Paul LePage: LEPAGE’S REFUSAL AND INABILITY TO MAKE DEALS BROUGHT MAINE’S GOVERNMENT TO A GRINDING HALT

LePage Abused His Power as Maine’s Governor and Governed Through Obstruction Rather Than Compromise. LePage left office in 2018 as Maine’s “all-time veto leader,” having vetoed a record 642 bills across his 8 years in office – 173 more vetoes than the past 23 governors combined.114 Rather than use his veto pen as an outlet of his executive power, LePage used it for “political punishment” and to obstruct progress on bipartisan issues when he felt he wasn’t getting his way.115 Many of his vetoes were overridden unanimously, or at least with overwhelming majorities of legislative Republicans voting to override, “unprecedented for a sitting governor of a major political party in Maine.”116

  • LePage Ignored the Law as Governor and Was Repeatedly Ordered to Follow the Law by Maine Courts. LePage was responsible for five separate vetoes of bills to expand Medicaid in Maine, but even after Mainers voted to expand MaineCare, which would have provided health care coverage for 70,000 people in Maine, LePage resisted implementation.117 LePage missed an April 2018 deadline to submit a plan to the federal government for Maine’s Medicaid expansion, and labeled the expansion “a budget-busting form of welfare.”118 LePage was resultingly sued for refusing to take the necessary steps to follow the referendum approved by voters and by June, 2018 a Maine superior court ordered LePage to implement Medicaid expansion,119 but LePage resisted still, vetoing a bill that would’ve funded expansion.120 Maine ordered LePage to implement Medicaid expansion again in November after LePage had urged the federal government to reject MaineCare expansion.121 Maine ultimately didn’t expand Medicaid until after LePage left office.122 LePage had run afoul of the law before, in attempting to veto bills after the deadline to do had passed. LePage argued that he had longer than was mandated to veto legislation sent to his desk.123 LePage’s willingness to skirt laws he didn’t like also threatened Maine’s elections when LePage sought to cut $4 million from the Clean Election Fund which provided public funding for Maine state-level

candidates.124 The Bangor Daily News criticized LePage’s abuses of power as governor, saying it was a “sad state of affairs” that the Maine public couldn’t trust in its governor to uphold and execute the law and that even after eight years, LePage still “doesn’t understand his job. He is the governor, not the king.”125

  • LePage Was an Obstructionist Governor, Who Vetoed Hundreds of Overwhelmingly Bipartisan Bills, and Was Overridden. LePage has the most prolific veto record of any Maine governor, in fact, LePage vetoed 642 bills during his tenure which was more than his 23 predecessors combined.126 LePage’s vetoes weren’t used just to block Democratic bills either, his veto of a bipartisan state budget bill in 2017 led to a government shutdown.127 Morning Sentinel columnist Alan Cron noted as early as 2015 that “nearly all of LePage’s vetoes were overturned” by votes that included “every Republican in the legislature.”128
  • LePage Refused to Sign Dozens of Overwhelmingly Bipartisan Bills Into Law. LePage was an historically-obstructive governor, refusing to sign widely popular, uncontroversial, bipartisan bills. In July, 2018, LePage vetoed a bill to establish a lead abatement program to protect Maine’s children, the bill passed with overwhelming support.129 In 2017, LePage vetoed a bill to ban open pit mining, a practice that has been deemed the most “polluting form of mining.”130 The Maine legislature voted to override LePage‘s veto in a near unanimous vote.131 In 2014, the legislature was again required to override a LePage veto when he rejected a bill to provide $12 million in bonds to support small businesses in rural Maine.132
  • LePage’s Stubbornness and Inability to Lead Caused the First Government Shutdown in Maine Since 1991. After Democratic House Speaker Sara Gideon and Republican Senate President Michael Thibodeau negotiated a deal to avoid a government shutdown, LePage still refused to sign the deal.133 Despite the budget deal containing several Democratic concessions on education funding and taxes on top earners134 LePage still opposed the deal because it didn’t cut income tax.135 LePage whipped the necessary amount of Republicans in the Maine House to keep the budget from surviving his veto, resulting in Maine’s first government shutdown since 1991.136 After the shutdown, LePage continued his petulance by refusing to physically cross the street to negotiate a

deal to reopen the government with legislative leaders.137 Eventually, LePage negotiated a deal with House Speaker Sara Gideon to reopen the government with rumors swirling he planned to take a vacation amid the negotiations.138

LePage’s Disastrous Leadership Alienated Members Of His Own Party. LePage’s tumultuous tenure as governor of Maine led to other Maine Republicans growing tired of him and opting to publicly oppose his policies. As early as 2011, a block of Maine Republican Senators wrote a letter condemning LePage for making disparaging comments about political rivals.139 In 2015, a Republican strategist for Susan Collins and Kelly Ayotte, Lance Dutson, went so far as to say Republicans were “done” with LePage due to his flurry of vetoes.140 By 2016, GOP Maine Senator Amy Volk publicly blasted LePage after he left a threatening voicemail for a Democratic member of the Maine Legislature, Senator Volk suggested LePage was suffering from mental health or substance abuse issues as potential rationale for his behavior.141 GOP Maine Senators, Tom Saviello and Roger Katz said LePage took partisan politics to “a new, dark level,” and labeled LePage “angry and vindictive.”142 LePage’s resistance to problem solving even caused members of his own party to seek out Democrats as allies so as to pass legislation.143

  • LePage Campaigned Against Fellow Republicans. After Republicans were resistant to LePage’s tax plans, LePage decided to turn on the members of his own party that sided with Democrats to pass a state budget and other important bills, including running ads against GOP Senate president, Michael Thibodeau.144 LePage was labeled “the great divider” by Morning Sentinel Columnist, Alan Caron in 2015, due to his threats to oppose republicans in the next election cycle.145 LePage ended his tenure as the figurehead of the Maine GOP in 2018 by saying he hoped Republicans were “destroyed” in the next election.146

LePage Attempted to Circumvent Oversight from Lawmakers to Build New Mental Health Facility in Augusta. In 2016, Maine lawmakers were forced to override LePage’s veto of a bill to increase wages of workers at Maine’s mental health institutions.147 Just three years prior to this veto, LePage saw the Riverview psychiatric facility lose its federal certification and $20 million in federal funding due to the facility’s volume of safety violations.148 In 2015, LePage’s administration attempted to pass a new Riverview project through the legislature, but it failed due to concerns from mental health advocates.149 LePage then decided to circumvent the legislature and the city of Augusta using internal funds to build a new Riverview facility.150 LePage’s planned new facility lacked necessary review was called “shoehorned” by the Portland Press Herald.151 While using the Riverview as a political football with Maine’s legislators, LePage also contracted a Florida company to run the new facility, and sealed the proposal so independent parties couldn’t see the details of the negotiations.152

  1. Bangor Daily News, 6/6/19; Bangor Daily News, 12/30/18 ↩
  2. Sun Journal, Editorial, 4/29/14 ↩
  3. Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 9/19/15 ↩
  4. Bangor Daily News, 11/7/17 ↩
  5. New York Times, 7/24/18 ↩
  6. Press Release, Maine House Democrats, 6/4/18 ↩
  7. State of Maine Legislature, LD 837, Roll Call #698, 7/9/18; Associated Press, 7/3/18 ↩
  8. Portland Press Herald, 9/5/18 ↩
  9. Bangor Daily News, 12/6/20 ↩
  10. Sun Journal, 7/10/15 ↩
  11. Morning Sentinel, Editorial, 8/5/18 ↩
  12. Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 8/3/18; Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 7/15/18 ↩
  13. Bangor Daily News, 12/30/18 ↩
  14. Bangor Daily News, 9/13/18 ↩
  15. Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 9/19/15 ↩
  16. Sun Journal, 7/2/18 ↩
  17. Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17 ↩
  18. State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 820, 6/7/17; State of Maine Legislature, LD 820, Roll Call #269, 6/7/17; Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17 ↩
  19. Maine State Legislature, LD1827, Roll Call #787, 5/1/14; Maine State Legislature, LD1827 Bill Text, 2014 ↩
  20. Bangor Daily News, 6/30/17 ↩
  21. Kennebec Journal, 7/1/17; Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 7/1/17 ↩
  22. Bangor Daily News, 6/30/17 ↩
  23. Bangor Daily News, 7/1/17 ↩
  24. Boston Globe, 7/2/17 ↩
  25. Kennebec Journal, 7/4/17; Bangor Daily News, 7/3/17 ↩
  26. Kennebec Journal, 4/2/11; Portland Press Herald, 4/5/11; Bangor Daily News, 4/2/11 ↩
  27. Sun Journal, Editorial, 6/27/15 ↩
  28. Facebook, Honorable Amy Volk, 8/30/16; Facebook, Honorable Amy Volk, 8/28/16 ↩
  29. Sun Journal, Editorial, 6/27/15 ↩
  30. Bangor Daily News, 9/13/18 ↩
  31. Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 6/5/15 ↩
  32. Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 6/5/15 ↩
  33. Bangor Daily News, 9/13/18 ↩
  34. State of Maine Legislature, LD 1645, Roll Call #654, 4/29/16; State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 1645, 4/29/16; Joint Standing Committee on Appropriations and Financial Affairs, Summaries of Bills, LD1645, May 2016 ↩
  35. Maine Public Radio, 1/2/15 ↩
  36. Sun Journal, 11/30/16 ↩
  37. Bangor Daily News, 9/30/16 ↩
  38. Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 8/15/18 ↩
  39. Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 8/15/18 ↩

Source report (PDF)