Paul LePage: INCOME TAXES

Elimination

Bangor Daily News Headline: “LePage Says He Wants Maine Income Tax Gone By 2020.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/12/15]

American for Tax Reform: “In His 2015 State Of The State Address, Gov. Paul LePage (R-Maine) Called For An Elimination Of The State Income Tax ‘Once And For All.’” According to Americans For Tax Reform, “In his 2015 State of the State Address, Gov. Paul LePage (R-Maine) called for an elimination of the state income tax ‘once and for all.’ A significant potion of LePage's speech was dedicated to a tax reform proposal that he announced last month.” [Americans For Tax Reform, 2/10/15]

May 2015: LePage Vowed To Veto All Bills Sponsored By A Democrat Until Legislature Accepted His Proposal To Eliminate Maine’s Income Tax. “During a fiery news conference that lasted nearly an hour, Gov. Paul LePage pledged Friday to veto every bill sponsored by a Democrat until his opposition relents and accepts his constitutional amendment to eliminate Maine's income tax. LePage this year has proposed a constitutional amendment that would eliminate the state's income tax by the year 2020. Republicans, who have shied away from the governor's more comprehensive tax reform efforts, have rallied around the amendment.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/29/15]

  • LePage Accused Democrats Of Trying To “Disenfranchise The Maine People” By Refusing To Allow Income Tax Elimination To Be Approved By Maine Voters. “Efforts to amend the state's Constitution require not only the support of two-thirds of the Legislature but the approval of Maine voters. LePage has said voters should be given the option of eliminating the income tax, which accounts for about half of all state revenue. ‘If the Democrats are going to disenfranchise the Maine people, then the governor of Maine is going to make sure that every bill that comes down from the House and the Senate with a Democrat sponsor will be required to have a two-thirds vote, because I'm going to veto every one, and I did a bunch this morning,’ LePage said.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/29/15]
  • Democrats Said LePage’s Plan To Eliminate Income Tax Was “Too Generous To The Wealthy And Unpaid For” While GOP Were “Skeptical” Of Sales Tax

Increase.” “Democrats balked at LePage's income tax scheme, arguing it was too generous to the wealthy and unpaid for. Republicans were skeptical of a sales tax increase similar to one many of them had campaigned against in 2010.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/29/15]

LePage’s Plan To Eliminate Maine’s Income Tax “Failed To Garner The Support Of Either Republicans Or Democrats In The Legislature.” “The governor then launched a broadside against legislators for failing to authorize two initiatives: an aggressive tax overhaul plan that LePage embedded in his $6.5 billion two-year budget proposal, and a separate constitutional amendment that would eliminate the income tax by 2020. The latter proposal has become LePage's focus as his tax overhaul in the budget has failed to garner the support of either Republicans or Democrats in the Legislature. The governor described the overhaul as "dead" a long time ago.” [Kennebec Journal, 5/30/15]

Flat Tax

LePage Said “He Wants to Further Overhaul Maine’s Tax Policy, Including a Flat, 4 Percent Personal Income Tax and a Lower Corporate Income-Tax Rate.” Paul LePage, in April 2012, “told participants at the Bush Institute Conference on Taxes and Economic Growth in New York City…that he wants to further overhaul Maine’s tax policy, including a flat, 4 percent personal income tax and a lower corporate income-tax rate.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/11/12)

Income Tax Rates

Paul Lepage, In 2011, Said, “‘I Would Love To Tax The Rich If We Had Any In Maine.’” “A talk to a University of Maine at Farmington class by Maine Gov. Paul LePage” in 2011 “was interrupted by a heckler yelling for LePage to ‘tax the rich,’ leading the governor to retort, ‘I would love to tax the rich if we had any in Maine.’” (The New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal, 03/26/11)

2011: LePage Proposed “Huge Tax Cuts for the Wealthy” Partially Paid for by Cutting the Maine Residents Property Tax and Rent Refund Program, Which Provides Tax Relief to Low- and Moderate-Income Mainers. “Paul LePage, in 2011, proposed huge tax cuts for the wealthy, with some of the tax cuts offset by cutting the Maine Residents Property Tax and Rent Refund Program, which provides tax relief to low- and moderate-income Mainers. (Bangor Daily News, 04/02/11)

  • The Proposed Change Would Have Lowered Maine’s Top Income Tax Rate from 8.5% to 7.95% and Doubled the Estate Tax Exemption. Paul LePage, in 2011, “proposed changes to the tax code that would save Mainers an estimated $203 million over the biennium.” This included lowering “Maine’s top income tax rate from 8.5 percent to 7.95 percent,” and “doubling the…estate tax exemption, meaning heirs would pay only the so-called ‘death tax’ on property or businesses once the value hits the $2 million mark rather than the…threshold of $1 million.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/02/11)
  • “To Finance His Tax Cuts, Lepage…Proposed Increasing The Amount That State Employees Contribute To Their Retirement Plans And Raising The Minimum Retirement Age For New Hires From 62 To 65.” “Maine’s balanced budget requirement means any tax cuts have to be paid for in the current budget cycle.” “To finance his tax cuts, LePage…proposed increasing the amount that state employees contribute to their retirement plans and raising the minimum retirement age for new hires from 62 to 65,” as well as other budget cuts, such as cuts to the Maine Residents Property Tax and Rent Refund Program. (Bangor Daily News, 04/02/11)
  • Maine Center for Economic Policy Said LePage’s Budget “Cuts by 20 Percent the Maine Residents Property Tax and Rent Refund Program, Also Known as the ‘Circuit Breaker’ Program. That Program Provides Property Tax Relief to More Than 150,000 Families.” Additionally, the center points out that LePage’s budget cuts by 20 percent the Maine Residents Property Tax and Rent Refund Program, also known as the ‘Circuit Breaker’ program. That program provides property tax relief to more than 150,000 families.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/02/11)
  • Maine Center for Economic Policy Found the Wealthiest Top 10 Percent of Mainers Would Received Half the Tax Relief in LePage’s Proposal. “According to an analysis by the Maine Center for Economic Policy, a liberal think tank, the wealthiest top 10 percent of Maine’s population would receive roughly half of the tax relief in the governor’s proposal. And only 20 percent of the relief would be absorbed by Mainers earning less than $63,648. Additionally, the center points out that LePage’s budget cuts by 20 percent the Maine Residents Property Tax and Rent Refund Program, also known as the ‘Circuit Breaker’ program. That program provides property tax relief to more than 150,000 families.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/02/11)

Paul Lepage, In 2011, Signed Into Law “A Reduction In The Top Income Tax Rate.” Paul LePage, in 2011, signed into law “a reduction in the top income tax rate from 8.5 percent to 7.95 percent, and a bump in the threshold at which the estate tax kicks in from $1 million to $2 million.” “To give an idea of who benefits from the new estate tax policy, consider this advisory on the change from the Pierce Atwood law firm’s website: ‘Through proper estate tax planning, married couples essentially will be able to shield $4 million of assets from Maine estate taxation, and other techniques may also be used to further reduce the tax burden.’” (Bangor Daily News, 01/31/12)

Portland Press Herald: “During His Eight Years In Office, LePage Ushered In Some Of The Largest Income Tax Cuts In State History, Lowering Maine’s Top Tax Bracket From 8.5 Percent To 7.15 Percent.” According to the Portland Press Herald, “During his eight years in office, LePage ushered in some of the largest income tax cuts in state history, lowering Maine’s top tax bracket from 8.5 percent to 7.15 percent.” [Portland Press Herald, 5/9/19]

Impact of Paul LePage’s Policies on Maine Income Taxes

When LePage Left Office, the Wealthiest Households Paid Less in Taxes Than Any Other Group in Maine, Including the Poorest Households in Maine:

Image: see original report, p. 367

[Maine Center for Economic Policy, 9/4/19]

Maine Center for Economic Policy Analysis Determined That LePage’s Tax Cuts Cost the State Nearly $900 Million in Revenue. According to the Portland Press Herald, “‘We certainly feel there was a missed opportunity in the way that the state budgets have been handled by this administration,’ said Sarah Austin, a policy analyst with the left-leaning Maine Center for Economic Policy. Austin criticized LePage for prioritizing tax cuts that disproportionately benefited the wealthiest Mainers. An analysis by the policy center estimates that LePage’s tax cuts will result in nearly $900 million less revenue flowing into state coffers over the next two fiscal years when compared to projections based on the tax code at the time he took office.” [Portland Press Herald, 12/30/18]

Maine Beacon Headline: “Report: LePage’s Tax Cuts Favoring The Wealthy Costing Maine $864 Million In Revenue.” [Maine Beacon, 9/13/18]

Maine Beacon: “Maine Will Have $864 Million Less In Revenue To Pay For Vital Commitments Such As Education And Health Care Over The Next Two Years Than It Would Have Had Before Governor Paul LePage Gave Away Income Tax Rewards Tilted Towards The Wealthy.” According to the Beacon, “Maine will have $864 million less in revenue to pay for vital commitments such as education and health care over the next two years than it would have had before Governor Paul LePage gave away income tax rewards tilted towards the wealthy. Meanwhile, half of the state’s projected loss in revenue has been redistributed to the top one-fifth of Maine households.” [Maine Beacon, 9/13/18]

  • Maine Beacon: “Compensating For Shrinking State Budgets, All Mainers — Including Low- And Middle-Income Households — Have Had To Shoulder More Of The Burden To Fund Schools And Infrastructure, Collectively Paying An Average Of $30 Million More Per Year.” According to Beacon, “And compensating for shrinking state budgets, all Mainers — including low- and middle-income households — have had to shoulder more of the burden to fund schools and infrastructure, collectively paying an average of $30 million more per year in local property taxes from 2011 to 2016 than in the previous six-year period.” [Beacon, 9/13/18]

LePage’s Nearly $900 Million in Tax Cuts Would Have Paid for the $643 Million Needed to Fully Fund K-12 Education, Medicaid Expansion, and Revenue Sharing.

Image: see original report, p. 368

[Maine Center for Economic Policy, August 2018]

Maine Center for Economic Policy: “Because of Income Tax Cuts for Those at the Top, the Total Resources Available to Invest in Helping Maine Communities Thrive Has Dropped by a Third of a Billion Dollars Annually – Even With Average Mainers Paying Higher Property Taxes.” According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “The bottom line is that, because of income tax cuts for those at the top, the total resources available to invest in helping Maine communities thrive has dropped by a third of a billion dollars annually — even with average Mainers paying higher property taxes. (On average, Mainers paid $30 million more per year in property taxes between 2011 and 2016 than in the previous six-year period.)” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, August 2018]

From 2011 to 2017, the Wealthiest 20% of Mainers Benefited from $163 Million in Income Tax Cuts Each Year. According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “For example, since 2011, the wealthiest 20 percent of Mainers have benefited from $163 million in income tax cuts each year. Over the same period, communities have had to raise over a billion dollars in property taxes – an average of an additional $180 million each year – toward education to compensate for the state underfunding its share of education costs.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

Source report (PDF)