Brinker Harding: 2022: The Nebraska State Legislature Retirement Systems Committee Reported That The Omaha Civilian Pension Had The Lowest Funding Status Of Any Of The Public Pensions In Nebraska, And That The City Had Failed To Pay Millions Of Dollars In Its Annual Required Contributions To The Pension
November 2022: Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee Report Listed The Omaha Civilian Pension With Lowest Funding Status Of Any Of The Underfunded Public Pensions In Nebraska
LB 759 Required Reporting Of Underfunded Pensions To The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee If Their Contributions Did Not Equal The Actuarial Requirement For Funding Or The Funded Ratio Of The Plan Was Less Than 80%. “In 2014, LB 759 was enacted to require reporting by political subdivisions with underfunded defined benefit plans in order to provide oversight of these entities by the Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee. The bill was codified at Neb. Rev. Stat. 13-2402. It requires any governing entity that offers a defined benefit plan which was open to new employees on January 2004, to file a report with the Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee if the most recent actuarial valuation report indicates that (1) the contributions do not equal the actuarial requirement for funding or (2) the funded ratio of the plan is less than eighty percent. The report must include, at a minimum, an analysis of the future benefit changes, contribution changes, or other proposed corrective action to improve the plan's funding condition.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee Report: The Omaha Civilian Pension Had The Lowest Funding Status Of Any Of The Underfunded Public Pensions In Nebraska In 2020/2021 And 2021/2022. “In 2021, there were eight political subdivisions with defined benefit plans funded below the 80% funding level. This year, the Eastern Nebraska Health Agency Plan increased its funding level to 81% and Lincoln Police and Fire increased its funding level to 80%, so they were not required to report this year. Below is a list of the six political subdivisions with defined benefit plans that remain funded below 80% and a summary of the 2020/2021 and 2021/2022 funding status for each plan: Douglas County Employees, Metro Area Transit Hourly Employees, Omaha Civilian Employees, Omaha Police and Fire, Omaha Public Power District, Omaha Public Schools – Omaha School Employees Retirement.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
Image: see original report, p. 18
- November 2022: The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee Report Listed The Omaha Civilian Pension’s 2020/2021 Funding Status At 52.4%. “In 2021, there were eight political subdivisions with defined benefit plans funded below the 80% funding level. This year, the Eastern Nebraska Health Agency Plan increased its funding level to 81% and Lincoln Police and Fire increased its funding level to 80%, so they were not required to report this year. Below is a list of the six political subdivisions with defined benefit plans that remain funded below 80% and a summary of the 2020/2021 and 2021/2022 funding status for each plan: Douglas County Employees, Metro Area Transit Hourly Employees, Omaha Civilian Employees, Omaha Police and Fire, Omaha Public Power District, Omaha Public Schools – Omaha School Employees Retirement.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
Image: see original report, p. 18
- November 2022: The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee Report Listed The Omaha Civilian Pension’s 2021/2022 Funding Status At 53.7%. “In 2021, there were eight political subdivisions with defined benefit plans funded below the 80% funding level. This year, the Eastern Nebraska Health Agency Plan increased its funding level to 81% and Lincoln Police and Fire increased its funding level to 80%, so they were not required to report this year. Below is a list of the six political subdivisions with defined benefit plans that remain funded below 80% and a summary of the 2020/2021 and 2021/2022 funding status for each plan: Douglas County Employees, Metro Area Transit Hourly Employees, Omaha Civilian Employees, Omaha Police and Fire, Omaha Public Power District, Omaha Public Schools – Omaha School Employees Retirement.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
Image: see original report, p. 18
NOTE: The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee calculated the funding status using Unfunded Actuarial Liability (UAL), which is a different method from the calculation listed in the Omaha Civilian Pension’s reports cited in the section above. Additionally, the Retirement Systems Committee calculated funding status based on data between January 1, 2022 and October 21, 2022, rather than the whole year.
November 2022: The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee Report Found That Between 2017 And 2021 The City of Omaha Failed To Pay More Than $7.5 Million Of Its Full Annual Required Contributions Into The Omaha Civilian Pension
National Association of State Retirement Administrators: “The Annual Required Contribution, Or ARC, Refers To The Amount Needed To Be Contributed By Employers To Adequately Fund A Public Pension Plan.” “The annual required contribution, or ARC, refers to the amount needed to be contributed by employers to adequately fund a public pension plan. The ARC is the sum of two factors: a) the cost of pension benefits being accrued in the current year (known as the normal cost), plus b) the cost to amortize, or pay off, the plan’s unfunded liability. The ARC is the required employer contribution after accounting for other revenue, chiefly expected investment earnings and contributions from employee participants.” [National Association of State Retirement Administrators, March 2015]
Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee Report: “The Percentage Of The ARC The City Of Omaha Has Paid Over The Past 5 Years Has Declined […] The City Has Paid -$7.573 Million Less Than The Full Amount Of The ARC Between 2017 Through 2021.” “The percentage of the ARC the City of Omaha has paid over the past 5 years has declined. In 2016, the City of Omaha paid 106.81% […] The City has paid -$7.573 million less than the full amount of the ARC between 2017 through 2021. No more recent data is available. Last year the Unfunded Actuarial Liability decreased slightly from $230.2 million to $229 million.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
- In 2017, The City Of Omaha Paid 91.2% Of Its Annual Required Contribution. “The percentage of the ARCs that you pay, the actuarially required contributions over the last five years has continually declined. In 2016, you paid 106.81 percent, but then in 2010-- 2017, you paid 91.2 percent of the ARC. In 2018, you paid 86.8 percent and in 2019, you paid 87.4 and last year you paid 88.24 percent of the ARC. We don't have this year's yet. And your unfunded actuarial liability actually decreased slightly from $230 to $229 million.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
- In 2018, The City Of Omaha Paid 86.8% Of Its Annual Required Contribution. “The percentage of the ARCs that you pay, the actuarially required contributions over the last five years has continually declined. In 2016, you paid 106.81 percent, but then in 2010-- 2017, you paid 91.2 percent of the ARC. In 2018, you paid 86.8 percent and in 2019, you paid 87.4 and last year you paid 88.24 percent of the ARC. We don't have this year's yet. And your unfunded actuarial liability actually decreased slightly from $230 to $229 million.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
- In 2019, The City Of Omaha Paid 87.4% Of Its Annual Required Contribution. “The percentage of the ARCs that you pay, the actuarially required contributions over the last five years has continually declined. In 2016, you paid 106.81 percent, but then in 2010-- 2017, you paid 91.2 percent of the ARC. In 2018, you paid 86.8 percent and in 2019, you paid 87.4 and last year you paid 88.24 percent of the ARC. We don't have this year's yet. And your unfunded actuarial liability actually decreased slightly from $230 to $229 million.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
November 2022: The Republican Chair Of The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee Questioned The Management Of The Omaha Civilian Pension And Called Its Underfunding “A Blatant Disrespect For The Employees As Well As The Citizens Of Omaha”
State Senator Mark Kolterman Was The Republican Chair Of The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee
Senator Mark Kolterman Was The Chair Of The Nebraska Retirement Systems Committee. “Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans Committee Members Senator Mark Kolterman, Chair Senator Brett Lindstrom, Vice-Chair Senator Robert Clements Senator Mike McDonnell Senator Julie Slama Senator John Stinner Kate Allen, Committee Legal Counsel Katie Quintero, Committee Clerk.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
- Senator Mark Kolterman Was A Registered Republican. “Accusations of partisanship also surfaced when Sen. Mark Kolterman of Seward was objecting to Linehan’s proposal to move his district, which has been growing slowly, to fast-growing Sarpy County and Saunders County. Kolterman, a registered Republican, objected to the fact that the state Republican Party sent out an email in favor of Linehan’s plan, ‘I told you earlier I’ve been a Republican my entire life. This year it’ll be 50 years. But when I took the oath of office, I didn’t take it to serve the Republican Party. I was elected by the residents of District 24 to serve the state of Nebraska,’ Kolterman said.” [Nebraska Public Media, 9/15/21]
State Senator Kolterman Said That Legislators Had Asked For Funding Level Improvements For The Omaha Civilian Pension Plan “For [The] Last Seven Years” And That Consultants Had Warned The City That They “Were Going To Run Out Of Money” If They Did Not Make Minimum ARC Payments
Senator Kolterman On The Underfunded Status Of The Omaha Civilian Pension Plan: “It's Almost Like Everything We've Asked For Last Seven Years Has Fallen On Deaf Ears.” “The progress of making Omaha employees' pension plans fully funded draws the ire of one state senator. ‘It's almost like everything we've asked for last seven years has fallen on deaf ears,’ said State Sen. Mark Kolterman. Omaha's police and fire retirement system is currently funded at 57.5%. Its plan for civilians is funded at 53.7%. But Kolterman said Omaha has not been making the suggested minimum annual contributions to catch up in the past five years. ‘The people in the pension plan deserve to know the plan going to be funded,’ Kolterman said.” [KETV, 11/23/22]
Senator Kolterman: “Cavanaugh Macdonald Had Indicated, That You, You Were Going To Run Out Of Money If You Didn't Make Those ARC Payments […] That's Just The Minimum Amount That You Should Be Making.” “But, but my concern is-- and this is exactly what we saw with the Omaha Public Schools plan, they weren't making their ARC payments. And that, that's what's-- I mean, if you go back to 2014, that's what Cavanaugh Macdonald had indicated, that you, you were going to run out of money if you didn't make those ARC payments. And that's, that's just the minimum amount that you should be making. The other thing that we've heard for the-- at least since I've chaired this committee the last seven years is that you couldn't put more money in than an equal amount to what the, the employees were putting in because of your charter.” [Nebraska Legislature Retirement Systems Committee, Report on Political Subdivision Underfunded Defined Benefit Retirement Plans, 11/22/22]
- NC League Of Municipalities: “Cavanaugh Macdonald Consulting, D/B/A CavMac Was Founded To Offer State And Local Governments Actuarial Consulting Services For Their Employee Pension And Benefit Plans.” “Cavanaugh Macdonald Consulting, D/B/A CavMac was founded to offer state and local governments actuarial consulting services for their employee pension and benefit plans. Our capabilities are well recognized by the public sector benefit plan community. Cavanaugh Macdonald Consulting, LLC provides a broad range of actuarial consulting services to the public sector. We currently serve as the retained actuary and health care consultant for statewide and municipal retirement systems and retiree health care plans across the country from our two locations in Omaha, NE and Atlanta, GA.” [NC League Of Municipalities, accessed 12/10/25]
Senator Kolterman: “The People In The Pension Plan Deserve To Know The Plan [Is] Going To Be Funded.” “The progress of making Omaha employees' pension plans fully funded draws the ire of one state senator. ‘It's almost like everything we've asked for last seven years has fallen on deaf ears,’ said State Sen. Mark Kolterman. Omaha's police and fire retirement system is currently funded at 57.5%. Its plan for civilians is funded at 53.7%. But Kolterman said Omaha has not been making the suggested minimum annual contributions to catch up in the past five years. ‘The people in the pension plan deserve to know the plan going to be funded,’ Kolterman said.” [KETV, 11/23/22]
State Senator Kolterman Questioned Why Designated Tax Revenue Was Not Closing The Gap On Pension Plan Funding
KETV: “Kolterman Wanted To Know Why Omaha Isn't Using The Restaurant Tax It Imposed 12 Years Ago To Close The Gap.” “Kolterman wanted to know why Omaha isn't using the restaurant tax it imposed 12 years ago to close the gap. ‘It was my understanding that was designed to take care of the pension plan,’ Kolterman said. ‘What are you doing with the excess money that's coming from the restaurant tax? Is that going into the general fund?’ According to Deputy City Attorney Bernard in den Bosch, the Omaha Charter limits the amount the city can pay annually to only the amount matched by employee contributions. The city is currently in the process of reviewing the charter but that change is not being considered. ‘It doesn't make any sense to me,’ Kolterman said. ‘I think the citizens in Omaha need to understand what's going on here. I think it's a blatant disrespect for the employees as well as the citizens of Omaha,’ Kolterman said.” [KETV, 11/23/22]
- Senator Kolterman: “It Was My Understanding That [Restaurant Tax] Was Designed To Take Care Of The Pension Plan […] What Are You Doing With The Excess Money That's Coming From The Restaurant Tax?” “Kolterman wanted to know why Omaha isn't using the restaurant tax it imposed 12 years ago to close the gap. ‘It was my understanding that was designed to take care of the pension plan,’ Kolterman said. ‘What are you doing with the excess money that's coming from the restaurant tax? Is that going into the general fund?’ According to Deputy City Attorney Bernard in den Bosch, the Omaha Charter limits the amount the city can pay annually to only the amount matched by employee contributions. The city is currently in the process of reviewing the charter but that change is not being considered. ‘It doesn't make any sense to me,’ Kolterman said. ‘I think the citizens in Omaha need to understand what's going on here. I think it's a blatant disrespect for the employees as well as the citizens of Omaha,’ Kolterman said.” [KETV, 11/23/22]
The City Of Omaha Responded That The City Was Limited By The Charter To Pay Annually Only The Amount Matched By Employee Contributions, Yet At The Same Time Admitted They Were Not Planning To Change The Charter
The Deputy City Attorney Said The Omaha Charter Limits The Amount The City Can Pay Annually To Only The Amount Matched By Employee Contributions. “Kolterman wanted to know why Omaha isn't using the restaurant tax it imposed 12 years ago to close the gap. ‘It was my understanding that was designed to take care of the pension plan,’ Kolterman said. ‘What are you doing with the excess money that's coming from the restaurant tax? Is that going into the general fund?’ According to Deputy City Attorney Bernard in den Bosch, the Omaha Charter limits the amount the city can pay annually to only the amount matched by employee contributions. The city is currently in the process of reviewing the charter but that change is not being considered. ‘It doesn't make any sense to me,’ Kolterman said. ‘I think the citizens in Omaha need to understand what's going on here. I think it's a blatant disrespect for the employees as well as the citizens of Omaha,’ Kolterman said.” [KETV, 11/23/22]
- 2022: According To The Deputy City Attorney, Omaha Was Currently In The Process Of Reviewing The Charter But Was Not Considering A Change To The Limits On City Contributions. “Kolterman wanted to know why Omaha isn't using the restaurant tax it imposed 12 years ago to close the gap. ‘It was my understanding that was designed to take care of the pension plan,’ Kolterman said. ‘What are you doing with the excess money that's coming from the restaurant tax? Is that going into the general fund?’ According to Deputy City Attorney Bernard in den Bosch, the Omaha Charter limits the amount the city can pay annually to only the amount matched by employee contributions. The city is currently in the process of reviewing the charter but that change is not being considered. ‘It doesn't make any sense to me,’ Kolterman said. ‘I think the citizens in Omaha need to understand what's going on here. I think it's a blatant disrespect for the employees as well as the citizens of Omaha,’ Kolterman said.” [KETV, 11/23/22]
- Harding Previously Served As Chairman Of The 2013 Omaha Charter Review Convention. “Name Brinker Harding Occupation Senior Vice President at Colliers International […] Prior to being elected to the Omaha City Council in 2017, I served as the Chairman of the Omaha Planning Board, Chairman of the 2013 Charter review Convention, Campaign Manager for Hal Daub’s 2009 campaign, and as Chief of Staff to Mayor Hal Daub.” [Omaha Daily Record, 8/16/22]
- KPTM: “Any Amendments To The Charter Must Be Approved By Convention Members And The Omaha City Council.” “A Charter study convention will meet next month to consider amendments to the City Charter. The Convention, which was last held in 2013, requires an extensive citizen-led review of the Charter at least every 10 years. Any amendments to the Charter must be approved by convention members and the Omaha city council. Approved amendments will then appear on this November's ballot for public vote.” [KPTM, 4/6/22]
State Senator Kolterman Said That The Underfunding Of The Omaha Pension Plan Was “A Blatant Disrespect For The Employees As Well As The Citizens Of Omaha”
Senator Kolterman: “It Doesn't Make Any Sense To Me […] I Think The Citizens In Omaha Need To Understand What's Going On Here. I Think It's A Blatant Disrespect For The Employees As Well As The Citizens Of Omaha.” “Kolterman wanted to know why Omaha isn't using the restaurant tax it imposed 12 years ago to close the gap. ‘It was my understanding that was designed to take care of the pension plan,’ Kolterman said. ‘What are you doing with the excess money that's coming from the restaurant tax? Is that going into the general fund?’ According to Deputy City Attorney Bernard in den Bosch, the Omaha Charter limits the amount the city can pay annually to only the amount matched by employee contributions. The city is currently in the process of reviewing the charter but that change is not being considered. ‘It doesn't make any sense to me,’ Kolterman said. ‘I think the citizens in Omaha need to understand what's going on here. I think it's a blatant disrespect for the employees as well as the citizens of Omaha,’ Kolterman said.” [KETV, 11/23/22]