Paul LePage: UNEMPLOYMENT
Paul Lepage, In 2011, Suggested “That Some Collecting Unemployment Insurance Were Lazy.” Paul LePage, in 2011, suggested “that some collecting unemployment insurance were lazy.” (Bangor Daily News, 12/05/11)
HEADLINE: Emails Reveal Friction, Political Pressure On Unemployment Hearing Examiners. The Sun Journal reported, “The chief hearing officer at the Maine Department of Labor's Division of Administrative Hearings said in an email she was ‘totally shocked’ after attending a luncheon hosted by Gov. LePage at the Blaine House last month where he reportedly scolded hearing officers for doing their jobs poorly in the wake of complaints by businesses… Sources in a Sun Journal investigation who said pressure to find more cases in favor of employers was applied to hearing officers beginning in 2011 after an employer complained following an unfavorable appeals hearing.” [Sun Journal, 4/17/13]
- LePage Administration Fought for Change to Appointment for Unemployment Bureau Head. The Sun Journal reported, “A top Maine Democratic lawmaker said this week that Gov. Paul LePage orchestrated a change last year at the Department of Labor in an effort to wrest greater control over hearing officers who decide appeals of unemployment claims. The administration proposed last year changing the designation of the job of director at the Bureau of Unemployment Compensation from a civil service position to a political appointment… Peter Steele, director of communications for LePage, said the administration's actions last year were simply an effort to achieve consistency within the Maine Department of Labor where all bureau directors — except [current director Laura] Boyett — are political appointees and have been since before LePage took office.” [Sun Journal, 4/25/13]
- Kennebec Journal Editorial: LePage Crossed Line at Meeting with Labor Officials. In an editorial noting how LePage “trips, falls over line he shouldn't cross” in the headline, the Kennebec Journal opined in 2013 that, “Gov. Paul LePage invited the people who decide unemployment claims to the Blaine House and told them that he had heard reports that they were being too hard on employers when they decide cases… that
meeting never should have happened. The governor has no more business telling hearing officers how to decide cases than he would assembling a group of umpires to tell them to call more strikes.” [Kennebec Journal, 4/23/13]
- Sun Journal Editorial: Investigation Yielded Confirmation of Pressure. The Sun Journal wrote in an editorial, “We knew this involved the hearing officers, the people who decide unemployment claim disputes between employees and employers, but they were afraid to talk for fear of losing their jobs. By teasing out bits and pieces here and there, double checking accounts against each other and then rechecking those accounts, we were finally able to establish what they were so "disgruntled" about. The same reason came up time and time again: The hearing officers felt the governor was pressuring them to decide fewer cases in favor of employees.” [Sun Journal editorial, 4/19/13]
In 2018, Bipartisan Majorities of the House and Senate Overrode LePage’s Veto of a Bill Exempting Individuals Receiving Unemployment Benefits Because They Were Temporarily Laid Off From Their Job But Had a Definite Recall Date from the Job Search Requirement to Receive Benefits. In July 2018, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD700 by a 140-3 vote and the Senate by a 32-1 vote. LD700 “creates an exemption from the eligibility requirements for unemployment benefits dealing with work search. Under this new exemption, an individual who has been temporarily laid off by an employer with a definite recall date and is otherwise eligible for unemployment benefits is exempt from the requirement to search for work while receiving benefits, as long as the individual remains in contact with and is able and available to work for that employer. This exemption may be used up to six weeks during an individual’s unemployment benefit year, and may be used beyond six weeks subject to approval by the Department of Labor.” [Summaries of Bills, LD700, 2018; Maine State Legislature, LD700, 2018]
July 2018: LePage Vetoed Bill That Exempted Laid-Off Employees From Work-Search Requirements While Receiving Maine Unemployment Benefit For 6 Weeks; Was Overridden On Bipartisan Vote. “Gov. Paul LePage is urging employers to push for the repeal of a new law that relaxes work-search requirements for Mainers who experience short-term job layoffs. The new law exempts laid-off employees from work-search requirements in Maine's unemployment insurance law for up to six weeks, provided that their employers set a specific date for them to return to their jobs after no more than 12 weeks. LePage vetoed the bill in July but it was overridden on a bipartisan vote by the Legislature. This week, LePage sent a letter to employers calling on them to pressure lawmakers into repealing the new law. ‘You and I know that unemployment is insurance, not an entitlement,’ LePage wrote. ‘It is a safety net - not a means of subsidizing one industry's or one employer's payroll on the backs of all other employers.’” [Portland Press Herald, 8/24/18]
Portland Press Herald: GOP Maine Sen. Amy Volk Was Disappointed In LePage’s Veto Level Of Her Bill To Exempt Laid-Off Employees From Work-Search Requirement In UI Benefits. “The key sponsor of the new law, Sen. Amy Volk, R-Scarborough, said the measure is meant to help employers such as construction and logging companies, who regularly use temporary layoffs to get through seasonal shifts in the weather. […] ‘If we were not at such very low unemployment levels we obviously would have considered this bill in a very different light,’
Volk said. Volk, who has sided with LePage on other legislation, said she's disappointed in the letter, but doesn't see it as improper. LePage contends in his letter that the new law will increase costs for all businesses, and that it turns unemployment compensation into an entitlement.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/24/18]
Measure Was Meant to “Help Employers Such as Construction and Logging Companies, Who Regularly Use Temporary Layoffs to Get Through Seasonal Shifts in the Weather.” According to the Portland Press Herald, “Gov. Paul LePage is urging employers to push for the repeal of a new law that relaxes work-search requirements for Mainers who experience short-term job layoffs. The new law exempts laid-off employees from work-search requirements in Maine's unemployment insurance law for up to six weeks, provided that their employers set a specific date for them to return to their jobs after no more than 12 weeks. […] The key sponsor of the new law, Sen. Amy Volk, R-Scarborough, said the measure is meant to help employers such as construction and logging companies, who regularly use temporary layoffs to get through seasonal shifts in the weather.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/24/18]
Republican Bill Sponsor Said Logging Workers “Go Through the Motions of the Work Search” Knowing They’ll be Returning to Employment. According to the Portland Press Herald, “The key sponsor of the new law, Sen. Amy Volk, R-Scarborough, said the measure is meant to help employers such as construction and logging companies, who regularly use temporary layoffs to get through seasonal shifts in the weather. ‘We have a mud season in Maine when roads are often posted, three weeks, four weeks, and they can't get their large equipment in and out to do jobs,’ said Volk, who is the Senate chairwoman of the Legislature's Labor, Commerce, Research and Economic Development Committee. Volk said logging and construction workers frequently go through the motions of the work search knowing they will be returning to work with the employer they recently left. ‘It is just an exercise they had to go through, they are not switching employers, these are truly temporary layoffs and they are going back to the exact same employer you were working for the month before,’ she said.” [Portland Press Herald, 8/24/18]
After the Legislature Overrode His Veto on the Bill, LePage Sent a Letter to Employers Urging Them to Call for a Repeal of the Law. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Gov. Paul LePage is urging employers to push for the repeal of a new law that relaxes work-search requirements for Mainers who experience short-term job layoffs. The new law exempts laid-off employees from work-search requirements in Maine's unemployment insurance law for up to six weeks, provided that their employers set a specific date for them to return to their jobs after no more than 12 weeks. LePage vetoed the bill in July but it was overridden on a bipartisan vote by the Legislature. This week, LePage sent a letter to employers calling on them to pressure lawmakers into repealing the new law. ‘You and I know that unemployment is insurance, not an entitlement,’ LePage wrote. ‘It is a safety net - not a means of subsidizing one industry's or one employer's payroll on the backs of all other employers.’” [Portland Press Herald, 8/24/18]
Paul LePage Left Legacy Of Shrinking Government To Detriment Of Mainers
Bangor Daily News Editorial: Continuation Of LePage’s “Legacy” Of “Shrinking The Number Of People Served” As Measure Of Success Was Not In Maine’s Best Interest.
“Republican Shawn Moody, is a successful businessman who has built a growing chain of car repair facilities. As we've learned from LePage and President Donald Trump, a broader set of skills, beyond running a business, is needed to be a governor. Moody, who thankfully is more positive and less combative than LePage, has pledged to continue many of the current governor's policies. We don't believe a continuation of the LePage legacy of measuring government success solely based on shrinking the number of people served and dollars spent instead of whether residents' lives have improved is in Maine's best interest.” [Bangor Daily News—Editorial, 10/19/18]