Paul LePage: AFFORDABLE CARE ACT

Criticism

Paul Lepage Compared Obamacare “To The Holocaust,” And He Called The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) The Gestapo For Its Role In Obamacare. In 2012, “Paul LePage…compared the health care reform law [signed by President Obama] to the Holocaust.” (The New York Times, 07/18/12) In reference to ObamaCare he said, “‘you must buy health insurance or pay the new Gestapo – the IRS.’” (Bangor Daily News, 07/09/12) “The Gestapo was the secret police force of German dictator Adolf Hitler before and during World War II. It was notorious for ruthless and brutal actions against Hitler’s political opponents.” (Lewiston Sun Journal, 07/07/12) “It imprisoned and murdered thousands of people.” (Kennebec Journal, 07/08/12)

· Bangor Daily News Editorial: “LePage ‘Gestapo’ comment embarrasses Maine.” [Bangor Daily News, 07/09/12]

· Bangor Daily News Editorial: It Is “Not Unusual For Gov. Paul Lepage To Say Something Offensive Off-The-Cuff. But What’s Disturbing About” The “Blunder” In Which He Called “The Internal Revenue Service ‘The New Gestapo,’ Is That It Wasn’t A Slip-Up. He Purposefully Put The Language Into His…Radio Address After It Was Drafted By Staff.” According to a Bangor Daily News editorial titled, “LePage ‘Gestapo’ comment embarrasses Maine,” it is “not unusual for Gov. Paul LePage to say something offensive off-the-cuff. But what’s disturbing about” the “blunder” in which he called “the Internal Revenue Service ‘the new Gestapo,’ is that it wasn’t a slip-up. He purposefully put the language into his…radio address after it was drafted by staff.” In reference to ObamaCare he said, “‘you must buy health insurance or pay the new Gestapo – the IRS.’” “The coverage of LePage’s comments has been widespread and embarrassing to Maine – no way to encourage businesses to move here.” “As common as it is for LePage to blurt out some attacking remark, the Gestapo comment was planned insensitivity. It did nothing to further real debate about the Affordable Care Act and brought embarrassment to the state.” (Bangor Daily News, 07/09/12)

· LePage on His Comments: “It Was Never Intended to Offend Anyone, and if Someone’s Offended, Then They Ought to be Goddamned Mad at the Federal Government.” After these comments, Paul “LePage told WMTW- TV in an interview…that ‘it was never intended to offend anyone, and if someone’s offended, then they ought to be goddamned mad at the federal government.’” (Kennebec Journal, 07/10/12)

· Days Later Lepage Said He Thinks “The IRS…[Is] Going To Kill A Lot Of People,” Much Like The Gestapo Did. Days later he “attempted to clarify his…comment comparing the Internal Revenue Service to the Gestapo” in “an interview with a reporter from the Burlington weekly Seven Days.” He “said that the IRS wasn’t as bad as the Gestapo, the Nazi police force that imprisoned and murdered millions during World War II, but that the agency was headed in that direction.” “‘What I am trying to say is the Holocaust was a horrific crime against humanity and, frankly, I would never want to see that repeated,’ LePage said. ‘Maybe the IRS is not quite as bad – yet.’” “Seven Days reporter Paul Heintz asked, ‘but they’re headed in that direction?’ LePage responded, ‘they’re headed in that direction.’ Heintz then asked LePage if he knew what the Gestapo did during World War II. LePage said, ‘yeah, they killed a lot of people.’ Heintz asked if he thought the IRS was going to kill a lot of people. ‘Yeah,’ LePage said. ‘They’re headed in the direction of killing a lot of people? Are you serious?’ Heintz asked. LePage said he was ‘very serious,’ adding that the agency would be rationing health care.” (Waterville Morning Sentinel, 07/13/12)

Paul Lepage Opposes Obamacare. “Gov. Paul LePage used his weekly radio address …[on July 7, 2012] to further his long-running criticisms of the federal Affordable Care Act,” which is commonly known as ObamaCare. “LePage said the measure ‘raises taxes, cuts Medicare for the elderly, gets between patients and their doctors, costs trillions of taxpayer dollars and kills jobs.’ LePage also took a shot at the individual mandate part of the law, which requires everyone to purchase health insurance or face penalties, by calling the Internal Revenue Service ‘the new Gestapo.’” (Bangor Daily News, 07/07/12)

LePage Said the ACA Was a “Degradation of Our Nation’s Premier Health Care System.” The Kennebec Journal reported that LePage said “he will not implement a state-customized insurance exchange or participate in an expansion of Medicaid for an estimated 37,000 uninsured Mainers. LePage called the federal health care law provisions the ‘degradation of our nation's premier health care system.’ Both moves were met with disappointment, but not surprise, from the incoming Democratic legislative majority… According to an analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation, states that run their own exchanges or partner with the federal government will have more control over which coverage plans will be available to consumers. Additionally, states can customize the plans to their residents' health care needs. Last year, an advisory panel comprising insurers and hospitals unanimously recommended that the state create its own exchange.” [Kennebec Journal, 11/16/12]

LePage Said ACA was Going to Send the Country “Into a Spiral.” The Portland Press Herald reported, “LePage lashed out against President Obama's health care initiative… ‘I think the ACA is going to put this country into a spiral,’ said LePage.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/30/13]

Insurance Exchanges

LePage Would Rather Let The Federal Government Set Up Exchanges Mandated By Obamacare For Maine Than Have Maine Runs Its Own Health Care System. “Maine will let the federal government take the reins on setting up a mandated online health insurance market, according to comments Gov. Paul LePage made” in 2012. “‘I’m not lifting a finger,’ he said in an interview with Bloomberg at a Republican Governors Association meeting in Las Vegas. ‘We’re not going to get involved. We’re going to let Mr. Obama do a federal exchange. It’s his bill.’” (Bangor Daily News, 11/15/12)

Lawsuit

Headline: “LePage Joins New Lawsuit Designed to Overturn Obamacare.” [Bangor Daily News, 2/27/18]

In Feb. 2018, LePage Signed Onto the Texas Lawsuit to Overturn the ACA as an Individual Because He Can’t Represent Maine in Lawsuits Without Permission from the Attorney General. According to the Bangor Daily News, “Gov. Paul LePage has signed onto a Texas-led lawsuit to overturn the Affordable Care Act, saying it's unconstitutional now that Congress has moved to repeal the key tax at the heart of the health care law enshrined by former President Barack Obama. The Republican governor and 19 Republican-led states filed the lawsuit on Monday in a Texas federal court against the administration of President Donald Trump -- an Obamacare opponent -- alleging that the 2010 law now ‘forces an unconstitutional and irrational regime’ onto states. […] LePage signed on as an individual because he can't represent Maine in lawsuits without permission from Attorney General Janet Mills, a Democratic gubernatorial candidate who the governor sued unsuccessfully last year over refusing to represent him in another lawsuit.” [Bangor Daily News, 2/27/18]

Preventive Care Requirements

In 2018, Bipartisan Majorities of the House and Senate Overrode Governor LePage’s Veto Of Legislation To Codify The Affordable Care Act’s Preventive Care Coverage Requirements In Maine Law. In March 2018, the House overrode LePage’s veto of LD1476 by a 115-34 vote and the Senate by a 30-4 vote. LD 1476 “incorporates current requirements under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act for coverage of preventive health services, including services for women, into state law.” [State of Maine Legislature, LD 1476, Roll Call #530, 3/22/18; Joint Standing Committee on Insurance and Financial Services, Summaries of Bills, LD 1476, October 2018]

  • The Legislation Required Health Insurers To Cover Preventive Services Without Cost-Sharing Requirements As Mandated Under The Affordable Care Act. “The Affordable Care Act mandates that all health insurance policies include certain preventive services without the burden of cost-sharing requirements, creating consistency in a kind of care shown to improve health. That requirement, however, could go away through the rule-making process with a stroke of President Trump’s pen, adding uncertainty where it is not welcome or needed. Maine lawmakers took a step toward eliminating that uncertainty by passing with bipartisan support L.D. 1476, which would put the ACA preventive mandate in state law.” [Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 3/19/18]
  • Covered Preventive Services Included Immunizations, Pregnancy Screenings, STD Screenings, Preventive Medications, And Blood Pressure And Diabetes Screenings. “L.D. 1476, from Rep. Joyce McCreight, D-Harpswell, follows on the heels of a law passed last year that put in state statute the ACA’s requirement of no-copay birth control. It would require all health insurance policies to include without cost-sharing requirements all preventive services given an A or B rating by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, a longstanding, independent panel of national experts in prevention and medicine that makes evidence-based recommendations. Included in the task force’s recommendations are services that cover Mainers from birth to old age, and which can identify health problems well before they get too difficult – and costly – to treat. Immunizations and screenings for infants, children and adolescents are included, as are screenings for pregnant women. Breast-feeding services and supplies make the grade, as do Pap tests and screenings for sexually transmitted infections and the BRCA gene mutation, which are linked to the risk of cervical and breast cancer. Blood pressure and diabetes screenings are also included in the bill, as well as preventive medications for older adults such as aspirin and statins.” [Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 3/19/18]
  • Maine Family Planning’s Kate Brogan: “By Ensuring This Baseline Level Of Preventive Services, LD 1476 Will Protect The Public Health, Reduce Health Care Costs, And Build A Healthier, Brighter Future For Maine.” “Codifying these required health care services at the state level will provide Mainers with the security of knowing that they will be able to maintain coverage of essential preventive health care, regardless of what happens with the federal health care debate. By ensuring this baseline level of preventive services, LD 1476 will protect the public health, reduce health care costs, and build a healthier, brighter future for Maine.” [Joint Standing Committee on Insurance and Financial Services, Maine Family Planning’s Kate Brogran Testimony on LD 1476, 4/25/17]
  • Planned Parenthood’s Nicole Clegg: “Instead Of Worrying About What May Or May Not Be Repealed, LD 1467 Establishes Continuity For The Consumer By Codifying These Basic Preventive Measures Into Maine Law.” “LD 1467 is intended to take some of the guessing game out of insurance coverage. Instead of worrying about what may or may not be repealed, LD 1467 establishes continuity for the consumer by codifying these basic preventive measures into Maine law.” [Joint Standing Committee on Insurance and Financial Services, Planned Parenthood’s Nicole Clegg Testimony on LD 1476, 4/25/17]
  • Maine Women’s Lobby’s Danna Hayes: Requiring Preventive Services Coverage Would Allow Maine Women And Mothers To Obtain Necessary Preventive Health Care “Without Concerns About Cost.” “Guaranteeing the same coverage in Maine statute that currently exists federally would provide a level of confidence to Mainers that they can see a doctor, get regular cancer screenings, have healthier pregnancies and postpartum experiences, and moms can choose to breastfeed if they want, without concerns about cost.” [Joint Standing Committee on Insurance and Financial Services, Maine Women’s Lobby’s Danna Hayes Testimony on LD 1476, 4/25/17]
  • American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network: “Including Preventive Services As Standard Benefits In Health Insurance Has Benefits To Overall Public Health, Saves Lives And Can Reduce Health Care Spending.” “Coverage of preventive services such as cancer screenings helps to prevent some forms of cancer and can help detect other cancers at an earlier stage when the individual has a higher likelihood of more treatment options and a better overall health outcome. Including preventive services as standard benefits in health insurance has benefits to overall public health, saves lives and can reduce health care spending.” [Joint Standing Committee on Insurance and Financial Services, American Cancer Society Cancer Action Networks’ Hilary Schneider Testimony on LD 1476, 4/25/17]
  • American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network: “Given The Uncertainty At The Federal Level, Passing LD 1476 Is Imperative To Ensure That We Are Continuing To Prevent Cancer And Detect It Early For Mainers Covered By Individual And Small Group Health Plans.” “Given the uncertainty at the federal level, passing LD 1476 is imperative to ensure that we are continuing to prevent cancer and detect it early for Mainers covered by individual and small group health plans.” [Joint Standing Committee on Insurance and Financial Services, American Cancer Society Cancer Action Networks’ Hilary Schneider Testimony on LD 1476, 4/25/17]
  • American Heart And Stroke Associations’ Becky Smith: “Cardiovascular Disease Can Be Prevented If Individuals Modify Their Risk Factors For The Disease. Screening And Preventative Services Are Crucial To Individuals’ Ability To Know Their Risks And To Assure They Have The Tools To Make Healthy Lifestyle Changes.” “Cardiovascular disease (CVD), including heart disease and stroke, is the leading cause of death and disability in the U.S. Unfortunately, the disease process can start early in life and is influenced over time by lifestyle behaviors, the environments where people live, and modifiable risk factors, including smoking, overweight and obesity, unhealthy diet, physical inactivity, high blood pressure, elevated blood cholesterol, and Type 2 diabetes. In many instances, CVD can be prevented if individuals modify their risk factors for the disease. Screening and preventative services are crucial to individuals’ ability to know their risks and to assure they have the tools to make healthy lifestyle changes.” [Joint Standing Committee on Insurance and Financial Services, American Heart Association and American Stroke Association’s Becky Smith Testimony on LD 1476, 4/25/17]

HEADLINE: “Preventive Care Mandate Should Not Be Controversial.” [Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 3/19/18]

Portland Press Herald Editorial: “The Evidence Is Clear – Preventive Care Makes A Difference In People’s Lives, And All Mainers Should Have Access To It.” “But the preventive care aspects of the ACA have been a success by any measure, and legislators can make sure they don't disappear from Maine at a moment's notice. The evidence is clear - preventive care makes a difference in people's lives, and all Mainers should have access to it.” [Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 3/19/18]

Portland Press Herald Editorial: “It Is Clear That When More People Have Access To [Preventive] Services, More People Use Them, And More People Have Their Health Problems Diagnosed Before They Are Too Far Along.” “Prevention and early detection can make all the difference. Detecting cancer in its early stages, for instance, increases greatly the five-year survival rate for colorectal, cervical and breast cancer. Finding and removing pre-cancerous polyps can literally mean the difference between life and death. It is clear that when more people have access to these services, more people use them, and more people have their health problems diagnosed before they are too far along.” [Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 3/19/18]

Source report (PDF)