Brinker Harding: 1995-1997: Omaha Garbage Contractor Deffenbaugh Industries Faced Multiple Scandals Including Hiring Undocumented Workers To Replace Unionizing Employees, Investigations By The National Labor Relations Board And The Department Of Justice, And Fines By OSHA For Multiple Violations

1995: Omaha Entered A Seven Year, $60 Million Contract With Garbage Collection Company Deffenbaugh Industries

Omaha World Herald: “[Deffenbaugh Industries] Took Over Omaha's Garbage Collection In September 1995.” “The company took over Omaha's garbage collection in September 1995. Soon after, Deffenbaugh became involved in a dispute with the Teamsters Union, which is trying to unionize company workers. About 70 Deffenbaugh employees who want to organize a union ended up walking off the job last fall, prompting Deffenbaugh to hire replacement workers. In December, federal immigration agents raided Deffenbaugh's facility at 16th Street and the Storz Expressway, eventually deporting more than 75 employees who weren't legal U.S. residents. The raid by the Immigration and Naturalization Service forced Deffenbaugh to replace nearly half its Omaha work force.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

1995: The City Of Omaha Entered A Seven-Year, $60 Million Contract With Deffenbaugh. “Thus far, the mayor has declined to revisit the seven-year, $60 million contract with Deffenbaugh, which began in 1995. ‘Until we let their ability to appeal [in the OSHA case run its course], or until a determination is made in the hiring case, we're going to proceed cautiously,’ Harding said. The turmoil has had little noticeable effect on service, he said. ‘They've been great service providers.’” [Waste News, 2/3/97]

1996: Deffenbaugh Industries’ Omaha Facility Was Raided By Federal Immigration Agents After They Employed More Than 70 Undocumented Workers To Replace Unionizing Employees

1995: Deffenbaugh Industries “Became Involved In A Dispute With The Teamsters Union,” Which Attempted To Unionize Company Workers. “The company took over Omaha's garbage collection in September 1995. Soon after, Deffenbaugh became involved in a dispute with the Teamsters Union, which is trying to unionize company workers. About 70 Deffenbaugh employees who want to organize a union ended up walking off the job last fall, prompting Deffenbaugh to hire replacement workers. In December, federal immigration agents raided Deffenbaugh's facility at 16th Street and the Storz Expressway, eventually deporting more than 75 employees who weren't legal U.S. residents. The raid by the Immigration and Naturalization Service forced Deffenbaugh to replace nearly half its Omaha work force.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

Omaha World Herald: “About 70 Deffenbaugh Employees Who Want To Organize A Union Ended Up Walking Off The Job” In The Fall Of 1996. “The company took over Omaha's garbage collection in September 1995. Soon after, Deffenbaugh became involved in a dispute with the Teamsters Union, which is trying to unionize company workers. About 70 Deffenbaugh employees who want to organize a union ended up walking off the job last fall, prompting Deffenbaugh to hire replacement workers. In December, federal immigration agents raided Deffenbaugh's facility at 16th Street and the Storz Expressway, eventually deporting more than 75 employees who weren't legal U.S. residents. The raid by the Immigration and Naturalization Service forced Deffenbaugh to replace nearly half its Omaha work force.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

Omaha World Herald: Deffenbaugh Hired “Replacement Workers” For 70 Unionizing Employees Who Walked Off The Job. “The company took over Omaha's garbage collection in September 1995. Soon after, Deffenbaugh became involved in a dispute with the Teamsters Union, which is trying to unionize company workers. About 70 Deffenbaugh employees who want to organize a union ended up walking off the job last fall, prompting Deffenbaugh to hire replacement workers. In December, federal immigration agents raided Deffenbaugh's facility at 16th Street and the Storz Expressway, eventually deporting more than 75 employees who weren't legal U.S. residents. The raid by the Immigration and Naturalization Service forced Deffenbaugh to replace nearly half its Omaha work force.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

1996: Omaha World Herald: “In December, Federal Immigration Agents Raided Deffenbaugh's Facility At 16th Street And The Storz Expressway, Eventually Deporting More Than 75 Employees Who Weren't Legal U.S. Residents.” “The company took over Omaha's garbage collection in September 1995. Soon after, Deffenbaugh became involved in a dispute with the Teamsters Union, which is trying to unionize company workers. About 70 Deffenbaugh employees who want to organize a union ended up walking off the job last fall, prompting Deffenbaugh to hire replacement workers. In December, federal immigration agents raided Deffenbaugh's facility at 16th Street and the Storz Expressway, eventually deporting more than 75 employees who weren't legal U.S. residents. The raid by the Immigration and Naturalization Service forced Deffenbaugh to replace nearly half its Omaha work force.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

  • Omaha World Herald: “The Raid By The Immigration And Naturalization Service Forced Deffenbaugh To Replace Nearly Half Its Omaha Work Force.” “The company took over Omaha's garbage collection in September 1995. Soon after, Deffenbaugh became involved in a dispute with the Teamsters Union, which is trying to unionize company workers. About 70 Deffenbaugh employees who want to organize a union ended up walking off the job last fall, prompting Deffenbaugh to hire replacement workers. In December, federal immigration agents raided Deffenbaugh's facility at 16th Street and the Storz Expressway, eventually deporting more than 75 employees who weren't legal U.S. residents. The raid by the Immigration and Naturalization Service forced Deffenbaugh to replace nearly half its Omaha work force.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

1997: OSHA Fined Deffenbaugh Industries More Than $14,000 For Five Alleged Violations, Including Forbidding Workers To Take Breaks

February 1997: Deffenbaugh Industries Inc Appealed $14,400 In Proposed Fines By The US Occupational Safety & Health Administration After Being Accused Of Five Violations. “Deffenbaugh Industries Inc (Shawnee, KS) is currently appealing $14,400 in proposed fines by the US Occupational Safety & Health Administration. The company, which contracted to collect and dispose of Omaha's residential trash, is accused of five violations. These include providing little or no chance for drivers and helpers to use the bathroom. OSHA discovered that some workers were using the back of compactors as toilets because company rules forbade them from taking breaks. According to OSHA, not only was this unsanitary, it was also life threatening because of the potential for activating the compactor while a worker was back of the truck. Additional allegations against Deffenbaugh include: poor guarding on the trucks' hydraulic systems, poor procedures ensuring the cutoff of power to equipment while being maintained, poor first-aid training for workers and inconsistent use of reflective vests by employees operating in heavy traffic. Deffenbaugh also faces a federal investigation of its hiring practices.” [Waste News, 2/3/97]

Waste News: One Of Deffenbaugh’s Alleged Violations Was “Providing Little Or No Chance For Drivers And Helpers To Use The Bathroom.” “Deffenbaugh Industries Inc (Shawnee, KS) is currently appealing $14,400 in proposed fines by the US Occupational Safety & Health Administration. The company, which contracted to collect and dispose of Omaha's residential trash, is accused of five violations. These include providing little or no chance for drivers and helpers to use the bathroom. OSHA discovered that some workers were using the back of compactors as toilets because company rules forbade them from taking breaks. According to OSHA, not only was this unsanitary, it was also life threatening because of the potential for activating the compactor while a worker was back of the truck. Additional allegations against Deffenbaugh include: poor guarding on the trucks' hydraulic systems, poor procedures ensuring the cutoff of power to equipment while being maintained, poor first-aid training for workers and inconsistent use of reflective vests by employees operating in heavy traffic. Deffenbaugh also faces a federal investigation of its hiring practices.” [Waste News, 2/3/97]

Waste News: “OSHA Discovered That Some Workers Were Using The Back Of Compactors As Toilets Because [Deffenbaugh] Rules Forbade Them From Taking Breaks.” “Deffenbaugh Industries Inc (Shawnee, KS) is currently appealing $14,400 in proposed fines by the US Occupational Safety & Health Administration. The company, which contracted to collect and dispose of Omaha's residential trash, is accused of five violations. These include providing little or no chance for drivers and helpers to use the bathroom. OSHA discovered that some workers were using the back of compactors as toilets because company rules forbade them from taking breaks. According to OSHA, not only was this unsanitary, it was also life threatening because of the potential for activating the compactor while a worker was back of the truck. Additional allegations against Deffenbaugh include: poor guarding on the trucks' hydraulic systems, poor procedures ensuring the cutoff of power to equipment while being maintained, poor first-aid training for workers and inconsistent use of reflective vests by employees operating in heavy traffic. Deffenbaugh also faces a federal investigation of its hiring practices.” [Waste News, 2/3/97]

  • According To OSHA, Deffenbaugh Workers Using Trash Compactors As Toilets Was Both Unsanitary And Life Threatening To Workers. “OSHA discovered that some workers were using the back of compactors as toilets because company rules forbade them from taking breaks. According to OSHA, not only was this unsanitary, it was also life threatening because of the potential for activating the compactor while a worker was back of the truck. Additional allegations against Deffenbaugh include: poor guarding on the trucks' hydraulic systems, poor procedures ensuring the cutoff of power to equipment while being maintained, poor first-aid training for workers and inconsistent use of reflective vests by employees operating in heavy traffic. Deffenbaugh also faces a federal investigation of its hiring practices.” [Waste News, 2/3/97]

Waste News: Deffenbaugh Industries Inc Alleged Violations Included “Poor Guarding On The Trucks' Hydraulic Systems, Poor Procedures Ensuring The Cutoff Of Power To Equipment While Being Maintained, Poor First-Aid Training For Workers And Inconsistent Use Of Reflective Vests By Employees Operating In Heavy Traffic.” “Deffenbaugh Industries Inc (Shawnee, KS) is currently appealing $14,400 in proposed fines by the US Occupational Safety & Health Administration. The company, which contracted to collect and dispose of Omaha's residential trash, is accused of five violations. These include providing little or no chance for drivers and helpers to use the bathroom. OSHA discovered that some workers were using the back of compactors as toilets because company rules forbade them from taking breaks. According to OSHA, not only was this unsanitary, it was also life threatening because of the potential for activating the compactor while a worker was back of the truck. Additional allegations against Deffenbaugh include: poor guarding on the trucks' hydraulic systems, poor procedures ensuring the cutoff of power to equipment while being maintained, poor first-aid training for workers and inconsistent use of reflective vests by employees operating in heavy traffic. Deffenbaugh also faces a federal investigation of its hiring practices.” [Waste News, 2/3/97]

November 1997: Deffenbaugh Industries Reached A Formal Settlement With OSHA Where The Company’s Penalties Were Reduced From $14,400 To $4,700. [US Occupational Safety & Health Administration, accessed 12/16/25]

Image: see original report, p. 45

1997: The National Labor Relations Board Found Deffenbaugh Had Violated The National Labor Relations Act By Refusing To Bargain With Its Union

January 1997: Deffenbaugh Was Investigated By The National Labor Relations Board. “Councilman Paul Koneck accused the Mayor's Office of turning a blind eye to problems at Deffenbaugh. Besides problems with the INS, he said, Deffenbaugh has been investigated by OSHA and the National Labor Relations Board. ‘There has been a flagrant attempt by the administration to ignore these allegations,’ Koneck said. Harding, Daub's aide for economic development, denied those charges, saying the administration has been following a U.S. Justice Department investigation into Deffenbaugh. The mayor, Harding said, supports Christensen's resolution and plans to submit a report to the council within the required 90 days.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

  • NLRB: “The National Labor Relations Board […] Safeguard Employees' Rights To Organize And To Determine Whether To Have Unions As Their Bargaining Representative.” “The National Labor Relations Board is an independent federal agency vested with the power to safeguard employees' rights to organize and to determine whether to have unions as their bargaining representative. The agency also acts to prevent and

remedy unfair labor practices committed by private sector employers and unions.” [National Labor Relations Board, accessed 12/2/25]

  • NLRB: “The National Labor Relations Board […] Acts To Prevent And Remedy Unfair Labor Practices Committed By Private Sector Employers And Unions.” “The National Labor Relations Board is an independent federal agency vested with the power to safeguard employees' rights to organize and to determine whether to have unions as their bargaining representative. The agency also acts to prevent and remedy unfair labor practices committed by private sector employers and unions.” [National Labor Relations Board, accessed 12/2/25]

U.S. Court Of Appeals For The Eighth Circuit: “The National Labor Relations Board Found That Deffenbaugh Industries, Inc. Had Committed Unfair Labor Practices By Refusing To Bargain With […] The Collective Bargaining Representative Of Some Of Its Employees.” “The National Labor Relations Board found that Deffenbaugh Industries, Inc. had committed unfair labor practices by refusing to bargain with and furnish relevant information to the General Drivers & Helpers Union, Local No. 554, the collective bargaining representative of some of its employees. After the board issued an order requiring Deffenbaugh to bargain with the union, provide it necessary information, and post a notice to that effect, Deffenbaugh petitioned for review, requesting that the board's order be completely set aside. The board in turn filed a cross-application seeking enforcement of its order. We deny the petition and grant enforcement of the board's order.” [U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, Deffenbaugh Industries, Inc., Petitioner. VS National Labor Relations Board, et al., Filed 5/21/97]

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit: “The Board's General Counsel Then Issued An Unfair Labor Practice Complaint, Alleging That Deffenbaugh's Refusal To Bargain Or To Provide Requested Relevant Bargaining Information Violated Sections 8(a) (1) And (a) (5) Of The National Labor Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. §§ 158(a) (1) And (a) (5).” “The board's general counsel then issued an unfair labor practice complaint, alleging that Deffenbaugh's refusal to bargain or to provide requested relevant bargaining information violated sections 8(a) (1) and (a) (5) of the National Labor Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. §§ 158(a) (1) and (a) (5). Deffenbaugh admitted the factual allegations, but asserted that it had not violated the Act because the union's certification was not valid.2 The general counsel moved for summary judgment, and the board granted it, finding that Deffenbaugh had raised no new evidence or special circumstances requiring reexamination of the certification and that all of the certification issues had been or could have been litigated in the representation proceeding on the election. The board issued an order directing Deffenbaugh to cease refusing to bargain with the union, to furnish necessary and relevant information, to bargain upon request, and to post a remedial notice.” [U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, Deffenbaugh Industries, Inc., Petitioner. VS National Labor Relations Board, et al., Filed 5/21/97]

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit: “Deffenbaugh Admitted The Factual Allegations, But Asserted That It Had Not Violated The Act Because The Union's Certification Was Not Valid.” “The board's general counsel then issued an unfair labor practice complaint, alleging that Deffenbaugh's refusal to bargain or to provide requested relevant bargaining information violated sections 8(a) (1) and (a) (5) of the National Labor Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. §§ 158(a) (1) and (a) (5). Deffenbaugh admitted the factual allegations, but asserted that it had not violated the Act because the union's certification was not valid.2 The general counsel moved for summary judgment, and the board granted it, finding that Deffenbaugh had raised no new evidence or special circumstances requiring reexamination of the certification and that all of the certification issues had been or could have been litigated in the representation proceeding on the election. The board issued an order directing Deffenbaugh to cease refusing to bargain with the union, to furnish necessary and relevant information, to bargain upon request, and to post a remedial notice.” [U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, Deffenbaugh Industries, Inc., Petitioner. VS National Labor Relations Board, et al., Filed 5/21/97]

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit Ruled “Deffenbaugh Did Not Meet Its Burden Of Proving That What Occurred […] For These Reasons We Deny The Petition And Grant Enforcement Of The Board's Order.” “A careful review of the record shows that Deffenbaugh did not meet its burden of proving that what occurred in this election made an expression of free choice impossible. Deffenbaugh has not shown that the election environment was infused with coercion and intimidation. The board found, and Deffenbaugh does not contest, that there were no threats of physical violence and no vandalism or harassment in the pre-election period. Some statements about the INS were made, but far from the election date and not widely disseminated. Less weight is given to the impact of such statements […] Since Deffenbaugh has not shown the union should not have been certified and it admitted it refused to bargain with it and provide relevant information, the petition for review must be denied. The remedy the board fashioned is not outside its discretion, see Millard, 2 F.3d at 261, and the board is therefore entitled to enforcement of its order. Earle Inds., 999 F.2d at 1272. For these reasons we deny the petition and grant enforcement of the board's order.” [U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, Deffenbaugh Industries, Inc., Petitioner. VS National Labor Relations Board, et al., Filed 5/21/97]

  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit “Since Deffenbaugh Has Not Shown The Union Should Not Have Been Certified And It Admitted It Refused To Bargain With It And Provide Relevant Information, The Petition For Review Must Be Denied. The Remedy The Board Fashioned Is Not Outside Its Discretion.” “A careful review of the record shows that Deffenbaugh did not meet its burden of proving that what occurred in this election made an expression of free choice impossible. Deffenbaugh has not shown that the election environment was infused with coercion and intimidation. The board found, and Deffenbaugh does not contest, that there were no threats of physical violence and no vandalism or harassment in the pre-election period. Some statements about the INS were made, but far from the election date and not widely disseminated. Less weight is given to the impact of such statements […] Since Deffenbaugh has not shown the union should not have been certified and it admitted it refused to bargain with it and provide relevant information, the petition for review must be denied. The remedy the board fashioned is not outside its discretion, see Millard, 2 F.3d at 261, and the board is therefore entitled to enforcement of its order. Earle Inds., 999 F.2d at 1272. For these reasons we deny the petition and grant enforcement of the board's order.” [U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, Deffenbaugh Industries, Inc., Petitioner. VS National Labor Relations Board, et al., Filed 5/21/97]

1997: Deffenbaugh Was Reportedly Under Federal Investigation By The U.S. Justice Department

January 1997: According To A Omaha City Councilman, Deffenbaugh Was Reportedly Under U.S. Justice Department Investigation. “Councilman Paul Koneck accused the Mayor's Office of turning a blind eye to problems at Deffenbaugh. Besides problems with the INS, he said, Deffenbaugh has been investigated by OSHA and the National Labor Relations Board. ‘There has been a flagrant attempt by the administration to ignore these allegations,’ Koneck said. Harding, Daub's aide for economic development, denied those charges, saying the administration has been following a U.S. Justice Department investigation into Deffenbaugh. The mayor, Harding said, supports Christensen's resolution and plans to submit a report to the council within the required 90 days.” [Omaha World Herald, 1/15/97]

February 1997: Waste News Reported That Deffenbaugh Was Being Investigated At The Federal Level For Its Hiring Practices. “Deffenbaugh Industries Inc (Shawnee, KS) is currently appealing $14,400 in proposed fines by the US Occupational Safety & Health Administration. The company, which contracted to collect and dispose of Omaha's residential trash, is accused of five violations. These include providing little or no chance for drivers and helpers to use the bathroom. OSHA discovered that some workers were using the back of compactors as toilets because company rules forbade them from taking breaks. According to OSHA, not only was this unsanitary, it was also life threatening because of the potential for activating the compactor while a worker was back of the truck. Additional allegations against Deffenbaugh include: poor guarding on the trucks' hydraulic systems, poor procedures ensuring the cutoff of power to equipment while being maintained, poor first-aid training for workers and inconsistent use of reflective vests by employees operating in heavy traffic. Deffenbaugh also faces a federal investigation of its hiring practices.” [Waste News, 2/3/97]

Source report (PDF)