2022: Peter Oberacker Voted Against A Bill Capping Outside Income For State Legislators That Would Impact The Legislature’s Top Private Earners, Including Peter Oberacker
December 2022: Oberacker Voted Against A Bill That Capped New York Lawmakers’ Outside Income To $35,000 A Year In An Attempt To Limit Conflicts Of Interest
December 2022: Oberacker Voted Against S9617. In December 2022 Oberacker voted against S9617: “Increases the salary of members of the legislature to one hundred forty-two thousand dollars per annum; limits the outside earned income by such members; provides that an intentional violation of outside income provisions is a class A misdemeanor.” The bill passed the Senate (33-23) and was signed by Governor Hochul. [New York State Senate, S9617, 12/22/22]
- S9617 Raised State Legislators’ Pay To $142,000 Per Year But Capped Their Outside Income To $35,000 Per Year. “S9617/A10730 created new pay and income rules for lawmakers, raising their annual pay to $142,000 while capping extra earnings. Lawmakers seem to approve of this aspect of the law. But it also restricted outside income from fees or services to $35,000 a year, a number taken from the existing cap on income for retired individuals in public service. The law covers wages, fees, and other payments for services lawmakers perform outside of their official work. Some earnings do not count, like income from state pay, military service, royalties, pensions, investments, family business earnings, or pay from before January 2025 or before taking office.” [ABC News, 3/19/25]
- Outside Income Was Defined As “Wages, Salaries, Fees And Other Forms Of Compensation For Services Actually Rendered.” “For purposes of this section, the term 'outside earned income' shall mean wages, salaries, fees and other forms of compensation for services actually rendered.” [New York State Legislative Ethics Commission, accessed 2/27/26]
- The Outside Income Cap Exempted Pension Plans, Military Compensation, Investments And Capital Gains, And Income From Family Businesses. “Even with the law in place, legislators in New York could still legally make more than $177,000 per year ($142,000 plus $35,000). The bill carved out several income exemptions, like: Compensation for service in the armed forces Royalties for copyrights and patents Disbursements from retirement and pension plans Investments and capital gains Income from a family business Delayed compensation from before being sworn in.” [ABC News, 7/22/24]
Times Union: The Outside Income Cap Was Intended To “Reduce Conflicts Of Interest And The Appearance Of Any Impropriety Connected With Outside Employment.” “The measure, which amended state Legislative Law, was enacted in conjunction with increasing their annual governmental salaries by $32,000 to $142,000. The bill passed in the Senate by a vote of 33-23 and in the Assembly 84-47. It was intended, in part, to reduce conflicts of interest and the appearance of any impropriety connected with outside employment.” [Times Union, 3/18/25]
2023: New York State Focus Identified Oberacker As One Of The “Top Private Earners” In The New York Legislature And Determined His Outside Income Would Exceed The Legislative Income Cap In 2025
New York State Focus Identified Oberacker As One Of The “Top Private Earners” In The New York Legislature
New York State Focus Headline: “Meet the Top Private Earners Among New York Lawmakers.” [NYS Focus, 3/11/23]
2023: New York State Focus Identified Oberacker As One Of The “Top Private Earners” In The New York Legislature And Determined His Outside Income Would Exceed The Legislative Income Cap In 2025. Oberacker was included in a list of the New York Legislature’s “top private earners,” based on 2021 personal financial disclosures provided to the NYS Commission on Ethics and Lobbying. [NYS Focus, 3/11/23]
Image: see original report, p. 63
New York State Focus Determined Oberacker’s Outside Income Would Exceed The Legislative Income Cap In 2025
2023: New York State Focus Determined Oberacker’s Outside Income Would Exceed The Legislative Income Cap In 2025. Oberacker was included in a list of the New York Legislature’s “top private earners,” based on 2021 personal financial disclosures provided to the NYS Commission on Ethics and Lobbying. [NYS Focus, 3/11/23]
Image: see original report, p. 63
The Majority Of Legislators Whose Outside Income Exceeded The Cap Were Republicans
City & State New York: Republican Lawmakers Made Up A Majority Of Legislators Whose Outside Income Exceeded The Cap. “But the state judge made a final decision earlier this month, ruling that the outside income limit is in fact constitutional. That now places members who draw big paychecks outside of their legislative work in a bind – leave office, or give up their lucrative other jobs. […] Although Republicans brought the lawsuit, and make up the majority of legislators who have outside income above the limit, some Democrats will have to make a decision as well.” [City & State New York, 3/19/25]
Republicans Sued To Block The Outside Income Cap, Then Agreed To A Settlement With Democrats To Delay Its Enforcement For Two Years As Legal Challenges Played Out
August 2023: New York Republicans Filed A Federal Lawsuit To Block The Outside Income Cap, Arguing It Was Unconstitutional And Disenfranchised Voters. “The pay raise also came with a cap on outside income. The measure, meant to curb corruption, did not sit well with a number of lawmakers. Starting in 2025, members of the state Legislature won’t be allowed to make more than $35,000 from other jobs they may hold. In response, 10 sitting lawmakers filed a federal lawsuit to block the raise and income cap, arguing that it’s unconstitutional and disenfranchises voters.” [City & State New York, 8/9/23]
March 2025: A Judge Ruled The Outside Income Cap Was Constitutional, Which Republicans Appealed. “The last-minute decision was prompted by a March 6 decision by state Supreme Court Justice Alison J. Napolitano, who ruled that the law limiting the outside income of state lawmakers is constitutional, leaving dozens of members of the Legislature with the decision to leave public office or give up their private-sector incomes. Although Republican leaders have appealed the judge’s ruling, the state solicitor general recently filed a motion asking an appellate court to lift a temporary stay of the law that Napolitano had granted in the wake of her decision.” [Times Union, 5/6/25]
- Times Union Headline: “‘Chaos’ After Judge Upholds Law Limiting Outside Income For NY Lawmakers.” [Times Union, 3/18/25]
May 2025: New York State Legislators Reached An Agreement To Delay Enforcement Of The Outside Income Cap For Two Years. “Dozens of state legislators whose outside income exceeds the $35,000 annual limit that was supposed to take effect in January are being provided a last-minute escape hatch as legislative leaders have included a provision in the state budget delaying enforcement of the law for two years. […] The last-minute decision was prompted by a March 6 decision by state Supreme Court Justice Alison J. Napolitano, who ruled that the law limiting the outside income of state lawmakers is constitutional, leaving dozens of members of the Legislature with the decision to leave public office or give up their private-sector incomes. Although Republican leaders have appealed the judge’s ruling, the state solicitor general recently filed a motion asking an appellate court to lift a temporary stay of the law that Napolitano had granted in the wake of her decision.” [Times Union, 5/6/25]
- Times Union: “The Uncertainty Over Whether An Appeals Court Will Lift The Stay And Allow The Commission On Ethics And Lobbying In Government To Penalize Legislators Who Are Violating The Law Hastened The Negotiations.” “After Napolitano’s ruling, state lawmakers on both sides of the aisle began privately discussing the prospect of negotiating a two-year delay for the effective date of the law. The uncertainty over whether an appeals court will lift the stay and allow the Commission on Ethics and Lobbying in Government to penalize legislators who are violating the law hastened the negotiations.” [Times Union, 5/6/25]