Paul LePage: NURSING HOMES

Paul LePage Set and Holds the Record for Annual Nursing Home Closures

When LePage Was Elected in 2010, Maine Had 108 Nursing Homes – When He Left, It Had Just 94, a Loss of 14 Homes:

YEAR

TOTAL NUMBER OF NURSING FACILITIES

# OF CLOSED HOMES OVER PRIOR YEAR

2020

93

0

2019

93

1

2018

94*

6

2017

100

1

2016

101

2

2015

103

0

2014

103

4

2013

107

1

2012

108

+2

2011

106

2

2010

108

--

*Kaiser did not have data for 2018, so this data for 2018 is based off of news reporting, cited below [Kaiser Family Foundation, Accessed 12/7/21; Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2021: Four Nursing Homes in Maine Closed. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Four long-term care homes in Maine have announced they will close, displacing 120 residents. The ominous trend also means overburdened hospitals are losing a key lifeline for discharged patients.” [Portland Press Herald, 9/19/21]

July 2019: Maine Had 94 Nursing Homes. According to the Associated Press, “Maine currently has 94 nursing homes, down from 102 in 2017, according to a Department of Health and Human Services spokeswoman.” [Associated Press, 7/19/19]

2018: Six Nursing Homes in Maine Shut Down, Displacing About 200 Elderly Nursing Home Residents and “Accelerating a Trend of Closures in Rural Towns.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Ledgeview was one of half a dozen nursing homes that shut down in Maine this year, uprooting roughly 200 elderly residents across the state and accelerating a trend of closures in rural towns.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

  • HEADLINE: “Record Number of Maine Nursing Homes Closed This Year, Displacing Hundreds.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]
  • The Six Nursing Homes That Closed Were in Jonesport, Patten, West Paris, Fryeburg, Bridgton, and Freeport, Housing About 200 People in Total. According to the Bangor Daily News, “In 2018, six nursing homes closed in Jonesport, Patten, West Paris, Fryeburg, Bridgton and Freeport, according to the ombudsman program. Collectively, just over 200 people resided at those homes when each closure was announced.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2014-2019: Maine Lost More Than a Dozen Nursing Homes. According to the Associated Press, “More than a dozen nursing homes have shuttered in Maine in past five years, and leaders representing them in the aging state plan to meet next week with the administration of Gov. Janet Mills to push for $1 million in held-up funding.” [Associated Press, 7/19/19]

2018: Maine Had 94 Nursing Homes – Since 1995, it Has Lost Nearly 40 Nursing Homes. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine, the oldest state in the nation, is now home to 94 nursing homes. Since 1995, the state has lost nearly 40 of them.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

  • In 2018, Maine Had Fewer Nursing Home Beds Than Other States, Averaging 24 Per 1,000 Residents Over 65 – the National Average is 36 Beds Per 1,000 Residents Over 65. According to the Bangor Daily News, “By 2030, nearly a third of Maine’s population is projected to be over age 65. Yet the state has fewer nursing home beds than other states, averaging 24 per 1,000 residents in the over-65 age group, said Richard Erb, president and CEO of the Maine Health Care Association, a trade group for long-term care providers. The national average is 36 beds.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2017: One Nursing Home in Maine Shut Down. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine lost three more nursing homes in 2014, and one each in 2016 and 2017, before the significant uptick this year.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2016: One Nursing Home in Maine Shut Down. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine lost three more nursing homes in 2014, and one each in 2016 and 2017, before the significant uptick this year.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2014: Three Nursing Homes in Maine Shut Down. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine lost three more nursing homes in 2014, and one each in 2016 and 2017, before the significant uptick this year.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2013: Maine Had 107 Nursing Homes. [CDC, Accessed 12/7/21]

Maine’s Nursing Homes Struggled Throughout the Entirety of Paul LePage’s Tenure

2018: Bangor Daily News: “Years of Pressures, from Underfunding to Struggles to Recruit Staff, Have Caught Up With the Facilities Housing Maine’s Oldest Residents, Leading Not Only to Closures But to Poorer Care Overall.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Years of pressures, from underfunding to struggles to recruit staff, have caught up with the facilities housing Maine’s oldest residents, leading not only to closures but to poorer care overall. That reality is beginning to emerge in federal data and is even acknowledged by the trade group that represents nursing homes in Maine.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

Bangor Daily News: “Maine’s Nursing Homes Have Been Fighting for Survival Since at Least 2012,” When a Calais Nursing Home Shut Down, Leaving 100 People Unemployed and Forcing Some Residents to Move an Hour Away. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Maine’s nursing homes have been fighting for survival since at least 2012. That year, the shuttering of a Calais nursing home reverberated throughout its Washington County community, with some residents forced to move an hour away to Lubec and almost 100 people left jobless.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

MaineCare Pays for 66% of Maine’s 6,500 Nursing Home Residents, But Has “Underpaid Nursing Homes for Years,” Stretching Nursing Homes’ Bottom Lines. According to the Bangor Daily News, “MaineCare, the state’s Medicaid program, foots the bill for most — 66 percent — of Maine’s roughly 6,500 nursing home residents. At some homes, the health insurance program for low-income people covers nearly every resident, stretching bottom lines even further. But the program has underpaid nursing homes for years, according to nursing home operators.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

In 2014 and 2015, MaineCare Increased its Payments to Maine Nursing Homes, Preventing “Catastrophe,” But Nursing Home Costs Increased Even More. According to the Bangor Daily News, “MaineCare bumped up payments in 2014 and again in 2015, preventing an ‘absolute catastrophe,’ but nursing homes’ costs escalated more, Erb said. Reimbursement policies also tend to favor larger facilities with a greater volume of residents, he said.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2011: Paul LePage Proposed Eliminating State Funding for Institutions That Care for Thousands of Needy Elderly Before They Qualify for Nursing Homes

In 2011, LePage Proposed Eliminating State Funding, $60 Million, for Private Nonmedical Institutions, Which Serve the Elderly, Mentally and Physically Disabled, and Patients of Substance Abuse Treatment Programs. According to the Bangor Daily News, “One of the most controversial cuts in Gov. Paul LePage’s proposal to overhaul MaineCare hit a roadblock Tuesday after Republican lawmakers refused to back the plan. Rep. Patrick Flood, House chairman of the Legislature’s Appropriations Committee, said his colleagues oppose the governor’s proposal to save $60 million by eliminating funding for private nonmedical institutions, facilities that serve the elderly, the mentally and physically disabled and patients of substance abuse treatment programs.” [Bangor Daily News, 1/3/12]

  • Private Nonmedical Institutions Cared for 4,000 Seniors, Whose Homes Would Have Been Taken Away Had LePage Been Successful. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Flood spoke at the second of two work sessions on LePage’s proposal held by the Appropriations and Health and Human Services committees to determine its economic and public health impacts. About 6,000 people would be affected by the PNMI cuts, including 4,000 elderly residents who would need to find new housing if Maine’s PNMIs

are forced to close. Under the plan, funding for the institutions would cease July 1.” [Bangor Daily News, 1/3/12]

2013: Paul LePage Tried to Block or Refused to Support $38 Million in Funding for Nursing Homes

2013: Maine’s Bipartisan Budget, Enacted Over LePage’s Veto, Increased Nursing Home Funding by $26 Million in State and Federal Funding. According to the Portland Press Herald, “The Legislature pumped more money into nursing home funding as part of a bipartisan budget enacted in 2013. That budget - approved over LePage's veto - increased nursing home funding by $26 million in state and federal funds beginning July 1, 2015.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/17/14]

Maine Legislature Enacted a Law Without LePage’s Signature That Increased Funding for Nursing Homes by $12 Million and Increased the Reimbursement Rate to Medicaid Nursing Homes. According to the Portland Press Herald, “The Legislature pumped more money into nursing home funding as part of a bipartisan budget enacted in 2013. That budget - approved over Le-Page's veto - increased nursing home funding by $26 million in state and federal funds beginning July 1, 2015. A separate bill - which became law without LePage's signature - added another $12 million in state and federal funds and increased the reimbursement rate to nursing homes under MaineCare, the state's version of Medicaid and the primary funding source for most nursing homes.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/17/14]

  • 2014: Legislature Passed $12 Million for Nursing Homes for the Current Fiscal Year, in Addition to $26 Million in New State and Federal Funding as Part of the Bipartisan Budget. According to a press release from the Maine Senate Democrats, “The new funds will augment $12 million in state and federal funds the Legislature allocated for the current fiscal year, which began July 1. The administration has delayed the release of those dollars for more than two weeks. Lawmakers also approved $26 million in new state and federal funding for nursing homes as part of the bipartisan budget which the Legislature passed despite Governor LePage’s veto.” [Maine Senate Democrats, Press Release, 7/17/14]

2014: Paul LePage Tried to Block or Refused to Sign $24 Million for Nursing Homes

In 2014, Bipartisan Majorities of the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of a Bipartisan Supplemental Budget That Increased Nursing Home Reimbursements by $13 Million in Fiscal Years 2016 and 2017. In May 2014, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD1858 by a 134-12 vote and the Senate by a 35-0 vote. “The politics of nursing home funding ramped up in the final days of the last legislative session. In mid-April, LePage vetoed a bipartisan supplemental budget, L.D. 1858, that would increase nursing home reimbursements by $13 million in fiscal 2016 and 2017. It also would provide $1.1 million when the funding mechanism started in June 2015, the last month of fiscal 2015. The Legislature easily overrode LePage's budget veto and passed another bill, L.D. 1776, that included an initial $11.6 million to increase reimbursements in fiscal 2015, which started July 1.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14; State of Maine Legislature, LD 1858, Roll Call #749, 5/1/14; State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 1858, 5/1/14]

  • Sun Journal Editorial Board: “If The Legislature Overrides Both LD 1719 And LD 1858, The Nursing Homes Get The Funding They Need.” “If the Legislature overrides both LD 1719 and LD 1858, the nursing homes get the funding they need and public health agencies can help teach thousands of Maine's "vulnerable citizens" how to prevent disease while they're young so they can be healthier as they age. You know, before they get to the nursing home.” [Editorial, Sun Journal, 4/29/14]
  • Sun Journal: “Lawmakers Considered The Budget Bill A Victory Because It Was The First Supplemental Budget In Recent Memory For Which There Was No Upfront Participation From The Governor’s Office.” “LD 1858, which patched an approximately $30 million hole in the current biennial budget, passed through the Legislature with votes of 136-8 in the House and 35-0 in the Senate. Lawmakers considered the budget bill a victory because it was the first supplemental budget in recent memory for which there was no upfront participation from the governor's office. LePage has been saying since last fall that he would not submit a supplemental budget because his original biennial budget proposal was amended by the Legislature to include tax increases and, in his view, was not balanced because it called for a study group to identify and close tax loopholes as a money-saving initiative.” [Sun Journal, 4/26/14]

In 2014, LePage Refused to Sign a Bipartisan Bill That Increased Nursing Home Reimbursements By $11.6 Million For Fiscal Year 2015 And Increased Payments to Nursing Homes With 70 Percent MaineCare Residents. “The Legislature easily overrode LePage's budget veto and passed another bill, L.D. 1776, that included an initial $11.6 million to increase reimbursements in fiscal 2015, which started July 1. The bill also would provide slightly higher payments to nursing homes with more than 70 percent MaineCare residents and would require the state to adjust reimbursement rates every two years to more closely reflect actual costs. LePage let L.D. 1776 become law without his signature, but he didn't let the Legislature's efforts go unchallenged.” The House voted to enact the bill by a 143-0 vote, the Senate by a 31-0 vote, and the bill became law without Governor LePage’s signature. [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14; State of Maine Legislature, LD 1776, Roll Call #712, 4/16/14; State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 1776, 5/1/14]

  • The Bill’s Total Financial Benefit to Nursing Homes Was $11.6 Million, $4 Million in State Money Via Increased Medicaid Reimbursements and $7.6 Million in Federal Matching Funds. According to the Portland Press Herald, “L.D. 1776: A bill from a long-term care study commission that provides a one-time, $4 million infusion of state money to increase Medicaid reimbursements to nursing homes in fiscal 2015. Most of the cash would come from computer-error Medicaid overpayments that the state hopes to recoup from nursing homes. With $7.6 million in federal matching funds, the bill's total financial benefit to nursing homes is $11.6 million. LePage lets the bill become law without his signature.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14]
  • The Bill Required Maine To Adjust Nursing Home Reimbursement Rates Every Two Years To Keep Pace With Actual Costs. “The Legislature easily overrode LePage's budget veto and passed another bill, L.D. 1776, that included an initial $11.6

million to increase reimbursements in fiscal 2015, which started July 1. The bill also would provide slightly higher payments to nursing homes with more than 70 percent MaineCare residents and would require the state to adjust reimbursement rates every two years to more closely reflect actual costs. LePage let L.D. 1776 become law without his signature, but he didn't let the Legislature's efforts go unchallenged.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14]

2014: LePage Submitted a Bill That Would Have Used $5 Million from the Fund for a Healthy Maine to Increase Nursing Home Reimbursements. According to the Portland Press Herald, “L.D. 1864: An emergency bill, submitted by LePage, that would use about $5 million from the Fund for a Healthy Maine to increase nursing home reimbursements. The bill dies.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14]

  • The Bipartisan Budget Committee Killed LePage’s Measure After They Were Told LePage Would Veto it if They Amended it. According to the Associated Press, “LePage originally wanted to aid the nursing homes by taking $5 million of tobacco settlement funds, which are meant for anti-smoking campaigns. The bipartisan budget-writing committee spiked that measure in the final hours of the session after lawmakers were told LePage would veto it if amended.” [Associated Press, 7/17/14]
  • LePage Submitted His Proposal the Day Before the Legislative Session Was Scheduled to End. According to the Sun Journal, “LePage's nursing home proposal was submitted to lawmakers the day before the session was scheduled to end. The one-time, $5 million payment would have drawn roughly $8 million in federal matching funds.” [Sun Journal, 7/17/14]
  • After Legislative Democrats Did Not Want to Raid the Fund for a Healthy Maine to Pay for LePage’s Proposal, and Instead Suggested Using Surplus Funds, LePage Said He’d Veto it. According to the Sun Journal, “Lawmakers on the Appropriations Committee, which would have had to approve the reallocation of state funds, worked late into the morning to come up with a deal, but there was an impasse. Majority Democrats on the committee did not want to raid the Fund for a Healthy Maine, opting instead to use $2 million from surplus for a one-time payment. Legislative leaders and Appropriations Committee members from both parties said the word came from LePage's office that the governor would veto that bill, so Democrats and Republicans agreed to kill the bill rather than push the measure through the House and Senate only to be vetoed by the governor.” [Sun Journal, 7/17/14]

2014: After the Legislative Session Ended, LePage Announced That He’d Increase Nursing Home Reimbursement Rates Without the Legislature by Using $4.6 Million of the MaineCare Surplus to Increase Reimbursement Rates for Nursing Homes in FY2015. According to the Kennebec Journal, “On May 1, in the final hours of the session, LePage submitted an emergency bill, L.D. 1864, that would use about $5 million from the fund to increase nursing home reimbursements. Both bills died and the money remains in the fund, unspent. Then, a little over a week ago, the governor announced that he'd found a new revenue source to increase nursing home reimbursements without the Legislature. The Department of Health and Human Services anticipates a $10 million surplus in MaineCare programs in fiscal 2014, which ended June 30. The programs were $100 million in the hole earlier this year. LePage said he plans to spend $4.6 million of the surplus to increase nursing home reimbursements in fiscal 2015. With federal matching funds factored in, LePage's action will add a total $13.1 million to nursing home reimbursements this year.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/27/14]

  • With the Addition of Federal Matching Funds, LePage’s Action Added $13.1 Million to Nursing Home Reimbursements. According to the Kennebec Journal, “On May 1, in the final hours of the session, LePage submitted an emergency bill, L.D. 1864, that would use about $5 million from the fund to increase nursing home reimbursements. Both bills died and the money remains in the fund, unspent. Then, a little over a week ago, the governor announced that he'd found a new revenue source to increase nursing home reimbursements without the Legislature. The Department of Health and Human Services anticipates a $10 million surplus in MaineCare programs in fiscal 2014, which ended June 30. The programs were $100 million in the hole earlier this year. LePage said he plans to spend $4.6 million of the surplus to increase nursing home reimbursements in fiscal 2015. With federal matching funds factored in, LePage's action will add a total $13.1 million to nursing home reimbursements this year.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/27/14]

Kennebec Journal Editorial Board: On the Nursing Home Funding Issue, “LePage Never Really Worked With the Legislature Toward a Solution, Content to Veto One Bill” and the Demand the Last-Minute Bill He Offered Not be Amended or Else He’d Veto it. According to a Kennebec Journal editorial, “Just because these measures make sense doesn’t mean they’re a shoo-in next legislative session. The spat over nursing home funding, for instance, shows how partisanship, particularly in the hands of LePage, can threaten to sink even the best of intentions. In that case, LePage never really worked with the Legislature toward a solution, content to veto one bill and then offer another of his own, at the last minute and with a demand that it not be altered. The governor spent much of the early summer criticizing Democrats for failing to follow his orders and call a special session to address the funding, even though the governor could have called the session himself. Then, with the Democrats attempting to negotiate with the governor, LePage announced that he would increase nursing home reimbursements using budget surplus funds.” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 8/24/14]

2014: Maine’s Nursing Homes Received an Additional $25.8 Million in Medicaid Reimbursements – with the Legislature Providing Half of it and LePage the Other Half. According to the Kennebec Journal, “When the dust settles and the political rhetoric fades, Maine's nursing homes will get an additional $25.8 million for Medicaid reimbursements this year. In the wake of recent vetoes, overrides and invective, the Democrat-led Legislature can take credit for about half of the money, and Republican Gov. Paul LePage can take credit for the other half. Both sides say they weren't playing politics and simply wanted to do the right thing.” [Kennebec Journal, 7/27/14]

2014: Paul LePage Failed to Release $12.3 Million in Funding to Nursing Facilities in a Timely Fashion

2014: LePage’s DHHS Failed to Complete Rulemaking in Time for Maine to Release $12.3 Million in State and Federal Funds to Nursing Facilities Under a Law Passed the Year

Prior. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Democrats also questioned why the LePage administration was slow to complete a rulemaking process needed to release $12.3 million in state and federal funds to nursing facilities under one of the laws approved in the last legislative session. DHHS has not completed the rulemaking in time to provide the additional funding by July 1, as prescribed in the new law.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/18/14]

  • July 2014: LePage Administration Had Been Delaying the Release of $12 Million for Nursing Homes. According to a press release from the Maine Senate Democrats, “The new funds will augment $12 million in state and federal funds the Legislature allocated for the current fiscal year, which began July 1. The administration has delayed the release of those dollars for more than two weeks. Lawmakers also approved $26 million in new state and federal funding for nursing homes as part of the bipartisan budget which the Legislature passed despite Governor LePage’s veto.” [Maine Senate Democrats, Press Release, 7/17/14]

Portland Press Herald Editorial Board: “Funding for Maine Nursing Homes Has Been Held Up for Weeks Because of Gov. LePage’s Refusal to Compromise.” According to an editorial in the Portland Press Herald, “Funding for Maine nursing homes has been held up for weeks because of Gov. LePage’s refusal to compromise.” [Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 7/18/14]

2016: Paul LePage refused to Sign a Bill That Funded a $4 Million Reimbursement Rate Increase for Home Care Workers

2016: LePage Refused to Sign a Bipartisan Bill That Funded at $4 Million Reimbursement Rate Increases for Home Care Workers and Community-Based Services. On 4/27/16, LD866 “includes a General Fund appropriation of $4,000,000 in fiscal year 2016-17 to the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) to fund 50% of rate increases for personal support and related services. Federal Expenditures Fund allocations will also be included for these changes that impact the FMAP match. The bill also includes a one-time offsetting reduction of $4,000,000 in fiscal year 2016-17 to the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. The bill requires the Department of Health and Human Services to conduct a rate study of services in Section 40 Home Health Services and report back to the legislature by January 1, 2017. Any additional costs to the DHHS to perform the study and prepare a report are expected to be minor and can be absorbed within existing budgeted resources.” [Maine State Legislature, LD886 Fiscal Note, 4/13/16; Maine State Legislature, LD886, 4/27/16]

  • The Bill Used Federal Funds to Provide $4 Million for Increased Reimbursements to Home Care Workers and Community-Based Services to Help Seniors and People With Disabilities Remain in Their Communities. “The Maine Senate on Wednesday gave unanimous approval to a bill that increases state reimbursement for home care workers and community-based service providers. The bill, LD 886, was removed from the Appropriations Table, passed and funded unanimously by the Senate. It would help Maine seniors and people with disabilities remain in their communities by improving recruitment and retention efforts and raising wages for workers who provide their care. […] As amended, the bill uses federal funds to provide $4 million for increased reimbursements to home care workers and community-based services. The new rate

includes increases for wages, benefits and travel.” [Maine Senate Demcorats, Press Release, 4/13/16]

2018: Paul LePage Tried to Block a Reimbursement Rate Increase for Direct Care Workers in Nursing Homes

HEADLINE: “LePage Plans to Veto Bills That Would Raise Reimbursement Rates for Direct Care Workers.” [Times Record, 7/2/18]

July 2018: Bipartisan Majorities of the Maine Legislature Overrode LePage’s Veto of a Bill That Increased Reimbursements to Nursing Home Workers. In 2018, LePage vetoed LD925. On July 9, 2018, the House overrode his veto by a 139-4 vote and the Senate by a 32-1 vote, and it became law. LD925 “would have allowed for increased reimbursements to pay those who care for the elderly in nursing homes, has a better chance of being sustained since lawmakers didn’t give it their unanimous support.” [Times Record, 7/2/18; Maine State Legislature, LD925, 7/9/18]

  • July 2018: Maine Lawmakers Overrode LePage’s Veto on a Supplemental Spending Bill That Earmarked Funding for Nursing Home Workers. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Lawmakers voted overwhelmingly Monday to increase reimbursement rates for group homes serving individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities over the protests of Gov. Paul LePage. Lawmakers approved the rate increase for ‘direct care’ workers while overriding LePage vetoes on two supplemental spending bills that also earmark additional funds for nursing home workers and for opiate addiction treatment programs.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/10/18]
  • The Bill Would Increase State Reimbursement Rate for 4,000 Direct Care Workers, Including Those Working in Nursing Homes. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Another $21 million spending package consists of three bills that would set state funding for county jails and increase state reimbursement rates for some 4,000 direct care workers, including those working in nursing homes and group homes for individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/19/18]
  • 2018: The New Law Increased Nursing Home Workers’ Pay by 10% While a Rate Study Was Conducted. According to Maine Public, “Maurer said a new state law may help ease the burden. It bumps direct workers’ pay up 10 percent while a rate study is conducted.” [Maine Public, 7/31/18]

2018: Paul LePage Tried to Block a $5.5 Million Infusion of Cash into Maine’s Nursing Homes

2018: Maine Lawmakers Approved Over LePage’s Veto a One-Time, $5.5 Million Infusion of Funds into Maine’s Nursing Homes. According to the Associated Press, “Lawmakers approved $5.5 million in additional, one-time general funds for nursing homes in 2018, over the veto of Republican Paul LePage, the governor at the time. LePage, who unsuccessfully tried to roll back minimum wage increases, called the legislation a ‘short-term fix.’” [Associated Press, 7/19/19]

2018: Paul LePage Tried to Block a Bill That Allowed Hospitals to be PAid While Patients Waited for Placement in Nursing Facilities

2018: LePage Vetoed, and Bipartisan Majorities of the Legislature Overrode His Veto of, a Bill That Allowed Hospitals to be Reimbursed for Each Day After 10 Days During Which a MaineCare-Eligible Patient Remained Hospitalized While Awaiting Placement in a Nursing Facility. In July 2018, LePage vetoed LD401, which the House then overrode by a 139-3 vote on 7/9/18 and the Senate on the same day by a 33-0 vote. LD401 “includes General Fund appropriations to the Department of Health and Human Services of $17,690 in fiscal year 2018-19 to provide reimbursement to hospitals other than critical access hospitals for each day after the 10th day that a MaineCare-eligible individual is in the care of a hospital while awaiting placement in a nursing facility, beginning January 1, 2019 and ending December 31, 2023. Federal Expenditures Fund allocations are also included for the FMAP match.” [Maine State Legislature, LD401 Fiscal Note, 6/29/18; Maine State Legislature, LD401, 7/9/18]

Maine Nursing Homes Under Paul LePage Were Penalized for Their High Hospital Readmission Rates Under Paul LePage

2018: Four Maine Nursing Homes Received the Lowest Possible Score for Their Staffing Levels, and Two of the Four Closed Later in 2018. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Earlier this year, four Maine nursing homes received the lowest possible score for staffing levels, according to an analysis of federal data by Kaiser Health News. Two of them, in Fryeburg and Bridgton, were among the half dozen that later closed in 2018.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

  • Headline: “Maine Nursing Homes Receive Lowest Score in New National Ranking.” [Maine Public, 7/31/18]
  • August 2018: “Four Nursing Homes Received the Lowest Possible Score for Staffing Levels.” According to Maine Public, “Four nursing homes in Maine have received the lowest possible score for staffing levels, according to an analysis of federal data by Kaiser Health News.” [Maine Public, 7/31/18]

2018: Nearly 70% of Maine’s 100 Nursing Homes That Provide Skilled Nursing Care Were Penalized for Their Rate of Patients Winding Up in the Hospital Repeatedly. According to the Bangor Daily News, “In December, the federal government announced it would cut payments to nursing homes whose patients wind up in the hospital repeatedly. In Maine, nearly 70 percent of the 100 nursing homes that provide skilled nursing care were penalized. About 30 percent earned bonuses. That showing was roughly in line with national averages.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/12/18]

2018: More Nursing Homes in Maine Were Penalized for the Quality of Their Care Than in Vermont and New York. According to the Kaiser Health Network, “The federal government has taken a new step to reduce avoidable hospital readmissions of nursing home patients by lowering a year’s worth of payments to nearly 11,000 nursing homes. It gave bonuses to nearly 4,000 others. These financial incentives, determined by each home’s readmission rates, significantly expand Medicare’s effort to pay medical providers based on the quality of care instead of just the number or condition of their patients.”

STATE

BONUS

NO CHANGE

PENALTY

GRAND TOTAL

% PENALIZED

Maine

31

2

67

100

67%

New Hampshire

19

--

53

72

74%

Vermont

16

2

17

35

49%

Massachusetts 75

6

315

396

80%

Connecticut

56

--

168

224

75%

Rhode Island

21

2

60

83

72%

New York

202

10

409

621

66%

[Kaiser Health Network, 11/30/18]

The Average Number of Deficiencies Annually in Maine’s Nursing Homes Decreased Under LePage, and Have Increased in Both of Mills’ First Two Years in Office:

YEAR

AVERAGE NUMBER OF DEFICIENCIES

2020

6.7

2019

5.8

2018

--*

2017

4.0

2016

4.3

2015

4.8

2014

4.8

2013

4.7

2012

5.3

2011

5.6

2010

7.4

[Kaiser Family Foundation, Accessed 12/7/21]

In 2014, Bipartisan Majorities of the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto Of A Bipartisan Supplemental Budget That Increased Nursing Home Reimbursements By $13 Million In Fiscal Years 2016 And 2017. In May 2014, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD1858 by a 134-12 vote and the Senate by a 35-0 vote. “The politics of nursing home funding ramped up in the final days of the last legislative session. In mid-April, LePage vetoed a bipartisan supplemental budget, L.D. 1858, that would increase nursing home reimbursements by $13 million in fiscal 2016 and 2017. It also would provide $1.1 million when the funding mechanism started in June 2015, the last month of fiscal 2015. The Legislature easily overrode LePage's budget veto and passed another bill, L.D. 1776, that included an initial $11.6 million to increase reimbursements in fiscal 2015, which started July 1.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14; State of Maine Legislature, LD 1858, Roll Call #749, 5/1/14; State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 1858, 5/1/14]

  • Sun Journal Editorial Board: “If The Legislature Overrides Both LD 1719 And LD 1858, The Nursing Homes Get The Funding They Need.” “If the Legislature overrides both LD 1719 and LD 1858, the nursing homes get the funding they need and public health agencies can help teach thousands of Maine's "vulnerable citizens" how to prevent disease while they're young so they can be healthier as they age. You know, before they get to the nursing home.” [Editorial, Sun Journal, 4/29/14]
  • Sun Journal: “Lawmakers Considered The Budget Bill A Victory Because It Was The First Supplemental Budget In Recent Memory For Which There Was No Upfront Participation From The Governor’s Office.” “LD 1858, which patched an approximately $30 million hole in the current biennial budget, passed through the Legislature with votes of 136-8 in the House and 35-0 in the Senate. Lawmakers considered the budget bill a victory because it was the first supplemental budget in recent memory for which there was no upfront participation from the governor's office. LePage has been saying since last fall that he would not submit a supplemental budget because his original biennial budget proposal was amended by the Legislature to include tax increases and, in his view, was not balanced because it called for a study group to identify and close tax loopholes as a money-saving initiative.” [Sun Journal, 4/26/14]

In 2014, LePage Refused to Sign a Bipartisan Bill That Increased Nursing Home Reimbursements By $11.6 Million For Fiscal Year 2015 And Increased Payments To Nursing Homes With 70 Percent MaineCare Residents. “The Legislature easily overrode LePage's budget veto and passed another bill, L.D. 1776, that included an initial $11.6 million to increase reimbursements in fiscal 2015, which started July 1. The bill also would provide slightly higher payments to nursing homes with more than 70 percent MaineCare residents and would require the state to adjust reimbursement rates every two years to more closely reflect actual costs. LePage let L.D. 1776 become law without his signature, but he didn't let the Legislature's efforts go unchallenged.” The House voted to enact the bill by a 143-0 vote, the Senate by a 31-0 vote, and the bill became law without Governor LePage’s signature. [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14; State of Maine Legislature, LD 1776, Roll Call #712, 4/16/14; State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 1776, 5/1/14]

The Bill Required Maine To Adjust Nursing Home Reimbursement Rates Every Two Years To Keep Pace With Actual Costs. “The Legislature easily overrode LePage's budget veto and passed another bill, L.D. 1776, that included an initial $11.6 million to increase reimbursements in fiscal 2015, which started July 1. The bill also would provide slightly higher payments to nursing homes with more than 70 percent MaineCare residents and would require the state to adjust reimbursement rates every two years to more closely reflect actual costs. LePage let L.D. 1776 become law without his signature, but he didn't let the Legislature's efforts go unchallenged.” [Portland Press Herald, 7/27/14]

Source report (PDF)