The One Big Beautiful Bill Was Estimated To Cut More Than $100 Million In Hospital Revenue In Mike Lawler’s District And Forced Hudson Valley Hospitals To Enact Mass Layoffs

The Hudson Valley Examiner Reported That Lawler’s Vote For The Big Beautiful Bill Could Cause Local Hospitals To Lose Over $100 Million In Revenue, Sparking Backlash From Hospital Officials

Hudson Valley Examiner News Headline: “Lawler Faces Scrutiny As Medicaid Cuts Threaten Local Hospitals.” [Examiner News, 9/17/25]

Examiner News Reported That Lawler’s Vote For The “Big Beautiful Bill” Could Cause Hospitals To Lose More Than $100 Million In Revenue. “Area lawmakers are warning that Medicaid cuts stemming from the enactment of President Donald Trump’s so-called ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ could put hospitals in the Hudson Valley under severe pressure, potentially forcing service reductions and driving more residents to emergency rooms. The legislation has also drawn scrutiny of local Republican Rep. Mike Lawler’s vote, with Democratic-aligned groups highlighting his earlier statements opposing Medicaid cuts. Although exact figures are hard to project, Northern Westchester Hospital could lose $5.8 million in Medicaid revenue and Phelps Hospital $6.5 million, part of more than $100 million in cuts projected across Hudson Valley hospitals, according to estimates from the center-left think tank Third Way.” [Examiner News, 9/17/25]

President Of Northwell Health’s Northern Westchester Hospital Derek Anderson On The Bill: “We’re In Probably One Of The Biggest Fights In Our Lives That We’ve Seen In Healthcare In A Very Long Time.” “A spokesperson for Northwell Health declined The Examiner’s request for comment and directed questions about the projected cuts and their impact to the Greater New York Hospital Association (GNYHA). When reached, the GNYHA also declined an interview request. However, this past spring, on Examiner Media’s weekly podcast Local Matters Westchester, Derek Anderson, president of Northwell Health’s Northern Westchester Hospital, discussed the gravity of the pending bill. ‘We’re in probably one of the biggest fights in our lives that we’ve seen in healthcare in a very long time,’ he said. ‘Those who have been in healthcare 30, 40 years have never seen anything quite like this.’” [Examiner News, 9/17/25]

  • Anderson: The Big Beautiful Bill “Really Could Have Devastating Effects” On Northwell Health’s Hospital. “‘If you look at Northwell Health in totality, we operate on a 1 percent margin,’ Anderson explained in May on the podcast. ‘This particular proposed legislation really could have devastating effects.’ Anderson also said important programs could face major challenges.” [Examiner News, 9/17/25]

Examiner News: “The Cuts Are Likely To Exacerbate The Financial Strain Hospitals Already Navigate.” “The cuts are likely to exacerbate the financial strain hospitals already navigate. A local legislative office said that 70 hospitals in New York currently earn a quarter of total patient revenue through government funding, including Medicaid. With just a 10 percent cut to Medicaid revenue, 94 out of New York’s 156 hospitals are expected to see their annual profits erode entirely.” [Examiner News, 9/17/25]

Examiner News: The Big Beautiful Bill’s Medicaid Cuts “Are Expected To Eliminate More Than 78,000 Healthcare Jobs.” “In terms of employment, Medicaid reductions are expected to eliminate more than 78,000 healthcare jobs, leading to an additional 136,000 jobs lost through an economic ripple effect, according to a local legislative office. This loss accounts for over 2 percent of New York State’s workforce. The office said $14.4 billion will be lost in hospital-generated economic activity as a result, weakening the state’s economy.” [Examiner News, 9/17/25]

Lawler’s District Was Expected To See $103,712,756.09 In Cuts To Hospital Revenue As A Result Of The Big Beautiful Bill

The Big Beautiful Bill Would Cost Hospitals In Lawler’s District More Than $103,712,756.09 In Lost Revenue. [Third Way, 7/8/25]

Third Way: Projected Revenue Cuts To Hospitals In NY-17 As A Result Of The Big Beautiful Bill

Hospital Name

Address

Projected Revenue Cut

Westchester Medical Center

100 Woods Rd, Valhalla, 10595

$67,006,423.09

Montefiore Nyack Hospital

160 North Midland Avenue, Nyack, 10960

$9,614,690.55

Good Samaritan Hospital

255 Lafayette Avenue, Suffern, 10901

$8,135,233.55

Phelps Memorial Hospital Center

701 North Broadway, Sleepy Hollow, 10591

$6,511,036.57

Northern Westchester Hospital

400 East Main Street, Mount Kisco, 10549

$5,781,646.50

New York Presbyterian Hudson Valley

1980 Crompond Road, Cortlandt Manor, 10567

$4,834,870.84

Putnam Hospital Center

670 Stoneleigh Ave, Carmel, 10512

$1,828,854.99

Total:

$103,712,756.09

[Third Way, 7/8/25]

Hospitals In The Hudson Valley Were Already Cutting Essential Services And Staff In Anticipation Of The Big Beautiful Bill’s Cuts

Mid Hudson News Headline: “Garnet Health Cuts Programs; Lays Off 42.” [Mid Hudson News, 6/18/25]

June 2025: Garnet Health Medical Center Announced It Would Be Laying Off 42 Employees And Eliminating Various Outpatients Programs, Citing Anticipated Federal Medicaid Cuts. “TOWN OF WALLKILL – Noting a challenging healthcare climate, shrinking federal reimbursements and anticipated federal cuts to Medicaid, Garnet Health Medical Center announced late Tuesday that it was laying off 42 employees and eliminating the underutilized outpatients pulmonary rehabilitation service at Garnet Health Medical Center in the Town of Wallkill and outpatient diabetes services at both Garnet Health Center and Garnet Health Medical Center – Catskills.” [Mid Hudson News, 6/18/25]

  • Garnet Health President And CEO Jonathan Schiller Said The Layoffs Were “The Direct Result Of Diminishing Federal Reimbursement And Cuts.” “‘Without question, the healthcare climate continues to be challenging, with no immediate signs of reprieve,’ said Garnet Health President and CEO Jonathan Schiller. […] ‘I share this news with a deep and personal sadness,’ said Schiller. ‘This restructuring and reduction in force is in no way about the performance of individuals. Instead, it is the direct result of diminishing federal reimbursement and cuts impacting Garnet Health’s current and projected financial sustainability.’” [Mid Hudson News, 6/18/25]

Source report (PDF)