Paul LePage: PROPERTY TAXES

Waterville Property Taxes Under Mayor Paul LePage

Column: Waterville Taxes Under LePage Only Went Down Because State Bailed it Out. “The facts are, first, that Waterville’s tax rate actually declined less than in other Maine cities during his seven years as mayor, and, second, that Waterville’s tax rate declined only because taxpayers across the state bailed out LePage. Over the past six years, the property tax mill rate in Waterville declined by 13.46 percent. Other municipalities of similar size fared considerably better. Brewer’s mill rate dropped by about 18 percent, Windham’s by 17.49 percent, Biddeford’s by 15.3 percent and Bangor’s by 13.61 percent.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/30/10]

Waterville Mayor Paul Lepage, In 2004, Opposed A Referendum To Cap Property Taxes In Maine. Property Taxes In Maine Hit Low- And Moderate-Income Maine “Residents

Hardest,” According To Maine Revenue Services Data. “Of the different types of taxes, the property tax… [hits] lower-income [Maine] residents hardest,” according to Maine Revenue Services data. “The average property tax bill in 2009 for homeowners earning $12,167 or less – the bottom 20 percent – was $2,006, or 30.6 percent of income. The top 10 percent of homeowners – those earning $108,724 or more – paid a larger average property tax bill, $5,258, but it accounted for just 2.5 percent of income.” (Bangor Daily News, 02/22/13) “The [2004] Palesky tax cap proposal would cap property taxes at $10 per $1,000 of assessed property valuation, based on 1996-97 values. It also would limit assessment increases to 2 percent a year while the property’s ownership remains in a family.” (Bangor Daily News, 09/11/04)

  • LePage: The Property Cap Legislation Was “A Less-Than-Stellar Piece of Legislation That Would Cripple Many Communities, Including Waterville.” Waterville Mayor Paul LePage wrote in 2004, “the Palesky tax cap referendum…[was] a less-than- stellar piece of legislation that would cripple many communities, including Waterville.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 10/29/04)
  • Tax Cap Measure Failed on the Nov. 2004 Ballot. “The Palesky tax cap measure failed on the November [2004] ballot.” (Bangor Daily News, 12/21/04)

Paul Lepage, In 2012, Proposed A Change In State Law That The Mayor Of Portland Said “‘Will Increase Local Property Taxes And Make Hundreds Of People Homeless In Portland.’” Paul LePage, in 2012, proposed limiting “housing assistance to 90 days per calendar year,” giving “all cities and towns a 50 percent reimbursement rate” instead of giving “bigger communities…90 percent reimbursement after they spend a set amount of money,” and eliminating “General Assistance for anyone who receives federal Temporary Assistance to Needy Families funds.” His “proposal to change the way General Assistance money is distributed in Maine would shift costs to property taxpayers and increase homelessness, say officials in Portland and other cities. The governor’s plan…[called] for the most far- reaching change to Maine’s General Assistance funding in 20 years, said Portland Mayor Michael Brennan. ‘It will increase local property taxes and make hundreds of people homeless in Portland,’ he said.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 03/17/12)

Waterville Mayor Paul Lepage, In 2004, Supported Charging “Service Fees To Organizations Or Institutions Owning Tax-Exempt Residential Property That Generates Rental Income.” Waterville city councilors, in 2004, considered “an ordinance designed to allow the city to charge service fees to organizations or institutions owning tax-exempt residential property that generates rental income,” though it “would not apply to student housing or parsonages. It would be calculated according to the actual cost of providing municipal services to the properties and people using them. The services include fire and police protection, road maintenance and construction, traffic control, snow and ice removal, sanitation services and any services other than education and welfare,” with “the total service charge against any entity” not exceeding “two percent of its gross annual revenues.” “Mayor Paul R. LePage said…that the service-fee issue would apply only to places such as Seton Village, an elderly housing complex, and the Waterville Housing Authority. ‘We plow and pick up garbage there, but we get nothing in return,’ LePage said.” While “the service-fee issue would not apply to colleges,” it “would affect places such as halfway houses where people stay for extended periods of time, according to LePage.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 03/02/04)

  • LePage Said Waterville Was Trying to Reverse the Growth of Tax Exempt Properties. “Waterville is trying to reverse the growth of tax- exempt properties, LePage said, as the council took a small first step…[in June 2004] to impose a service fee on low-income rental housing.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 06/02/04)

Paul LePage Changes to Property Taxes

Bangor Daily News Editorial: In 2013, LePage Eliminated the Circuit Breaker Refund, Which Provided Partial Property Tax Refunds to Low-Income Families, Replaced it With Less Generous Property Tax Fairness Credit. According to an editorial in the Bangor Daily News, “On the other side of the ledger, the governor could restore property tax relief programs that he pushed to cut. LePage successfully pushed for the elimination of the Circuit Breaker, which provided partial property tax refunds to low income families, in 2013. Lawmakers replaced it with a less generous Property Tax Fairness Credit. Legislators also rejected LePage proposals to eliminate the Homestead Exemption and to limit it to only seniors.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 2/17/18]

  • The Circuit Breaker Property Tax Relief Program Maxed Out at $1,600; its Replacement, the Property Tax Fairness Credit, Maxed Out at $600 for Younger Filers and $900 for Seniors. According to the Bangor Daily News, “The circuit breaker program became a casualty of budget negotiations last year. In his budget proposal, Gov. Paul LePage proposed gutting the program almost entirely. Ultimately, Democrats retained a broad property tax relief program, but at a much smaller level than before, with something they called the Property Tax Fairness Credit. Where circuit breaker maxed out at $1,600, the maximum Property Tax Fairness Credit came in at $400 for those older than 70 and $300 for those younger. It was available to anyone earning less than $40,000 annually who paid more than 10 percent of their income in property taxes or more than 40 percent of their income in rent. The credit also was applied through the state income tax filing -- so it meant no more separate process for property tax relief. The passage of LD 1751 doubled the maximum credit to $600 for anyone younger than 65 and $900 for senior tax filers. It also changed eligibility rules to account for more kinds of income, which means some will no longer receive the credit. About 112,000 Maine tax filers will likely be eligible next year, according to Maine Revenue Service.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/1/14]
  • The Elimination of the Circuit Breaker Program Was Expected to Save the State $20-$25 Million, Equating to a $20-$25 Million Tax Hike on Property Tax-Paying Mainers. According to the Morning Sentinel, “The new program adopted by the Legislature is expected to save the state between $20 million and $25 million, but lawmakers are getting pushback from residents who came to rely on a circuit breaker benefit that provided a tax refund ranging from $479 to $1,600.” [Morning Sentinel, 8/9/13]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: LePage Pushed to Eliminate the Homestead Exemption and Limit it to Only Seniors. According to an editorial in the Bangor Daily News, “On the other side of the ledger, the governor could restore property tax relief programs that he pushed to cut. LePage successfully pushed for the elimination of the Circuit Breaker, which provided partial property tax refunds to low income families, in 2013. Lawmakers replaced it with a less generous Property Tax Fairness Credit. Legislators also rejected LePage proposals to eliminate the Homestead Exemption and to limit it to only seniors.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 2/17/18]

Impact of Property Tax Changes Under Paul LePage

Headline: “Property Taxes Hurt Low-Income Mainers More Than Ever, But a Fix Won’t be Easy.” [Bangor Daily News, 1/21/19]

In Fiscal Year 2016, Maine Was The Ninth Top State In Terms Of Its Reliance On Property Taxes. [Tax Foundation, 5/1/19]

In Fiscal Year 2016, Maine Collected The Tenth-Highest Amount Of State And Local Property Taxes Per Capita Out Of All 50 States, At $2,105 Per Capita. [Tax Foundation, 3/13/19]

In 2019, the Year After LePage Left Office, 40% Of Taxes Collected From Maine Residents Were Property Taxes, With 20% From Sales Taxes, 22% From Income Taxes, 2% From Corporate Taxes, And 15% From Other Taxes. [Tax Foundation, 2019]

In 2015, Municipalities Collected $1 Billion More From Property Taxes Than The State Of Maine Did From The Sales Tax And $600 Million More Than The State Of Maine Did From Income Taxes. “Cities and towns amassed nearly $2.4 billion in property taxes in 2015, the Maine Municipal Association estimates. It's far larger than the individual and corporate income tax or the sales tax, of which Maine collected $1.8 billion and $1.4 billion, respectively, in the 2018 fiscal year.” [Bangor Daily News, 1/21/19]

Maine Center for Economic Policy: “On Average, Mainers Paid $30 Million More Per Year in Property Taxes Between 2011 and 2016 Than in the Previous Six-Year Period.” According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “On average, Mainers paid $30 million more per year in property taxes between 2011 and 2016 than in the previous six-year period.)” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, August 2018]

Maine Center for Economic Policy: “Property Tax Rates Have Increased Across The State, Thanks In No Small Part To Previous Income Tax Cuts That Made It Harder For The State To Meet Its Fiscal Obligations To Communities, Most Visibly in Funding For Local Services And K-12 Education.” “Property tax rates have increased across the state, thanks in no small part to previous income tax cuts that made it harder for the state to meet its fiscal obligations to communities, most visibly in funding for local services and K-12 education. For example, payments to municipalities for local services such as public safety and road maintenance have been reduced by $602 million between 2011 and 2019, and Maine has underfunded its share of school funding by $1.3 billion in the same period. As municipalities struggle to make up the difference from state funding cuts, property taxpayers have felt the crunch.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, August 2018]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “The Governor Could Also Focus on Keeping Property Taxes Low for All Who Pay Property Taxes. But He’s Stood in the Way of Those Efforts as Well.” According to an editorial in the Bangor Daily News, “The governor could also focus on keeping property taxes low for all who pay property taxes. But he's stood in the way of those efforts as well. He has attempted to eliminate municipal revenue sharing, a program mandated by state law that sends towns and cities a small share of the state's sales and income tax revenue. If successful, that move would have eliminated a revenue source on which towns and cities rely. Without it, towns and cities would have to make up for it with higher property taxes, cuts to services or both. The governor has also attempted to eliminate the circuit breaker property tax reduction program for low-income homeowners under age 65 as well as the homestead exemption for homeowners younger than 65.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 3/28/18]

Bangor Daily News Editorial Headline: “LePage Policies, Not Land Trusts, Have Driven Up Property Taxes.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 2/17/18]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: “If LePage is Serious About Lowering Property Taxes...He Could Restore Cuts to Municipal Revenue Sharing. LePage Pushed for Years to Eliminate Revenue Sharing.” According to an editorial in the Bangor Daily News, “So, if LePage is serious about lowering property taxes, he should stop blaming land trusts and look at what actions his administration could take. First, he could restore cuts to municipal revenue sharing. LePage pushed for years to eliminate revenue sharing, which has instead been pared back by the Legislature. According to an analysis by the Maine Center for Economic Policy, payments to municipalities have been reduced by $602 million between 2011 and 2019 because of these cuts.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 2/17/18]

Since 2011, Maine’s Property Tax Rates Went Up 33% on Average, “Largely as a Result of Having to Raise More Funds Locally for Municipal Services sand to Fund Education.” According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “Since 2011, Maine’s property tax rates, on average, have gone up by 33 percent, largely as a result of having to raise more funds locally for municipal services and to fund education.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

From 2011 to 2017, Maine Towns Had To Raise Over $1 Billion in Property Taxes to Pay for Education in Order to “Compensate for the State Underfunding its Share of Education Costs.” According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “For example, since 2011, the wealthiest 20 percent of Mainers have benefited from $163 million in income tax cuts each year. Over the same period, communities have had to raise over a billion dollars in property taxes – an average of an additional $180 million each year – toward education to compensate for the state underfunding its share of education costs.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

In 2018 When LePage Left Office, the Wealthiest Top 1% of Mainers Paid the Smallest Share of Their Income on Property Taxes and the Poorest 20% Paid the Highest Share of Their Income on Property Taxes:

Image: see original report, p. 374

[Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, 10/17/18]

Source report (PDF)