Paul LePage: MINING

In 2017, Bipartisan Majorities of the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of Legislation That Banned Open Pit Mining in Maine. In June 2017, the Senate overrode LePage’s veto of LD820 by a 35-0 vote and the House overrode his veto by a 122-21 vote. “The Maine Senate has passed a bipartisan metal mining bill that would ban open pit mines and wastewater impoundments, although some environmental advocates fear it does not go far enough. LD 820, An Act To Protect Maine’s Clean Water and Taxpayers from Mining Pollution, passed in the Senate Tuesday morning by a vote of 34-0.” [State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 820, 6/7/17; State of Maine Legislature, LD 820, Roll Call #269, 6/7/17; Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17]

  • HEADLINE: “Maine Lawmakers Ban Open-Pit Mining, Approve Restrictions.” [Bloomberg Law, 6/8/17]
  • Headline: “Maine Senate Unanimously Votes to Ban Open-Pit Mining.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17]
  • The Legislation Prohibited Open-Pit Mining And Wet Mine Tailings Impoundments. LD 820 “requires the use of dry stack tailings management and prohibits the use of wet mine waste units or tailings impoundments for the management of mine waste and tailings. 9. It prohibits open-pit mining.” [Joint Standing Committee on Environment and Natural Resources, Summaries of Bills, LD 820, August 2017]
  • Supporters of the Bill Said it Was “the Strongest Metal Mining Law in the Country.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “LD 820, which now heads to the Maine House, would amend the controversial 2012 law with provisions banning open pit mines, large wastewater impoundments and mining on public lands, along with a host of other limits and requirements that backers say would make it the strongest metal mining law in the country.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17]
  • Open Pit Mining Was “the Most Polluting Form of Mining in Our Country.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Carson noted that the bill would ban open pit mining, ‘the most polluting form of mining in our country,’ and the kinds of wastewater impoundments that have failed and led to environmental disasters in others parts of North America and around the world.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17]
  • The Bill Prohibited the Use of Wet Mine Waste, Requiring “Dry Waste Management” Instead, Preventing Water Buildup and Runoff of Acid Mine Drainage. According to the Bangor Daily News, “The bill would prohibit the use of wet mine waste, a source of acid mine drainage and other naturally occurring contaminants, and instead require ‘dry waste management’ where waste rock is stored in lined structures that prevent water buildup and runoff.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17]
  • The Bill Required Companies That Wanted to Develop a Mine in Maine to Post “Sufficient Cash ‘to Cover the Cost in the Event of an Accident or Spill of a Worst-

Case Accident or Spill.;” According to the Bangor Daily News, “A company that wants to apply to develop a metal mine in Maine would have to post sufficient cash ‘to cover the cost in the event of an accident or spill of a worst-case accident or spill,’ as determined by an independent third party, Carson said.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17]

  • The Law Was “The Strongest Metal Mining Law In The Country.” “LD 820, which now heads to the Maine House, would amend the controversial 2012 law with provisions banning open pit mines, large wastewater impoundments and mining on public lands, along with a host of other limits and requirements that backers say would make it the strongest metal mining law in the country.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/9/17]
  • Natural Resources Council Of Maine Scientist: Mining Regulations Bill Supported By “Democrats And Republicans” Crucial To Protect “Citizens And Environment From Mining Pollution.” “Many of the state's environmental organizations, including the Natural Resources Council of Maine and Trout Unlimited, were heavily involved in developing the language that went into L.D. 820. ‘The bill sets a new standard that could serve as a model for any state interested in protecting their citizens and environment from mining pollution,’ Nick Bennett, a staff scientist at NRCM who helped craft the bill, said in a statement. ‘We are delighted that both Republicans and Democrats voted with such overwhelming margins to ensure that this protective bill will become law despite the governor's objections.’" [Press Herald, 6/8/17]

In 2014 and 2015, Canada-Based Irving Corporation Pushed for Weakening the Mining Rules in Maine Because it Wanted to Open a 400-Acre Open-Pit Mine at Bald Mountain in Aroostook County. According to the Natural Resources Council of Maine, “Governor LePage is angry with the Legislature, and with NRCM, because strong bipartisan majorities defeated his proposal to weaken Maine’s mining rules in 2014 and 2015. Canada-based Irving Corporation pushed these rules so it could pursue a 400-acre open-pit mine at Bald Mountain in Aroostook County. This mine would result in so much pollution that Irving sought weaker regulations.” [Natural Resources Council of Maine, 2016]

Source report (PDF)