Paul LePage: MINIMUM WAGE

Opposition to Minimum Wage Increase

Paul Lepage, In 2006, Implied That He Opposes A Minimum Wage Increase, At Least In Part Because It “Likely Would” Force Employers To Adjust… [The] Entire Pay Scale In Order To Keep…Veteran Workers” Happy. Paul LePage, in 2006, “said that politics – more than compassion – was the driving force behind the latest [minimum] wage hike. ‘It’s nothing more than a political feel-good during an election year,’ LePage said. ‘It certainly does nothing to show that you are business friendly.’ LePage…[was] quick to note that starting pay at Marden’s…[was] already $7 an hour. But he said that doesn’t mean his company, which employs about 850 people, won’t feel the effects of the increase. He predicted the company likely would adjust its entire pay scale in order to keep its veteran workers. ‘If you increase the minimum, you’ve got to increase everybody,’ said LePage, describing what is known in economic circles as the ‘spillover effect’ of a wage increase. ‘People want to maintain their distance from the minimum wage.’” (Bangor Daily News, 07/22/06)

Paul Lepage Does Not Support Raising The State Minimum Wage, And He Does Not Support Raising “The State’s Minimum Wage Each Year To Match The Cost Of Inflation.” Maine “has raised its minimum wage 30 times since 1959 and nine times since 1996. In 2008 the Legislature raised the rate to $7.50, the current rate.” According to an article with the headline, “Effort to raise Maine’s minimum wage meets opposition by business groups, LePage,” the governor did not support a bill “to raise the state’s minimum wage each year to match the cost of inflation” and a bill to “raise the current minimum wage of $7.50 an hour by 50 cents over the next two years.” His administration, “through testimony from the Bureau of Labor Standards, said the state’s economy was too fragile to increase the burden on businesses. Mike Rowland told the panel that the administration would prefer that Maine’s minimum wage conform with the federal rate of $7.25 an hour.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 03/12/11)

LePage Opposed Legislation to Raise the Minimum Wage From $7.50 to $9 an Hour by 2016 and Index it to Inflation Thereafter. Paul LePage opposes legislation to “raise the minimum wage from $7.50 to $9 an hour by 2016 and index it to inflation thereafter.” In fact, “representatives of the state Department of Labor and Department of Economic and Community Development testified against the bill.” (Portland Press Herald, 03/29/13)

  • LePage Ultimately Vetoed the Legislation. In 2013 LePage vetoed a bill that “would incrementally increase the minimum wage from the current $7.50 per hour to $9 an hour by 2015, followed by annual increases tied to inflation… LePage wrote in his veto letter that Maine should focus on creating better jobs rather than improving its lowest-paying jobs.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/8/13]

LePage Opposed Legislation to Increase Maine’s Minimum Wage to $8.50 and Raise it Annually Thereafter by the Same Percentage as the CPI. Paul LePage’s administration also opposes LD 611, which is a bill to “increase Maine’s minimum wage to $8.50…and raise it annually by the same percentage as the Consumer Price Index.” (Bangor Daily News, 03/14/13)

2013: Called Minimum Wage Raise a Job Killer. The Portland Press Herald reported, “Gov. Paul LePage is calling the minimum wage bill that awaits final disposition a job killer. In his weekly radio address, the Republican governor said the bill to raise Maine's minimum wage to $9 an hour by 2016 and then automatically adjust it for inflation each year after that has a cost. To absorb the cost of higher wages, LePage said, businesses will hire fewer workers and increase prices on their products and services. And he said consumers will pay that cost.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/28/13]

“Training” Wage

The Lepage Administration, In 2011, Supported Cutting The Minimum Wage For Many Teenagers By Creating A Training Wage For Them That Is Lower Than The Minimum Wage. A representative from the Maine Department of Labor, in 2011, said the LePage “administration was in favor of a training wage.” A bill, in 2011, by Republican Representative David Burns would have established “a low ‘training wage’ for teens starting a new job.” “According to a summary of the bill, it would establish a training wage for new workers 20 years old or younger of $5.62 per hour for their first 90 days of employment.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/16/11)

Opposition to Voter-Passed Minimum Wage Increase

2016: Maine Voters Passed Referendum Raising Minimum Wage to $9 in 2017 and $12 in 2020. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine voters decided Tuesday to raise the state’s minimum wage for the first time since 2009, bumping it to $9 per hour next year, from $7.50, and to $12 by 2020 as part of a national push by progressive groups. […] The Maine referendum raises the state’s minimum wage to $9 in 2017 and by $1 each year until 2020. After that, it will be tied to inflation.” [Bangor Daily News, 11/9/16]

Governing Headline: “Maine Governor: Advocates Should Be Jailed For Supporting Minimum-Wage Hike.” [Governing, 10/17/16]

LePage “Loudly Opposed” Statewide Minimum Wage Hike in 2016. According to the Bangor Daily News “The governor also tried and failed to block Portland and Bangor from raising their local minimum wages in 2015, and loudly opposed a statewide wage hike to similar effect the next year.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/19/18]

October 2016: LePage Threatened To Jail Proponents Of Referendum On Raising The Maine Minimum Wage To $12 An Hour. “LePage, speaking to the Lewiston-Auburn Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce, said Mike Tipping and Ben Chin, both officials with the Maine People's Alliance, should be jailed because increasing the minimum wage will lead to higher prices and potentially harm elderly residents on fixed incomes. The MPA is a progressive organization that frequently backs Democratic initiatives and is one of the major groups pushing for a stepped increase in the minimum wage, which would rise to $12 an hour by 2020 if voters approve the question.” [Kennebec Journal, 10/14/16]

  • Sun Journal: Minimum Wage Hike Would Lift Incomes Of 181,000 Maine Residents, Including One In Three Working Seniors. “The referendum, if approved, would gradually raise the state's minimum wage, boosting the incomes of 181,000 Maine residents, including more than one in three working seniors, according to the National Employment Law Project.” [Sun Journal, 10/13/16]

LePage Said Two Advocates for Minimum Wage Increase “Should Be Thrown in Jail for What They’re Doing to the Elderly.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Blasting a ballot measure that would hike Maine’s minimum wage, Gov. Paul LePage said Thursday that two proponents of the increase — Ben Chin and Mike Tipping of the Maine People’s Alliance — ‘should be thrown in jail for what they’re doing to the elderly.’” [Bangor Daily News, 10/13/16]

LePage Called for Two Advocates of Ballot Measure to Increase Minimum Wage to Be Jailed, Saying They Were Guilty of “Attempted Murder” of Senior Citizens. According to Governing, “Gov. Paul LePage affirmed his statement Friday that two advocates of a state ballot question to increase the minimum wage should be jailed, saying they are guilty of the ‘attempted murder’ of senior citizens because of the alleged impact of a wage increase.” [Governing, 10/17/16]

  • LePage: “To Me When You Go Out And Kill Somebody, You Go To Jail. Well, This Is Attempted Murder In My Mind Because It Is Pushing People To The Brink Of Survival,’ LePage Said Of The Proposed Minimum Wage Increase.” According to Governing, “‘To me when you go out and kill somebody, you go to jail. Well, this is attempted murder in my mind because it is pushing people to the brink of survival,’ LePage said of the proposed minimum wage increase.” [Governing, 10/17/16]
  • LePage On Two Advocates For A Minimum Wage Increase: “They Are Deliberately And Knowingly Hurting Mainers.” According to Governing, “LePage, who first suggested Mike Tipping and Ben Chin should be jailed for supporting the ballot question during an appearance before the Lewiston-Auburn Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce on Thursday, repeated that during a phone-in interview on the South Portland-based WGAN radio, saying, ‘They are deliberately and knowingly hurting Mainers.’” [Governing, 10/17/16]

Governing: “LePage Has Argued The Wage Increase Will Push The Prices Of Consumer Goods And Services Beyond The Reach Of Retirees On Fixed Incomes.” According to Governing, “LePage has argued the wage increase will push the prices of consumer goods and services beyond the reach of retirees on fixed incomes and said he believed Tipping and Chin were committing a moral crime.” [Governing, 10/17/16]

LePage Tried and Failed to Block Minimum Wage Increases in Portland and Bangor. According to the Bangor Daily News “The governor also tried and failed to block Portland and Bangor from raising their local minimum wages in 2015, and loudly opposed a statewide wage hike to similar effect the next year.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/19/18]

June 2018: LePage Continued “Fight Against The Minimum Wage” With Introduction Of Bill To Slow Increase And Eliminate Future Increases. “The Legislature reconvened to continue work on a number of bills that were left in limbo when a vote to extend the session in April failed. The impasse at that time was over Medicaid funding and Republicans' demand that scheduled increases in Maine's minimum wage, which would go to $12 and hour by 2020, be slowed. Gov. Paul LePage continued his fight against the minimum wage Tuesday with the introduction of another bill to slow the increases and eliminate future bumps related to increases in the cost of living.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/19/18]

Tip Sharing

Lobbyists “From The State’s Most Powerful Law Firms” Were Placed By Paul Lepage “In The Enviable Position Of Being Able To Oversee The Drafting Of The Governor’s Policies On Behalf Of The Corporate Clients They” Represent. “Top attorneys from the state’s most powerful law firms – Pierce Atwood managing partner Gloria Pinza and, especially, Ann Robinson, head of lobbying at Preti Flaherty – were placed in the enviable position of being able to oversee the drafting of the governor’s policies on behalf of the corporate clients they are paid to represent.” The “two Portland-based firms wrote at least 28 of the 50 environmental rollbacks the governor’s office submitted to the legislature in January” 2011. “In most cases, language from the industry and lobbyist’s memos was copied word-for-word into LePage’s reform proposal.” “These include rolling back Maine’s civil rights and wage and tip sharing laws to weaker federal standards (proposed by Portland restaurateur STEVE DIMILLO)” and “weakening child labor laws (MAINE INNKEEPERS ASSOCIATION),” as well as “directing the Bureau of Insurance to ease oversight over insurance rates (MAINE ASSOCIATION OF HEALTH PLANS).” (The Portland Phoenix, 07/20/11)

  • In Most Cases, “Language From The Industry And Lobbyist’s Memos Was Copied Word-For-Word Into Lepage’s Reform” Proposals, Including “Wage and Tip Sharing Laws” and Child Labor Laws. “In most cases, language from the industry and lobbyist’s memos was copied word-for-word into LePage’s reform proposal.” “These include rolling back Maine’s civil rights and wage and tip sharing laws to weaker federal standards (proposed by Portland restaurateur STEVE DIMILLO)” and “weakening child labor laws (MAINE INNKEEPERS ASSOCIATION),” as well as “directing the Bureau of Insurance to ease oversight over insurance rates (MAINE ASSOCIATION OF HEALTH PLANS).” (The Portland Phoenix, 07/20/11)

Source report (PDF)