Brad Finstad Was A Member Of Leadership For The Republican Study Committee, Which Proposed Raising The Retirement Age And Slashing Social Security Benefits As Well As Increasing Medicare Costs For Beneficiaries Through A “Premium Support” Structure

2026: Finstad Served On The Steering Committee Of The Republican Study Committee After Previously Being A Member Of The Caucus During The 118th Congress

July 2026: Finstad Served On The Steering Committee Of The Republican Study Committee. [Republican Study Committee, accessed 7/23/26]

Image: see original report, p. 105

[Republican Study Committee, accessed 7/23/26]

The Republican Study Committee Was The Largest Caucus Of House Conservatives. “Hegseth is set to meet behind closed doors on Wednesday with the Republican Study Committee, the largest caucus of House conservatives, and he has been spotted on Capitol Hill meeting with other lawmakers as he tries to build support. He made a public case Tuesday in an op-ed in the New York Post, arguing that pro-defense lawmakers and fiscal hardliners should be on the same side.” [NOTUS, 6/24/26]

  • 2023: Three-Fourths Of The House GOP Were Members Of The RSC. “A large group of conservative House Republicans are preparing a proposed budget that could exacerbate rifts within the party with proposals to reduce Social Security and Medicare benefits. The blueprint by the Republican Study Committee, whose membership includes three-fourths of House GOP, comes as party leaders are struggling to reach consensus on spending reductions which they want to tie to raising the debt limit in negotiations with the White House. The plan is expected to be released in early May.” [Bloomberg Government, 4/12/23]

December 2024: Finstad Was A Member Of The Republican Study Committee. Finstad was listed on the “Membership” page of the Republican Study Committee website. [Republican Study Committee via Internet Archive, 12/29/24]

Image: see original report, p. 106

[Republican Study Committee via Internet Archive, 12/29/24]

2023-2024: The RSC FY 2024 And FY 2025 Budgets Proposed Raising The Retirement Age, Which Would Cut Benefits For New Retirees By Up To Nearly $100,000 When Fully Phased-In

March 2024: The Republican Study Committee’s Fiscal Year 2025 Budget Proposal Included “Significant Cuts To Social Security”

2024: Center For American Progress: The Republican Study Committee Fiscal Year 2025 Budget Proposal Included “Significant Cuts To Social Security.” “In March, the Republican Study Committee (RSC) released its fiscal year 2025 budget proposal, which includes significant cuts to Social Security. For years, the RSC has included proposals for raising the full retirement age (FRA), or the age at which seniors become eligible to access Social Security retirement benefits without a financial penalty. These far-right plans are similar to those put forward by Project 2025’s authors and would threaten low- and moderate-income workers with economic insecurity once they leave the workforce.” [Center for American Progress, 7/31/24]

  • March 2024: The RSC’s FY24 Budget Called For Raising The Retirement Age For Social Security. According to the Republican Study Committee Fiscal Year 2025 Budget Proposal, “For instance, the RSC Budget would make modest changes to the primary insurance amount (PIA) benefit formula for individuals who are not near retirement and earn more than the wealthiest PIA benefit factor. It would also make modest adjustments to the retirement age for future retirees to account for increases in life expectancy. Finally, for these individuals, it would limit and phase out auxiliary benefits for high income earners.” [Republican Study Committee FY 2025 Budget Proposal, 3/20/24]

2023: The Republican Study Committee’s Fiscal Year 2024 Budget Proposal Included Cuts To Social Security Benefits

June 2023: Bloomberg Headline: “Social Security Benefits Targeted For Cuts By House Conservatives.” [Bloomberg, 6/14/23]

  • 2023: The RSC’s FY24 Budget Called For Raising The Retirement Age For Social Security. The RSC Budget would “[…] make modest adjustments to the retirement age for future retirees to account for increases

in life expectancy.” “Every Social Security retirement reform supported by the RSC Budget was previously offered in a bipartisan fashion. For instance, the RSC Budget would make modest changes to the primary insurance amount (PIA) benefit formula for individuals who are not near retirement and earn more than the wealthiest PIA benefit factor. It would also make modest adjustments to the retirement age for future retirees to account for increases in life expectancy. Finally, for these individuals, it would limit and phase out auxiliary benefits for high income earners.” [Republican Study Committee, Fiscal Year 2024 Budget, 6/14/23]

2023-2024: The Republican Study Committee Proposed Raising The Full Retirement Age From 67 To 69

The RSC’s FY 2024 And FY 2025 Budgets Did Not Include Specific Details On Raising The Retirement Age, But RSC Budget And Spending Task Force Chairman Rep. Ben Cline Told Roll Call That The Plan Included Raising The Full Retirement Age From 67 To 69. “The RSC’s FY 2025 budget proposal borrows much of its language on Social Security from its FY 2024 counterpart. Nonetheless, specific details on the plan to increase the FRA did not come from the FY 2024 budget proposal itself, but rather Roll Call’s reporting on comments made by RSC Budget and Spending Task Force Chairman Rep. Ben Cline (R-VA) on behalf of the RSC. This is important because despite dedicating six pages to a section on Social Security, the document’s policy proposals for the program were given just one paragraph, with the increase to the FRA mentioned in just one sentence on page 108: ‘For instance, the RSC Budget would … also make modest adjustments to the retirement age for future retirees to account for increases in life expectancy.’ Fortunately, Rep. Cline’s comments provided additional insight. He stated that the FRA would increase by three months per year, starting with those turning 62 in 2026, until it rises by two years—from 67 to 69. Then, the new FRA of 69 would be fully phased in for those turning 62 in 2033. Considering the language for this proposal has remained the same between years, it is likely that this timeline would simply be pushed back a year with the FY 2025 version. This means the phase-in would begin with those turning 62 in 2027 and finish with those turning 62 in 2034.” [Center for American Progress, 7/31/24]

  • Cline Told Roll Call The Retirement Age Would Reach 69 For Those Who Turn 62 In 2033. “Cline said the group has proposed gradually raising the Social Security retirement age, but not for current retirees or those nearing retirement. He said those now aged 59 would see an increase in the retirement age of three months per year beginning in 2026. The retirement age would reach 69 for those who turn 62 in 2033.” [Roll Call, 6/14/23]

July 2024: Center For American Progress: One Policy That Has “Continually Been Included In RSC Budget Proposals For Years” Is An Increase To Social Security’s Full Retirement Age (FRA) From 67 To 69. “One policy that has continually been included in RSC budget proposals for years is an increase to Social Security’s full retirement age (FRA), the age at which seniors become eligible to access Social Security retirement benefits without a financial penalty for retiring early. The FRA is 67 under current law, but the RSC plan would push it back to 69, leading to drastic benefit cuts for a large majority of Americans. While raising the FRA is overwhelmingly unpopular among the American people, it has enjoyed the support of some of the most extreme far-right groups in Washington, D.C., including the Heritage Foundation, which is spearheading the authoritarian playbook known as Project 2025.” [Center for American Progress, 7/31/24]

Raising The Retirement Age For Social Security Would Cut Benefits By Thousands Of Dollars Each Year

Center For American Progress Headline: “Raising The Retirement Age For Social Security Would Cut Benefits By Thousands Of Dollars Each Year.” [Center for American Progress, 7/31/24]

Center For American Progress: “An FRA Of 69 Would Cut Benefits For All New Retirees Between Roughly 12.5 Percent And 14.3 Percent By The Time It Is Fully Phased In.” “This higher FRA would cut Social Security benefits. According to Center for American Progress analysis, an FRA of 69 would cut benefits for all new retirees between roughly 12.5 percent and 14.3 percent by the time it is fully phased in. In addition, it would cost a median-wage retiree who earned $70,000 in 2022 and turns 62 in 2034 thousands of dollars every year.” [Center for American Progress, 7/31/24]

Under An FRA Of 69, “The Median-Wage Retiree Would Lose Between $46,104 And $99,252 After 10 Years Of Receiving Social Security.” “Increasing the FRA to 69 would raise this maximum penalty from 30 percent to 39 percent, cutting benefits by nearly 13 percent.This would affect all ages at which someone could claim Social Security. In the example above, the median-wage retiree turning 62 in 2034 would have their monthly benefit cut between $345 and $741, depending on the age at which they claimed benefits. After just one year, they would lose between $4,140 and $8,892. However, the dollar amount of the cut would not be static each year. To account for inflation, Social Security benefits are updated with cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs), which the Social Security Administration expects to equal 2.4 percent each year after 2025, according to its intermediate cost projections. After accounting for these COLAs, the median-wage retiree would lose between $46,104 and $99,252 after 10 years of receiving Social Security. (see Figure 1) For context, these losses equal about 25 to 54 percent of the median retirement account balance for those ages 55 to 64 and would create a significant gap in a typical retiree’s finances. These retirement accounts also vary widely in accessibility and account balance by income, so low- and middle-income retirees, who are likely to rely more heavily on Social Security as a source of retirement income, would be most affected by these cuts.” [Center for American Progress, 7/31/24]

2023-2024: The Republican Study Committee’s Budget Proposals Included A Proposal To Switch Medicare To A “Premium Support” System, Which Would Raise Costs For Beneficiaries

March 2024: The Republican Study Committee’s Fiscal Year 2025 Budget Proposed A “Premium Support” Model For Medicare Beneficiaries

The Republican Study Committee’s Fiscal Year 2025 Budget Proposed A “Premium Support” Model For Medicare Beneficiaries. “The RSC budget would implement a premium support model where private, Medicare Advantage (MA) plans would compete with a federal Medicare plan (the ‘Fed Plan’) that would offer the traditional Medicare benefits received through Part A, B, and D. Medicare Advantage (MA) plans provide the same services as Medicare but are administered by private health insurance providers. Under this plan, Medicare’s trust funds would be merged into a singular fund that would be responsible for paying premium support subsidies to cover the vast majority of their premium costs. This new singular trust fund would be funded with revenues from existing payroll taxes, Part B premiums, and Part B and D cost sharing—which would help ensure continued traditional Medicare benefits remain available. This framework would ensure seniors, whether they choose a private plan or the Fed Plan, receive more affordable, high-quality coverage.” [Republican Study Committee, FY 2025 Budget Proposal, 3/20/24]

June 2023: The Republican Study Committee’s Fiscal Year 2024 Budget Proposed A “Premium Support” Model For Medicare Beneficiaries

The Fiscal Year 2024 RSC Budget Would Reform Medicare By Implementing A Premium Support Model. “To achieve this, the RSC budget would implement a premium support model where private plans would compete with a federal Medicare plan (the ‘Fed Plan’) that would offer the traditional Medicare benefits received through Part A, B, and D.” [Republican Study Committee, FY 2024 Budget Proposal, 6/14/23]

Under A Premium Support Model, Medicare Would Compete With Private Plans, Shifting Costs Onto Beneficiaries

Under A Premium Support Model, Medicare Would Compete With Private Plans. “The new budget also calls for converting Medicare to a ‘premium support model,’ echoing a proposal that Republican former Speaker Paul Ryan had rallied support for. Under the new RSC plan, traditional Medicare would compete with private plans and beneficiaries would be given subsidies to shop for the policies of their choice. The size of the subsidies could be pegged to the ‘average premium’ or ‘second lowest price’ in a particular market, the budget says.” [NBC News, 3/20/24]

  • KFF: “Premium Support” Was A General Term To Describe An Approach To Reforming Medicare By Increasing Competition Among Health Plans. “Premium support is a general term used to describe an approach to reform Medicare that aims to reduce the growth in Medicare spending by increasing competition among health plans and providing a stronger incentive for beneficiaries to be cost-conscious in their plan selection. On June 22, 2016, the House Republicans included in their health care reform plan a proposal to

gradually transform Medicare into a system of premium supports, building on proposals of the Speaker of the House, Paul Ryan, when he was Chair of the House Committee on Budget, as well as the proposals of many other policymakers.” [KFF, 7/19/16]

Premium Support Models Shifted Costs Onto Beneficiaries. “In areas where Medicare incurs relatively high costs, the amount of the premium-support payment would equal the cost of a relatively inexpensive private plan, and beneficiaries would have to pay higher premiums to participate in traditional Medicare. In areas with relatively low Medicare spending, beneficiaries who wanted to enroll in a private plan would face higher premiums or fewer benefits, or might find that no private plan was available. […] The vouchers would purchase less coverage with each passing year, pushing more costs on to beneficiaries. Over time, seniors would have to pay more to keep the health plans and the doctors they like, or they would get fewer benefits.” [Center On Budget and Policy Priorities, 3/28/12]

  • Republicans’ Proposal To Switch To A Medicare “Premium Support” System Would Result In Most Beneficiaries Paying More For Health Care Than They Do Under Current Laws. “Under premium support, Medicare would make a fixed-dollar payment (often called a voucher) for each beneficiary to defray part of the cost of health insurance — either through a private plan or a form of traditional Medicare. The beneficiary’s premium would equal the difference between the voucher amount and the cost of the plan that he or she selected. Premium support would apply to all new beneficiaries starting in 2024 and to any other beneficiaries who chose to participate. Unlike the current system, in which Part B premiums are generally the same for all beneficiaries, premiums under the House GOP plan would vary by region and by plan. Although the GOP plan lacks the details to assess its impact on beneficiaries, most beneficiaries enrolled in traditional Medicare would pay more than under current law, according to the Congressional Budget Office.” [Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 7/26/16]

Beneficiaries Who Remained On Traditional Medicare Would Pay A Higher Premium If A Premium Support System Was Implemented. “In a premium support system, the federal government would provide a payment on behalf of each Medicare beneficiary toward the purchase of a health insurance plan – either a private plan, similar a Medicare Advantage plan, or traditional Medicare. This approach is sometimes called a defined contribution or voucher approach. Under a premium support system, health plans would compete for enrollees and people on Medicare would choose among plans for their coverage – an approach that sounds similar to the current system, but is not the same. A key difference is that payments for services provided to beneficiaries in traditional Medicare would be capitated rather than the current approach that generally ties payments to the specific services that beneficiaries use. […] Beneficiaries’ premiums and out-of-pocket costs could rise or fall, relative to current law, depending on a number of factors, including the overall design of the new system, the response of plans to a different payment policy, and the role of traditional Medicare. In contrast to the current system, in which Medicare Part B premiums are generally the same for all beneficiaries regardless of which plan they select,4 premiums for Medicare-covered services would be expected to vary from one part of the country to another, and from one plan to the next, under a premium support system.5 According to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), if the federal payments to plans were tied to the average plan bid, then beneficiaries’ total out of pocket costs (including premiums) generally would decrease, but if the federal payment was tied to the second lowest plan bid, then beneficiaries’ total out of pocket costs generally would increase.6 However, even in a situation where average premiums go down in the aggregate, some beneficiaries would pay higher premiums while others would pay less. According to the CBO, most beneficiaries who choose to remain in traditional Medicare would pay higher premiums than they would under current law, regardless of whether the federal payment was tied to the second lowest plan bid or tied to the average plan bid.” [KFF, 7/19/16]

Source report (PDF)