Peter Oberacker: The One Big Beautiful Bill Was Projected To Slash More Than $33.5 Million In Revenue To NY-19 Area Hospitals, And One NY-19 Hospital Terminated Outpatient Diabetes Services Due To Federal Cuts

The One Big Beautiful Bill Was Projected To Cut More Than $33.5 Million In Revenue To Hospitals In NY-19

Under The One Big Beautiful Bill, Hospitals In NY-19 Were Projected To Lose $33,572,929 As A Result Of Medicaid Cuts Enacted In The One Big Beautiful Bill. [Third Way, GOP Medicaid Cuts Will Decimate Hospitals Nationwide, 7/8/25]

Projected Cuts To NY-19 Hospital Revenue From Medicaid Cuts In The One Big Beautiful Bill

Hospital

City

Projected Cut To Hospital Revenue

Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital

Cooperstown

$11,099,350

Our Lady Of Lourdes Memorial Hospital

Binghamton

$8,375,515

Columbia Memorial Hospital

Hudson

$3,952,320

Garnet Health Medical Center - Catskills

Harris

$2,786,189

Chenango Memorial Hospital

Norwich

$2,562,315

Aurelia Osborn Fox Memorial Hospital

Oneonta

$1,889,981

Delaware Valley Hospital

Walton

$922,355

Ellenville Regional Hospital

Ellenville

$819,571

Margaretville Hospital

Margaretville

$518,182

O’Connor Hospital

Delhi

$460,350

Garnet Health Medical Center - Catskills

Callicoon

$186,801

TOTAL:

$33,572,929

[Third Way, GOP Medicaid Cuts Will Decimate Hospitals Nationwide, 7/8/25]

The One Big Beautiful Bill Threatened The Closure Of Vital Rural Hospitals, And Garnet Health Medical Center-Catskills In NY-19 Terminated Its Outpatient Diabetes Services Due To Federal Cuts

The One Big Beautiful Bill’s Cuts To Medicaid Would Result In A $50.4 Billion Reduction In Funding For Rural Hospitals Nationwide

Under The One Big Beautiful Bill, Rural Hospitals Would Collectively Lose More Than $1.8 Billion In Funding, Which Would Be Equivalent To 21,000 Full-Time Hospital Employees’ Salaries. “Hospitals in rural areas would collectively lose more than $1.8 billion with a 15% cut to Medicaid. That loss in revenue is roughly equivalent to 21,000 full-time hospital employees’ salaries. Rural hospitals’ margins have been deteriorating for 10 to 15 years, said Michael Topchik, executive director for the Chartis Center for Rural Health, which analyzes and consults on rural hospital finances. Ten years ago, about one-third of rural hospitals were operating in the red. That’s closer to 50% now, he said.” [KFF, 6/12/25]

  • American Hospital Association: The One Big Beautiful Bill Would Result In A $50.4 Billion Reduction In Spending For Rural Hospitals Over The Next Ten Years. “Medicaid, which covers over 16 million people in rural communities, helps address barriers to health care and sustain rural hospitals. But many in Congress are considering Medicaid cuts that would have a devastating impact on rural hospitals and patients. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (H.R. 1) would result in 1.8 million individuals in rural communities losing their Medicaid coverage by 2034. In addition, select Medicaid provisions in H.R. 1 would result in a $50.4 billion reduction in federal Medicaid spending on rural hospitals over 10 years.” [American Hospital Association, 6/16/25]

The One Big Beautiful Bill Threatened To Force The Closure Of Garnet Health Medical Center-Catskills, A Rural Hospital In NY-19

2025: Garnet Health Medical Center-Catskills, A Rural Hospital In NY-19, Was Listed As At-Risk Based On Financial Vulnerability. “In order to understand in greater detail how rural communities could be impacted by health care cuts contained in the reconciliation package, we requested the attached data from the Sheps Center on the financial vulnerability of rural hospitals and potential impacts on their viability. These hospitals have been identified as at-risk hospitals based on financial data, including: whether the hospital has been unprofitable for the last three years; whether the hospital is at risk of financial distress relative to peer hospitals; and whether the hospital serves a disproportionately high share of Medicaid patients. The findings demonstrate that hundreds of rural hospitals across the country would feel pain from the House-passed reconciliation bill.” [Office of Senator Edward J. Markey, Letter on Rural Hospitals, 6/12/25]

2025: At-Risk Rural Hospitals In NY-19

Hospital

City

Top Medicaid Provider

Three Consecutive Years Of Negative Margins

Garnet Health Medical Center - Catskills

Harris

Yes

No

[Office of Senator Edward J. Markey, At-Risk Rural Hospitals List, 6/12/25]

Garnet Health Medical Center-Catskills In Sullivan County Ended Outpatient Diabetes Services Due To Federal Cuts And Garnet’s CEO And President Said They Were Faced With “Very Difficult Decisions” As A Result Of Anticipated Federal Cuts To Medicaid

June 2025: Garnet President And CEO: “Due To Shrinking Federal Reimbursements, As Well As Additional Anticipated Federal Cuts To The Medicaid Program, We Are Faced Once Again With Very Difficult Decisions.” “‘Without question, the healthcare climate continues to be challenging, with no immediate signs of reprieve,’ Garnet President and CEO Jonathan Schiller said. ‘And due to shrinking federal reimbursements, as well as additional anticipated federal cuts to the Medicaid program, we are faced once again with very difficult decisions.’” [Spectrum News1, 6/18/25]

June 2025: Garnet Health Medical Center-Catskills In Sullivan County Terminated Outpatient Diabetes Services And The Garnet System Laid Off 42 Employees Due In Part To Federal Cuts. “The Hudson Valley-based Garnet Health system on Wednesday announced job cuts and restructuring moves, citing tough choices brought on, in part, by federal cuts. Forty-two employees will lose their jobs as the company ceases offering outpatient pulmonary rehabilitation and diabetes services at Garnet Health Medical Center in Middletown and outpatient diabetes services at Garnet Health Medical Center - Catskills in Callicoon, Sullivan County, the company said in a statement. […] Garnet President and CEO Jonathan Schiller said. ‘And due to shrinking federal reimbursements, as well as additional anticipated federal cuts to the Medicaid program, we are faced once again with very difficult decisions.” [Spectrum News1, 6/18/25]

  • Sullivan County Health Chair: “[The Service] Helps Diabetics Learn How To Manage Their Diabetes, Which Cuts Down On Emergency Room Trips And Further Medical Interventions And Medications.” “Sullivan County Health Chair and District 5 Legislator, Cat Scott, said that these abrupt decisions are ‘very concerning’ for county residents. […] ‘[The service] helps diabetics learn how to manage their diabetes, which cuts down on emergency room trips and further medical interventions and medications,’ said Scott.” [WJFF Radio Catskill, 6/19/25]
  • Sullivan County’s Health Chair Said The Cuts To Garnet’s Outpatient Diabetes Services Were “Very Concerning” Given The “Aging Population” Of The County Which “Does Not Have Economic Advantages Or Privilege” To Travel Farther For Health Care. “Sullivan County Health Chair and District 5 Legislator, Cat Scott, said that these abrupt decisions are ‘very concerning’ for county residents. ‘We have an aging population. We have a population that does not have economic advantages or privilege, so traveling further for healthcare is not necessarily an option or it is a hardship,’ said Scott. ‘These are folks who can’t take the day off. They don’t have unlimited paid time off to go further for healthcare.’ While Garnet Health stated in a press statement that these programs were being cut due to ‘consistent underutilization,’ Scott said that she recently had a conversation with a practitioner who refers several people a week to Garnet Health’s diabetic outpatient trainings. ‘[The service] helps diabetics learn how to manage their diabetes, which cuts down on emergency room trips and further medical interventions and medications,’ said Scott.” [WJFF Radio Catskill, 6/19/25]

The One Big Beautiful Bill’s Cuts To Medicaid Jeopardized 1 In 5 Sullivan County Jobs And Risked Burdening Local Taxpayers With The Costs Of Providing County Services

Sullivan County Leadership Expressed Concern For The 1 In 5 County Employees Whose Jobs Were Funded By Medicaid And The Potential Burden On Taxpayers To Cover County Services Impacted By Federal Cuts

August 2025: 1 In 5 Sullivan County Employees Were Funded By Medicaid, Including Those At The County Public Health Agency, Mental Health Clinic, And An Adult Care Center. “Sullivan County Manager Josh Potosek said that out of the county's 1000 employees, around 200—one in five—are funded by Medicaid. These include employees at the Sunset Lake Adult Care Center, as well as at the public health agency and mental health clinic. Potosek said that the county is concerned that with the cuts to federal aid, the burden of providing services will shift to local taxpayers. ‘We're already wrestling with a potential property tax hike just to cover the increased expense that will be coming our way in 2026, and we've yet to learn what New York State's reaction will be to the impacts of these Federal-level changes,’ Potosek said.” [River Reporter, 8/15/25]

August 2025: Sullivan County Manager Josh Potsoek Said He Was Concerned About The Difficulty Of Providing Services Following Cuts To Federal Aid, Anticipating Local Taxpayers Would Shoulder The Burden In 2026. “Sullivan County Manager Josh Potosek said that out of the county's 1000 employees, around 200—one in five—are funded by Medicaid. These include employees at the Sunset Lake Adult Care Center, as well as at the public health agency and mental health clinic. Potosek said that the county is concerned that with the cuts to federal aid, the burden of providing services will shift to local taxpayers. ‘We're already wrestling with a potential property tax hike just to cover the increased expense that will be coming our way in 2026, and we've yet to learn what New York State's reaction will be to the impacts of these Federal-level changes,’ Potosek said.” [River Reporter, 8/15/25]

Source report (PDF)