Paul LePage: WIND POWER

Paul Lepage “Doesn’t Support Land-Based Wind Power.” Paul LePage “doesn’t support land-based wind power, because the industry requires taxpayer subsidies to reduce the true cost of generation. ‘While I believe wind may have future promise as a commercially viable source of energy,’ he said, ‘it clearly is not there at this time.’” [Kennebec Journal, 05/02/10]

LePage Called Wind a “Boutique Energy Source.” In 2012 LePage “said wind could not support the baseload energy needs of the state, and called it a “boutique energy source.” [Bangor Daily News, 8/3/12]

LePage Hold on Bonding Funds Affected an Offshore Wind Power Demonstration Site. In 2012 “LePage placed a hold on $40 million in bonds in an attempt to rein in state borrowing. On that list was about $7.3 million in funding for the offshore wind demonstration site… Members of LePage’s administration have questioned the feasibility of the offshore wind project in the past.” [Bangor Daily News, 12/9/12]

LePage Claimed That a Motor Was Used to Spin the Wind Turbine of a Turbine on UM Presque Isle’s Campus “to Give People the Impression That it is Generating Electricity Even on Days When it Isn’t Gusty.” LePage “claimed that a motor spins the blades of a wind turbine located on the campus of the University of Maine at Presque Isle to give people the impression that it is generating electricity even on days when it isn't gusty.” [Talking Points Memo, 4/18/13]

LePage Wanted to Rewrite State Wind Energy Act to Remove Wind Energy Goals. The Bangor Daily News reported, “LePage wants to strip from state law goals for increasing the state’s wind energy capacity over the next two decades. LePage’s energy director, Patrick Woodcock, made recommendations Thursday to rewrite the state’s 2008 Wind Energy Act, shifting focus from growing wind energy capacity to lowering electricity costs and making sure Maine sees an economic return on its wind energy investments.” [Bangor Daily News, 5/9/13]

Headline: “Effort to Build Offshore Wind Industry May Hinge on 73 Cents; Gov. LePage Imperils a 2014 Power Contract for Floating Turbines Off Monhegan Island That Would Raise Consumer Bills Less Than $1 a Month.” [Portland Press Herald, 4/1/18]

Paul LePage’s Opposition To Wind Power Hurt Maine’s Economy

Kennebec Journal Editorial: In 2013, LePage Killed a Plan to Have Norwegian Energy Company Statoil Test an Ocean Wind Concept Off of the Coast of Maine – the Company Moved to and Invested $2.5 Billion in Scotland, Taking its Employees and Business With it. According to an editorial in the Kennebec Journal, “He has repeatedly vetoed bills to modernize solar power regulation, which had been a dynamic job creator until the Trump administration put a tariff on Chinese solar panels. And he used his veto of the omnibus energy bill of 2013 as leverage to tear up a previous power purchase contract with the Norwegian energy giant Statoil, which planned to test its own ocean wind concept off the coast of Maine. Statoil pulled up stakes here and invested $2.5 billion in Scotland, where its offshore project is beating projections for production. When the company left, it took its employees with it, along with any business it would have done with local vendors.” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 6/13/18]

Kennebec Journal Editorial: LePage “Overlooks the Value in Attracting Investment to the State That Will Build an Industry Here to Replace Some of the Jobs Lost When the Paper Companies Downsized Their Workforce.” According to an editorial in the Kennebec Journal, “The governor’s hostility toward clean energy is based on his belief that nothing matters about energy policy except the price. He doesn’t consider that the state can help people conserve energy, lowering their bills even if the per-unit price goes up. He also overlooks the value in attracting investment to the state that will build an industry here to replace some of the jobs lost when the paper companies downsized their workforce.” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 6/13/18]

Headline: “Other East Coast States Capitalizing On Wind; While Maine's Priorities Shifted After 2010 With The Election Of Paul Lepage, Massachusetts Is Leading In Ocean Energy.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/13/18]

Before LePage Took Office, “Maine Aspired to be a Leader in Ocean Energy by Passing Legislation That Set Ambitious Goals for Wind Power,” But Priorities Shifted After LePage Took Office. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Nearly 10 years ago, Maine aspired to be a leader in ocean energy by passing legislation that set ambitious goals for wind power. But those priorities shifted after 2010 with the election of Republican Gov. Paul LePage, a strident critic of the above-market costs that have underpinned many major renewable energy projects.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/13/18]

Policies to Attract Wind Power Were Attracting “Billions of Dollars in Global Investment” to East Coast States from Massachusetts to Virginia. According to the Portland Press Herald, “Tuesday's decision by the Maine Public Utilities Commission to further review the terms of the power-contract for the Maine Aqua Ventus wind farm comes as offshore wind energy, refined for decades in Europe, is poised to become a major new industry in the United States. Policies by state governments from Massachusetts to Virginia are attracting billions of dollars in global investment to the East Coast.” [Portland Press Herald, 6/13/18]

Kennebec Journal Editorial Headline: “PUC Carries Out LePage’s Shortsighted Agenda.” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 6/13/18]

In June 2018, Three LePage Appointees on the Public Utilities Commission Voted to Get Rid of a Previously-Negotiated Power Purchase Agreement With Maine Aqua Ventus, a Move “Likely to Kill a First-of-its-Kind Floating Wind Farm.” According to an editorial in the Kennebec Journal, “The three members of the Public Utilities Commission, all LePage appointees, voted Tuesday to toss out a previously negotiated power purchase agreement with the University of Maine’s public-private partnership, known as Maine Aqua Ventus. The move is likely to kill a first-of-its-kind floating wind farm, planned to be built off Monhegan Island.” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 6/13/18]

Kennebec Journal Editorial: “Gov. Paul LePage’s Leadership, or Lack of Leadership, Has Hampered Clean-Energy Development Throughout His Time in Office.” According to an editorial in the Kennebec Journal, “Gov. Paul LePage’s leadership, or lack of leadership, has hampered clean-energy development thoughout his time in office.” [Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 6/13/18]

Morning Sentinel Editorial: Maine’s Energy Policy Failures “Can Largely Be Traced Back To One Man, Gov. Paul LePage.” “OVER THE LAST six years, there have been several bipartisan policy failures -- notably, on tax policy, where Republicans and Democrats collaborated to deprive Maine of the revenue it needs to run its basic programs and adequately support schools, colleges and local government. On energy policy, though, the failures can largely be traced back to one man, Gov. Paul LePage, whose hidebound, backward-looking ideas have left the state far behind the curve, particularly when it comes to economic and business development.” [Morning Sentinel—Editorial, 4/14/16]

  • LePage Vetoed Omnibus Energy Act, “Chased Off The $120 Statoil Million Offshore Wind Project” Reneging On Signed Contract. “It started early. LePage, notoriously, vetoed the Omnibus Energy Act of 2013, the Legislature's major achievement in this area, which was overridden, but he then chased off the $120 Statoil million offshore wind project by reneging on an already signed contract. The Hywind project is now being built off the coast of Scotland.” [Morning Sentinel—Editorial, 4/14/16]
  • LePage Appointees Reneged On Contracts With Two Wind Developers, Caused One Developer To Drop Maine As Investment Partner. “LePage has been equally short-sighted about land-based wind, where Maine was already the identified leader in the burgeoning Northeast market for renewable energy. His appointees to the Public Utilities Commission also reneged on contracts with two wind developers; while one project finally went ahead, the other was dropped. And LePage appointees at the Department of Environmental Protection have used decidedly thin rationales to veto wind projects, undoubtedly prompting other developers to take their business elsewhere.” [Morning Sentinel—Editorial, 4/14/16]
  • “Fellow Republican, Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker” Told LePage More Natural Gas Wasn’t Coming To New England Without “Expensive New Pipeline Capacity.” “More natural gas isn't coming here without expensive new pipeline capacity, and even a fellow Republican, Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker, has told LePage it's not going to happen. As for Quebec, LePage leaves out the fact that we have no adequate transmission lines, which could cost up to $1 billion to build, certainly canceling out LePage's ‘cheap power.’ His alternatives are utter fantasy, and it's about time lawmakers started saying so.” [Morning Sentinel—Editorial, 4/14/16]

2013: LePage Drove Norwegian Company Statoil to Back Off from Plans to Invest $120 Million in Maine for Wind Energy Development Projects. According to an editorial from the Bangor Daily News, “Likewise, LePage has driven wind energy development away from Maine. In 2013, Statoil, a Norwegian company that said it planned to invest $120 million in the state, withdrew its plans after LePage and lawmakers worked to have the utilities commission change the terms of an agreement with the company.” [Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 8/8/18]

WBUR: “ [LePage] Has Also Stymied Development Of Renewable Energy Sources While Pursuing And Attempting To Revive The State’s Traditional Industries In Forest Products.” According to WBUR, “He [LePage] has also stymied development of renewable energy sources while pursuing and attempting to revive the state’s traditional industries in forest products.” [WBUR, 1/2/19]

AP Headline: “Governor Wants To Know If Wind Turbines ‘Truly’ Help Maine.” [AP, 6/16/18]

AP: “Maine’s Republican Governor Wants To Know If What He Calls ‘Massive’ Wind Turbines Help The Rural State’s Economy.” According to the Associated Press, “Maine’s Republican governor wants to know if what he calls ‘massive’ wind turbines help the rural state’s economy. Gov. Paul LePage has prohibited state agencies from permitting new wind energy projects in western and coastal Maine, on coastal islands and along certain avian migratory pathways.” [Associated Press, 6/17/18]

Associated Press: “Gov. Paul LePage Has Prohibited State Agencies From Permitting New Wind Energy Projects In Western And Coastal Maine, On Coastal Islands And Along Certain Avian Migratory Pathways.” According to the Associated Press, “Gov. Paul LePage has prohibited state agencies from permitting new wind energy projects in western and coastal Maine, on coastal islands and along certain avian migratory pathways. He also created a secretive commission that is seeking public comment through Aug. 15 from communities, organizations and residents. The commission is not subject to Maine’s public meetings law.” [Associated Press, 6/16/18]

  • In 2018, LePage Issued an Executive Order Halting New Wind Projects in Parts of Maine. According to the St. John Valley Times, “LePage, who has derided subsidies for ‘boutique’ wind energy, issued an executive order last year ordering a halt to new wind projects in certain areas of Maine. He also launched the wind energy advisory commission to investigate the impact of turbines on central and coastal areas of Maine.” [St. John Valley Times, 1/16/19]

Paul LePage’s Wind Energy Advisory Commission

Headline: “Report Shows How Badly LePage’s Wind Energy Panel Fizzled.” [St. John Valley Times, 1/16/19]

St. John Valley Times: “A Maine Commission Created as Part of the Former Republican Governor’s Efforts to Hinder Wind Projects Has Released a Report Drawing Few

Conclusions About the Impact of Wind Turbines.” According to the St. John Valley Times, “A Maine commission created as part of the former Republican governor's efforts to hinder wind projects has released a report drawing few conclusions about the impact of wind turbines.” [St. John Valley Times, 1/16/19]

St. John Valley Times: The Report “Had Limited Information” and “Was Unable to Draw Conclusions” About Wind Power in Maine. According to the St. John Valley Times, “The commission's report said it had limited information and was unable to draw conclusions. The commission, whose members included the manager of a sporting camp and LePage's technical adviser Jim LaBrecque, recommended additional research on issues such as the impacts of wind turbines on health.” [St. John Valley Times, 1/16/19]

Source report (PDF)