Paul LePage: TANF

When LePage Took Office in 2011, 25,000 Children in the TANF Program – by the Time He Left, That Number Was 7,600, Attributable to a Better Economy But Also the Tighter Eligibility Restrictions LePage Implemented. According to the Bangor Daily News, “When LePage took office in 2011, there were 350,000 Mainers who received Medicaid, 25,000 children in the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program and 246,000 Mainers who received food stamps. By this fall, those figures were at 261,000, 7,600 and 176,000, respectively, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation and state data. That's attributable to a better national and state economy and the eligibility standards that the LePage administration tightened, largely during the governor's first term that made Maine a model for conservatives nationwide.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/31/18]

From 2011 to 2017, the Number of Maine Households Receiving TANF Assistance Declined by More Than 60% After LePage Tightened Eligibility Requirements. According to the Maine Sunday Telegram, “Participation in the food stamp program, for instance, fell 20 percent after eligibility requirements were tightened. The number of households receiving Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, or TANF, declined by more than 60 percent from 2012 to 2017 after the LePage administration tightened eligibility requirements and instituted a five-year lifetime cap on benefits.” [Maine Sunday Telegram, 12/30/18]

LePage Proposed Bill to Grant Additional Subpoena Powers to the DHHS Commissioner, Which “May Be Aimed at Welfare Fraud.” The Portland Press Herald reported, “The administration has submitted a bill that could ban convicted drug felons from receiving public assistance. Another proposal could allow the Department of Health and Human Services to prohibit the use of food stamps to buy soda. A third proposal, which may be aimed at welfare fraud, could grant additional subpoena powers to the commissioner of the DHHS.” [Portland Press Herald, 1/3/13]

LePage Proposed Bill to Ban Convicted Drug Felons From Receiving Public Assistance. The Portland Press Herald reported, “The administration has submitted a bill that could ban convicted drug felons from receiving public assistance. Another proposal could allow the Department of Health and Human Services to prohibit the use of food stamps to buy soda. A third proposal, which may be aimed at welfare fraud, could grant additional subpoena powers to the commissioner of the DHHS.” [Portland Press Herald, 1/3/13]

LePage Proposed Making Drug Felons Ineligible for Benefits Via the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families Program. The Bangor Daily News reported, “The Health and Human Services Committee on Friday also heard testimony on another LePage bill, LD 1443, that would make drug felons ineligible for benefits through the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, or TANF, program. That measure is only sponsored by Republican legislators.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/3/13]

In 2017, Bipartisan Majorities of the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of a Bill That Gave a One-Time Employment Incentive of $400 to Individuals Enrolled in TANF

That Entered Employment and Retained Employment for Four Months. In July 2017, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD481 by a 116-24 vote and the Senate by a 30-0 vote. LD481 “provides for a one-time employment incentive payment of $400 to a Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program recipient who enters employment and retains employment for the subsequent four months. This provision is repealed December 31, 2018.” [Summaries of Bills, LD481, 2017; Maine State Legislature, LD481, 2017]

In 2017, LePage Refused to Sign a Bipartisan Bill That Expanded Eligibility and Benefits for TANF Recipients. In June 2017, LePage allowed LD336 to become law without his signature after it passed the House by a 146-0 vote and the Senate without a roll call vote. LD336 “changes the laws governing Temporary Assistance for Needy Families. 1. It establishes the same eligibility requirements for TANF and alternative aid benefits to two-parent families that apply to single-parent families. 2. It increases the special housing allowance for families receiving TANF benefits from $200 to $300. 3. It removes certain good cause provisions from the laws governing the ASPIRE-TANF program and instead transfers to the Department of Health and Human Services the responsibility to determine other good cause.” [Summaries of Bills, LD336, 2017; Maine State Legislature, LD336, 2017]

  • The Bill Applied the Same Eligibility Requirements for TANF Benefits to Two-Parent Families That Applied to Single-Parent Families. In June 2017, LePage allowed LD336 to become law without his signature after it passed the House by a 146-0 vote and the Senate without a roll call vote. LD336 “changes the laws governing Temporary Assistance for Needy Families. 1. It establishes the same eligibility requirements for TANF and alternative aid benefits to two-parent families that apply to single-parent families. 2. It increases the special housing allowance for families receiving TANF benefits from $200 to $300. 3. It removes certain good cause provisions from the laws governing the ASPIRE-TANF program and instead transfers to the Department of Health and Human Services the responsibility to determine other good cause.” [Summaries of Bills, LD336, 2017; Maine State Legislature, LD336, 2017]
  • The Bill Increased the Special Housing Allowance for Families Receiving TANF Benefits from $200 to $300. In June 2017, LePage allowed LD336 to become law without his signature after it passed the House by a 146-0 vote and the Senate without a roll call vote. LD336 “changes the laws governing Temporary Assistance for Needy Families. 1. It establishes the same eligibility requirements for TANF and alternative aid benefits to two-parent families that apply to single-parent families. 2. It increases the special housing allowance for families receiving TANF benefits from $200 to $300. 3. It removes certain good cause provisions from the laws governing the ASPIRE-TANF program and instead transfers to the Department of Health and Human Services the responsibility to determine other good cause.” [Summaries of Bills, LD336, 2017; Maine State Legislature, LD336, 2017]

Eligibility Requirements

In 2012, LePage Implemented a 60-Month Limit for Families to Receive TANF Cash Benefits, After Maine Had Opted Out of That Provision Since 1996. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Under the LePage administration, more than 8,700 Maine families, including nearly 15,350 children, have lost cash assistance since a policy change went into effect. In 2012, LePage successfully pushed to implement a 60-month lifetime limit for families to receive cash assistance under the federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. Maine had previously opted out of that provision since the program’s inception in 1996.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/29/18]

LePage Argued That His Five-Year Time Limit for TANF Benefits Helped Families Get Off Welfare; the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities Found That “Most Families That Reached the Time Limit Have Not Been Able to Replace the Cash Assistance They Lost With Income from Work.” According to the Maine Sunday Telegram, “The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a Washington, D.C.-based liberal think tank, also accused the LePage administration of issuing a ‘methodologically flawed report (that) cherry picks data and omits key findings’ to suggest the five-year TANF limit helped families get off welfare. ‘It hides facts that show that most families that reached the time limit have not been able to replace the cash assistance they lost with income from work, putting the children in these families at great risk of experiencing high levels of deprivation and stress, which have lifelong negative consequences,’ the center wrote in August 2017.” [Maine Sunday Telegram, 12/30/18]

Impact of Paul LePage’s TANF Restrictions

Headline: “LePage Slashed the Number of Mainers Who Rely on State Assistance. Here are the Results.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/29/18]

2012-2017: Households On TANF Fell By More Than 60 Percent As LePage Tightened Requirements. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Participation in the food stamp program, for instance, fell 20 percent after eligibility requirements were tightened. The number of households receiving Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, or TANF, declined by more than 60 percent between 2012 and 2017 after the LePage administration tightened eligibility requirements and instituted a five-year lifetime cap on benefits.” [Portland Press Herald, 12/30/18]

Bangor Daily News: “Under the LePage Administration, More Than 8,700 Maine Families, Including Nearly 15,350 Children, Have Lost Cash Assistance.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Under the LePage administration, more than 8,700 Maine families, including nearly 15,350 children, have lost cash assistance since a policy change went into effect. In 2012, LePage successfully pushed to implement a 60-month lifetime limit for families to receive cash assistance under the federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. Maine had previously opted out of that provision since the program’s inception in 1996.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/29/18]

From May 2012 to November 2018, TANF Caseloads Dropped from Just Over 12,700 to 4,000. According to the Bangor Daily News, “TANF caseloads have dropped from just over 12,700 in May 2012 to about 4,000 in November 2018. At the same time, the number of children covered by TANF has fallen from 22,425 to 7,081 during that same period.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/29/18]

From May 2012 to November 2018, the Number of Children Covered by TANF Dropped from 22,425 to 7,081. According to the Bangor Daily News, “TANF caseloads have dropped from just over 12,700 in May 2012 to about 4,000 in November 2018. At the same time, the number of children covered by TANF has fallen from 22,425 to 7,081 during that same period.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/29/18]

Bangor Daily News Editorial: Since 2011, the Number of Low-Income Families With Children That Received Monthly Cash Assistance Fell by More Than Two-Thirds. According to an editorial in the Bangor Daily News, “Gov. Paul LePage's administration has made a point of scaling back welfare in Maine. Since his administration's 2011 start, the number of low-income families with children receiving small amounts of cash assistance each month has fallen by more than two-thirds.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 1/5/18]

From December 2011 to December 2012, the Number of Children Under 18 with TANF Dropped “Dramatic[ally]” from 23,922 to 15,293, Attributed to LePage’s New 60-Month Lifetime Limit for the Program. According to the Maine Children’s Alliance, “In Maine, there was a dramatic one-year decrease from 23,922 children under 18 with TANF in December 2011 to 15,293 in December 2012 that resulted from a new 60-month lifetime limit and stricter policies related to meetings with TANF caseworkers.” [Maine Children’s Alliance, 2020]

LePage Cut TANF Spending Even as Poverty Remained High in Maine:

Image: see original report, p. 315

[Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

In 2017, Maine Was “Sitting on” $200 Million in Unspent TANF Funding. According to the Maine Center for Economic Policy, “[Maine] is sitting on $200 million in Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) funds intended to help Maine’s poorest families and even tried to divert these funds to other uses.” [Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17]

Bangor Daily News: LePage’s Proposed Cuts To Government Workforce Met Resistance From GOP That Feared Cuts Would Hamstring Welfare Reform Efforts. Bangor Daily News’ Michael Shepherd wrote in July of 2016, “Some employees classified as "limited period" have been working for the state since the 1960s, and many of those positions intersect with some of the governor's top goals in government, including welfare fraud investigators. LePage can expect opposition from his usual critics -- Democrats and public sector unions -- but he might also have to fend off criticism from Republican legislative candidates and others concerned that his philosophical commitment to small government will hamstring efforts to reform Maine's welfare system, help unemployed workers find jobs or provide services their constituents have come to expect.” [Bangor Daily News, 7/31/16]

Misspending of Federal Welfare Funds

Thanks to LePage’s Restrictions on TANF Eligibility, Maine Experienced a Surplus of Federal Funding, Which Was Used to Illegally Spend $13 Million in TANF Funds on Services for Elderly and Disabled Mainers Without Children. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Even as the number of families receiving TANF has fallen, Maine continues to receive the same amount of funds — $78.1 million per year — from the federal government for the program. The resulting surplus of those funds has been used to cover a range of existing state spending obligations, such as sheltering homeless youth and transportation for families involved in the child protection system, freeing up state money. In one notable episode, DHHS officials spent more than $13 million of TANF funds on services for elderly and disabled Mainers without children, a violation of federal law. The department returned those funds to the TANF account after the BDN reported on the unlawful spending.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/29/18]

Bangor Daily News Headline: “Auditor Finds DHHS Misspent $13M In Welfare Funds.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16]

Bangor Daily News: “The State Office Responsible For Ensuring Government Funds Are Used According To Law Has Determined That The Maine Department Of Health And Human Services Misspent $13.4 Million In Federal Welfare Money.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “The state office responsible for ensuring government funds are used according to law has determined that the Maine Department of Health and Human Services misspent $13.4 million in federal welfare money.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16]

Bangor Daily News: “The State Auditor’s Finding, Released Tuesday, Follows The Bangor Daily News’ Reporting In June That Found DHHS Spent Funds Earmarked For Low-Income Families With Children On Seniors And Disabled Mainers.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “The state auditor’s finding, released Tuesday, follows the Bangor Daily News’ reporting in June that found DHHS spent funds earmarked for low-income families with children on seniors and disabled Mainers.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16]

Bangor Daily News: “The Department ‘Took An Overly Aggressive Approach’ That Signals ‘Troublesome’ Practices When It Comes To Managing Federal Grant Awards.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “The department ‘took an overly aggressive approach’ that signals ‘troublesome’ practices when it comes to managing federal grant awards, wrote Maine State Auditor Pola Buckley in a rare report highlighting ‘improper management’ of funds at the agency level that should rise to the attention of the Governor, the Attorney General and the Legislature.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16]

  • Bangor Daily News: “Federal Law Allows The State To Transfer Up To 10 Percent Of The $78.1 Million Each Year To A Smaller But More Flexible Federal Grant, The Social Services Block Grant, Which States Can Use To Pay For A Wide Range Of Social Services.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Federal law allows the state to transfer up to 10 percent of the $78.1 million each year to a smaller but more flexible federal grant, the Social Services Block Grant, which states can use to pay for a wide range of social services.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16]
  • Bangor Daily News: “But They Are Required To Spend The Money On Low-Income Families With Children, Not The Elderly, As The LePage Administration Did.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “But they are required to spend the money on low-income families with children, not the elderly, as the LePage administration did.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16]
  • Bangor Daily News: “Federal Law Specifies That The Transferred Funds ‘Shall Be Used Only For Programs And Services To Children Or Their Families Whose Income Is Less Than 200 Percent Of The Income Official Poverty Line.” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Federal law specifies that the transferred funds ‘shall be used only for programs and services to children or their families whose income is less than 200 percent of the income official poverty line,’ which works out to about $40,000 for a family of three.” [Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16]

LePage’s Administration Used Surplus TANF Money Freed Up By His Limitations on Eligibility Requirements to Spend $1.7 Million in TANF Money on After-School Programs, Justifying it By Using a TANF Provision Allowing States to Use Their Funds to “Curb ‘Out-of-Wedlock Pregnancies.’” According to the Bangor Daily News, “Even as the number of families receiving TANF has fallen, Maine continues to receive the same amount of funds — $78.1 million per year — from the federal government for the program. The resulting surplus of those funds has been used to cover a range of existing state spending obligations, such as sheltering homeless youth and transportation for families involved in the child protection system, freeing up state money. […] Later on, the department directed more than $1.7 million in TANF funds to after-school programs, justifying it by using a provision in TANF law that allows states to spend their federal money to curb ‘out-of-wedlock pregnancies.’” [Bangor Daily News, 12/29/18]

Source report (PDF)