Paul LePage: LEPAGE’S DISASTROUS TENURE LEFT MAINE’S MOST VULNERABLE CITIZENS BEHIND
LePage Presided Over Worsening Public Health Crises in Maine as Governor, and Actively Blocked Efforts to Improve the Health and Well-Being of Mainers. Under LePage’s leadership, Maine fell from the 8th healthiest state in the country to the 16th healthiest state, and from 2015 to 2018, the percentage of Maine adults who avoided health care due to cost increased by 31%, from 9.4% to 12.3%.41 These statistics worsened as LePage blocked Medicaid expansion at every turn, which would have helped thousands of Mainers afford preventive and lifesaving health care. The Portland Press Herald wrote that LePage left Maine’s public health system “decimated” upon leaving office, after halving the number of public health nurses who helped contain disease outbreaks, visited new mothers and babies, and conducted immunization clinics.42 Under LePage, Maine was the only state that as of 2015 had not experienced an increase in the percentage of people with health insurance since the passage of the ACA, falling from 10th to 24th nationally in terms of percentage of people with health coverage.43
- LePage Failed to Address the Raging Opioid Epidemic and Even Stood in the Way of Lifesaving Bipartisan Reforms. Under LePage, Maine’s opioid crisis rapidly escalated and the state set records for drug overdose deaths three years in a row peaking at 418 deaths in 2017 as LePage “continue[d] a pattern of slow response to the crisis” and vetoed bipartisan legislation to address the worsening crisis.44 Near the end of LePage’s tenure, Maine was still one of the top states in the country in number of opioid overdose deaths, while other New England states were seeing decreases in annual overdose deaths.45 Under LePage’s leadership, Maine was one of only two states nationally that reduced its spending on anti-addiction medications like naloxone and while Medicaid spending dropped by 24%, the number of opioid overdose deaths increased by 300%.46 Despite the death rate, LePage insisted on attacking drug users, vetoing bipartisan bills that made it cheaper to be prescribed abuse-deterrent painkillers, expanded access to opioid treatment, and funded a $6.6 million program to help more people access recovery and treatment services.47 Despite other Republican governors embracing expanding access to the opioid overdose reversal drug naloxone and Maine being a national outlier on not allowing naloxone to be dispensed without a prescription, LePage “absurd[ly]” opposed it repeatedly as governor.48 He refused to sign or vetoed bipartisan bills to expand access to the lifesaving drug by making it more widely available without a prescription, and then fought implementation of the bipartisan-backed legislation for years while Mainers died of potentially preventable overdose had they had better access to naloxone.49 Maine’s editorial boards took LePage to task for his inaction on the opioid epidemic, saying he “undermine[d]” the state’s response, and “[put] lives in danger.”50
- LePage Blocked Medicaid Expansion Throughout His Eight Years in Office, Denying 70,000 Mainers Access to Affordable Health Care. LePage vetoed Medicaid expansion five times as governor, and called those vetoes “among the most important acts of [his] governorship.”51 Even after Maine voters overwhelmingly passed Medicaid expansion in 2017, LePage blocked implementation at every turn, even when ordered to implement the law by Maine judges.52 Medicaid expansion in Maine was expected to cover 70,000 Mainers, concentrated in the older, rural population, help fight the opioid
epidemic in Maine, provided a “much-needed” boost to rural hospitals, create 6,000 new jobs across the state, and have a $684 million economic impact.53
- LePage Cut Maine Families Out of Assistance Programs Designed to the Most Vulnerable Mainers and Maine Families. When LePage took office in 2011 Maine had 25,000 children in the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, by 2017 that number was cut to 7,600.54 LePage accomplished this slash in participation by tightening eligibility restrictions for the program, including a five year lifetime cap on eligibility for assistance from the program.55 LePage additionally tried to bar people convicted of a felony from being eligible for the TANF program.56 In 2017, LePage even vetoed a bipartisan bill that sought to provide a $400 incentive to TANF recipients that entered and retained employment for four months, the veto was overridden by the legislature.57 LePage’s moves to decrease the number of children in the TANF program did little to alleviate poverty, as families that were removed from the program due to new eligibility restrictions remained in poverty, the result was that Maine ended up with $200 million in unspent TANF funds in 2017 while poverty rates maintained their same level.58
- LePage’s Attempt at Welfare Reform Actually Added to Child Poverty Levels and Left Maine’s Neediest More Vulnerable. LePage campaigned hard on reining in welfare and even called it the “greatest thing” he had ever done. Despite LePage’s insistence to reform welfare, child poverty actually increased in Maine during his tenure according to reporting from the Bangor Daily News.59 LePage’s administration was even cited in 2016 for misspending over $13 million in federal welfare funds on programs that didn’t help low-income families.60
LePage Would Threaten and Undermine the Seniors of the “Oldest State in the Nation.”61 The former Governor has shown outright contempt for programs seniors have earned after paying into their whole working lives, calling Social Security and Medicare “welfare” programs.62 In 2012, he used his line-item veto to cut part of a bill that created a pilot program to “maximize” the award of Supplemental Social Security benefits and to help veterans access benefits from the VA.63 LePage’s attitude towards Maine’s seniors was such that the Portland Press Herald editorial board criticized him for offering “no leadership” on Maine’s aging crisis during his time in office, “creating unnecessary suffering for today’s seniors and guaranteeing more of the same for tomorrow’s.”64 Under LePage, the number of seniors who suffered from food insecurity increased from 12.2% to 15.6%, which the PPH editorial board called “appalling,” even as legislators dropped a proposal in 2018 to fund Meals on Wheels at $500,000 because they didn’t believe they could pass it over LePage’s veto.65 LePage “inexplicabl[y]” failed to apply for $300,000 in federal money to help the 28,000 Mainers with Alzheimer’s, $1 million in federal funding for dementia programming, and refused $2.5 million in federal funding to promote colonoscopies among older Mainers.66 He repeatedly opposed legislation increasing reimbursement rates for direct caregivers of older Mainers and vetoed a bipartisan bill requiring his DHHS to report on its efforts to reach elderly or disabled Mainers living in rural parts of Maine.67 And despite there being an affordable housing shortage for Maine seniors, LePage withheld for years $15 million in voter-passed funding to build new affordable homes for Maine seniors.68
LePage Proved to be an “Enemy of Public Education” and Pre-K as Governor and Left Maine Kids Behind. In 2013, the Maine Sunday Telegram editorial board called LePage “an enemy of public education” and his record backs this characterization up.69As governor, LePage backed cuts to Head Start and in his first term, slashed funding for Head Start by $2 million, or more than 50%.70 In 2012, LePage ordered a $12.5 million cut to education aid but by the end of his second term, the state share of school funding had been cut by $1.3 billion.71 By the 2015-2016 school year, education funding per pupil in Maine had dropped by $1,200 per pupil 72 Throughout his two terms, he failed to get Maine’s share of education funding to 55% as mandated by law, dropping the state share from 52.8% by 2009 to only 47% under his tenure.73 He even ridiculed Maine’s public school system, saying “if you want a good education, go to private schools.”74 His threats to public education didn’t end when students graduated high school – he repeatedly proposed massive cuts to Maine’s community colleges and University of Maine System.75 Under LePage, the percentage of high school graduates who go on to attend college remained flat, and statewide test scores have “shown little improvement.”76
LePage’s Budgets Slashed Funding for Victims of Domestic Abuse as Maine Ranked Highest in the Country for Domestic Violence Deaths. LePage claimed in 2013 that he was an advocate for domestic violence prevention, but that didn’t mesh with his proposed budgets that sought to slash funding for domestic violence victims.77 In 2015, a bipartisan majority of Maine lawmakers were forced to override LePage’s veto of a legislation prohibited landlords from evicting a tenant that was a victim of domestic violence.78 In 2018, LePage refused to sign a bill that appropriated $150,000 to establish a batterer intervention program.79 As LePage resisted efforts to curb domestic violence in Maine, deaths due to domestic violence accounted for half of all homicides in Maine, making the state the highest in the country for such deaths.80
- LePage Frequently Opposed Measures Meant to Curtail Sexual Violence. LePage repeatedly opposed measures meant to curtail sexual violence. In 2016, the Maine Legislature was forced to override his veto of a bill that lifted the 17-years or younger cap on unlawful sexual conduct towards students by someone that had authority over them, therefore making sexual advances by teachers or principals towards students that were 18 a felony.81 In 2018, bipartisan majorities in the Maine legislature overrode LePage’s veto of a bill to strengthen protections for victims of sexual assault and stalking.82 In 2017, LePage refused to sign legislation that made new class of gross sexual assault a crime when one party had not expressly consented, no matter if that person voluntarily consumed drugs.83 LePage even refused to sign legislation into law in 2015 that allowed victims of sexual assault to still receive benefits from their workplace after taking leave.84 Finally, LePage refused to sign legislation that expanded the scope of the crime of stalking.85
Another Term Under LePage Would Threaten to Roll Back the Pro-LGBTQ and Pro-Women Equality Gains Made Under Governor Mills. As governor, LePage vetoed a bill that would have banned conversion therapy, a practice that was finally successfully banned under Governor Mills.86 He also joined a lawsuit that called for allowing employers to fire their workers based on their sexual orientation.87 “Staunchly anti-abortion,” a return to LePage could threaten the numerous strides forward on abortion access achieved under Governor Mills.88 LePage refused to sign bipartisan legislation requiring health insurance plans to cover contraceptives dispensed for a 12-month period and even said that if Supreme Court justices could make a case to “get rid of” Roe v. Wade, “let’s do it.”89
- United Health Foundation, America’s Health Rankings, 2020; United Health Foundation, America’s Health Rankings, 2018 ↩
- Portland Press Herald, 3/18/20; Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 8/5/17 ↩
- Maine Center for Economic Policy, Press Release, 9/16/15; Maine Center for Economic Policy, Press Release, 9/16/15 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 2/22/18; Bangor Daily News, 3/7/16; Bangor Daily News, 2/2/17 ↩
- National Institute on Drug Abuse, accessed 9/5/19; Bangor Daily News, 8/21/18 ↩
- Maine Center for Economic Policy, 7/13/17 ↩
- Portland Press Herald, 5/11/15; Maine State Legislature, LD 1771, Roll Call #658, 5/2/18; Portland Press Herald, 7/16/18 ↩
- Portland Press Herald, 1/28/18; Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 7/18/16; Portland Press Herald, 3/23/18 ↩
- Editorial, Bangor Daily News, 4/27/18 ↩
- Kennebec Journal, Editorial, 1/15/18; Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 8/7/16 ↩
- Associated Press, 7/3/18; Bangor Daily News, 9/8/18 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 11/7/17; New York Times, 7/24/18]; Bangor Daily News, 11/21/18 ↩
- Maine Center for Economic Policy, Medicaid Expansion Fact Sheets, 2017; Maine Department of Health and Human Services, 4/1/21; Portland Press Herald, 8/21/19; Portland Press Herald, 9/17/19; Editorial, Portland Press Herald, 11/12/19 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 12/31/18 ↩
- Maine Sunday Telegram, 12/30/18 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 5/3/13 ↩
- Summaries of Bills, LD481, 2017; Maine State Legislature, LD481, 2017 ↩
- Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 12/31/18 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 10/18/16] ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 9/14/18 ↩
- Portland Press Herald, 6/25/14 ↩
- Paul LePage’s Veto Message on LD 1903, 04/14/12 ↩
- Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 9/16/18 ↩
- Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 9/16/18 ↩
- Portland Press Herald, Editorial, 9/16/18; Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17 ↩
- Summary of Benefits, LD525, 2015; Maine State Legislature, LD525, 2015; Morning Sentinel, 5/18/15; Maine State Legislature, LD 886, 4/27/16; Maine State Legislature, LD 1350, 7/12/15; Portland Press Herald, 6/30/18; Maine State Legislature, LD 925, Roll Call #702, 7/9/18 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 6/8/17 ↩
- Maine Sunday Telegram, 1/6/13 ↩
- Lewiston Sun Journal, 5/14/12; Kennebec Journal, 12/16/11; Bangor Daily News, 9/11/12 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 12/27/12; Maine Center for Economic Policy, August 2018 ↩
- American Federation of Teachers, 2018 ↩
- Maine Beacon, 2/23/17 ↩
- New York Times, 8/13/18 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 12/17/12; Bangor Daily News, 5/6/15; Kennebec Journal, 3/14/12 ↩
- New York Times, 8/13/18 ↩
- Kennebec Journal, 2/3/13 ↩
- Joint Standing Committee on Judiciary, Summaries of Bills, LD 861, August 2015; State of Maine Legislature, LD 861, Roll Call #445, 6/30/15; State of Maine Legislature, Summary of LD 861, 6/30/15 ↩
- Summaries of Bills, LD525, 2018; Maine State Legislature, LD525, 2018 ↩
- Maine Center for Economic Policy, 3/21/17 ↩
- Sun Journal, 4/29/16; Morning Sentinel, 4/30/16; Summaries of Bills, LD1540, 2016; Maine State Legislature, LD1540, 2016 ↩
- State of Maine Legislature, Summary of LD 1788, 7/9/18; Joint Standing Committee on Judiciary, Summaries of Bills, LD 1788, October 2018 ↩
- Joint Standing Committee on Criminal Justice and Public Safety, Summaries of Bills, LD 654, August 2017; State of Maine Legislature, LD 654, Roll Call #227, 6/5/17; State of Maine Legislature, Actions for LD 654, 8/2/17 ↩
- Joint Standing Committee on Labor, Commerce, Research and Economic Development, Summaries of Bills, LD 921, August 2015; State of Maine Legislature, Summary of LD 921, 7/12/15; Bangor Daily News, 10/15/15 ↩
- Summaries of Bills, LD431, 2015; Maine State Legislature, LD431, 2015 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, 7/7/18 ↩
- Bangor Daily News, Editorial, 10/30/18 ↩
- Kennebec Journal, 5/17/13 ↩
- Maine State Legislature, LD1237 Bill Text as Amended, 2017; Bangor Daily News, 7/8/18 ↩