Paul LePage: LEPAGE PRIORITIZED CORPORATE SPECIAL INTERESTS OVER WORKING MAINERS

LePage Oversaw Sluggish Economic Growth and Rapid Decline of Key Maine Industries While the State Remained Among the Worst in the Country for Businesses. Maine experienced year after year of sluggish economic growth under Governor Paul LePage, trailing its regional New England peers and national averages, and in 2016 was rated as one of the states with the slowest growing economies by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis.1 The state remained at the bottom of national rankings for the best states for business and suffered one of the slowest recoveries in the country from the Great Recession under LePage’s leadership.2 In 2016, years after the official end of the Great Recession, Maine was one of only ten states that had not recovered all jobs lost during the recession and it ultimately took “four times longer than usual” under LePage’s leadership to fully recover from the recession.3

  • During LePage’s Tenure, Maine’s Legacy Paper Industry Continued to Decline Rapidly as the State “Was Devastated by Mill Closures.”4 LePage oversaw a decline in Maine’s paper and manufacturing industries – from 2011 to 2014, Maine lost roughly 1,400 manufacturing jobs.5 During his first five years in office, five of Maine’s paper mills shut down, costing thousands of good-paying mill jobs, especially in more rural parts of the state and resulting in a “ripple effect” throughout the industry, impacting logging and biomass energy production as well.6 Even with the struggles facing Maine’s historic industry, LePage refused to sign bipartisan legislation creating a commission tasked with recommending how to maintain a sustainable future for the industry and opposed a $45 million subsidy for Maine’s struggling biomass industry.7 Additionally, LePage refused to seek nearly $2 million in federal funding for Maine’s Forest Legacy Program, which helped preserve 6,400 acres of working forest land.8
  • LePage Blocked Renewable Energy Investments and Scuttled a Deal That Would Have Provided a $120 Million Investment in Renewable Energy in Maine.9 Despite the downward trend in Maine’s forest products industry under his leadership, LePage took “few steps” to help the Maine economy and workers transition away from natural

resource extraction.10 He was criticized by the Kennebec Journal editorial board for “overlook[ing] the value in attracting investment [to Maine] that will build an industry here to replace some of the jobs lost when the paper companies downsized their workforce.”11 Thanks to LePage’s opposition to wind energy, other New England and Atlantic seaboard states benefited from “billions of dollars in global investment” and the jobs created from those investments, while Maine’s economy struggled.12 LePage’s “ambivalence” towards solar energy also negatively impacted Maine – while nearby Massachusetts ranked second nationally in solar power-related jobs, Maine ranked 43rd under LePage.13

LePage Delivered Millions in Tax Benefits for the Wealthy While Giving Working Class Mainers the Shaft. LePage delivered for Maine’s wealthiest with reforms aimed to benefit the rich, including slashing the top income tax rate and nearly tripling the estate tax exemption – costing the state nearly $900 million in revenue.14 That nearly $900 million would be enough to fully fund K-12 education, Medicaid expansion, and revenue-sharing in Maine.15 LePage even proposed eliminating the state income tax entirely.16 When LePage left office, the wealthiest Maine households paid a lower effective tax rate than any other income bracket in Maine, including the poorest 20% of Mainers.17

  • LePage’s Tax and Revenue-Sharing Cuts Drove Up Local Property Taxes by Tens of Millions of Dollars. LePage’s tax cuts meant local Maine taxes had to go up to fund schools, infrastructure, and other vital services – low- and middle-class Mainers collectively paid an average of $30 million more per year in local property taxes from 2011 to 2016.18 In 2013, LePage eliminated a popular property tax refund program and replaced it with a less-generous property tax credit program, amounting to an effective $20 to $25 million tax increase on property tax-paying Mainers.19 An additional stressor to local property taxes under LePage came from his dedicated attacks and cuts to revenue-sharing and education; from 2011 to 2017, Maine towns had to raise over $1 billion in property taxes to pay for the state underfunding its share of education costs.20 By the middle of LePage’s tenure, Maine collected the tenth-highest amount of state and local property taxes out of all 50 states, at $2,105 per capita.21 Even with Mainers paying higher property taxes under LePage, the amount of total resources available to the state to invest in helping Mainers and their communities went down by about one-third of $1 billion per year under LePage.22 The Bangor Daily News editorialized that LePage could

have focused on keeping property taxes low, but “he’s stood in the way of those efforts” by cutting revenue-sharing to localities.23

  • As He Delivered Tax Breaks to the Wealthy, LePage Fiercely Opposed Policies That Would Help Working Mainers and the Maine Middle Class. LePage fiercely opposed raising the minimum wage in Maine, even called for jailing supporters of a voter-passed minimum wage increase that helped raise the incomes of 181,000 Maine residents, including one in three working seniors.24 During his time in office, Maine workers’ wages fell farther behind the national average.25 LePage also actively opposed opportunities to help expand opportunities for Maine workers, vetoing a bipartisan bill that helped low-income individuals pay for education or job training, refusing to sign bipartisan legislation expanding job training programs, and vetoing a bipartisan bill creating job training programs in high-demand fields like logging, health care, and precision manufacturing at Maine’s community colleges.26 LePage even made a “meddlesome and uninformed” decision to reject $8 million in federal funding for job training programs that provided services to thousands of unemployed Mainers.27 The Bangor Daily News editorial board wrote that that decision “cost Maine workers”, and that “Maine’s job seekers will keep losing out” under LePage should he get his way on workforce issues.28

LePage Prioritized His Personal Friends and Special Interests in Choosing His Appointees Rather Than Experience or Qualifications to do the Job. Over his two terms as governor, LePage appointed a number of questionable individuals with conflicts of interest or inadequate experience to work in his administration, with sometimes disastrous results. Immediately upon winning election in 2010, LePage hired his “recent college graduate” daughter to a “high-level administration job,” where she was paid about $10,000 more annually than Maine workers who passed teacher and police officer exams.29 Two years later, LePage gave his brother-in-law a job in his administration that paid nearly $70,000 per year.30 Beyond his tendencies towards nepotism, LePage has hired and appointed individuals with histories of tax liens and unpaid debts, property tax dodgers, corporate lobbyists, and even an individual accused of hiding accusations of pedophilia.31 Politicos in Maine noted that LePage’s appointees had “precious little idea how [their agencies] actually function. [And] what’s worse, second-tier managers who could help accelerate that learning curve have either resigned or been fired.”32 LePage Cozied Up to Corporate Lobbyists, Allowed His Policies to be Dictated by Special Interests. In 2011, the Portland Press Herald wrote that big business “comes first” in LePage’s administration, going on to say that LePage governed like “a friend of corporations.”33 Despite campaigning like a man of the people and receiving strong backing from Tea Party protesters, LePage moved to quickly appoint members of corporate boards to positions within his administration, opting to allow corporate special interest to call the shots in Maine.34 LePage appointed a hospital lobbyist to head up the Department of Health and Human Services, and a land developer to lead the Environmental Protection Agency.35 LePage’s coziness with special interest doesn’t end at appointments, he also allowed lobbying interest to essentially author his policies. The Portland Phoenix reported that LePage essentially copy and pasted passages from memos his staff received from lobbyist to craft policy that served as a list of giveaways for corporations.36 LePage moved to weaken Maine’s wage and tip haring laws down to federal standards at the behest of lawyers representing Maine restaurant owners and sought to rollback child labor laws based on the recommendation of Maine Innkeepers Association’s lobbyists.37

  • LePage Earned $7,500 Lobbying For Central Maine Power Company Immediately After Leaving Office. In 2019, LePage was paid $7,50038 by high powered lobbying firm, Mitchell Tardy Jackson, to lobby in support of a 145-mile transmission line to deliver Hydro-Quebec power.39 LePage insisted that he wasn’t required to register as a lobbyist under Maine law for the services he provided to Mitchell Tardy Jackson.40
  1. Portland Press Herald, 4/25/17; Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16; Associated Press, 5/11/17; Portland Press Herald, 7/26/18 ↩
  2. Portland Press Herald, 4/25/17; Bangor Daily News, 3/13/17; CNBC, 2011; CNBC, 2018; Bangor Daily News, 10/23/15 ↩
  3. Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16; Bangor Daily News, 3/13/17 ↩
  4. Bangor Daily News, 12/31/18; Bangor Daily News, 12/17/18; Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel, Editorial, 10/4/15 ↩
  5. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Maine, Manufacturing, Accessed 5/2/21 ↩
  6. Natural Resources Council of Maine, 2016; Bangor Daily News, 6/18/16; Portland Press Herald, 1/11/18 ↩
  7. Maine State Legislature, LD 1693, 4/28/16; Biomass Magazine, 4/19/16 ↩
  8. Bangor Daily News, 11/9/15; Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17 ↩
  9. WBUR, 1/2/19; Associated Press, 6/16/18; Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 8/8/18 ↩
  10. Bangor Daily News, 6/16/16 ↩
  11. Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 6/13/18 ↩
  12. Portland Press Herald, 6/13/18 ↩
  13. Kennebec Journal, 6/28/15 ↩
  14. Portland Press Herald, 12/30/18; Portland Press Herald, 5/9/19; Maine Center For Economic Policy, 2/27/20 ↩
  15. Maine Center for Economic Policy, August 2018 ↩
  16. Americans For Tax Reform, 2/10/15 ↩
  17. Maine Center for Economic Policy, 9/4/19 ↩
  18. Maine Beacon, 9/13/18 ↩
  19. Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 2/17/18; Morning Sentinel, 8/9/13 ↩
  20. Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17 ↩
  21. Tax Foundation, 3/13/19 ↩
  22. Maine Center for Economic Policy, August 2018 ↩
  23. Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 3/28/18; ↩
  24. Governing, 10/17/16; Bangor Daily News, 12/19/18; Sun Journal, 10/13/16 ↩
  25. Bangor Daily News, 12/31/18; Bangor Daily News, 12/19/18; Governing, 10/17/16 ↩
  26. State of Maine Legislature, Actions of LD 1774, 4/15/18; Portland Press Herald, 4/17/18; Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 2/28/18; State of Maine Legislature, LD 1019 Text, 2015 ↩
  27. Bangor Daily News, 9/8/17; Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 10/25/17 ↩
  28. Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 3/26/18 ↩
  29. Lewiston Sun Journal, 4/5/11; Seacoastonline.com, 3/17/12 ↩
  30. Lewiston Sun Journal, 4/5/11; Seacoastonline.com, 3/17/12 ↩
  31. Kennebec Journal, 4/15/11; Lewiston Sun Journal, 4/5/11; Lewiston Sun Journal, 3/14/12; Portland Press Herald, 8/30/12 ↩
  32. Portland Press Herald, 4/29/11 ↩
  33. Portland Press Herald, 2/2/11 ↩
  34. Portland Press Herald, 2/2/11 ↩
  35. Portland Press Herald, 2/2/11 ↩
  36. The Portland Phoenix, 7/20/11 ↩
  37. The Portland Phoenix, 7/20/11 ↩
  38. WGME, 2/25/20 ↩
  39. WGME, 2/25/20 ↩
  40. AP, 2/25/20 ↩

Source report (PDF)