Paul LePage: MAINE ECONOMY UNDER LEPAGE
2013: LePage Tied for Second-Worst Governor for Private Sector Job Creation. “LePage tied for second-from-worst among the 45 governors ranked. Citing figures from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the publication found that about 10,500 private-sector jobs had been created since LePage took office in January 2011, which works out to an annual growth rate of 0.91 percent, about half the national average of 1.98 percent.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/6/13; Business Journals, 6/27/13]
- Maine Listed as 41st in Job Creation in the US. As of July 2013 Jobs USA ranked Maine at 41st for nonfarm job creation over the past year in the US, having only a 1.1% increase in job creation. [Job Growth USA, Arizona State University, 7/13]
HEADLINE: Maine Leads List Of The Worst States For Business. At the end of 2012, Forbes reported, “For the third straight year Maine ranks No. 50 in Forbes seventh annual Best States for Business. Maine’s problems run deep. It has the second highest corporate tax burden at 16% above the national average, according to Moody’s Analytics. Energy costs, like the rest of New England, are also sky high at 27% above the U.S. average. The state is burdened with the oldest population in the U.S. with a median age of 42. The numbers tell the story on Maine. Its economy contracted 0.6% a year between 2006 and 2011, versus 0.5% annual growth (net of inflation) for the U.S. as a whole. The five-year projected growth rate of 2.5% is fifth worst in the U.S. The job growth picture is equally anemic, as its 1.4% forecasted rate through 2016 ranks fourth worst among states. Maine has few big businesses headquartered there, including none of the 1,000 largest U.S. companies by sales.” [Forbes.com, 12/12/12]
HEADLINE: Bangor Manufacturer Moving Headquarters To N.H., Citing ‘Less Than Friendly’ Business Environment. “P.A.T. Products, an international distributor of specialty chemicals, plastic and raw materials, has been based in Bangor for 39 years. Leo Coyle, the company’s founder and president, told the Bangor Daily News he is moving the company’s corporate headquarters to the Pease International Tradeport in Portsmouth, N.H., because of that state’s more attractive tax structure… Maine has a ‘far less than friendly business environment, and that’s clear, no matter what our friend Mr. LePage puts out there,’ he said.” [Bangor Daily News, 2/28/13]
Maine Economic Growth Council Found “Cause for Concern” in Maine’s Lack of Research and Development. “Maine has more cause for concern than optimism, according to the Maine Economic Growth Council’s” report, which cited Maine’s relatively low level of research and development funding and that “Gov. Paul LePage’s veto of a $20 million general obligation bond in May 2012 exacerbates the problem, the report states.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/5/13]
HEADLINE: Maine Remains in the Pits on Job Creation Despite Lepage’s Prolonged Focus. The Bangor Daily News reported that though “Between when LePage took office in January 2011 and May of this year, the state has seen an increase in the ranks of the employed workers of about 13,750, according to seasonally adjusted figures from the Maine Department of Labor… Maine continues to rank near the bottom in various measures of states’ business climates. Maine was one of only three states (along with Wisconsin and Wyoming) to lose private-sector jobs between April 2012 and April 2013, according to data released June 14 by the Pew Charitable Trusts. Maine’s second-from-last ranking was caused by the loss of 1,500 jobs for a drop of about 0.3 percent, according to the trust.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/6/13]
Bangor Daily News: 2018 Maine Department Of Labor Report Projected Net Gain Of Only 100 Jobs By 2026. In August of 2018 the Bangor Daily News detailed “A report released last week by the Maine Department of Labor paints a bleak picture of the state's economic future -- fewer than 100 net jobs will be added by 2026. Most job gains will come in the health care sector while losses will be mainly in the service and manufacturing sector.” [Bangor Daily News, 8/8/18]
Bangor Daily News: Maine DoL Reports Indicated Maine Needed To Attract More People To Fill Jobs, Pay Taxes But LePage Has Been “Insulting” To New Mainers. “When it comes to new Mainers, LePage has sometimes been downright insulting. He has blamed immigrants for bringing diseases and the fictional ‘ziki fly’ to Maine. He called asylum seekers, people fleeing violence and persecution in their homelands the ‘biggest problem in our state,’ although Maine is home to very few of them. He has also insulted black people and fought against LGBT rights in other states. The Maine Department of Labor report makes clear -- as have countless reports before it -- that Maine needs to attract new residents to fill jobs and pay taxes to support government services.” [Bangor Daily News, 8/8/18]
Maine Was Rated Among the Worst States in the Country for Business Under Paul LePage
2010-2018: Maine Ranked Among Worst States for Businesses According to CNBC’s “Top States for Business” Rankings Which Placed Maine 35th to 46th Under LePage.
Year Ranking According to CNBC’s “Top States for Business”
2010 | |
2011 | |
2012 | |
2013 | |
2014 | |
2015 | |
2016 | |
2017 | |
2018 |
Bangor Daily News Headline: “Forbes Lists Maine as Worst State for Business, Again.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/11]
Bangor Daily News Headline: “Study: Maine Is Fifth-Worst State for Business Taxes.” [Bangor Daily News, 4/17/12]
WCVB Headline: “Maine Ranked as Worst State for Business: Forbes Gives Maine Last-Place Ranking, Again.” [WVCB, 12/12/12]
2015: Maine Moved Up to 48th Ranking in Forbes’ List of Business-Friendly States After Being Ranked 50th from 2010-2013. According to the Bangor Daily News, “We’re No. 48! That’s on the Forbes magazine list of business-friendly states. Maine sat at 49th last year after taking 50th place — last among states, for you civic-minded people — from 2010 to 2013.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/23/15]
NewsCenter Maine Headline: “CNBC Ranks Maine Fifth Worst State for Business.” [NewsCenter Maine, 7/12/17]
MaineBiz Headline: “WalletHub's 'Best And Worst' State Economies Puts Maine In Bottom Tier.” [MaineBiz, 6/5/17]
Mainebiz 2017: “An Analysis Of 2017 ‘Best And Worst State Economies’ By The Personal Finance Website WalletHub Ranks Maine 45th Nationwide.” According to MaineBiz, “An analysis of 2017 ‘best and worst state economies’ by the personal finance website WalletHub ranks Maine 45th nationwide. WalletHub compared the 50 states and the District of Columbia across 27 key indicators of economic performance and strength. The data set ranges from GDP growth to startup activity to share of jobs in high-tech industries.” [MaineBiz, 6/5/17]
Maine’s Economy Lagged Behind its New England Neighbors and National Averages
2010-2015: Maine’s GDP Growth Was “Essentially Even, at 0.3 Percent, Compared to 4.1 Percent Growth in New England and 10 Percent Nationally.” According to the Portland Press Herald, “Maine’s GDP growth between 2010 and 2015 was essentially even, at 0.3 percent, compared with 4.1 percent growth in New England and 10 percent nationally.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/25/17]
2015: “Maine’s Economy Grew by a Sluggish 0.4 Percent […] Lagging Behind New England’s 1.3 Percent Growth Rate and the Nation’s 2.4 Percent Growth.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine’s economy grew by a sluggish 0.4 percent last year, lagging behind New England’s 1.3 percent growth rate and the nation’s 2.4 percent growth.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16]
2016: “Maine is Among the States With the Slowest Growing Economies, According to the Latest Report Card from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine is among the states with the slowest growing economies, according to the latest report card from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16]
2016: President of Envision Maine On LePage Economy, “If You Look at the Economic Traction We’ve Had During His Administration, It’s Horrifying […] Maine is Creating a
Fraction of the Jobs Created Elsewhere.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “‘If you look at the economic traction we’ve had during his administration, it’s horrifying,’ Alan Caron, president of Envision Maine, said. ‘Maine is creating a fraction of the jobs created elsewhere.’” [Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16]
Associated Press Headline: “Maine Sees Sluggish Economic Growth at End of 2016.” [Associated Press, 5/11/17]
Q4 2016: Maine Was Ranked 43rd in Economic Growth for Late 2016. According to the Associated Press, “Maine ranks 43rd in the nation in terms of economy growth late last year. The state's economy grew just 0.7 percent in the final three months of 2016. That makes Maine the slowest-growing state in New England, where the average growth rate was 1.9 percent.” [Associated Press, 5/11/17]
Q4 2016: Maine Was Slowest Growing State in New England. According to the Associated Press, “Maine ranks 43rd in the nation in terms of economy growth late last year. The state's economy grew just 0.7 percent in the final three months of 2016. That makes Maine the slowest-growing state in New England, where the average growth rate was 1.9 percent.” [Associated Press, 5/11/17]
Maine Public Headline: “Feds: Maine's Economic Growth Accelerates In 3rd Quarter, But Lags In New England.” [Maine Public, 1/24/18]
2017: Maine GDP “Grew 1.4 Percent, Below the National Growth Rate of 2.1 Percent and the New England Regional Growth Rate of 1.6 Percent.” According to the Portland Press Herald, “Last year, the state’s gross domestic product – the measure of the output of goods and services in Maine – grew 1.4 percent, below the national growth rate of 2.1 percent and the New England regional growth rate of 1.6 percent.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/26/18]
Q1 2018: Maine’s GDP Grew 0.6 Percent, 46th in the Nation. According to the Portland Press Herald, “The federal Bureau of Economic Analysis reported this week that the state’s economy grew at an annual rate of just 0.6 percent in the first three months of this year, 46th in the nation.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/26/18]
2018: TD Bank Forecasted Maine GDP to Grow 1.8 Percent, Well Below National Forecast of 3 Percent. According to the Portland Press Herald, “TD Bank forecasts that economic growth in Maine will pick up for the rest of the year and end up by 1.8 percent. But that’s well below the 3 percent growth rate forecast for the rest of the country in 2018, said James Marple, a senior economist for the bank.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/26/18]
Maine Had One of the Slowest Recoveries in the Nation from the Great Recession
2016: Maine Was One Of 10 States That Had Not Recovered All Jobs Lost During The Great Recession. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine also is among 10 states that haven’t recovered all the jobs they lost during the Great Recession.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16]
2017: President and CEO of Maine Development Foundation: “There is No Question That Maine’s Economic Recovery Has Generally Been Lower Than the Country and the Region.” According to the Portland Press Herald, “‘There is no question that Maine’s economic recovery has generally been lower than the country and the region,’ said Yellow Light Breen, president and CEO of the Maine Development Foundation.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/25/17]
2017: Maine Took “Four Times Longer Than Usual” to Recover from Great Recession, Finally Recovering to Pre-Recession Employment Levels in 2017. According to the Bangor Daily News, “The estimate of Maine payroll jobs in January topped 620,000 for the first time since before the Great Recession, a recovery that took four times longer than usual.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/13/17]
- Maine’s Recovery to Pre-Recession Employment Levels Came “More Than Two Years After the Nation as a Whole Recovered Jobs Lost During the Great Recession.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “The benchmark comes more than two years after the nation as a whole recovered jobs lost during the Great Recession. Research into the recovery has found a steady pattern in recent recessions, in which rural areas are left behind as new business growth becomes increasingly concentrated in urban areas.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/13/17]
- It Took Maine an Average of 27 Months to Recover from Previous Six Recessions Compared to 109 Months to Recover from Great Recession of 2007. According to the Bangor Daily News, “The Maine Department of Labor has compared that recovery to past recessions, noting that the previous six recessions took an average of 27 months for payroll jobs to recover. If the latest preliminary payroll job estimates hold, recovery from the Great Recession that started in December 2007 will have taken 109 months.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/13/17]
- Bangor Daily News Headline: “After 109 Months, Maine’s Finally Recovered Jobs Lost to the Recession.” [Bangor Daily News, 3/13/17]
Maine’s Northern, Rural Areas Suffered Slowest Recovery Under Paul LePage
WGME: Under LePage, Maine’s Rural, More Northern Counties “Struggled To Rebound” From Recession. In 2018, WGME noted that Maine’s economic recovery was most stunted in areas that voted for LePage in greater numbers, noting “many northern and rural portions of Maine have struggled to rebound, and continue to face population losses and unemployment rates well above the state and national averages.” [WGME, 12/19/18]
2011-2017: Maine’s More Conservative, Rural Second Congressional District Had “Consistently Higher” Unemployment Rate Than Southern Part Of The State. “In Maine’s left-leaning 1st Congressional District — made up of Cumberland, Knox, Lincoln, Sagadahoc, York and most of Kennebec county — the average unemployment rate dropped from 7.2 to under 3 percent from 2011 to 2017, the most recent year available, according to state data. During the same period, the unemployment rate in the more conservative, rural 2nd Congressional District, excluding a small part of Kennebec County, remained consistently higher, falling from 9.5 to 3.9 percent.” [WGME, 12/19/18]
Maine Lost Thousands of Manufacturing Jobs Under Paul LePage
2011-2014: Maine Lost Roughly 1,400 Manufacturing Jobs Under LePage. According to data reported by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Maine’s manufacturing jobs declined from 51,000 statewide to 49,700 between 2011 and 2014. [Bureau Of Labor Statistics, Maine, Manufacturing, Accessed 5/2/21]
Maine Department of Labor Report Forecasted Net Increase of 94 Jobs in Maine from 2016 to 2026. According to the Bangor Daily News, “The Maine Department of Labor’s latest workforce forecast reflects a changing job market in which health care and food service workers will be in high demand in the coming years, while people in office administration and production may have a tough time finding work. And the job fields that are growing at a healthy clip aren’t enough to offset the number of jobs lost in older industries or slower growing job areas. That’s according to a report by the Department of Labor’s Center for Workforce Research and Information looking at job projections for 10 years from 2016 to 2026. In fact, the net job growth over that period is only 94 jobs total, or about nine per year.” [Bangor Daily News, 8/7/18]
2016: LePage Said the State Was On the Verge of Losing Up to 1,500 Manufacturing Jobs. According to WGME, “Now, the governor is saying he knows firsthand, that the state is on the verge of losing as many as 1,500 manufacturing jobs. ‘We're taking jobs in the 60's and 70's and 80-thousand dollars a year,’ LePage said. Governor LePage won't say exactly where those jobs will be lost, only that they're coming.” [WGME, 4/20/16]
- WMTW Headline: “Gov. LePage Increases Prediction of Maine Job Losses.” [WMTW, 4/20/16]
- Maine Public Headline: “LePage: Maine to Lose Between 1,200 and 1,500 Jobs This Summer.” [Maine Public, 4/20/16]
- 2016: LePage Predicted 1,000-1,600 Maine Job Losses During the Summer. According to Maine Public, “Gov. Paul LePage has upped by hundreds the number of jobs he says will be lost in Maine this summer. LePage made the prediction at one of his ongoing town hall meetings in Biddeford Tuesday night. ‘This summer, we're going to lose between 1,200 and 1,500 more jobs - not all paper, but some paper and some other industries,’ LePage said. ‘The problem is this: Every single job that we're talking about are jobs that get paid above the per capita median income of Mainers. We're talking jobs in the $60,000, $70,000 and $80,000 a year. I find that appalling.’” [Maine Public, 4/20/16]
- LePage: “This Summer, We're Going to Lose Between 1,200 and 1,500 More Jobs.” According to Maine Public, “Gov. Paul LePage has upped by hundreds the number of jobs he says will be lost in Maine this summer. LePage made the prediction at one of his ongoing town hall meetings in Biddeford Tuesday night. ‘This summer, we're going to
lose between 1,200 and 1,500 more jobs - not all paper, but some paper and some other industries,’ LePage said. ‘The problem is this: Every single job that we're talking about are jobs that get paid above the per capita median income of Mainers. We're talking jobs in the $60,000, $70,000 and $80,000 a year. I find that appalling.’” [Maine Public, 4/20/16]