Paul LePage: TEMPERAMENT AS GOVERNOR
Bipartisanship
Bangor Daily News: Bipartisan Deals On Big Issues “Were Few And Far Between During The Hard-Charging Administration Of LePage.” “Mills broke with LePage to look for consensus on key issues. Progressives are wondering if that's the right tactic. Bipartisan deals on big issues were few and far between during the hard-charging administration of LePage, Maine's all-time veto leader and presider over a 2017 state shutdown.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/6/19]
Kennebec Journal Editorial: LePage “Won’t be Able to Talk About the Times He Got Everyone to Work Together for the Common Good, Because There Aren’t Any.” According to an editorial in the Kennebec Journal, “The chief executive will likely toot his own horn during the speech, taking credit for Maine's low unemployment rate and other benefits of the long national recovery that happened to coincide with his term in office. But he won't be able to talk about the times he got everyone to work together for the common good, because there aren't any.” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 2/11/18]
Bangor Daily News: “Lawmakers, Party Affiliation Aside, Are Breathing A Sigh Of Relief To Have Gov. Paul LePage ‘In The Rearview Mirror.’” “House Speaker Sara Gideon, who on Wednesday earned a second term as leader of the Legislature's lower chamber, said that she and other lawmakers, party affiliation aside, are breathing a sigh of relief to have Gov. Paul LePage ‘in the rearview mirror.’" [Bangor Daily News, 12/10/18]
Maine Senate President Troy Jackson: Many Democrats And Republicans Looked “Forward To A Better Working Relationship” After LePage Left Office. “Sen. Troy Jackson, D-Allagash, last session's Senate minority leader, was chosen to replace Sen. Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, as Senate president. Jackson and Gideon said recently that the 129th Legislature brings potential for bipartisan deal-making that hasn't come in almost a decade. […] ‘Despite anything that Gov. LePage might've done over his eight years, there's a lot of Democrats and Republicans that look forward to a better working relationship,’ Jackson said, by ‘not having this constant adversarial mindset.’" [St. John Valley Times, 12/10/18]
Portland Press Herald: LePage “Denied Citizens In District 32 Representation In The State Senate” By Refusing To Seat Elected Democrat As Retaliation For Unemployment Board Pick Rejection. “Gov. Paul LePage says he will swear in a newly elected state senator Tuesday afternoon, ending a spat with Democratic legislators […] LePage's move made Deschambault the pawn in yet another tussle between the Republican governor and legislative Democrats, several of whom voted Thursday to reject his nominee to the Unemployment Insurance Commission. LePage officials acknowledged Friday that the governor's decision to cancel Deschambault's swearing-in ceremony was in retaliation for Democrats' "despicable" spurning of Steven Webster, his pick for the unemployment board. The tit-for-tat prompted Democrats to charge that LePage effectively denied citizens in District 32 representation in the state Senate. The District 32 seat has been vacant since former Sen. David Dutremble, D-Biddeford, resigned in January.” [Press Herald, 4/5/16]
“Vengeful” and Insulting
Paul Lepage, According To The American Conservative, Is Hostile And “Quick To Anger.” He “Wears His Vengeful Reputation Proudly.” Paul LePage is “quick to anger.” He “wears his vengeful reputation proudly.” “But underneath all of the hostility to his colleagues, expert opinion, and the press, LePage has some serious accomplishments to his name. In his first year as governor LePage passed a two-year budget – with supermajorities in both chambers – that included the state’s largest ever tax cut and a lowering of the top income tax rate from 8.5 to 7.95 percent.” (The American Conservative, 09/01/12)
According To A Portland Press Herald Editorial, Paul Lepage “Steps On Toes, Insults Opponents, [And] Impanels Secret Discussion Groups.” According to a Portland Press Herald editorial, Paul LePage “steps on toes, insults opponents, impanels secret discussion groups and brashly pursues policy initiatives that, in some cases, are very likely opposed by a majority of Mainers.” (Portland Press Herald, 03/13/11)
According To A News Story With The Headline, “Lepage Swears, Storms Out Of Meeting With Independent House Members, Lawmakers Say,” The Governor “Swore, Pounded A Table And Stormed Out Of A Meeting With [The Only] Three Independent House Members.” They Said “The Governor Called Them ‘Idiots.’” According to a news story with the headline, “LePage swears, storms out of meeting with independent House members, lawmakers say,” the governor “swore, pounded a table and stormed out of a meeting with [the only] three independent House members…according to the lawmakers. The trio said they hoped to talk to the governor about alternate approaches to balancing the state budget. Instead, the lawmakers said the governor called them ‘idiots.’” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/22/13)
- One Of These Three House Members Said, “‘I Was Somewhat In Shock. I Have Worked With Every Governor… Since Gov. [John] Reed’” In The 1980s. “‘There’s No Comparison To Gov. Lepage,’” He Said. “The trio are the only members of the 151-member Maine House who aren’t caucusing with either the Republican or Democratic parties.” State Representative Ben “Chipman said the unenrolled members went into their meeting with LePage intent on discussing the governor’s post- Christmas $35.5 million spending curtailment order and his…two-year budget proposal.” When Representative Jeff “Evangelos brought up concerns from municipal leaders in his midcoast district that the elimination of revenue sharing – designed to save the state nearly $200 million during the two-year budget cycle – could cause property taxes to spike hundreds of dollars for an average property owner, LePage grew irritated, [Representative Joe] Brooks, Chipman and Evangelos said…in separate telephone interviews. He raised his hands over his head, then pounded the table, Brooks said. ‘‘You guys, you’re idiots and you’re just as bad if not worse than those other guys,’’ LePage said, according to Brooks. ‘I assumed that he was talking about the Democrats.’ ‘He went right through the roof when I asked him the question,’ Evangelos said. ‘He flew up like a jack-in-the-box and ran out of the room and slammed the door.’” “Brooks, Chipman and Evangelos thought the meeting was over just a minute after it began, but LePage returned minutes later. ‘When he came back in the room, he was hollering at us and swearing at us,’ Evangelos said.” “‘I was somewhat in shock. I have worked with every governor, for heaven’s sake, since Gov. [John] Reed,’ said Brooks, who is serving his fourth term in the Legislature and worked for the Bangor Daily News before he was elected to the Legislature. ‘There’s no comparison to Gov. LePage.’” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 01/22/13)
PPH Editorial: Paul Lepage “Recklessly Established A Culture Of So- Called ‘Straight Talk’ That More Often Than Not Manifests Itself In Outrageous Pronouncements And Hurtful Wisecracks That Leave Many Mainers At Least Shaking Their Heads.” According to an editorial with the headline, “Gov. LePage acts like he’s in over his head; Personnel meltdowns…show a management style unsuited to public office,” Paul LePage “recklessly established a culture of so-called ‘straight talk’ that more often than not manifests itself in outrageous pronouncements and hurtful wisecracks that leave many Mainers at least shaking their heads and sometimes shaking their fists.” (Portland Press Herald, 05/01/11)
Unwilling to Negotiate
Bangor Daily News Editorial: LePage Has “Bullied and Insulted Those Who Disagree With Him. As a Result, Much of LePage’s Agenda Has Withered on the Sidelines.” According to an editorial in the Bangor Daily News, “LePage has had seven years to work with lawmakers, to persuade them that his priorities -- and his plans to meet them -- are the right ones for Maine. Instead, he has bullied and insulted those who disagree with him. As a result, much of LePage's agenda has withered on the sidelines.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 2/14/18]
Kennebec Journal Editorial: “LePage is Not Big on Checks and Balances. Whether it’s a Voter-Approved Bond He Won’t Issue, a Life-Saving Medicine He Won’t Distribute or a Renewable Energy Project He Can Disrupt, the Governor Knows How to Say ‘No.’” According to an editorial in the Kennebec Journal, “LePage is not big on checks and balances.
Whether it's a voter-approved bond he won't issue, a life-saving medicine he won't distribute or a renewable energy project he can disrupt, the governor knows how to say ‘no.’” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 2/11/18]
Republican Criticism/Opposition to Paul LePage
Eight Republican State Senators Wrote A Letter “Criticizing Gov. Paul Lepage…For Making Demeaning Comments About Members Of The Public.” “Eight Republican Senators are criticizing Gov. Paul LePage openly for making demeaning comments about members of the public, and they are urging him to take a more civil tone.” (Kennebec Journal, 04/02/11) “‘Belittling comments, whether they come from the governor or his opponents, have no place in Maine public life,’ the senators wrote.” (Portland Press Herald, 04/05/11) They said, “we feel compelled to express our discomfort and dismay with the tone and spirit of some of the remarks he has made.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/04/11) “‘Were these isolated incidents, we would bite our collective tongues, because we are all human and make mistakes. But, unfortunately, they are not isolated but frequent. Therefore, we feel we must speak out,’” they said in a “column…written by Sen. Roger Katz of Augusta and Sen. Brian Langley Ellsworth. Six other senators added their names to the column. They are Sen. Thomas Saviello of Wilton, Sen. Chris Rector of Thomaston, Sen. Nichi Farnham of Bangor, Sen. Earle McCormick of West Gardiner, Sen. Roger Sherman of Houlton and Sen. Thomas Martin of Benton.” (Kennebec Journal, 04/02/11) “‘By demeaning others, the governor…discourages people from taking part in debating the issues of the day – worrying if not only their ideas, but they themselves as people, will be the subject of scorn,’ the document reads.” “The Republican senators go on to criticize LePage for putting down others who disagree with him and diverting attention from important issues as evidenced during the recent removal of a mural from the Department of Labor offices.” (Bangor Daily News, 04/02/11) “On LePage’s decision to order the…[removal] of the mural from the Maine Department of Labor, the senators state in their letter that the issue represents a legitimate disagreement between the governor and labor. ‘But for (LePage) to announce that he would ‘laugh at the idiots’ should they choose to engage in our honored tradition of civil disobedience is another personal attack that only serves to further lower the bar of our public discourse,’ the senators say in their column.” (Kennebec Journal, 04/02/11) They called “on the governor to reject ‘government by disrespect.’” “‘The governor is the leader of our party,’ Rector said. ‘He reflects on all of us who are also Republicans and are worried about being painted with the same brush. We wanted to indicate that what’s been happening is unfortunate and unproductive.’” (Bangor Daily News, 04/02/11)
- State “Sen. Ronald Collins, R-Wells, Who Did Not Sign The Letter, Said That He And Other Republicans Who Did Not Sign The Letter Share Some Of The Same Concerns.” “Sen. Ronald Collins, R-Wells, who did not sign the letter, said that he and other Republicans who did not sign the letter share some of the same concerns.” “He said some of LePage’s comments, such as telling the NAACP to ‘kiss my butt,’ have made it more difficult for the Legislature to enact his agenda, which is create jobs and lower taxes.” (Kennebec Journal, 04/02/11)
- In Response To This Letter The Portland Press Herald Said, “Maine Needs A Leader In The Governor’s Office, Not A Self- Indulgent Troublemaker Prone To
Starting Fights ‘Not Worth Fighting.’” The Portland Press Herald said, “the senators’ op- ed was encouraging not only because it put the governor on notice that his behavior is unacceptable, but also because it demonstrates emphatically and dramatically that criticism of the governor is not the exclusive province of the media and opponents of his policy agenda.” “Maine needs a leader in the governor’s office, not a self-indulgent troublemaker prone to starting fights ‘not worth fighting,’” the Portland Press Herald said. (Portland Press Herald, 04/05/11)
August 2016: Maine GOP Senator Amy Volk Said She Was Concerned About LePage’s Behavior Saying She Wasn’t Sure If He Suffered From Substance Abuse, Mental Illness, Or Just Ignorance.” On August 28, 2016, Maine GOP Senator Amy Volk reacted to a violent voicemail LePage left for a Democratic lawmaker saying, “Dear friends and constituents, I share your deep concerns regarding the governor's behavior. What I do not know is whether it is due to substance abuse, mental illness or just ignorance. I certainly hope that his family and small circle of close staff are considering how best to address the issue. Things definitely appear to be out of control. Leadership is considering whether we need a special session of the legislature. Some sort of censure would seem appropriate and I would welcome the ability to go on the record with a vote.” [Facebook, Honorable Amy Volk, 8/28/16]
Maine GOP Senator Amy Volk: I Would Call LePage “If I Felt The Governor And I Were Friends” But “We Do Not Have That Sort Of Relationship.” On August 28, 2016, Maine GOP Senator Amy Volk said she didn’t feel like her and Paul LePage were friendly enough to have a conversation about his inappropriate behavior saying, “up until this point, I have refrained from publicly criticizing any of the governor's behavior both out of respect for the office and a desire to preserve a working relationship with him and his staff, but this latest and the unwelcome attention it has brought to our state is a bridge too far for me. If I felt the governor and I were friends, I would give him a call or sit down with him, but we do not have that sort of relationship. He has family, he has friends and he has staff, I ask them to intervene as well as they can.” [Facebook, Honorable Amy Volk, 8/28/16]
June 2018: Maine GOP Senator Amy Volk Celebrated Judge Forcing LePage To Submit Plan For Medicaid Expansion. On June 5, 2018, Maine GOP Senator Amy Volk posted on Facebook, “Judge orders LePage to submit plan for Medicaid expansion and I think this is a good thing. Conservative states across the country have models we can learn from. It's time to implement what voters approved.” [Facebook, Honorable Amy Volk, 6/5/18]
August 2016: Maine GOP Senator Amy Volk Reacted To Comments LePage Made About Wanted To Duel Member Of The Maine Legislature By Calling For Civility In Public Debate. On August 30, 2016, Amy Volk posted an Op-Ed by a fellow legislator that criticized LePage For uncivil comments made amid public debate, Volk agreed with the piece calling for LePage to be more civil. [Facebook, Honorable Amy Volk, 8/30/16]
Sun Journal Editorial Headline: “Some Republican Lawmakers Frustrated With Paul LePage.” [Sun Journal—Editorial, 6/27/15]
- Maine GOP Strategist: GOP Members Of The Legislature Said They “Are Done” With LePage Due To His Retreat To His Office And Flurry Of Vetoes. “Critics say his decision to retreat to his office and issue a flurry of vetoes shows a lack of leadership and that his attacks on fellow Republicans are counterproductive. Finally, they say his latest actions, including meddling in a charter school's personnel decisions, are distracting from his agenda. ‘There are members of the Legislature that have stood beside Gov. LePage through thick and thin that are saying that they are done with him. That's something that I've never heard before,’ said Lance Dutson, a Republican strategist who worked on several high-profile political campaigns, including those of Maine Sen. Susan Collins and New Hampshire Sen. Kelly Ayotte.” [Sun Journal—Editorial, 6/27/15]
- GOP Maine Senators Tom Saviello, Roger Katz Said LePage Took Partisan Politics To “A New, Dark Level” And Was “Angry And Vindictive.” “This week, the Democratic speaker of the House of Representatives accused him of blackmailing a school for at-risk youth by threatening to withhold state funds unless they fired him for the top job there. House Speaker Mark Eves says he's considering suing LePage. After that incident, Saviello said LePage took partisan politics so a ‘new, dark level.’ GOP Sen. Roger Katz called his actions ‘personal, angry and vindictive.’ A Maine newspaper splashed the headline ‘Gov. LeRage.’ Another newspaper's editorial board suggested that he should be investigated for possible impeachment.” [Sun Journal—Editorial, 6/27/15]
- LePage’s “Strong-Arm” Tactics Often “Backfired” And Pushed GOP To Side With Democrats To Override LePage’s Vetoes. “LePage's strong-arm tactics have often backfired, observers say, pushing Republicans to join Democrats more often than not to override the more than 100 vetoes he has issued so far this session. ‘It's just striking how quickly he squandered any political capital he gained from his re-election,’ said Phil Bartlett, chairman of the Maine Democratic Party.” [Sun Journal—Editorial, 6/27/15]
Morning Sentinel: LePage “Not Great At Inspiring Positive Change,” Ignored GOP Allies In State Legislature For “Go-It-Alone” Approach On Tax Reform. “LePage ignored his Republican allies in the State House and the Legislature as a whole. One problem: The Legislature is not an indifferent bystander, but an equal branch of government. That go-it-alone approach underscores LePage's limitations as a leader. He has very few tools in his leadership toolbox. He's not great at inspiring positive change. Nobody has accused him of bringing people together to solve problems. And he instinctively isolates himself from anyone who isn't 100 percent compliant.” [Morning Sentinel—Editorial, 9/19/15]
Morning Sentinel: LePage “Lost The Confidence And Trust Of Many Of His Allies” And “His Threats Are No Longer Taken Seriously By Legislators.” “LePage has lost that power, because he's lost the confidence and trust of many of his allies. His threats are no longer taken seriously by legislators. They've stood up to the bully and won, and others will follow. For a leader who relies on threats to "lead," this is a profound change. Republicans no doubt will try to put the best face on all this, as they must, going into the next round of elections, but LePage's legacy is now largely written. He'll, of course, still make annual speeches to the Legislature and propose required budgets. But nobody is listening. For all practical purposes, LePage has become a three-year lame duck.” [Morning Sentinel—Editorial, 9/19/15]
GOP Maine State Senator Roger Katz: LePage’s Inability To Be Viewed As Role Model Was Hopefully “A Blip On The Screen.” “Sen. Roger Katz, R-Augusta, who is also termed out, said the presidents and some Maine governors who he looked up to as a kid took seriously the responsibility of being a positive role model for the people they were leading. ‘Sadly, I don't think we've experienced that in the last eight years,’ Katz said. ‘I hope that is a blip on the screen and that the next chief executive, no matter who it is, will understand what a real responsibility that is.’" [Press Herald, 9/14/18]
Bangor Daily News: Maine Senate Republicans Found “Odd Allies, The Democrats,” Against LePage And Minority Of House GOP. “The 128th Maine Legislature, which presided over a state shutdown last year and stretched nearly five months past its scheduled end in 2018, closed its work for the year on Thursday -- but not without dealing with Gov. Paul LePage's late threat to call it back. This Legislature was defined by battles between Senate Republicans and their odd allies, the Democrats, against the Republican governor and the minority group of mostly conservative House Republicans in whom LePage's legislative power almost solely rested.” [Bangor Daily News, 9/13/18]
Press Herald Columnist Greg Kesich: LePage “Stole The Show” In Campaign Appearance For GOP Maine US Senate Candidate, Eric Brakey, By Saying He Was Moving To Florida. “The celebrity guest at the news conference stole the show. Instead of staying on the Brakey message, Gov. LePage took the opportunity to make some news of his own. In response to a reporter's question, the governor announced that he would be getting out of Maine as soon as possible, choosing to spend his golden years in Florida so he won't have to pay so much in taxes. And suddenly, nobody wanted to ask about Brakey's poster, with its colored boxes and timelines. Conspiracy theories are fun, but it's not every day you hear a governor say that he can't wait to get out of his own state.” [Portland Press Herald, Greg Kesich Column, 11/11/18]
Attacks on Fellow Republicans
Morning Sentinel Columnist Alan Caron Headline: “LePage’s Overreach Alienates Even Some Fellow Republicans.” [Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 6/5/15]
- Caron: GOP PAC Run By LePage’s Daughter Attacked GOP Senate President Michael Thibodeau Over Compromising With Democrats To Pass State Budget. Morning Sentinel contributor Alan Caron remarked in June 2015, “Outside of Augusta, a Republican PAC run by Gov. Paul LePage's daughter is attacking Republican Senate President Michael Thibodeau, of Winterport, in his home district, for having the audacity to support compromises on the budget. What they don't seem to understand is that the state budget requires a two-thirds vote of the Legislature, a majority that cannot be achieved without those dreaded compromises from all sides. Thibodeau and others are being accused of two crimes that agitate the most far-right Republicans. One is the notion of consorting with the enemy. The other is living in the real world.” [Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 6/5/15]
- Caron: LePage Was “Being Routed In This Legislature” As He Was Headed Toward “Nearly Complete Rejection Of His Second-Term Agenda. “While we're still a few weeks away from the last hours of this Legislature, the ending is already coming into focus. LePage is headed toward a nearly complete rejection of his second-term agenda. Aside from the crumbs that the Legislature will throw at him when they can, he's being routed in this Legislature. Budget negotiators from both parties already have agreed to scrap LePage's sales tax increases, along with deep cuts in income taxes, revenue sharing cuts to towns and most other elements of the governor's budget.” [Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 6/5/15]
- Caron: LePage Vowed Not To Sign Any Bills Sponsored By Democrats, Threatened To Oppose GOP In Next Election After Tax, Energy Initiatives Were Rejected By Legislature. “Budget negotiators from both parties already have agreed to scrap LePage's sales tax increases, along with deep cuts in income taxes, revenue sharing cuts to towns and most other elements of the governor's budget. On the energy front, the Senate this week voted unanimously for an energy-efficiency bill that will fix a simple clerical error in an earlier bill, and dismisses the changes that LePage demanded. On issue after issue, in fact, the Legislature is ignoring LePage's ideas and overriding his vetoes. LePage has responded, not surprisingly, by lashing out in all directions. Last week, he held one of the most bizarre news conferences by a sitting governor in anyone's memory. In what can only be called a tantrum, he threatened to oppose Republicans during next year's campaigns. He also promised not to sign any bills sponsored by Democrats, or release any bonds, no matter how important they are to Maine.” [Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 6/5/15]
- Caron: LePage Became GOP’s “Great Divider.” “Most of us who follow these things marveled at LePage's newfound political skill in uniting Republicans around these ideas, some of which the party, and its current legislative leaders, had fought just a few years back. Republicans must be awestruck by LePage's election, I thought, and they're all falling in line. It turns out, as we now know, that LePage hadn't even talked with fellow Republicans, who learned about his bold plan just like you and I did, by following the news. So rather than being the new Republican unifier, LePage has quickly become the Great Divider.” [Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 6/5/15]
Morning Sentinel Columnist Caron: LePage “Attacked Fellow Republicans On Radio” And Began To “Veto All Bills From The Legislature” After His Tax Plan Was Rejected. “You know the particulars. LePage launched a big tax plan. The Legislature, which hadn't been consulted on any of it, didn't like it. That made LePage mad, which in turn seemed to make him irrational. He began to veto all bills from the Legislature, chortling about ‘wasting their time.’ He attacked fellow Republicans on radio and managed to get Democratic House Speaker Mark Eves fired from his new job at Good Will-Hinckley by threatening to withhold funds from the school.” [Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 9/19/15]
Morning Sentinel Columnist Caron: LePage Pursued Tax Rewrite That Would Lower Income Taxes, Increase Taxes On Services And Tourists; Plan Was “Energetically Opposed By Republican Leaders.” “They concluded that it was time to firmly establish LePage's legacy as The People's Champion. It was time to go big. They ultimately settled on an idea that was shockingly ambitious: LePage would rewrite Maine's tax laws to lower income taxes, and pay for it by increasing taxes on services and tourists. It was an idea long supported by moderates and Democrats, and energetically opposed by Republican leaders. At that moment, LePage's self-destruction began -- not because of his tax reform ideas, but because of the clumsy arrogance of his approach.” [Morning Sentinel, Alan Caron Column, 9/19/15]
March 2015: LePage Pledged To Spend The Rest Of His Days “Going After Lawmakers” Who Opposed His Plan To Lower Maine’s Income Tax, Including GOP. “Gov. Paul LePage has made it known he won't settle for any half-measures on his plan to lower Maine's income tax and overhaul its tax system. He pledged in March to ‘spend the rest of my days going after’ lawmakers who opposed it. The latest salvo in the battle of the biennial budget came Monday, when Maine People Before Politics, a conservative advocacy group with ties to the governor, turned its guns on Senate Republican leaders after they reached a tentative budget deal with Democrats that did not include a number of LePage's more contentious proposals.” [Bangor Daily News, 6/4/15]
Bangor Daily News: LePage Said He Hoped Maine Senate GOP Got “Destroyed” In 2018 Election. “The same divide played in 2018 and on Thursday, when an incensed LePage said legislative leaders wouldn't advance a governor's bill aimed at shielding elderly Mainers from municipal foreclosures. Among others, he blamed Senate President Mike Thibodeau, R-Winterport, and said he hoped Senate Republicans get ‘destroyed’ in the November elections if they block it.” [Bangor Daily News, 9/13/18]