workers by 90 percent or more.” “As consumer advocates had feared, hardest hit were indeed older workers and people living in rural areas, most of whom saw good coverage options previously available to them disappear.” (Politics Daily, 09/10/12)
Former Cigna Health Communications Expert Said Health Insurance Companies “Hit the Jackpot” When the Law Was Passed. “Wendell Potter, a former communications expert for Cigna Health…wrote that the insurance companies ‘hit the jackpot’ when LePage and the Legislature pushed through the law.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 10/06/11)