Paul LePage: MAINECARE MISMANAGEMENT
Paul Lepage Hired Mary Mayhew, A Corporate Lobbyist, To Run Maine’s Department Of Health And Human Services (DHHS). Under Her Watch DHHS “Was Providing Medicaid Benefits To 19,000 Ineligible People.” “All the time Gov. Paul LePage was insisting that 65,000 Mainers must be dropped immediately from the Medicaid rolls because the state couldn’t afford to pay for them, his administration was providing Medicaid benefits to 19,000 ineligible people.” “Department of Health and Human Services Commissioner Mary Mayhew told the Appropriations Committees that ‘computer problems’ were the culprit.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/05/11 and 03/25/12) “She said the bill paying computer system could not communicate with the eligibility system, so individuals were not being removed from the billing system after they were determined not to be eligible for benefits any more.” Mayhew said the problem “was not brought to the attention of her and other agency leaders until January” 2012. “‘The magnitude of that incompetence is astounding to me,’” Democratic Representative Peggy Rotundo said. “‘One of the things that is particularly disturbing to me is that someone in DHHS knew in January [2012] that there was a problem. This is at the same time we were meeting with the commissioner and her staff trying to figure out why we had a shortfall.’” (Kennebec Journal, 03/07/12)
- It is not clear “if Mayhew had dark motives in concealing the depths of the department’s ineptitude. What matters is the sheer incompetence of the agency’s performance under her management. From the beginning, Mayhew was seriously unqualified for the job. She had no significant administrative credentials.” Douglas Rooks, “a former daily and weekly newspaper editor who…covered the State House for 25 years,” said Paul LePage “must do something that only he can – fire Mayhew as DHHS commissioner. At this point, it doesn’t really matter if Mayhew had dark motives in concealing the depths of the department’s ineptitude. What matters is the sheer incompetence of the agency’s performance under her management. From the beginning, Mayhew was seriously unqualified for the job. She had no significant administrative credentials and her primary State House experience was as a lobbyist for the Maine Hospital Association.” “The only way Mayhew could have succeeded would be to lean on the department’s more experienced managers to learn the ropes and understand the system. She did the opposite. She fired 10 of the department’s top directors. She even sacked [the non-political] Dora Mills, the former DHHS public health director who, clearing the way for a new appointee, volunteered to help out with Medicaid – an offer LePage had accepted before Mayhew’s arrival.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/05/11 and 03/25/12)
- Instead Of Leaning “On The Department’s More Experienced Managers To Learn The Ropes And Understand The System…She Fired 10 Of The Department’s Top Directors.” “The only way Mayhew could have succeeded would be to lean on the department’s more experienced managers to learn the ropes and understand the system. She did the opposite. She fired 10 of the department’s top directors. She even sacked [the
non-political] Dora Mills, the former DHHS public health director who, clearing the way for a new appointee, volunteered to help out with Medicaid – an offer LePage had accepted before Mayhew’s arrival.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/05/11 and 03/25/12)
- She “Was Flying Blind,” And As A Result Her “Crash Was Inevitable.” The Lepage Administration Took Away Health Care From Thousands Of Mainers Because Of A Budget Problem That Was Caused At Least In Part By This Issue. “According to Mayhew, the program managers who would have been notified of the problem were the director of MaineCare Services, the MaineCare finance director and the director for the Office of Family Independence. The directors are political appointments by the governor. Gov. Paul LePage, in an effort to implement his new policy initiatives…jettisoned a host of program directors from DHHS, including all three directors from the aforementioned offices. Two of the replacement directors were new to the agency. A third was promoted from within DHHS.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 03/08/12) “It isn’t an exaggeration to say that Mayhew was flying blind, and that the crash was inevitable. Seven years after DHHS’ computer woes were first identified, to blame machines for the problems the new commissioner has created is laughable.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/05/11 and 03/25/12) “The 19,000…[represented] 5 percent of the 361,000 Mainers enrolled in MaineCare,” which is Maine’s Medicaid program. (The Associated Press State & Local Wire, 03/07/12) “Democrats said that the LePage administration’s decision to withhold information about the inappropriate payments means lawmakers effectively removed health care services for 14,000 Mainers with a recently-enacted budget built on inaccurate data.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 03/08/12)
Paul Lepage Argued That Mainers Needed To Be Cut From Mainecare Because Costs Were Spiraling Out Of Control Due To Enrollment Increases. However, Under Mary Mayhew’s Watch The “Shortfall Was Largely Driven By A Variety Of Budgeting Miscalculations…Made” By The Department She Runs. Paul “LePage has repeatedly argued” that the MaineCare revenue shortfall has been caused by an increase in the number of people enrolled in the program. (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/10/12) “Gov. Paul LePage…proposed a sweeping overhaul of the MaineCare program that would eliminate coverage for 65,000 residents and reduce services for many others to close the budget gap” because of a shortfall caused by “a big jump in MaineCare enrollment” and fraud. (Bangor Daily News, 12/07/11) “But according to the LePage administration’s own analysis, increased enrollment in MaineCare comprises only about 5 percent of the shortfall.” “Also, according to the administration’s analysis, the current shortfall was largely driven by a variety of budgeting miscalculations it made” in 2011. “For example, DHHS officials significantly under- budgeted for the state’s private, nonmedical institutions. It also didn’t sufficiently account for the loss of federal stimulus funds or increased Medicaid premiums by the federal government. According to DHHS, the biggest driver in…[the shortfall]…is…a new claims system that caused benefit payments that should have been settled” in 2011 to be paid in 2012. (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/10/12)
Paul Lepage’s Reason For Wanting To Kick 65,000 Mainers Off Mainecare And Take Away Health Benefits From Mainers, Including Prescription Drugs For The Elderly, Turns Out Not To Be True. The Bangor Daily News Opined, “Miscasting A… Problem In Order To…Fulfill An Ideological Agenda Is Politically Disingenuous. Doing So At The Expense
Of The State’s Most Vulnerable People – Without Plans To Help Them And Their Families Through The Changes – Is Callous.” “All the time Gov. Paul LePage was insisting that 65,000 Mainers must be dropped immediately from the Medicaid rolls because the state couldn’t afford to pay for them, his administration was providing Medicaid benefits to 19,000 ineligible people.” “Department of Health and Human Services Commissioner Mary Mayhew told the Appropriations Committees that ‘computer problems’ were the culprit.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 04/05/11 and 03/25/12) “Those reasons are very different from the rationale used by the governor to try to justify major cuts he …proposed. Gov. Paul LePage…proposed a sweeping overhaul of the MaineCare program that would eliminate coverage for 65,000 residents and reduce services for many others to close the budget gap” because of a shortfall caused by “a big jump in MaineCare enrollment” and fraud. The Bangor Daily News opined, “miscasting a budget problem in order to quickly make changes to fulfill an ideological agenda is politically disingenuous. Doing so at the expense of the state’s most vulnerable people – without plans to help them and their families through the changes – is callous.” (Bangor Daily News, 12/07/11)
Mary Mayhew’s Department, A Year After The Abovementioned Miscalculations, Miscalculated Medicaid Costs By Another $100 Million. “These Miscalculations Are Mammoth.” According to former daily and weekly newspaper editor Douglas Rooks, “the shocker in…[a late 2012] Appropriations Committee presentation was the LePage administration’s assertion that the Department of Health and Human Services is another $100 million in the red for the…fiscal year. That’s on top of $200 million in shortfalls the administration ‘discovered’ in early 2012, which led to harsh cuts in…[the previous] year’s supplemental budget, pushed through solely by Republican votes. These miscalculations are mammoth. They total 15 percent of all DHHS spending. Shortfalls of that amount in any department point to one thing – managerial incompetence.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 12/09/12)
- According To Former Daily And Weekly Newspaper Editor Douglas Rooks, “Shortfalls Of That Amount In Any Department Point To One Thing – Managerial Incompetence.” He Continued, “There’s No Excuse For Botching The Estimates This Badly, Particularly When It Involves The Largest State Department.” Shortfalls of that amount in any department point to one thing – managerial incompetence.” “The administration has cranked out excuse after excuse for the unending shortfalls. It cites Medicaid match-rate cutbacks as federal stimulus spending expired.” “They cite growth in Medicaid spending in previous years. And they complain that federal authorities haven’t approved cuts to existing Medicaid programs – waivers never granted to any state, and which won’t be now, since the Affordable Care Act’s thrust is to expand Medicaid (and privately-insured citizens) to approach universal coverage.” “The trouble with the administration’s excuses is that all these facts were known when it signed off on the budget.” “There’s no excuse for botching the estimates this badly, particularly when it involves the largest state department, in terms of both state and federal funding.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 12/09/12)
- Douglas Rooks Said This Shows “The Administration Seems Utterly Clueless” And That Lepage’s DHHS Lacks “Credibility And Competence.” Democratic “Rep. Peggy Rotundo…said after the shortfall bombshell dropped that she hoped for ‘an in-depth analysis.’ She won’t likely get one, for the administration seems utterly clueless.”
“Democratic leaders should insist Mayhew be replaced with someone qualified to oversee DHHS, manage its programs, and explain its budget. It’s abundantly clear she can’t.” “Democrats can safely brush aside LePage’s trivial complaints about ‘trackers’ and ask him about something serious – restoring a DHHS with credibility and competence. It may be their first big test.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 12/09/12)
Sun Journal Editorial: LePage May be Intentionally Misinterpreting Relationship with Federal Government. The Sun Journal wrote of “LePage has shown a disconcerting tendency recently to either mishear, misinterpret or misquote important information he has been told by federal officials… the governor seems to have conflated or confused a conversation he had with U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius.” [Sun Journal, 1/11/12]
- Administration May Have Knowingly Sought Budget Crisis in Getting
Medicaid Waiver. The Sun Journal wrote of LePage’s relationship with Secretary Sebelius, “The governor said he was told in April the state would have to make cuts to the program before Sebelius' department would consider granting the waiver. That, as some legislators have pointed out, would be risky. The state could adopt a budget based upon the cuts, only to learn later that the cuts were not permitted. Contacted by the Sun Journal, federal sources refused to confirm Sebelius gave LePage such advice and declined to confirm that the DHHS cuts are necessary to obtain a waiver. Confronted with that information, a LePage spokesperson said the administration knew it could apply for the waiver at any time and that cutting the budget first was meant to ‘put pressure’ on the federal government to grant the waiver. If we understand that correctly, the idea would be to knowingly create a budget crisis and then shift the blame to the feds.” [Sun Journal, 1/11/12]
Kennebec Journal Headline: “As LePage Fights Medicaid, Mainers Apply.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/24/18]
- July 2018: Mainers That Were Newly Eligible For Medicaid Signed Up Despite LePage Administration Failing To Implement Expansion. “At least 25 Mainers who are newly eligible for Medicaid have applied for health insurance under the expanded program this month, and hundreds more have gone online to determine whether they qualify for coverage under the voter-approved law. It is unclear, however, whether anyone who signs up will obtain insurance because the LePage administration has balked at implementing the expansion, citing the lack of a sustainable funding source. Maine Equal Justice Partners, an Augusta advocacy group that has sued the LePage administration for failing to implement the expansion, is urging people to sign up and has created an online screening tool to help.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/24/18]
- Kennebec Journal: LePage Refused To Expand Medicaid Despite Voters Approving Expansion By 59 To 41 Percent Margin. “Voters approved Medicaid expansion by a 59 to 41 percent margin in 2017, but Republican Gov. Paul LePage has refused to implement the expansion, arguing that the Legislature needs to adequately fund it. LePage vetoed a
funding bill, and the Legislature failed to override the veto in a July 9 vote.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/24/18]